Sims v. State

2015 Ark. 363, 472 S.W.3d 107, 2015 Ark. LEXIS 576
Supreme Court of Arkansas·Decided October 8, 2015·No. CR-15-153·Published·Cited by 32 cases

Opinion

COURTNEY HUDSON GOODSON, Associate Justice

11Appellant Brian Elam Sims appeals the order entered by the Pulaski County Circuit Court denying his petition for postcon-viction relief pursuant to Rule 37.1 of the Arkansas Rules of Criminal Procedure. For reversal, Sims contends that the circuit court erred in rejecting his seven claims of ineffective assistance of counsel and by denying his petition without a hearing. We affirm on all issues.

I. Factual Background

The prosecuting attorney in Pulaski County charged Sims with the offenses of first-degree murder, second-degree battery, and aggravated assault. Sims’s first trial ended in a mistrial after it was discov: ered that his attorney had been suspended from the practice of law. The record of the second trial reflects that the charges stemmed from an incident that occurred on September 24, 2011, at the Rock City Lounge in Little Rock. According to the testimony, Sims and his wife, Charleena Sims, were at the bar for a birthday celebration with isCharleena’s sister, Hannah Monroe; Hannah’s boyfriend, Chris Mar-tis; and Chris’s aunt and uncle, Michelle and Rodney Brazeal. Robert Cauley was an acquaintance of the bartender, Tina Powell, and Robert arrived at the lounge with his friend, Thomas Jones, at approximately 1:30 a.m. to help Tina close the bar.

At closing time, Robert and Thomas were in the kitchen eating pizza when they heard a commotion outside the bar. By all accounts, Charleena was causing a disturbance. The witnesses described her as “belligerent,” and “out of control” and said that she was yelling and screaming, cussing at everyone, “throwing legs and arms,” beating on the windows, and kicking the door of the bar. Robert, who stood six-feet tall and weighed 258 pounds, approached Charleena from behind and “bear hugged” her. With Hannah’s help, Robert carried Charleena to the Simses’ vehicle and placed her inside. Tina testified that she saw Sims walk down the sidewalk carrying a knife cupped in his hand and held behind his back.

Thomas testified that Robert remained at the Sims’s vehicle in a kneeling position and that he appeared to be conversing with someone inside the car. Thomas stated that Sims approached Robert from the rear and struck Robert on either his shoulder or his neck. Upon seeing this altercation, Thomas ran toward the Simses’ vehicle and found Sims on top of and straddling Robert, as Robert lay on his back on the ground. Thomas testified that Sims was- stabbing Robert, as Robert pleaded for Sims to stop. Thomas intervened, during which time Sims stabbed Thomas. Thomas testified that he placed his left hand on Sims’s shoulder and said that Sims struck upwards twice, hitting Thomas’s hand and his arm.

Rodney also observed Robert in a crouched position beside the Simses’ car. He ^testified that Sims was behind Robert and that he saw Sims swing at Robert, striking Robert in the lower back. Like Thomas, Rodney ran to the area, observed Sims on top of Robert, and saw Sims stabbing Robert. Rodney also testified that Robert was asking Sims to stop stabbing him. Rodney dislodged the knife from Sims’s hand and threw Sims backwards. Rodney secured the knife, and he, Thomas, and others tended to Robert’s wounds.

In her testimony, Hannah stated that she walked to her car after putting Char-leena in the vehicle. She next saw Rodney running in the direction of the Simses’ vehicle. Hannah - said that she did not know who was driving the Simses’ vehicle, but.she testified that the vehicle backed up and stopped before leaving the parking lot. She stated that Sims and Charleena exited the car and that they took turns waving a gun at the crowd. Hannah testified that both Sims and Charleena pointed the gun at her.

Robert died at the hospital days later. Dr. Charles Paul Kokes, the chief medical examiner, testified that the cause of death was multiple stab wounds. Specifically, Robert had been stabbed seven times. He received two stab wounds to the right upper chest; one in the lower left side of the chest; one to the lower left side of the back; another to the middle of the back; one to the back right shoulder; and lastly, one to the back side of the right thigh.

