Smith, Joe Dale

CourtCourt of Appeals of Texas
DecidedAugust 12, 2015
DocketWR-83,726-01
StatusPublished

This text of Smith, Joe Dale (Smith, Joe Dale) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Texas primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Smith, Joe Dale, (Tex. Ct. App. 2015).

Opinion

§?>\,€ \>!QQ®& §

`l \Q'>c(\ §1<\0$`\§\05 <`<\\5%9~\€-` ®‘?_\\\\F\Qb%oo m \MQ_GQ_M“% %OU M\ ` %:>Mwm_ /%MQM\\¢ \\Q§ m m \\.cr\ wqu QQ '§<>wv.v@k :\\QQ\ \x w ><\, \Qx\@@-S 3<\Q:z; DO_Y M m®, OQ\ Q&QQ\)QS Q)£\% Q`Q§QG(\SQ. 1¥ '\3 COQ'\\QO§X

5}\~S Cb\\>€f\ §(\O\ QQOI\~Q. lc\m O~S\<\V\<\©\Y`Y\QA \§00§:\\0 \\Q K`{\G<\€>L\rv\® \\f\£)\\ 11\/\ \ N C\QSM;> 03\\\¢\1\ Q\\<’@c> \\0~3 § CQ>Q\§@Q &\\<\ \.Q\\Q@S lwe SQ\\- 1@<;@§10@€\¥1. \(QQ_“\\/\»QM m\< \m\ \/@> m wm Q\ Q@;z\=§\<\QQ § \\Qc\.

m<;\§w\\%

¢M€. M

RECEi\/ED |N cOuRT oF cR!P.'nNAL APPEALS

AU~S 12 2015

AbefAc‘-JS?&,@E@U

Wl ` ` ' 'Q@¢Q_x Q>Q ae_\m\c\¢\\ g@pwj _ , v Q,Q '\Q.¥®

Qm%e Nc> .QY_’L'LQL<§

0 . \/

[;.~¢ Q@QQ id

`bc>e ’©c\\QQQ\\L\:\\~`J \f. '_\\~0_ 3\@.\§. Q>(/ \Q:l~C\S ws@<\w\\ |®Q.mw.\\

B,QQ>;\\\U\\(\Q\ \\.§`\ l§lQQQ£\\\\\cb»-`. J

's%*“ 5\£>‘.@.&\\ max Q> '\Q_~l~c~%

JQQ,\\\`.G C\ C§un<£_\\ Q& mc\§\dm\":¢~§` \/

_ QQ§QQQ\<» Q\\¢5 w\>\x\x\® d 30 § "bc,`\fl_ 3 {\/\\ \€ \r;

C\ws€ r\) s . Q

joe

5069¢§9§- SM§v\ W §\\°v 3%\"` DC\"~C\¢\\

'\I, (D`®\\>\\\~/ ,”\Q~¢c~§ "%Q.Ouaw (,Ouf.\\~

Q:s\¢- L\¢

\N \S`QY.. O(`

Qa%<`>@m¢\§

%, ?\§:\\\~&Q`S Q\3\\1¢>\\€><\ Q®Z_ \)\\<2_\\ §§ ("N§w£\§m\~.%

`T¢ ‘v§% v\¢mc>se,\_z au©\ne c>Q §§\Q lmun C,cv\~<\&% mw.~ ';§0& ”\)m_Y-_ B’N\\T\-\> V`gl_<>r\<>€_~, QQ_@' 545 m 'rm'; -. §§9\) E~§'\VZ_ED 999 \\>&>A\Q£YZEO (‘_\\§\)SE §§ (§CT\DN 9mm Q\LES 1113

DQA(Y\`\\~I§L ‘\\®L\Q_%'\\Cm Q@Q_ \§d‘{\`\’\ c:.§- €\\Q\w§§§?<\\§%% ?u §Q§<\C\Q \\.9‘11 §EC§\@\> 3 LC) QQ `\\\Q U"TE\MA§ Cob€ c€ CQ,;~\;M\\ ?%&9@\2£;7 mm Lm@\'<§ 9\\0\,_~. )§§e amax T§E Qc\\c>u.:s\<\l[\°. ' -'

§ QE)_Q§GQ 1 '\¢,1>.\ z<>e_'wm_; wm y "ma_§ §§ \va_ou§ \3 m <:>QQ&w-:)ee \NL\>`M€Q_UEQ m we ’\e>AQ.TME~T se Q_Q_\'mmm_fh>%§:w£ wm . 16 §WE€>&\N(`/\ "QCO SE,~ \M§C> (’_§.N §£ LC>CX§§ED §§ §\\\?_ED‘\>N\T'/ '2_\0\ P/v\ Séczl‘l»» 1993<>\’\?%\<2\£, ’\`E><¢S/ ?&Sé?

