Skinner v. Spann

93 N.E. 1061, 175 Ind. 672, 1911 Ind. LEXIS 80
CourtIndiana Supreme Court
DecidedFebruary 21, 1911
DocketNo. 21,583
StatusPublished
Cited by36 cases

This text of 93 N.E. 1061 (Skinner v. Spann) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Indiana Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Skinner v. Spann, 93 N.E. 1061, 175 Ind. 672, 1911 Ind. LEXIS 80 (Ind. 1911).

Opinions

Jordan, J.

This is an appeal prosecuted by appellants Effie C. Skinner and Georgiana Smith, from a judgment in the Probate Court of Marion County, Indiana, whereby the last wills of James W. Brown and Agnes C. Brown, deceased, were construed and interpreted by that court. The proceedings were instituted b.y appellee Thomas H. Spann, the executor of the will of Agnes C. Brown. All persons concerned in the interpretation of either or both of these wills — so far as they were in controversy — were brought before the lower court by the complaint of the executor and by the five cross-complaints of defendants. The issues raised by these pleadings were in respect to the proper construction or interpretation of the respective wills. The facts alleged in the complaints in question, in relation to the real estate owned by James W. Brown and the property remaining on hand at the death of Agnes C. Brown, are substantially the same.

There was a special finding of facts by the lower court and conclusions of law thereon. To these conclusions, and each of them, appellants herein separately excepted. Over [676]*676their exceptions the court rendered its final judgment and decree, whereby it construed and interpreted the provisions of the two wills in controversy, substantially as follows: Said Agnes C. Brown, at the time of her death, was the absolute owner of all the personal estate of every kind and nature then in her possession, and which had been inventoried by her executor, Thomas H. Spann, except the sum of $15,600, in notes and money, arising from the sale of real estate sold by her under the power conferred by the will of James W. Brown. Prior to the death of Agnes C. Brown she was the owner of a life estate in all the real estate of which her husband, James W. Brown, died seized, except certain described real estate in the city of Indianapolis, which by item three of the will of her said husband was devised to his sister, Margaret M. Sprole, and, except also, the real estate that she had sold under authority of the will during her lifetime. Said Agnes C. Brown was also, in addition to her life estate in said real estate, empowered to sell and convey any part thereof except that devised by James W. Brown to his sister, Margaret M. Sprole, and to reinvest the proceeds thereof according to her judgment for the betterment of the estate, and to increase the income thereof. Upon the death of the testator, James W. Brown, the absolute title and ownership in and to the fee simple of the real estate of which he died seized, subject to the life estate and power of sale aforesaid, vested in the nieces and nephews of the testator, James W. Brown, as mentioned in item two of his will, to wit, Nellie M. Johnson (only child of John B. Munson, nephew of said James W. Brown) an undivided one-eighth, etc. Here the decree names the various persons and their interests, who, under item two of the will of James W. Brown, were invested with the fee in and to the real estate devised for life to his wife, Agnes C. Brown, and here in controversy, and also names certain children who succeeded to and acquired the interest of their deceased father, who was a beneficiary under [677]*677item two of the will of James W. Brown, and also decrees that the cross-complainants, Alpharetta Munson and Kate Munson, by the death of said Charles Munson, husband of said Alpharetta and father of said Kate, succeeded to and became seized of the entire interest of said Charles Munson in the real estate so devised to him by the will of said James W. Brown, in the following proportions, to wit, each the undivided one-sixteenth thereof. The real estate of which the said James W. Brown died seized and which at the death of his wife, Agnes C. Brown, remained unsold, is described and set out in the decree. It is further decreed that Thomas H. Spann, as executor of the last will of Agnes C. Brown, is entitled to and does hold, as a part of the assets of the estate of said Agnes C. Brown, all the personal estate which has come into his hands as such executor, including all the money, notes, accounts, stocks, bonds, choses in action and all other personal property of any kind and character, to be by him disposed of according to the terms of the will of Agnes C. Brown, except the sum of $15,600, in notes and money, which represents the proceeds of the real estate sold by Agnes C. Brown in her lifetime under her said husband’s will.