Sims testified and asserted that he had killed Robert, whom he did not know, in self-defense. • Sims said that he noticed a crowd around his vehicle when he walked out of the bar. He denied that he saw Robert carry Charleena to their vehicle. Sims stated that Charleena was seated in the front passenger seat when he reached the car and that he was standing beside the driver’s side door and about to get inside to leave, when someone struck him in the head. |4He testified that the blow knocked him to the ground and that, when he looked up, he saw a “humongous” man coming down upon him. Sims said that he feared for his and his wife’s lives and that he retrieved a knife from his back pocket and began swinging upward. He did not recall anyone else touching him and had no recollection of stabbing Thomas. Sims stated that he was able to roll to the side after the last time he struck Robert and that someone pushed Robert off of him. He said that no one took the knife from him and that he immediately got into his car to leave. Sims denied having a firearm in his hand at any time. ■

A jury in the Pulaski County Cirfeuit Court found Sims guilty as ■ charged of first-degree murder, second-degree battery, and aggravated assault. As a consequence, he received an aggregate term of thirty-three years’ imprisonment. The court of appeals affirmed his convictions and sentences. Sims v. State, 2014 Ark. App. 312, 2014 WL 2013413. Thereafter, Sims filed a timely, verified petition for postconviction relief claiming that he had received ineffective assistance of counsel at trial. In his petition, Sims alleged that counsel’s performance was deficient because he failed to request various jury instructions. He also claimed that his counsel was ineffective with respect to his handling of evidentiary issues. 1 The circuit court entered an order denying the petition without a hearing. Sims now appeals, challenging the circuit court’s findings and the court’s failure to hold a hearing. '

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Sims v. State, 2015 Ark. 363, 472 S.W.3d 107, 2015 Ark. LEXIS 576 (Ark. 2015).

2015 Ark. 363 (Sims v. State) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Jermaine Lawson v. State of Arkansas
Court of Appeals of Arkansas, 2026
Charles McChristian v. State of Arkansas
Court of Appeals of Arkansas, 2026
Tyler Chandler v. State of Arkansas
2025 Ark. App. 566 (Court of Appeals of Arkansas, 2025)
Gwendolyn Spencer v. State of Arkansas
2025 Ark. App. 450 (Court of Appeals of Arkansas, 2025)
John Britt v. State of Arkansas
2025 Ark. App. 412 (Court of Appeals of Arkansas, 2025)
John Krieger v. State of Arkansas
2025 Ark. App. 147 (Court of Appeals of Arkansas, 2025)
Charles Johnson, Jr. v. State of Arkansas
2025 Ark. App. 2 (Court of Appeals of Arkansas, 2025)
Tyler Joseph Barefield v. State of Arkansas
2024 Ark. 141 (Supreme Court of Arkansas, 2024)
Shanteria Montgomery v. State of Arkansas
2024 Ark. App. 302 (Court of Appeals of Arkansas, 2024)
Jimmie Holland v. State of Arkansas
2023 Ark. App. 594 (Court of Appeals of Arkansas, 2023)
John Patrick Cullen v. State of Arkansas
2023 Ark. 172 (Supreme Court of Arkansas, 2023)
William Edward Gray v. State of Arkansas
2021 Ark. App. 406 (Court of Appeals of Arkansas, 2021)
Lazaro Veneros-Figueroa v. State of Arkansas
2021 Ark. App. 144 (Court of Appeals of Arkansas, 2021)
Anthony Baumann v. State of Arkansas
2021 Ark. App. 58 (Court of Appeals of Arkansas, 2021)
Brad Hunter Smith v. State of Arkansas
2020 Ark. 410 (Supreme Court of Arkansas, 2020)
Willie Antone Matlock v. State of Arkansas
2020 Ark. App. 399 (Court of Appeals of Arkansas, 2020)
Nicholas Roos v. State of Arkansas
2019 Ark. 360 (Supreme Court of Arkansas, 2019)
Blackwell v. Kelley
E.D. Arkansas, 2019
Douglas v. State
540 S.W.3d 685 (Supreme Court of Arkansas, 2018)
Pokatilov v. State
2017 Ark. 264 (Supreme Court of Arkansas, 2017)