\ 91 iam 02 \\\>\5 &~L\d§\>%§e9 \§:\w %Ew\m\£$ \§99 \§or> m cx\§~e\z wmme

§§ \_§\M,

'\.SS we §§c§ wm §§ §§ Cc>vc\§>&\\eci\ \% m\\\:$§£\€_\\q\_\, wm

G:SL'Q£§\N\EQ_ -\»¢ f\e\\p@$. °rll£€> §Q.T. \\.(>’+ S/_-'€§tor\ %(é'\ '\QQ(§L>\Q/;S QQSOAOA&<\\, §0 \N\\m£c\c\\ g|M §Q_&\\§\w\\§ \c> §990, CQL>Q§ c>\$ ('_Q_\\v\\<\<§\

§§’\>QE<§\S §§ a<>W 9% §\<\E %QQ\\C_Q\ @<\ 9;@\\ §§ \§9&>>¢;95 CC>Q.'P@"> , \§c\>/ \ANS;,UCQS c\\eo~ 901\ 9 U-;Q\~€ 09§& v_ea\§\ mm §v\e C\m\§ oQQ.~ w\\\¢;\n §§\c\§ ‘Q\ <\M\L~ was <\\mme, \Q §\\E C§»\>\LL\§\\(\ COQQ§ de`€\c§€$ §\’\c\§

“'\\§e®; mae u<> \<~,Suea §§ §& ?_&§e\\>€©. ms C<>?\/ QQ §\\e \AQQ\\L\>\:U\ 902

\\l\<;\>< ‘@,<; \;®em CM>QS-,- w\/ umw ~;\\c-;<§-, AN§ 9 Ce¢\\£\@me

Q~F_C;§z\\&\ §\\E ’Q)?\\E \>Q<;<\ ud\\¢\<\ \\Q\\ Q\<\E>\\'\Kc\ w_\'&® wohl X\&.\)Q ‘ \Q \\\~\ Lm\v.\ Q§ §99@~\% %y Qe§gmc§e¢\§ 969 QQ \QQ(§ ’€>\/ 3\@\\\§¢1,, Qe\\§ QSZ_ @99\6 §\A\)e Q.e& e\)\e© m§\t€ Q

)Cm§ o€ C,Q_:w\zn@\ §Q\>QA\B. §C, 1

‘Q,€SQQC\QEC\\

'2,9\ §Qos\®x\§\, Q\>~QQ_\| \, ‘SBNES z m \§€V_ /'e\\$ CAQ%¢\§¢ §§ ”O`\§\Q\C_>< ("_`\€Q_\< c>§ 23me Lm®sz "Y E>L('\S m3 9 C<\\\\`.‘b\esz.:c\\' Au\\/ §G <&Qc\wz 9mm <\>0_1@@2»§

§\\ Q)\\W_V_ QQ\\QS \w\Qc>%QC) 0<\ \‘<\Q Q,\‘l<\< '\30\/ L_(>,\>`) {JQQ_SQ>W\;¢¢, Tc> ‘\' (’,C,P § \\.01 bee "¢»LC'> T<> \MM<-:Cx\¢\\@\`/

x<),<><\zm\ --\Q> \\;\Q_ m@< <>~< L §§ QU\>V Q><; \\\Q, §§QQ\"CC\\`~QS\ C@5 w&\>\)%¢; §§r\y §<.\)‘bo.>Q_t§ G\QEV_\"&~.Q\>§& Q_Q.Q\\z ms §\\Q, §§,\Q, gs mc>§ v\AQQ \Q \é\\Q.QQm\ c.\`\<\~ Q®Q,\ Q§¢)_Q\QQ,€;, X \‘=o%o€% \ s %E &C . Q,¥\EQ\/L Bcse\)€§,; 9@\<\;\ a\\;v_\<», wm wm\\/ m\wb\z>@, %Q_@\) &C> §§ \§€V_ 9mm 09 maness 9§ 100 9®\\\%<2;»<>§\&)&\/; %Qow<\wmc\; T€)< 95“, #Q,Q,@\, - IG_.

