Shea Palavan v. Brian McCulley, TBW Development, LLC, and Boulevard Realty, LLC

Opinion

&$6( &9 '$7(),/('



FILED IN &$6(7<3( 1st COURT OF APPEALS HOUSTON, TEXAS 3(5621$/,1-85< 12/31/2015 5:39:20 PM 67

9

%5,$10&&8//(<%28/(9$5'5($/7<//&$1'7%:'(9(/230(17//&

25,*352&

12

75$16)(5)520



75$16)(5,1

75$16)(5&$6(

75$16)(572

75$16)(5287

38%6(59,&(

:::67&2$&2857667$7(7;86

$33(/ / $7 ( %5, () 6

'$7(£ (9(177<3( '(6&5,37,21 '2&80(17

$33(1',; >3').%@

 5(3/<%5,()),/(' $33(//$17 %5,() >3').%@

127,&( >3').%@

%5,() ),/('  25$/ $5*80(17 127 %5,() >3')0%@  $33(//(( 5(48(67(' 127,&( >3').%@

$33(1',; >3').%@ %5,() 5(&(,9('  25$/ $5*80(17 127  5(48(67(' $33(//$17 %5,() >3').%@

$33(1',; >3').%@ %5,() ),/('  25$/ $5*80(17 127  $33(//$17 %5,() >3').%@ 5(48(67(' 127,&( >3').%@

&$6( (9(17 6

'$7( (9(177<3( '(6&5,37,21 ',6326,7,21 '2&80(17

&/(5.6 5(&25'  $33(//$17 £ ),/('

> &267%,// 3') .%@

>  0$1'$7(,668(' &,9,/ £ 0$1'$7( 3') .%@

> 127,&( 3') .%@

027,21 )25  5(+($5,1* :$6 £ £ 127),/(' 027,21 )25  £ £ 5(+($5,1*'8(

> 0(025$1'80 3') 23,1,21 0(025$1'80 .%@  £ ',60,66$33($/ 23,1,21,668(' > 127,&( 3') .%@

>  -8'*0(17,668(' £ £ -8'*0(17 3') .%@

 68%0,77(' £ £

> $33(1',; 3') .%@

>  5(3/<%5,()),/(' $33(//$17 £ %5,() 3') .%@

> 127,&( 3') .%@

 5(3/<%5,()'8( $33(//$17 £

6833/(0(17$/ >  &/(5.6 5(&25' $33(//(( £ 127,&( 3') ),/(' .%@ >

%5,() ),/('  25$/ %5,() 3')

 $5*80(17 127 $33(//(( £ 0%@

5(48(67(' >3') 127,&( .%@

&$6( 5($'< 72 %(  £ £ 6(7 $33(//((6 %5,()  $33(//(( £ '8(

6833/(0(17$/ >  &/(5.6 5(&25' $33(//$17 £ 127,&( 3') ),/(' .%@

>  /(77(5),/(' $33(//(( £ /(77(5 3') .%@

&(57,),&$7,21 2) >  :25' &2817 $33(//$17 £ &(5,7,)&$7( 3') &203/,$1&(),/(' .%@

> $33(1',; 3') %5,() 5(&(,9('  .%@  25$/ $5*80(17 $33(//$17 £ > 1275(48(67(' %5,() 3') .%@

> $33(1',; 3') .%@

%5,() ),/('  25$/ >  $5*80(17 127 $33(//$17 £ %5,() 3') 5(48(67(' .%@

> 127,&( 3') .%@

$33(//$176 %5,()  $33(//$17 £ '8(

 5(63216('8( $33(//$17 £ 75,$/ &2857 &/(5.  5(63216('8( $1' &2857 £ 5(3257(5

>  /(77(5),/(' $33(//$17 £ /(77(5 3') .%@

'($'/,1( 72  &21'8&7 £ £ 0(',$7,21

> &/(5.6 5(&25'  $33(//$17 £ 127,&( 3') ),/(' .%@

 &2857)(('8( $33(//$17 £ &/(5.6 127,&( 72  &2857 5(*$5',1* &2817<&/(5. £ 67$7862)5(&25' 12 3$<0(17 $55$1*(0(176 >  0$'( :,7+ 75,$/ $33(//$17 £ 127,&( 3') &2857 &/(5. )25 .%@ 5(&25' &/(5.6 127,&( 72  &2857 5(*$5',1* ',675,&7&/(5. £ 67$7862)5(&25' &2857 5(3257(56  ,1)250$7,21 &28575(3257(5 £ 6+((76(17

>  /(77(5),/(' £ £ /(77(5 3') 0%@

12 5(3257(56 >  5(&25' ),/(' ,1 &28575(3257(5 £ 127,&( 3') &,9,/&$6( .%@

> 12 &/(5.6 5(&25'  ',675,&7&/(5. £ 127,&( 3') ),/(',1&,9,/&$6( .%@

 5(&25''8( £ £ '($'/,1( )25  3$57,(6 72 6(/(&7 %27+3$57,(6 £ 0(',$725 2%-(&7,21 72  0(',$7,21 £ *5$17027,21 ',6326('

25'(5 > :,7+'5$:,1* 3') 0(',$7,21 .%@  25'(5:,7+'5$:1 £ £ 25'(5

> 127,&( 3') .%@

> 3$67 '8( &2857  $33(//$17 £ 127,&( 3') )((127,&( .%@

 &2857)(('8( $33(//$17 £ '2&.(7,1*  $33(//$17 £ 67$7(0(17'8(

>  2%-(&7,21),/(' $33(//(( £ 2%-(&7,21 3') .%@

> 0(',$7,21  $33(//(( £ 2%-(&7,21 3') 2%-(&7,21),/(' .%@

> 25'(5 3') .%@  25'(5(17(5(' £ 0(',$7,21 > 127,&( 3') .%@

> '2&.(7,1* '2&.(7,1*  $33(//$17 £ 3') 67$7(0(17),/(' 67$7(0(17 .%@

>  /(77(5),/(' $33(//(( £ /(77(5 3') .%@

> &$6( %(*$1 ,1  £ £ 127,&( 3') &28572)$33($/6 .%@

> /(77(52) 3') $66,*10(17 127,&( 2) $33($/ .%@  $33(//$17 £ 5(&(,9(' > 127,&( 3') .%@

127,&( 2) $33($/  ),/(' ,1 75,$/ £ £ &2857 -8'*0(17 6,*1('  %< 75,$/ &2857 £ £ -8'*(

&$/ (1'$56

6(7'$7( &$/(1'$57<3( 5($6216(7

 &$6(6725(' &$6(6725(' '$7( &,9,/ &$6( :,// %(  5(7(17,21 '(6752<('<56$)7(50$1'$7(

3$57 , (6

3$57< 3$57<7<3( 5(35(6(17$7,9(

0&&8//(<%5,$1 $33(//(( -2+1'+(5%(5*(5 3$/$9$16+($ $33(//$17 6+($3$/$9$1 7%:'(9(/230(17 $33(//(( -2+1'+(5%(5*(5 %28/(9$5'5($/7<//& $33(//(( 7,027+<53/2&+

7 5, $/  &2 857  , 1) 2 50 $7 , 2 1

&2857

&2&,9,/&7$7/$:12 &2817<

+$55,6

&2857-8'*(

+2125$%/(-8'*(&2817<&9&2857#/$:

&2857&$6(



&28575(3257(5

/$85$&87+(5(//

381,6+0(17