Scott v. Mitchell

Opinion

5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21 3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH 

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU )LOH 1DPH DS

81,7('67$7(6&28572)$33($/6 )257+(6,;7+&,5&8,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

s$< ' 6&277 ; 3HWLWLRQHU$SSHOODQW    1R Y  !  %(77< 0,7&+(//  5HVSRQGHQW$SSHOOHH  1 $SSHDOIURPWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUW IRUWKH1RUWKHUQ'LVWULFWRI2KLRDW&OHYHODQG 1Rn.DWKOHHQ0F'RQDOG2j0DOOH\ 'LVWULFWsXGJH 6XEPLWWHG0D\ 'HFLGHGDQG)LOHG0D\ %HIRUH%2**66,/(5DQG%$7&+(/'(5&LUFXLW sXGJHV BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB &2816(/ 21%5,()7LPRWK\)6ZHHQH\&OHYHODQG2KLRsRKQ6 3\OH *2/' 527$725, 6&+:$57=  *,%%216 &OHYHODQG2KLRIRU$SSHOODQW'DYLG0*RUPOH\2)),&( 2) 7+( $77251(< *(1(5$/ 2) 2+,2 &ROXPEXV 2KLR6WXDUW$&ROH$66,67$17$77251(<*(1(5$/ &ROXPEXV2KLRIRU$SSHOOHH

  6FRWWY0LWFKHOO 1R 1R 6FRWWY0LWFKHOO 

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB VWDWH2KLRjVVWDWXWHGRHVQRWFRQWHPSODWHEXUGHQVKLIWLQJWR HVWDEOLVKSUREDEOHFDXVH5DWKHUWKHVWDWXWHGLUHFWVWKHFRXUW 23,1,21 WR H[DPLQH WKH HYLGHQFH DQG WR PDNH D ILQGLQJ UHJDUGLQJ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB ZKHWKHU WKHUH LV  SUREDEOH FDXVH WR EHOLHYH WKDW D FRQYLFW PHHWVWKH)RUGVWDQGDUG+HUH'U0RVVPDQWHVWLILHGWKDW $/,&(0%$7&+(/'(5&LUFXLWsXGJH7KLVPDWWHULV 6FRWW VXIIHUV IURP VFKL]RSKUHQLD EXW KH GLG QRW VWDWH WKDW EHIRUHXVRQSHWLWLRQHUsD\'6FRWWjVPRWLRQIRUDVWD\RIKLV 6FRWWLVXQDEOHWRmXQGHUVWDQGWKHQDWXUHRIWKHGHDWKSHQDOW\ H[HFXWLRQVFKHGXOHGIRUSPRQWKLVGDWHDQGRQ6FRWWjV DQG ZK\ LW ZDV LPSRVHG XSRQl KLP  7KH WULDO FRXUW ZDV DSSHDO IURP WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV GHQLDO RI KLV VXSSOHPHQWDO WKHUHIRUH MXVWLILHG LQ ILQGLQJ WKDW 6FRWW KDG SUHVHQWHG QR SHWLWLRQIRUKDEHDVFRUSXV7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWGHQLHG6FRWWjV HYLGHQFHRISUREDEOHFDXVHVXIILFLHQWWRZDUUDQWKROGLQJDIXOO VXSSOHPHQWDOSHWLWLRQEHFDXVHLWFRQFOXGHGWKDWDOWKRXJKWKH HYLGHQWLDU\ KHDULQJ  )RU WKLV UHDVRQ ZH DJUHH ZLWK WKH FODLPVUDLVHGWKHUHLQZHUHQRWSURFHGXUDOO\EDUUHGXQGHUWKH GLVWULFW FRXUW WKDW m>Z@KDWHYHU WKH PHULWV RI 6FRWWjV 'XH $QWLWHUURULVP DQG (IIHFWLYH 'HDWK 3HQDOW\ $FW RI  3URFHVVFRQWHQWLRQVLQWKHDEVWUDFWWKH&RXUWIDLOVWRVHHKRZ $('3$  86& †  WKRVH FODLPV ZHUH ZLWKRXW WKH\ DUH PHDQLQJIXO LQ WKLV FDVHl  6FRWW Y 0LWFKHOO 1R PHULW:HFRQFOXGHWKDW6FRWWjVWKLUGFODLPnWKDWH[HFXWLRQ &92UGHUDW1'2KLR0D\ RI WKH VHYHUHO\ PHQWDOO\ LOO LV SURKLELWHG E\ WKH (LJKWK $PHQGPHQWnLVSURFHGXUDOO\EDUUHG:HIXUWKHUFRQFOXGH ,,,&RQFOXVLRQ WKDWKLVILUVWDQGVHFRQGFODLPVnWKDW2KLRjVSURFHGXUHVIRU GHWHUPLQLQJZKHWKHUKHLVFRPSHWHQWWREHH[HFXWHGDQGWKH )RUWKHIRUHJRLQJUHDVRQVZHDIILUPWKHMXGJPHQWRIWKH 2KLRFRXUWVjDSSOLFDWLRQRIWKRVHSURFHGXUHVWRKLPYLRODWHG GLVWULFWFRXUWGHQ\LQJWKHSHWLWLRQIRUDZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXV KLVULJKWVXQGHUWKH(LJKWK$PHQGPHQWDQGGHQLHGKLPGXH DQGZHGHQ\SHWLWLRQHUjVPRWLRQIRUDVWD\RIKLVH[HFXWLRQ SURFHVVDQGWKDWWKH)RUGY:DLQZULJKWWHVWIRUGHWHUPLQLQJ FRPSHWHQF\ WR EH H[HFXWHG LV LQDGHTXDWH LQ OLJKW RI FRQWHPSRUDU\VWDQGDUGVRIGHFHQF\nPD\EHFRQVLGHUHGRQ WKHLUPHULWVEHFDXVHWKH\ZHUHQRWULSHDWWKHWLPH6FRWWILOHG KLVLQLWLDOKDEHDVSHWLWLRQ)RUWKHUHDVRQVWKDWIROORZZH FRQFOXGHWKDWQHLWKHURIWKRVHFODLPVLVPHULWRULRXVDQGZH ZLOO WKHUHIRUH $)),50 WKH MXGJPHQW RI WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW GHQ\LQJWKHZULW)LQDOO\ZH'(1<WKHPRWLRQIRUVWD\RI 6FRWWjVH[HFXWLRQ ,3URFHGXUDO%DFNJURXQG sD\ 6FRWW ZDV FRQYLFWHG E\ DQ 2KLR MXU\ RI DJJUDYDWHG UREEHU\ DQG DJJUDYDWHG PXUGHU RQ 0DUFK   DQG VHQWHQFHGWRGHDWK+HSXUVXHGDOORIKLVVWDWHFRXUWDYHQXHV RIGLUHFWDSSHDODQGFROODWHUDOUHYLHZZLWKRXWVXFFHVVDQGWKH 2KLR6XSUHPH&RXUWVFKHGXOHGKLVH[HFXWLRQIRU2FWREHU 6FRWWLPPHGLDWHO\ILOHGLQIHGHUDOGLVWULFWFRXUWDQRWLFH RIKLVLQWHQWWRILOHDSHWLWLRQIRUKDEHDVFRUSXV7KHSHWLWLRQ ILOHGRQ)HEUXDU\ZDVXOWLPDWHO\GHQLHGWKH6XSUHPH  6FRWWY0LWFKHOO 1R 1R 6FRWWY0LWFKHOO 