It is further adjudged that neither of the cross-complainants, Georgiana Smith nor Effie C. Skinner (appellants herein), has any interest in any of the real estate described in the complaint or cross-complaints, or in any of the personal assets which have come into the hands of the executor of Agnes C. Brown, save and except that said Effie C. Skinner is entitled to have and receive, upon settlement of the estate of Agnes C. Brown, the sum of $4,000, which is especially devised to her by the will of said Agnes C. Brown; that all the personal estate of Agnes C. Brown of every kind and nature, including money, notes, accounts, stocks, bonds, choses in action, and all other kinds of property of such class that has come into the hands of Thomas H. Spann, as executor of the will of said Agnes C. [678]*678Brown, or which has been by him inventoried as a part of the assets of said estate, except the sum of $15,600, in notes and money, before referred to, is by said executor to be held in trust for the following purposes, to wit: (1) Payment of costs, etc.; (2) payment of the debts of decedent, Agnes C. Brown; (3) payment and satisfaction of the specific legacies and bequests created by the will of Agnes C. Brown; (4) all the residue of her said personal estate, if any, shall be by the executor, upon the settlement of the estate, divided equally between and paid over to the defendants, the Board of Home Missions of the Presbyterian Church in the United States of America and the Board of Home Missions and Church Extension of the Methodist Episcopal Church.

• Some of the material facts contained in the special finding of the court may be summarized as follows: James W. Brown and Agnes C. Brown were husband and wife. They were married in the year 1874, at which time Mr. Brown was fifty years old and his wife, Agnes C., was thirty-three years old. Neither of them had been previously married. No children resulted from their marriage. James W. Brown died on December 5, 1891, in Marion county, Indiana,, where he had resided for many years. At the time of his death he was the owner in fee simple of real estate situated in the city of Indianapolis, Marion county, Indiana, of the value of over $100,000. He was also the owner of personal property of the value of $5,518.79, which his widow, Agnes C. Brown, took and received absolutely as her own, after the payment of debts. His real estate, after his death, increased, in value, and what remained undisposed of at the death of his widow, Agnes C. Brown, who died on December 11, 1908, was of the value of $200,000. In addition to the real estate undisposed of at her death, there remained in her hands the sum of $15,600, the proceeds of lands owned by her husband at the date of his death, and which were sold by her under the power of sale provided by the will of her husband. The will of James W. Brown was executed on [679]*679November 11, 1891. At that time his father and mother and all his brothers and sisters were dead, except his sister, Margaret M. Sprole, who was childless.

Appellees herein, who are claiming under item two of the will of James W. Brown, are the only surviving blood kindred of Brown, except his childless sister, Margaret M. Sprole.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Ilene Breuning v. Tim W Breuning
Indiana Court of Appeals, 2026
University of Southern Indiana Foundation v. Baker
843 N.E.2d 528 (Indiana Supreme Court, 2006)
Carter v. Bank One Trust Co., N.A.
760 N.E.2d 1171 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 2002)
Estate of Prox v. Commissioner
1976 T.C. Memo. 229 (U.S. Tax Court, 1976)
Harper v. Coad
191 N.W.2d 682 (Supreme Court of Iowa, 1971)
Brown v. Schaffer
252 N.E.2d 142 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 1969)
Estate of Ensminger v. Indiana National Bank
246 N.E.2d 217 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 1969)
Stoner v. Custer
242 N.E.2d 651 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 1968)
Epply v. Knecht
230 N.E.2d 108 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 1967)
Spence v. Second Nat'l Bank, Admr., Etc.
130 N.E.2d 667 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 1955)
State Ex Rel. Evansville City Coach Lines v. Rawlings
99 N.E.2d 597 (Indiana Supreme Court, 1951)
Brown v. Union Trust Co.
98 N.E.2d 901 (Indiana Supreme Court, 1951)
Roush v. Hullinger
86 N.E.2d 714 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 1949)
Piersol v. Hays
47 N.E.2d 838 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 1943)
Major v. Major
15 N.E.2d 754 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 1938)
Hamlyn v. Hamlyn
7 N.E.2d 644 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 1937)
Shandy v. Bell
189 N.E. 627 (Indiana Supreme Court, 1934)
Smith v. Sweetser
19 F.2d 974 (Seventh Circuit, 1927)
Coil v. Schetter
152 N.E. 870 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 1926)
Billings v. Deputy
146 N.E. 219 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 1925)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
93 N.E. 1061, 175 Ind. 672, 1911 Ind. LEXIS 80, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/skinner-v-spann-ind-1911.