Scott v. City of Goodman

997 So. 2d 270, 2008 WL 5232813
CourtCourt of Appeals of Mississippi
DecidedDecember 16, 2008
Docket2007-CA-01403-COA
StatusPublished
Cited by12 cases

This text of 997 So. 2d 270 (Scott v. City of Goodman) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Mississippi primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Scott v. City of Goodman, 997 So. 2d 270, 2008 WL 5232813 (Mich. Ct. App. 2008).

Opinion

997 So.2d 270 (2008)

Randy SCOTT, Appellant
v.
CITY OF GOODMAN, Mississippi, Dickerson Petroleum, Inc. d/b/a BP Convenience and Service Station and Melvin Williams, Appellees.

No. 2007-CA-01403-COA.

Court of Appeals of Mississippi.

December 16, 2008.

*271 Marshall E. Sanders, attorney for appellant.

Daniel J. Griffith, Cleveland, Jan F. Gadow, Thomas Y. Page, Jackson, attorneys for appellees.

Before LEE, P.J., BARNES, ROBERTS and CARLTON, JJ.

*272 BARNES, J., for the Court.

¶ 1. Randy Scott filed a complaint in the Circuit Court of Holmes County alleging that Dickerson Petroleum, Inc. d/b/a BP Convenience and Service Station breached its duty to protect Scott from, or had negligently caused, a physical attack by Officer Melvin Williams, an on-duty police officer of the City of Goodman, on Dickerson Petroleum's property. Scott subsequently amended his complaint to add Officer Williams and the City of Goodman as defendants. Following discovery, Officer Williams was granted summary judgment, dismissing the claim against him with prejudice based on the uncontested fact that Officer Williams was acting in the scope of his employment. Dickerson Petroleum also filed a motion for summary judgment, which was granted on April 28, 2006. Following a bench trial which resulted in a final judgment in favor of the City of Goodman, Scott filed his notice of appeal on August 13, 2007.

SUMMARY OF FACTS

¶ 2. Approximately one month prior to the incident at issue, Officer Williams observed Scott driving erratically and attempted to arrest him for driving under the influence (DUI), reckless driving, and resisting arrest. However, Scott fled the scene, eluding Officer Williams. Scott later contacted the police chief, with whom he was acquainted, and agreed to come in on a cash bond. Scott was found guilty on all charges, fined $2,600, and had his driver's license suspended.

¶ 3. Before midnight on February 26, 2003, Officer Williams was at the BP store on Highway 17 and Interstate 55 in Pickens, Mississippi. Officer Williams, who was on duty at the time, was purchasing some refreshments.[1] Also present at the store were two BP employees, Melvin Jordan and Marjorie Freeman, as well as two truck drivers, Jimmy Lester and Rodney Harrison. Officer Williams was standing near the doorway talking to the truck drivers when Scott entered with two of his friends, Lamarcus Williams (Lamarcus) and Jonas Edwards. Officer Williams greeted them, and Scott replied, "I don't f____k with you." Scott, however, testified that Officer Williams greeted him with "you're the man I've been looking for." Scott and his friends then proceeded to the cooler at the back of the store to obtain refreshments. When they came back to the front to purchase their drinks, Officer Williams asked, "Did you just say what I thought you said?" Scott replied: "You heard me. I said I don't f____k with you." Officer Williams told Scott that he must have him "mixed up with someone else," to which Scott replied, "No, motherf____ker, I know you."[2] Other witnesses testified that Officer Williams said something to the effect of "do you know who I am?"

¶ 4. Scott "started back toward" Officer Williams, who put out his hand toward Scott's chest, and said "Hold up, sir." As Scott continued walking, his chest made contact with Williams's hand, and Scott slapped the hand down, saying, "Motherf____ker, get your hands off me." Freeman and both truck drivers corroborated this version of events stating that Scott appeared to be the aggressor. However, Scott and two witnesses, Jordan and Lamarcus, testified that Scott was only attempting *273 to exit the store, but Officer Williams blocked the entrance. Scott also stated that he thought the door was locked or jammed, but evidence refuted this claim.

¶ 5. Officer Williams stated that, immediately after this altercation, Scott put his hands into his pockets and appeared to be searching for something, which prompted Officer Williams to retrieve his weapon from his holster and attempt to radio for assistance from other law enforcement officers. There was conflicting testimony from witnesses whether Scott actually had pockets, and whether his hands were in his jacket pockets or pants pockets. However, video surveillance photos depicted that Scott was wearing a jacket and appeared to have both hands in his pockets as he was advancing toward Officer Williams. We also note that Scott, in his statement to the police on March 10, 2003, stated that "I had two dollars in my pocket."

¶ 6. When Scott continued to move toward Officer Williams, the officer grabbed Scott in a "bear hug" in order to pin Scott's arms to his side, presumably to keep him from retrieving anything from his pockets, and a tussle ensued. Scott pulled away, and fearing that Scott had a weapon, Officer Williams discharged his weapon, shooting Scott in the right leg.[3] Scott stumbled outside and resisted Officer Williams's repeated attempts to handcuff him. After Scott failed to obey commands to stop resisting, Officer Williams sprayed Scott in the face with a chemical agent and then handcuffed him. After law enforcement and emergency medical personnel arrived, Scott was transported to University Medical Center in Jackson, Mississippi for surgery on his leg.

¶ 7. Scott filed a complaint in the Circuit Court of Holmes County alleging that Dickerson Petroleum had breached its duty to protect Scott from, or had negligently caused, the physical attack by Officer Williams. Scott subsequently amended his complaint to add Officer Williams and the City of Goodman as defendants. Officer Williams filed a motion for summary judgment stating that, under the Mississippi Tort Claims Act (MTCA), he could not be held personally liable as he was acting within the course and scope of his police duties at the time of the shooting. The circuit court granted Officer Williams's motion for summary judgment on May 8, 2006, dismissing the claim against him with prejudice.[4] Dickerson Petroleum filed a motion for summary judgment, which was granted on April 28, 2006. A bench trial was held February 8-9, 2007, which resulted in a final judgment in favor of the City of Goodman. Scott now appeals the trial court's rulings.

I. Whether the trial court erred in granting summary judgment to Dickerson Petroleum.

¶ 8. Scott argues that the trial judge erred in granting summary judgment to Dickerson Petroleum, the owner of the premises where the shooting occurred. Due to his status as an invitee, Scott maintains that Dickerson Petroleum owed him a duty of reasonable care to *274 protect him from an unlawful attack by a third party-Officer Williams. Scott argues that, as Dickerson Petroleum was aware of frequent criminal activity on the premises, the shooting by Officer Williams was foreseeable and steps should have taken to prevent such an incident.

¶ 9. "The standard of review by which an appellate court reviews the grant or denial of a motion for summary judgment under Rule 56(c) of the Mississippi Rules of Civil Procedure is de novo." Grammar v. Dollar, 911 So.2d 619, 621-22(¶ 4) (Miss.Ct. App.2005) (citing McMillan v. Rodriguez, 823 So.2d 1173, 1176-77(¶ 9) (Miss.2002)). In determining whether a motion for summary judgment was properly granted, we must view the evidence "in the light most favorable to the party against whom the motion has been made." Weatherly v. Union Planters Bank, N.A., 914 So.2d 1222, 1224(¶ 9) (Miss.Ct.App.2005) (citation omitted).

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Marshall William Herrin v. Lacey Nicole Perkins
Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2019
Sanderson Farms, Inc. v. D. D. McCullough
212 So. 3d 69 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2017)
City of Vicksburg, Mississippi v. Herbert A. Williams
191 So. 3d 1242 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2016)
Richard C. Swenson v. James Kermit Brouillette
163 So. 3d 957 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2014)
Patterson v. City of Greenville
117 So. 3d 630 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2013)
Carter v. Reddix
115 So. 3d 851 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2012)
White v. State
127 So. 3d 241 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2012)
Welch Roofing & Construction, Inc. v. Farina
99 So. 3d 274 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2012)
T.C.B. Construction Co. v. W.C. Fore Trucking, Inc.
134 So. 3d 752 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2012)
Mangum v. Mississippi Parole Board
76 So. 3d 762 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2011)
McNabb v. L.T. Land & Gravel, LLC
77 So. 3d 1140 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2011)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
997 So. 2d 270, 2008 WL 5232813, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/scott-v-city-of-goodman-missctapp-2008.