Southern Underwriters v. Gallagher

116 S.W.2d 450, 1938 Tex. App. LEXIS 574
CourtCourt of Appeals of Texas
DecidedApril 1, 1938
DocketNo. 1770.
StatusPublished
Cited by2 cases

This text of 116 S.W.2d 450 (Southern Underwriters v. Gallagher) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Texas primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Southern Underwriters v. Gallagher, 116 S.W.2d 450, 1938 Tex. App. LEXIS 574 (Tex. Ct. App. 1938).

Opinions

GRISSOM, Justice.

Plaintiff, Gallagher, obtained a judgment against defendant, Southern Underwriters, under the Texas Workmen’s Compensation *451 Law, Vernon’s Ann.Civ.St. art. 8306 et seq., for the loss of a thumb while working for the Liberty Oil'& Drilling Company., Inc., about March 10, 1936, in New Mexico. Plaintiff alleged that at said time he was “an employee of the Liberty Oil and Drilling Company, Inc., in Winkler County, Texas, in the capacity of a tool dresser; that the Liberty Oil and Drilling Company, Inc., his said employer, was at said time engaged in the work of drilling and producing oil and by-products therefrom, which said work was in the usual course of employment of said employer.”

The question involved necessitates a construction of article 8306, section 19, subsection 1, R.S.1925, as amended, Vernon’s Ann.Civ.St. art. 8306, § 19, subsec. 1, and the application of the facts of the case thereto. The .question is presented whether or not at the time of his injury Gallagher was a Texas employee, or employee in Texas, under a contract of hiring who was temporarily sent out of Texas to perform labor or services for his employer.

Plaintiff testified, among other things, as follows:

“Q. Where and when was it that you first ran across 'any member of the Liberty Oil and Drilling Company and talked to them, if you did, about going to work for them? A. At Kermit, Winkler County, Texas.
“Q. Who was it you talked to at that time? A. Well, I talked to both Mr. H. Harold Berquest, the President of the Company and I talked to Mr. Lunceford, the Drilling Superintendent.
“Q. You say that conversation took place in Kermit, Texas? A. Yes sir.
“Q. How close is that to the New Mexico line? A. Winkler County and Lea County border; that’s about, I guess, twelve miles from the line. * * *
“Q. Now Joe, what if anything was said between you and these representátives of the Liberty Oil and Drilling Company, and yourself, with reference to or about your going to work for them? A. Well, the first time I talked to them about going to work they were going to drill a deep well there near Pecos, Texas. I spoke to them about going over there on that job and they said, ‘Well, when we get ready to start we will send you over there, near Jal. * *
“Q. Did you go to work on this well near Pecos, Texas? A. No sir; they started this one over here and said, ‘You go over there. When we get ready to rig up we will transfer you back here.’. * * ,*
“A. Well, he asked me, he said, ‘I will send you over on this deep test in Pecos County, which will be another job.’ I said, ‘I would rather work in Texas than in New Mexico,’ I said, ‘for several reasons. I live in Texas; my family lives in Kermit and I would prefer a job in Texas, and various reasons.’ He said, ‘Well, you go on over there:’ He said, ‘We carry Texas compensation’ and I took the job and went over on those premises.
“Q. Did you go to work for them in Pecos? A. No sir. I was injured before that job started. * * * .
“Q. When did you talk to Mr. Lunce-ford prior to the time you reported for work on the first day of March, in jal, New Mexico? A. I talked to him the day before I reported for work.
“Q. Where did you talk to Mr. Lunce-ford the day before? A. At his home .in Kermit, Texas. * * *
“Q. What, if anything, was said about the amount of money that you would get for doing the work? A. Eight dollars a day, was the wage scale. ' * * *
“Q. Did you have any conversation with Mr. Lunceford about when you were to report for work? A. Yes sir.
“Q. When, if any date, when if any time, did he tell you to report to the Liberty Drilling Company in Jal, New Mexico? A. I talked to him on the last day of February and he says, ‘You report in the morning for duty, and go to work rigging up.’
“Q. Where were you to report for duty? A. I reported in Jal, New Mexico, in Lea County.
“Q. In compliance with that conversation did you report for work the next morning in Jal, New Mexico? A. Yes sir.
“Q. Where did you stay during all of the time that you were working in Jal, New Mexico? A. I stayed in Kermit, Texas.
“Q. Would you come back there every night? A. Yes sir. * * *
“Q. What did he tell you that you were to receive? A. Eight dollars a day for eight hours.
“Q. And you went to work, as I understand, for the Liberty Oil & Drilling Company there at Jal, New Mexico, March the first, 1936? A. Yes sir.
“Q. When was it, if at any time, after that that you received an injury, while *452 working for the Liberty Oil & Drilling Company? A. It was about eleven o’clock A. M. March the tenth. * * *
“Q. What kind of work did the Liberty Oil & Drilling Company do? A. They were drilling contractors and independent oil operators.
“Q. Did they have any equipment or production property in Texas that you know of? * * * A. I could not say that they had any production; they had tools and drilling rigs running.
“Q. In Texas? A. Yes sir.
“Q. You knew that of your own knowledge? A. Yes sir. * * *
“Q. Was that similar, please state whether or not the work that you were doing on this particular well in Jal, New Mexico, was similar to other work that the Liberty Oil and Drilling Company was doing? A. The same work, yes sir. * * *
“A. Well, it was in January that I talked with Mr. Lunceford. I saw the Liberty Oil and Drilling Co. sign out there in his tool yard and I spoke to him there. * *
“Q. You say that conversation occurred in his yard? A. Yes sir, in his home.
“Q. At his home at Kermit? A. Yes sir.
“Q. Well, he didn’t agree to employ you at that time, did he? A. First opening he had. * * *
“Q. What did Mr. Lunceford tell you? A. He told me he had a job for me.
“Q. Where did he say it was? A. He said report for duty the next morning over at, in this Lea County, New Mexico, near Jal.
“Q. Was anything else said in connection with your going to work for him? A. Yes sir.
“Q. What else did he say? 'A. He said that they were figuring on starting this deep test in Pecos County and he would transfer me to that.
“Q. What else did he say about working at Jal at that time? A. lie said he only wanted me to stay there until they started this test and he would transfer me back.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Southern Underwriters v. Gallagher
136 S.W.2d 590 (Texas Supreme Court, 1940)
Associated Indemnity Corporation v. Scott
103 F.2d 203 (Fifth Circuit, 1939)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
116 S.W.2d 450, 1938 Tex. App. LEXIS 574, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/southern-underwriters-v-gallagher-texapp-1938.