,IDFRQYLFWVHQWHQFHGWRGHDWKDSSHDUVWREHLQVDQH &RXUW GHQLHG 6FRWWjV SHWLWLRQ IRU FHUWLRUDUL DQG WKH 2KLR WKHZDUGHQRUWKHVKHULIIKDYLQJFXVWRG\RIWKHFRQYLFW 6XSUHPH&RXUWVHW6FRWWjVH[HFXWLRQGDWHIRU$SULO WKH FRQYLFW V FRXQVHO RU D SV\FKLDWULVW RU SV\FKRORJLVW 6FRWW WKHQ VRXJKW DQ HYLGHQWLDU\ KHDULQJ LQ WKH VWDWH FRXUW ZKRKDVH[DPLQHGWKHFRQYLFWVKDOOJLYHQRWLFHRIWKH SXUVXDQWWR2+,2 5(9 &2'( $11†FODLPLQJWKDW DSSDUHQW LQVDQLW\ WR   WKH MXGJH ZKR LPSRVHG WKH KHKDVEHHQGLDJQRVHGDVVFKL]RSKUHQLFDQGWKDWWKHPHQWDO VHQWHQFHXSRQWKHFRQYLFW GLVHDVHKDVSURJUHVVHGWRWKHSRLQWWKDWKHLVQRWFRPSHWHQWWR EHH[HFXWHG7KHVWDWHWULDOFRXUWKHOGDKHDULQJDWZKLFK 8SRQUHFHLYLQJDQRWLFHSXUVXDQWWRGLYLVLRQ% RI 6FRWW ZDV SHUPLWWHG WR SUHVHQW WKH OLYH WHVWLPRQ\ RI KLV WKLVVHFWLRQDMXGJHVKDOOGHWHUPLQHEDVHGRQWKHQRWLFH SV\FKLDWULVWEXWFRQFOXGHGWKDWWKHUHZDVQRSUREDEOHFDXVH DQG DQ\ VXSSRUWLQJ LQIRUPDWLRQ DQ\ LQIRUPDWLRQ WR EHOLHYH WKDW 6FRWW PHHWV WKH 2KLR VWDWXWHjV GHILQLWLRQ RI VXEPLWWHGE\WKHSURVHFXWLQJDWWRUQH\DQGWKHUHFRUGLQ LQVDQLW\IRUSXUSRVHVRIFRPSHWHQFHWREHSXWWRGHDWK7KH WKHFDVHLQFOXGLQJSUHYLRXVKHDULQJVDQGRUGHUVZKHWKHU WULDO FRXUW WKHUHIRUH GHQLHG 6FRWWjV UHTXHVW IRU D IXOO SUREDEOHFDXVHH[LVWVWREHOLHYHWKDWWKHFRQYLFWLVLQVDQH HYLGHQWLDU\ KHDULQJ  7KH 2KLR 6XSUHPH &RXUW SRVWSRQHG ,IWKHMXGJHILQGVWKDWSUREDEOHFDXVHH[LVWVWREHOLHYH 6FRWWjVH[HFXWLRQ GDWH LQRUGHUWRSHUPLWWKHVWDWHFRXUWRI WKDWWKHFRQYLFWLVLQVDQHWKHMXGJHVKDOOKROGDKHDULQJ DSSHDOVWRFRQVLGHUKLVDSSHDORIWKHWULDOFRXUWjVMXGJPHQW WRGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHUWKHFRQYLFWLVLQVDQH,IWKHMXGJH WKDWMXGJPHQWXOWLPDWHO\ZDVDIILUPHGE\WKHVWDWHDSSHOODWH GRHVQRWILQGWKDWSUREDEOHFDXVHRIWKDWQDWXUHH[LVWVWKH FRXUWDQGWKH2KLR6XSUHPH&RXUWGHQLHG6FRWWjVUHTXHVWIRU MXGJHPD\GLVPLVVWKHPDWWHUZLWKRXWDKHDULQJ DIXUWKHUVWD\RIKLVH[HFXWLRQ7KH8QLWHG6WDWHV6XSUHPH &RXUW GHFOLQHG WR KHDU 6FRWWjV FKDOOHQJH WR WKH 2+,2 5(9 &2'( $11†%7KLVVWDWXWHDIIRUGHG FRQVWLWXWLRQDOLW\ RI WKH 2KLR 6XSUHPH &RXUWjV GHFLVLRQ 6FRWW WKH EDVLF IDLUQHVV WKDW )RUG UHTXLUHV QDPHO\ WKH GHQ\LQJ D IXUWKHU VWD\ RI H[HFXWLRQ  6FRWW WKHQ ILOHG D RSSRUWXQLW\ WR EH KHDUG  6FRWW DYDLOHG KLPVHOI RI WKDW m6XSSOHPHQWDO3HWLWLRQIRUD:ULWRI+DEHDV&RUSXVlVHHNLQJ RSSRUWXQLW\ZKHQIRUH[DPSOHKHSUHVHQWHGOLYHWHVWLPRQ\ WRDVVHUWKLVFODLPVWKDWKHLVQRWFRPSHWHQWWREHH[HFXWHG IURP 'U'RXJODV0RVVPDQ:HKDYHDFNQRZOHGJHGWKDW WKDWWKH2KLRSURFHGXUHVIRUGHWHUPLQLQJKLVFRPSHWHQFHWR )RUG DOORZV VWDWHV mVXEVWDQWLDO OHHZD\ WR GHWHUPLQH ZKDW EH H[HFXWHG DUH XQFRQVWLWXWLRQDO DQG WKDW WKH (LJKWK SURFHVVEHVWEDODQFHVWKHYDULRXVLQWHUHVWVDWVWDNHl&RH $PHQGPHQWSURKLELWVWKHH[HFXWLRQRIRQHZKRLVVHYHUHO\ )GDWTXRWDWLRQRPLWWHG$VWDWHSURFHVVXQGHU)RUG PHQWDOO\LOO7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWGHQLHGWKHSHWLWLRQDQG6FRWW PD\ HYHQ LQFRUSRUDWH mVRPH KLJK WKUHVKROG VKRZLQJ RQ LV QRZ EHIRUH WKLV FRXUW VHHNLQJ D VWD\ RI KLV VFKHGXOHG EHKDOI RI WKH SULVRQHU    WR FRQWURO WKH QXPEHU RI H[HFXWLRQDQGDUHYHUVDORIWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVGHQLDORIKLV QRQPHULWRULRXVRUUHSHWLWLYHFODLPVRILQVDQLW\l86DW SHWLWLRQIRUDZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXV SOXUDOLW\RSLQLRQ$FFRUGLQJO\WKDW2KLRGHQLHG6FRWW DQ HYLGHQWLDU\ KHDULQJ GRHV QRW YLRODWH GXH SURFHVV DV ,,$QDO\VLV HQXQFLDWHGLQ)RUG 6FRWWjV SHWLWLRQ EHIRUH WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW FODLPV ILUVW WKDW &RQFHUQLQJ 6FRWWjV DUJXPHQW WKDW WKH 2KLR VWDWXWH 2KLRjVVWDWXWRU\SURFHGXUHVIRUGHWHUPLQLQJKLVFRPSHWHQFH LPSHUPLVVLEO\ SODFHG XSRQ KLP WKH EXUGHQ RI SURYLQJ KLV WREHH[HFXWHGDUHXQFRQVWLWXWLRQDODQGWKDWWKH2KLRFRXUWVj FRPSHWHQF\ZHGRQRWUHDG)RUGDQG&RHnWKHJRYHUQLQJ DSSOLFDWLRQV RI WKRVH SURFHGXUHV WR KLP YLRODWHG KLV ULJKWV FDVHV KHUHnWR VD\ WKDW SURFHGXUDO GXH SURFHVV UHTXLUHV XQGHUWKH(LJKWK$PHQGPHQWDQGGHQLHGKLPGXHSURFHVV 2KLRjV)RUGVWDWXWHWRVHWXSDEXUGHQVKLIWLQJSDUDGLJPRUWR +LVSHWLWLRQQH[WFODLPVWKDW)RUGY:DLQZULJKW86 DVVLJQWKHLQLWLDOEXUGHQRIHVWDEOLVKLQJSUREDEOHFDXVHWRWKH LVREVROHWH)LQDOO\KLVSHWLWLRQDVVHUWVWKDWWKH  6FRWWY0LWFKHOO 1R 1R 6FRWWY0LWFKHOO 

