SPOTTIE v. BAIUL-FARINA

2024 ND 88
North Dakota Supreme Court·Decided May 2, 2024·No. 20230195·Published·Cited by 5 cases

Opinion

2023195 FILED

IN THE OFFICE OF THE

2nd Corrected Opinion Filed 7/16/24 by Clerk of the Supreme Court CLERK OF SUPREME COURT

05-02-2024

STATE OF NORTH DAKOTA

Corrected Opinion Filed 5/24/24 by Clerk of the Supreme Court IN THE SUPREME COURT STATE OF NORTH DAKOTA

2024 ND 88

SPOTTIE, INC., a Nevada corporation, Plaintiff and Appellant v.

BAIUL-FARINA, LTD., a Nevada corporation, CARLO J. FARINA CO. LTD., a Nevada corporation; UKRALIA, LLC, a Nevada limited liability company, Defendants and Appellees

No. 20230195

Appeal from the District Court of McKenzie County, Northwest Judicial District, the Honorable Daniel S. El-Dweek, Judge.

AFFIRMED IN PART AND REVERSED IN PART, AND REMANDED.

Opinion of the Court by Crothers, Justice.

William E. Sparks (argued), The Woodlands, TX, and Joshua A. Swanson (appeared), Fargo, ND, for plaintiff and appellant.

Bryan L. Van Grinsven (argued), Englewood, CO, and Bryan L. Van Grinsven (appeared), Minot, ND, for defendants and appellees.

2345567ÿ9ÿ 6  6 ÿÿÿ ÿÿ

!"#$%!&'ÿ()&#*+%,ÿ -.1/ÿ12344567ÿ89:;ÿ<226<=>ÿ?@3Aÿ<ÿBCDEA694ÿ6946@6Dÿ59ÿ?<F3@ÿ3?ÿ4G6ÿH<@59<ÿ D6?69D<94>;ÿI6ÿ<??5@Aÿ59ÿ2<@4ÿ:39:=CD59Eÿ4G6ÿD5>4@5:4ÿ:3C@4ÿD5Dÿ934ÿ6@@ÿJG69ÿ54ÿ KC5646Dÿ454=6ÿ43ÿD5>2C46Dÿ35=ÿ<9DÿE<>ÿ5946@6>4>ÿ59ÿ?<F3@ÿ3?ÿ4G6ÿH<@59<ÿD6?69D<94>ÿ <9Dÿ<J<@D6Dÿ4G6Aÿ<443@96Lÿ?66>;ÿI6ÿ@6F6@>6ÿ59ÿ2<@4ÿ:39:=CD59Eÿ4G6ÿ:3C@4ÿ6@@6Dÿ JG69ÿ54ÿ3@D6@6Dÿ1234456ÿ43ÿ2<Lÿ939M=6E<=ÿ:3>4>;ÿI6ÿ@6A<9Dÿ4G6ÿ:<>6ÿ?3@ÿ4G6ÿ :3C@4ÿ43ÿ@6:<=:C=<46ÿ54>ÿ:3>4ÿ<J<@DÿJ54G3C4ÿ939M=6E<=ÿ:3>4>ÿ<9Dÿ43ÿ:39>5D6@ÿ4G6ÿ NOPQROÿTUVURTORWXYÿPUZ[UXWÿV\PÿOTTQWQ\RO]ÿOWW\PRU^ÿVUUXÿORTÿ]U_O]ÿ̀\XWXaÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ 8ÿÿ

