Sewell Valley Railroad v. McClung

133 S.E. 315, 101 W. Va. 531, 1926 W. Va. LEXIS 211

• Court: West Virginia Supreme Court
• Decided: April 27, 1926
• Docket: 5646
• Status: Published

Opinion

Miller, Judge :

In this statutory proceeding to condemn land for railroad purposes, the circuit court found that the applicant had lawful right t9 take the property described in its petition, and that the land proposed to be taken was necessary for the purposes set out in the petition; and appointed commissioners, pursuant to section 14 of chapter 42 of the Code, to ascertain according to law what would be just compensation for the land proposed to be taken. Prom this order certain of the land owners interested obtained the present writ of error. No further proceedings appear in the record.

In view of our decisions it becomes apparent that the writ of error will have to be dismissed as imjjrovidently awarded.

The following cases hold that in a proceeding under the statute to condemn and take land for railroad purposes, an order adjudicating the rights of the applicant to take the land and appointing commissioners to ascertain what will be just compensation and damages to the land owner, is not a final order to which a writ of error will lie: Wheeling Railway Company v. Wheeling Steel & Iron Company, 41 W. Va. 747; White Oak Railway Company v. Gordon, 61 W. Va. 519; Panhandle Traction Company v. Schenk, 73 W. Va. 226. In City of Bluefield v. Bailey, 62 W. Va. 304, it was held that where there is an order adjudicating the right of the applicant to condemn, followed by the appointment of commissioners to assess compensation, a report by them, an order allowing the money to be paid, and its payment into court, and not otherwise, a writ of error and supersedeas is proper. The writ will therefore be dismissed.

Writ of error dismissed.