(LJKWK $PHQGPHQW SURKLELWV WKH H[HFXWLRQ RI RQH ZKR LV 8QGHUWKHSDUWLFXODUIDFWVRIWKLVFDVH6FRWWKDGQRUHDVRQWR VHYHUHO\PHQWDOO\LOO7KH6WDWHDUJXHVWKDWWKLVSHWLWLRQLVQRW FKDOOHQJH WKH DGHTXDF\ RI WKDW VWDQGDUG XQWLO KH UDLVHG KLV DVXSSOHPHQWDOSHWLWLRQDQGWKDWXQGHUWKH$('3$LWLVEDUUHG FODLPWKDWKHLVQRWFRPSHWHQWWREHH[HFXWHG LQLWVHQWLUHW\XQOHVV6FRWWREWDLQVSHUPLVVLRQIURPWKLVFRXUW WRILOHDVHFRQGDQGVXFFHVVLYHSHWLWLRQ6FRWWPDLQWDLQVWKDW :HILQGKRZHYHUQRHUURULQsXGJH2j0DOOH\jVFRQFOXVLRQ QRQHRIWKHVHFODLPVZDVULSHZKHQKHILOHGKLVLQLWLDOSHWLWLRQ WKDW ZH DUH ERXQG E\ )RUG EHFDXVH mQHLWKHU WKH 6XSUHPH IRUKDEHDVUHOLHILQDQGWKHUHIRUHWKH$('3$EDULVQRW &RXUWQRUWKH&RXUWRI$SSHDOVLQWKLV&LUFXLWKDVHYHULVVXHG DSSOLFDEOH DQ RSLQLRQ TXHVWLRQLQJ LWV YLWDOLW\l  sXGJH 2j0DOOH\ LV HQWLUHO\FRUUHFWDQGVKHLVIXUWKHUFRUUHFWWKDWWKH6XSUHPH :HDJUHHZLWKWKH6WDWHWKDW6FRWWjVFODLPWKDWWKH(LJKWK &RXUWjVJUDQWRIFHUWLRUDULLQ0F&DUYHUY1RUWK&DUROLQD $PHQGPHQWSURKLELWVWKHH[HFXWLRQRIRQHZKRLVVHYHUHO\  6 &W   GRHV QRW DIIHFW WKLV UHVXOW  :H PHQWDOO\LOOLVEDUUHG$OWKRXJK6FRWWZDVQRWVSHFLILFDOO\ WKHUHIRUHFRQFOXGHWKDWWKHGHILQLWLRQRILQVDQLW\VHWRXWLQ GLDJQRVHGDVEHLQJVFKL]RSKUHQLFXQWLOZHOODIWHUKHILOHGKLV 2KLRjV)RUGVWDWXWH2+,2 5(9 &2'( $11†$ LQLWLDOSHWLWLRQLQKLVRZQSOHDGLQJVPDNHLWFOHDUWKDW SURYLGHV WKH DSSURSULDWH VWDQGDUG IRU GHWHUPLQLQJ ZKHWKHU KHKDGVXIIHUHGIURPVHYHUHPHQWDOLOOQHVVIRU\HDUVEHIRUH 6FRWWLVFRPSHWHQWWREHH[HFXWHG7KDWGHILQLWLRQLVmWKDW WKDW SHWLWLRQ ZDV ILOHG  $Q\ FODLP WKDW KLV H[HFXWLRQ ZDV WKHFRQYLFWLQTXHVWLRQGRHVQRWKDYHWKHPHQWDOFDSDFLW\WR SURKLELWHGE\WKH(LJKWK$PHQGPHQWEHFDXVHKHZDVVHYHUHO\ XQGHUVWDQG WKH QDWXUH RI WKH GHDWK SHQDOW\ DQG ZK\ LW ZDV PHQWDOO\LOOZDVWKHUHIRUHULSHDWWKHWLPHWKDWKHILOHGWKDW LPSRVHGXSRQWKHFRQYLFWl,G SHWLWLRQEXWWKHSHWLWLRQPDNHVQRPHQWLRQRIVXFKDFODLP $FFRUGLQJO\ ZH FRQFOXGH WKDW WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW HUUHG LQ :HDUHOHIWZLWK6FRWWjVFODLPWKDW2KLRjVFRXUWVGHQLHG FRQVLGHULQJWKLVFODLPRQWKHPHULWV KLP GXH SURFHVV E\ EXUGHQLQJ KLP ZLWK SURYLQJ KLV FRPSHWHQF\XQGHU)RUGDQGE\GHQ\LQJKLPDQRSSRUWXQLW\ :HGRQRWDJUHHZLWKWKH6WDWHKRZHYHUWKDW6FRWWjVFODLP IRUDQHYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJRQWKDWTXHVWLRQ:HILQGQRPHULW WKDWKHZDVGHQLHGKLV(LJKWK$PHQGPHQWDQGGXHSURFHVV WRWKLVFODLP ULJKWVEHFDXVH2KLRjVSURFHGXUHVIRUGHWHUPLQLQJFRPSHWHQFH IRU SXUSRVHV RI H[HFXWLRQ DUH XQFRQVWLWXWLRQDO LV VLPLODUO\ )RUG SURYLGHV WKDW mDQ LQVDQH GHIHQGDQWjV (LJKWK EDUUHG6FRWWjVILUVWH[HFXWLRQGDWHSUHFHGHGKLVILOLQJRIKLV $PHQGPHQWLQWHUHVWLQIRUHVWDOOLQJKLVH[HFXWLRQXQOHVV RU LQLWLDO IHGHUDO KDEHDV SHWLWLRQ DQG KH FHUWDLQO\ FRXOG KDYH XQWLOKHUHFRYHUVKLVVDQLW\FDQQRWEHGHSULYHGZLWKRXWDµIDLU UDLVHG KLV)RUG FODLP LQ WKDW SHWLWLRQ  +RZHYHU WKH 6WDWH KHDULQJj,QGHHGIXQGDPHQWDOIDLUQHVVLVWKHKDOOPDUNRIWKH GRHV QRW GLVSXWH 6FRWWjV FODLP WKDW KH LV VFKL]RSKUHQLF SURWHFWLRQVDIIRUGHGE\WKH'XH3URFHVV&ODXVHl86DW QHLWKHUGRHVLWGLVSXWHKLVFODLPWKDWWKLVPHQWDOGLVHDVHLV 3RZHOOsFRQFXUULQJ$SSO\LQJWKLVSULQFLSOHZHKDYH SURJUHVVLYHDQGWKDWLWVYLFWLPVGRQRWLPSURYHEXWRQO\JHW UHFRJQL]HGWKDWmWKHVWDWHLVHQWLWOHGWRH[HUFLVHGLVFUHWLRQLQ ZRUVH  $FFRUGLQJO\ 6FRWWjV LPPLQHQW H[HFXWLRQ DQG KLV FUHDWLQJ LWV RZQ SURFHGXUHV DV ORQJ DV EDVLF IDLUQHVV LV FODLP WR D GHFOLQLQJ PHQWDO VWDWH OHDG XV WR FRQFOXGH REVHUYHGl&RHY%HOO)GWK&LU FRQVLVWHQWZLWKRXURSLQLRQLQ&RHY%HOO)G LQWHUQDODOWHUDWLRQVDQGFLWDWLRQRPLWWHGFRQFOXGLQJWKDWWKH WK&LUWKDWZKLOHWKLVFODLPPLJKWQRWKDYHEHHQ SURFHGXUHV IROORZHG E\ WKH 7HQQHVVHH FRXUWV VDWLVILHG WKH ULSHVL[\HDUVDJRLWLVFHUWDLQO\ULSHQRZ UHTXLUHPHQWV RI GXH SURFHVV DQG GLG QRW FRQVWLWXWH DQ XQUHDVRQDEOHDSSOLFDWLRQRI)RUG :HWKHUHIRUHFRQFOXGHWKDWZHZLOODGGUHVVRQLWVPHULWV 6FRWWjV FKDOOHQJH WR WKH DGHTXDF\ RI WKH )RUG VWDQGDUG 2KLRjV)RUGVWDWXWHSURYLGHV