-.b/ÿ1234456ÿ<9Dÿ54>ÿ>3=6ÿ>G<@6G3=D6@7ÿ4G6ÿcdeÿf5F59Eÿg@C>47ÿ>C6Dÿ4G6ÿH<@59<ÿ D6?69D<94>ÿ59ÿbhb1;ÿgG65@ÿ:3A2=<594ÿ<==6E6Dÿ4G6ÿH<@59<ÿD6?69D<94>ÿ5A2@326@=Lÿ :=<5A6Dÿ454=6ÿ43ÿ35=ÿ<9DÿE<>ÿ5946@6>4>ÿ39:6ÿ3J96DÿiLÿjDJ<@Dÿk<F5>7ÿJG3ÿ?3@A6Dÿ 1234456ÿ<9DÿC>6Dÿ54ÿ<>ÿ<ÿG3=D59Eÿ:3A2<9L;ÿgG6ÿ:3A2=<594ÿ<==6E6Dÿ1234456ÿ3J96Dÿ WlUÿTQXm[WUTÿQRWUPUXWXÿORTÿNOPQROYXÿOXXUPWQ\RXÿ\Vÿ\nRUPXlQmÿnUPUÿVPO[T[]URWaÿ gG6ÿH<@59<ÿD6?69D<94>ÿA3F6Dÿ43ÿD5>A5>>ÿ4G6ÿ:3A2=<594;ÿgG6ÿD5>4@5:4ÿ:3C@4ÿ E@<946Dÿ4G6ÿA34539ÿ59ÿ2<@4;ÿgG6ÿ:3C@4ÿ@C=6Dÿcdeÿ=<:o6Dÿ>4<9D59Eÿ<9Dÿ D5>A5>>6Dÿ54ÿ?@3Aÿ4G6ÿ:<>6;ÿgG6ÿ:3C@4ÿ<=>3ÿD5>A5>>6DÿF<@53C>ÿ:=<5A>ÿi@3CEG4ÿiLÿ 12344567ÿ6p:624ÿ?3@ÿ<ÿKC564ÿ454=6ÿ:=<5Aÿ<9Dÿ<ÿ:=<5Aÿ?3@ÿC9BC>4ÿ69@5:GA694;ÿÿ -.q/ÿgG6ÿH<@59<ÿD6?69D<94>ÿ?5=6Dÿ<9ÿ<9>J6@ÿ<9Dÿ:3C946@:=<5A;ÿgG6Lÿ<==6E6Dÿ H<@59<ÿ6946@6Dÿ5943ÿ<9ÿ35=ÿ<9DÿE<>ÿ5946@6>4ÿ<:KC5>54539ÿF694C@6ÿJ54Gÿk<F5>ÿ<9Dÿ <DF<9:6DÿG5Aÿ:<>G;ÿgG6Lÿ:=<5A6Dÿ4G6ÿD6<=ÿ?<5=6Dÿ<9Dÿ@6>C=46Dÿ59ÿ<ÿ>644=6A694ÿ <E@66A694ÿ59ÿJG5:Gÿk<F5>ÿ2@3A5>6Dÿ43ÿ:39F6Lÿ35=ÿ<9DÿE<>ÿ5946@6>4>ÿ43ÿH<@59<;ÿ gG6Lÿ<==6E6Dÿk<F5>ÿ<9Dÿ1234456ÿ:39F6L6Dÿ4G6ÿD5>2C46Dÿ5946@6>4>ÿ43ÿr<5C=M H<@59<7ÿf4D;ÿF5<ÿ<9ÿ<>>5E9A694ÿA<D6ÿ59ÿbh1s;ÿgG6ÿH<@59<ÿD6?69D<94>ÿ:=<5A6Dÿ k<F5>7ÿJG3ÿD56Dÿ4G<4ÿ><A6ÿL6<@7ÿ<E@66Dÿ43ÿ@6:3@Dÿ4G6ÿ<>>5E9A694ÿiC4ÿ?<5=6Dÿ43ÿ D3ÿ>3;ÿgG6Lÿ2=6<D6Dÿ:=<5A>ÿ?3@ÿi@6<:Gÿ3?ÿ:394@<:47ÿKC564ÿ454=67ÿ:39F6@>5397ÿC9BC>4ÿ 69@5:GA6947ÿ<9Dÿ>=<9D6@ÿ3?ÿ454=6;ÿ1234456ÿ<9>J6@6DÿiLÿ2=6<D59Eÿ<ÿ9CAi6@ÿ3?ÿ <??5@A<45F6ÿD6?69>6>7ÿ59:=CD59Eÿ=<:G6>;ÿÿÿÿ

1ÿ

2345ÿ789ÿ ÿÿ89ÿÿ899ÿ98ÿÿ ÿ 9 9ÿ 9 9 ÿ ÿÿÿ9 99 !9ÿÿ"  9ÿ9# 99ÿ#ÿ89ÿ $%9&9ÿÿ'()*'+(',-ÿ*//0)(1ÿ2ÿ3*42'5ÿ67*-(ÿ328(ÿ299(2'-ÿ*3ÿ #9 ÿÿ 9ÿ ÿ8  ÿ9: 9 ÿ9 ÿÿ98ÿ 9ÿ"  9ÿ 99 ÿ;:8 ÿ<1ÿÿ#9ÿ ÿ#9 ÿÿÿ ÿÿÿ9 ÿ #9ÿ !9ÿ89ÿ 9 ÿ99 ÿÿÿ"  9ÿÿ99 ÿ;:8 ÿ<=ÿ 88ÿÿÿ!9 ÿÿ89ÿ #9ÿ8ÿÿ # 9 ÿÿ9ÿ ÿ 9 ÿÿ$%9&9ÿÿ789ÿÿ99!9 ÿ8ÿ9:8 ÿÿ 9 9 ÿ89ÿ99 ÿ>! ÿ8 ÿÿ99 ÿ89ÿÿ #9ÿ89ÿ 9 ÿÿ89ÿ89ÿ#9ÿÿ9ÿÿ89ÿÿ9 9ÿÿ9 9 ÿ89ÿ 820?(+ÿ47(ÿ*'0@032?ÿ2--0@38(34ÿ4*ÿ47(ÿ'()*'+(',-ÿ*//0)(ÿAB4ÿ04ÿ62-ÿ'(C()4(+DÿE(ÿ 9 9 ÿ89ÿ89ÿ99 ÿÿ 8#9ÿÿ89ÿ #9ÿ88ÿ 99 ÿ89ÿ 99 ÿF9ÿÿ89ÿ!9)(1ÿ4*ÿ)*89?5ÿ6047ÿ47(ÿ'()*'+(',-ÿ82'@03ÿ23+ÿ  99ÿ9G9#9 ÿÿ 23H5ÿ789ÿ ÿÿ999 ÿÿ9ÿÿ!ÿÿ89ÿÿ99  ÿ789ÿ ÿ89ÿ89ÿ #9ÿ#ÿ>! ÿ ÿ"  9ÿÿIÿJ ÿÿ ! ÿ789ÿÿ ÿÿ# 9ÿ'0K(3(',-ÿ(''*'-ÿ67(3ÿ2?4('03@ÿ47(ÿ 2--0@38(341ÿ23+ÿ47(ÿ(''*'-ÿ6('(ÿ+(4'08(342?ÿ4*ÿ47(ÿL2'032ÿ+(/(3+234-,ÿ 034('(-4-DÿM7(ÿ)*B'4ÿ-424(+ÿ04ÿN+((8-ÿ'(/*'8240*3ÿ4*ÿA(ÿ47(ÿ9'*9('ÿ)B'(DOÿ789ÿ ÿ99# 9 ÿ"  9ÿ99 ÿ99!9 ÿP4<QR1<14ÿÿ9!99ÿ#ÿ89ÿ 9 ÿ99 ÿ ÿ9 ÿ89ÿÿ 99  ÿ #9ÿÿ8ÿ #ÿM7(ÿ)*B'4ÿ2?-*ÿ7(?+ÿ04-ÿCB+@8(34ÿN0-ÿA03+03@ÿB9*3OÿSTUÿA()2B-(ÿ04ÿ /*B3+ÿN*AK0*B-ÿ9'0K045OÿA(46((3ÿV9*440(ÿ23+ÿSTUDÿ789ÿÿÿ9 9 ÿ89ÿ ÿ99  ÿ99ÿ9 9 ÿÿ 9ÿ99ÿ ÿ ÿ9 ÿÿÿ! ÿ ÿ89ÿ #9ÿ789ÿÿ99  ÿ9G9ÿ9 ÿÿ 9#9ÿÿ  ÿ 8ÿ9:8 ÿÿ 23W5ÿ"  9ÿ 99 ÿ99ÿ89ÿ ÿÿ999 ÿF #9ÿ ÿ89ÿ 89ÿÿÿ 9ÿ89ÿÿ99  ,ÿ 9#9ÿÿ99ÿ ÿ ÿ X9ÿ9# ÿ9# 9 ÿ89ÿ9ÿ ÿ89ÿ ÿÿ999 ÿF #9ÿ 789ÿF #9ÿ 9ÿ47(ÿNL2'032ÿY--0@38(34ÿ0-ÿK2?0+ÿ23+ÿ(3/*')(2A?(ÿ-BAC()4ÿ 4*ÿ'(/*'8240*31Oÿ2 ÿÿ ÿÿ89ÿ#9ÿ89ÿÿ9 ÿ89ÿÿ 99  ÿP=4=QZ[<Wÿÿ 9ÿ99ÿ ÿPH[4[HHWÿÿ ÿ"  9ÿ9 ÿ ÿ9 ÿ 9ÿÿ 9ÿ ÿÿ 9#9ÿ 99ÿ9ÿ 1ÿ

22ÿ

3456ÿ89 ÿ ÿ ÿÿÿ 9ÿ   ÿÿ ÿ ÿ!"ÿ""#ÿ$%ÿ&ÿ"' ÿ89 ÿ( ÿ )ÿ ÿÿ99 (*ÿ +ÿ,-.ÿ ÿ ÿ/ ÿÿ ÿÿÿ)ÿ  *ÿ) ÿÿÿ &0ÿ&%122"2"&13ÿ4!"ÿ01%#1"#ÿ5ÿ"6&$ÿ5"ÿ122170ÿ18%ÿ15"ÿ1ÿ9%ÿ"&17ÿ &0ÿ$77ÿ0197&0#:ÿ ;2%ÿ1%ÿ12217ÿ5"<ÿ1ÿ9%ÿ"(=ÿ ÿÿ0ÿ5&%#&%>0ÿ5ÿ51ÿ 1"ÿ"6&$#ÿ!%#"ÿÿ71"7?ÿ""%!0ÿ01%#1"#ÿ5ÿ"6&$@ÿ1%#ÿ &0ÿ%7!0&%0ÿ5ÿ71$ÿ1"ÿ5!77?ÿ"6&$1973ÿAÿ5&%#&%>ÿ5ÿ51ÿ&0ÿ 71"7?ÿ""%!0ÿ&5ÿ&ÿ&0ÿ&%#!#ÿ9?ÿ1%ÿ""%!0ÿ6&$ÿ5ÿÿ71$@ÿ &5ÿ"ÿ&0ÿ% ÿ6&#%ÿÿ0!22 "ÿ&@ÿ"ÿ&5@ÿ15"ÿ"6&$&%>ÿ177ÿ5ÿÿ 6&#%@ÿ&0ÿB !"ÿ&0ÿ%6&%#ÿ1ÿ<&018ÿ10ÿ9%ÿ<1#3ÿ2%ÿ1ÿ 9%ÿ"&17@ÿÿ#&0"&ÿ!"ÿ&0ÿÿ#"<&%"ÿ5ÿ"#&9&7&?ÿ&00!0ÿ 1%#ÿ$ÿ$&77ÿ% ÿ0%#C>!00ÿÿ#&0"&ÿ!"ÿ%ÿ&0ÿ"#&9&7&?ÿ #"<&%1&%03ÿD&%#&%>0ÿ 5ÿÿ"&17ÿ!"ÿ1"ÿ2"0!<2&67?ÿ ""3Eÿ FGHIJÿLMINOPÿQRSIMJSÿTRGUVÿWVÿXIGMÿYZ[\IGJ]ÿTRV@ÿ^_^`ÿabÿc^@ÿ4ÿ̀_@ÿdefÿa3g3^#ÿ `^fÿhi! &%>ÿjZTIGWHMÿWVÿLHG[kP@ÿ^_^_ÿabÿ^c5@ÿ4ÿd@ÿde^ÿa3g3^#ÿfcl3ÿ 222ÿ