"\\. 9:¢>\¢\\\0<\ c>\Q Q¢.Q\e \\.C>‘J¢ c><» \\\Q.To_¢c»s CQ<§Q ¢>.C C\z:m“\ nc\\ "\>\c,xq¢> §Q>;.Q\Q. \\.o`k QDQQ\\Q><\ ’b §§ §§ \\\Q_ '¥e`&!§$ QQ¢»Q <><; Q@. 9\/ <€Q\\\\<\cn w 9@<)\)`~@\<§ § L<§>\/ Q\‘? \\N)_ *§Q@\`~Cc»\?c)'n V<)v wax Q><; \>\%ev% Q»QQQ%~, '9»®\/ w\%wa Q\\o.c§`, m 9 tesz\z@\w\Q<>m vo\\\¢l\ \\\& Q\ ' \<\g\ wa\%_““@¢>& \Q> \\NL QM\ Q§ Q\?_:m\na\ §WQC~`Z w§\r'\\c\ §\Q, \\m\o, QQQ_%QQ:\>Q§ \)\/ \c\w 99:§ m\\\r\\r\ 9 mmle §\ me <§om l\~Q §O.\Q C§\\ mem MGAQ)Q“\QA\S anew Q.B\Q:§ §Q %Q, §cc\s\%cv\`~§\szi\.

391 ,9@95 C@@o$; 9\_\»\/ 9\.\33®@5 <>\\QQ\ `, 906 9 Qe@\\. c:u\\% § Q`§\<\% §§ 35\@ \§Q@c\ w<\`\ddr\ §\\Q~\ Q"<\Q\\\<\clz> \>:JQ,\`§ \\c\Q\GQ, L)~>Q,Q_!>_ %L/ QQ\O~>~Q_ ¥Q) C)§€C\/L ”SC>N€,§; ©‘\`9\<`\®< Q.\Q.<\<`, §@C>m<\v Q_cm\\>§>/; @~/ `LE@§`.Q\QQ\ (Y\c\:\QL\ (Q§\QQ&><§<\§ \Q>

§Q,\;(,\Q_ \\.O“‘¥ §QC_\§Q¢\ "a (C) c>\? §\\Q, C@<\Q_ §§ QQ_\MJ\L\\ QO

§CQ\>QQ\§Q CQQ\Q.S Q>Q §\x\§_ §§9\)& \Q,§\stz§ %?,Q \§-§\§A Q\\e© \§Q_,Q,Q_ §§

il>¢\\~§nz§€ “w' v\@o\)w\ ‘L§__ \§<.\Q\ 9mm W come @§Q: 9v weaan \LQ(LQ \N Q@Q_Q\\\ @Q~QQQSQ.

5.0'5' "ic> Q\c.\\@\, Q-Q,\L\\®Z` \AQSQQQQ\\>QQM Q`S Q'~Qfx\\>@%\¢ <;<><2, \mw\r\\. w\ ass v uaw QQ x\Q.AQ@\\U¢@\\ cea wax Q>\; . \\“%€Q'% QQQ’Q®"’ m§ °‘§\W Q‘\Q§>°,W w QL©:&:CC~&Q@ €QQ.\\:Y\c>\é\\Q_'CQ~\Q \§‘QO§\ w\`\<.\(\ Q\‘>¢\<\% u)c>$ xvon Tc> \`\\Q, §;m?,¥ 05 Q£.\q\:<\c~\ %QQQ<)\\% o . .- ‘3¢0\1 N§ 13 C\QM. ,Q`\&%~z, QQ>Q\QQ. \\»3 QQ.QQQ\\Q§\\/ Q\`>x @Q%Qonc&@<\x 0\\ <\@\:\QQ >€<\Q\x Q_Q\c,\Q,Q_ wgeg\<§ ;N\Q/ XA Q:<\¢\\<\c> web mm@ \<> \\\o, C;»Q\ Q><; QQ.‘-. mined §QQQ¢~\%, '

§ .OU( \>\% \cb Q\Qr>& <<`§~QQQQ;>`\&Q§\\/ Qo\

Q°\ QQSQG<\§ ©<-"i§""€§@g §§ *\R“QQ\`~Q$\\\O\\ %@ \>v€\>§ QM\W% md mw mng »? \\<\Q> \>. C\Q):~<;`:Q>.\Q, Qm&>§\Q,€>®Q \>QQ<\ \~>3<\\§,\<\ \\\w\ _C \§\A\<\Qr\ w<\%\y\<>d©ems Q<>Q_Q® .. m\@\\<\€_ \\Q\\§>‘\R \\<.\\> QQQJT\Q¢\\ 01 Q'>%\:Q(\c\§.ze c\`\\_3 C"X`O\\“b §@‘\Qé “O C,-C>"\Q\`/ m\\\n '\ €\< \>S QQCBQ, Q\§ LC\rv\\r\C\\ Q§\ B§C§.,. \3 §AQ¥\<\<:~ m %c~é> é\\\“% \d,\%o, Qg\\\QG> ‘\o \AQC<>\<\d tomm©<\) QQ\»Q_\Q%>/ Q

QQQ,M\QQ U\A QQQQ\>Q®`B ,,` _ _ ` \ 305 %SL\:Q\Q \\.<>'1- ‘§QQ\`~O<\ '%.LC) L\Qs>

C®©< GQQ\

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack