Smith v. Ralph Dinapoli Landscaping, Inc.

Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York

Smith v. Ralph Dinapoli Landscaping, Inc.

111 A.D.3d 841, 977 N.Y.S.2d 663

Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York·Decided November 20, 2013·Published·Cited by 7 cases

Opinion

In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR 5239, inter alia, to determine that certain real property is free and clear of a judgment lien asserted by Ralph Dinapoli Landscaping, Inc., doing business as Country Landscaping, the appeal is from an order of the Supreme Court, Suffolk County (Pines, J.), dated May 1, 2012, which granted the petition, vacated the execution of the judgment lien, and directed the Suffolk County Sheriff to release the real property from the levy.

Ordered that the order is affirmed, with costs.

“CPLR 5203 (a) gives priority to a judgment creditor over [842] subsequent transferees with regard to the debtor’s real property in a county where the judgment has been docketed with the clerk of that county” (Matter of Accounts Retrievable Sys., LLC v Conway, 83 AD3d 1052, 1053 [2011]; see CPLR 5203 [a]; Matter of Soressi v SWF, L.P., 81 AD3d 1143, 1144 [2011]). Pursuant to CPLR 5018 (c), a judgment is docketed when the clerk makes an entry “under the surname of the judgment debtor . . . consisting] of . . . the name and last known address of [the] judgment debtor” (CPLR 5018 [c] [1] [i]; see Matter of Accounts Retrievable Sys., LLC v Conway, 83 AD3d at 1053). “ ‘Once docketed, a judgment becomes a lien on the real property of the debtor in that county’ ” (Matter of Accounts Retrievable Sys., LLC v Conway, 83 AD3d at 1053, quoting Matter of Soressi v SWF, L.P., 81 AD3d at 1144). Here, the petitioners’ submissions demonstrated that the judgment obtained by the appellant was not docketed under the correct surname of a title owner of the subject property. Therefore, no valid lien against the subject real property was created (see We Buy Now, LLC v Cadlerock Joint Venture, LP, 46 AD3d 549, 550 [2007]; cf. H. R. & C. Co., Inc. v Smith, 242 NY 267 [1926]; Matter of Accounts Retrievable Sys., LLC v Conway, 83 AD3d at 1053).

The appellant’s remaining contentions are either without merit or not properly before this Court.

Accordingly, the Supreme Court properly granted the petition, vacated the execution of the judgment lien, and directed the Suffolk County Sheriff to release the property from the levy. Eng, PJ., Dickerson, Chambers and Hall, JJ., concur.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR 5239, inter alia, to determine that certain real property is free and clear of a judgment lien asserted by Ralph Dinapoli Landscaping, Inc., doing business as Country Landscaping, the appeal is from an order of the Supreme Court, Suffolk County (Pines, J.), dated May 1, 2012, which granted the petition, vacated the execution of the judgment lien, and directed the Suffolk County Sheriff to release the real property from the levy.

Ordered that the order is affirmed, with costs.

“CPLR 5203 (a) gives priority to a judgment creditor over [842] subsequent transferees with regard to the debtor’s real property in a county where the judgment has been docketed with the clerk of that county” (Matter of Accounts Retrievable Sys., LLC v Conway, 83 AD3d 1052, 1053 [2011]; see CPLR 5203 [a]; Matter of Soressi v SWF, L.P., 81 AD3d 1143, 1144 [2011]). Pursuant to CPLR 5018 (c), a judgment is docketed when the clerk makes an entry “under the surname of the judgment debtor . . . consisting] of . . . the name and last known address of [the] judgment debtor” (CPLR 5018 [c] [1] [i]; see Matter of Accounts Retrievable Sys., LLC v Conway, 83 AD3d at 1053). “ ‘Once docketed, a judgment becomes a lien on the real property of the debtor in that county’ ” (Matter of Accounts Retrievable Sys., LLC v Conway, 83 AD3d at 1053, quoting Matter of Soressi v SWF, L.P., 81 AD3d at 1144). Here, the petitioners’ submissions demonstrated that the judgment obtained by the appellant was not docketed under the correct surname of a title owner of the subject property. Therefore, no valid lien against the subject real property was created (see We Buy Now, LLC v Cadlerock Joint Venture, LP, 46 AD3d 549, 550 [2007]; cf. H. R. & C. Co., Inc. v Smith, 242 NY 267 [1926]; Matter of Accounts Retrievable Sys., LLC v Conway, 83 AD3d at 1053).

The appellant’s remaining contentions are either without merit or not properly before this Court.

Accordingly, the Supreme Court properly granted the petition, vacated the execution of the judgment lien, and directed the Suffolk County Sheriff to release the property from the levy. Eng, PJ., Dickerson, Chambers and Hall, JJ., concur.

Smith v. Ralph Dinapoli Landscaping, Inc., 111 A.D.3d 841, 977 N.Y.S.2d 663 (N.Y. Ct. App. 2013).

Pincite

111 A.D.3d 841 (Smith v. Ralph Dinapoli Landscaping, Inc.) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Opinion

Related