34f6ÿA0ÿ1ÿ"0 7#ÿ<1"@ÿm2 &ÿ180ÿ>%"17ÿ&00!ÿ$&ÿÿ#&0"&ÿ ÿ9 C"&17ÿ"#"3ÿm2 &ÿ100"0@ÿ1%#ÿ$ÿ1>"@ÿÿ#&0"&ÿ!"ÿ1# 2#ÿ ÿD1"&%1ÿ#5%#1%ÿ2"2 0#ÿ"#"ÿ%1"7?@ÿ&5ÿ% ÿ%&"7?@ÿ6"91&<3ÿm2 &ÿ  ÿ=ÿ;noÿ ÿ=ÿ ÿp ÿq ÿ%!07?ÿ100!<#ÿ177ÿ51!17ÿ 1%#ÿ7>17ÿ%7!0&%0ÿ&%ÿ516"ÿ5ÿD1"&%1ÿ#02&ÿÿ6"$7<&%>ÿ6&#%ÿÿ  ÿ*rEÿs ÿtrprurq rÿvrw=ÿ ÿÿÿ*ÿÿ99 ÿ 5ÿ2"2 0#ÿ5&%#&%>0ÿ 5ÿ51ÿ1%#ÿ%7!0&%0ÿ 5ÿ71$ÿÿ!%073ÿgÿ16ÿ "21#7?ÿx2"00#ÿ#&0122"617ÿ5ÿ!"0ÿ1# 2&%>ÿ2"2 0#ÿ5&%#&%>0ÿ1%#ÿ %7!0&%0ÿ$ 70173ÿYHHyÿHVzVyÿ{HGP[I\ÿWVÿ|NOOPRO@ÿ^_^^ÿabÿ`ce@ÿ4ÿ`f@ÿdf_ÿ a3g3^#ÿ}_~ÿXPJIJHÿRÿ€MGHZ[J@ÿ^_^_ÿabÿ^5@ÿ4ÿd@ÿd1fÿa3g3^#ÿ`e`~ÿ‚IMHÿXƒUMVyÿ „„TÿWVÿ NHUMHG@ÿ^_`fÿabÿ^5`@ÿ4ÿf@ÿd^_ÿa3g3^#ÿ5e_~ÿ†OÿGHÿjV‡V@ÿ^__cÿabÿ`d@ÿ 4ÿ̀`@ÿ5_dÿa3g3^#ÿ``3ÿA7 !>ÿ$ÿ#&0122"6ÿ5ÿÿ2"1&@ÿ$ÿ$&77ÿ% ÿ ˆÿÿÿÿ  ÿÿ ÿ(ÿ+ÿÿ ÿ 9 ÿ99 ÿ

1ÿ

23453467ÿ82ÿ29 ÿ945ÿ84 73847ÿ82ÿ9ÿÿÿÿ!"#1ÿ$%ÿ!!&ÿ'ÿ(ÿ ()*ÿ$+!5ÿ&,*ÿ -.ÿÿ

/'01ÿ348 35ÿ966 57ÿ75ÿ53763 ÿ8 6ÿ56655ÿ754ÿ3ÿ8 3555ÿ35ÿ82ÿ75ÿ 5374 55ÿ3456577ÿ34ÿ29986ÿ82ÿ75ÿ:96349ÿ552545947ÿ348 35ÿ977567ÿ75ÿ8 6ÿ 3;468456<ÿ65355ÿ84ÿ75ÿ977364;54 ÿ75ÿ8 6ÿ3648655ÿ5935545ÿ82ÿ286656<ÿ945ÿ 75ÿ75 5;54ÿ96655;54ÿ97ÿ=659755ÿ86ÿ;8532355ÿ378 ÿ84735569384ÿ >ÿ

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

SPOTTIE v. BAIUL-FARINA, 2024 ND 88 (N.D. 2024).

2024 ND 88 (SPOTTIE v. BAIUL-FARINA) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Hoff v. City of Burlington
2025 ND 62 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2025)
Olson v. Olson
2024 ND 224 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2024)
Wollan v. Innovis Health
2024 ND 169 (North Dakota Supreme Court, 2024)