Scott Keeler Cornelius and James C. Finney v. Colette Greggs and Doug Welborn

• Court: Louisiana Court of Appeal
• Decided: August 2, 2021
• Docket: 2021CE0883
• Status: Unknown

Opinion

STATE OF LOUISIANA

COURT OF APPEAL To

FIRST CIRCUIT

j MA h NUMBER 2021 CE 0883

c

EW y SCOTT KEELER CORNELIUS AND JAMES C. FINNEY

VERSUS

COLETTE GREGGS AND DOUG WELBORN

Judgment Rendered: ' AUG 0 2 2021

Appealed from the Nineteenth Judicial District Court In and for the Parish of East Baton Rouge, Louisiana Docket Number C709920

Honorable Timothy E. Kelley, Judge Presiding

7FX c) C X CXXX: 7F

Brian F. Blackwell Counsel for Plaintiffs/ Appellees, Baton Rouge, LA Scott Keeler Cornelius and James C. Finney

J. Andrew Murrell Counsel for Defendant/Appellant, Baton Rouge, LA Colette Greggs

John C. Walsh Counsel for Defendant/Appellee, Baton Rouge, LA Doug Welborn, in his official capacity as Clerk of Court for East Baton Rouge Parish

x x Fkk' eXX: ti xx

BEFORE: GUIDRY, McDONALD, THERIOT, LANIER AND WOLFE, JJ.

i;OUR OF KF' l iE 1ST CIfdCt1IT f' iL rn

2021 AUG -- 2 FM 3: 29 RDDD NAQUIN CLERK LANIER, J.

In this suit challenging candidacy, defendant Colette Greggs seeks to appeal

the district court' s judgment granting plaintiffs' objection to her candidacy for the

office of City Judge, City Court, ES 2A, City of Baton Rouge and disqualifying her

as a candidate. For the following reasons, we dismiss the appeal as untimely.

FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

On July 14, 2021, Colette Greggs filed a sworn Notice of Candidacy with

the East Baton Rouge Parish Clerk of Court, declaring her intent to run for the

office of City Judge, City Court, ES 2A, City of Baton Rouge. On the Notice of

Candidacy, Greggs certified that her domicile address was 5225 Lone Pine Lane,

Baton Rouge, Louisiana, and her mailing address was 3111 Huron Street, Baton

Rouge, Louisiana,

On July 23, 2021, Scott Keeler Cornelius and James C. Finney, qualified

electors within the city limits of Baton Rouge, Parish of East Baton Rouge, filed a

Petition for Disqualification of Candidate, contending that Greggs' s declared

domicile address of 5225 Lone Pine Lane, the address for which she claims a

homestead exemption and at which she is registered to vote, is located outside the

city limits of Baton Rouge. Accordingly, they averred that Greggs did not meet

the qualifications for the office as set forth in La. R.S. 13: 1873 because she was

not a qualified resident elector of the territorial jurisdiction of the court for at least

two years prior to election. See La. R. S. 18: 491( A) & 18: 492( A)( 3).

The district court conducted a hearing in the matter on July 27, 2021, and, by

judgment dated the same day, granted plaintiffs' challenge to Greggs' s candidacy

and disqualified Greggs as a candidate in the primary election for the office of City

Judge, City Court, ES 2A, City of Baton Rouge. On July 28, 2021, Greggs filed a

Motion and Order for Appeal, seeking review of this judgment.

2 On July 30, 2021, plaintiffs filed a Motion to Dismiss Appeal for Lack of

Jurisdiction, contending that this court lacks jurisdiction over Greggs' s appeal

because she failed to timely post bond as required by La. R.S. 18: 1409( D).

DISCUSSION

Pursuant to La. R.S. 18: 1409( D), "[ w]ithin twenty- four hours after rendition

of judgment, a party aggrieved by the judgment may appeal by obtaining an order

of appeal and giving bond for a sum fixed by the court to secure the payment of

costs." ( Emphasis added). Regarding the meaning of "rendition ofjudgment," La.

R.S. 18: 1409( J) provides that "[ a] s used in this Chapter, judgment shall be deemed

to have been rendered when signed by the judge." The language of La. R.S.

18: 1409( D) is clear and unambiguous and requires that a party seeking to appeal

the district court' s judgment in an election suit to perform two procedural acts

within twenty- four hours of rendition of judgment: ( 1) obtain an order of appeal;

and ( 2) give bond for a sum fixed by the court. Dumas v. Jetson, 446 So. 2d 747,

749 ( La. App. 1St Cir. 1983), writ granted in part and remanded on other grounds,

445 So. 2d 424 ( La. 1984).

A party seeking relief under the Election Code must bring herself within the

strict provisions of the law governing election suits. Francis v. Daigle, 2020- 0723

La. App. 1st Cir. 8/ 14/ 20), 311 So. 3d 393, 394, writ denied, 2020- 01018 ( La.

8/ 24/ 20), 301 So. 3d 27. The legislature in drafting and enacting the Election Code

sought to expedite contests involving candidacy. The short time delays are in the

interest of the electorate, not the private litigants. Francis, 311 So. 3d at 394.

In the instant case, the district court signed its judgment on July 27, 2021 at

2: 11 p.m. See La. R.S. 18: 1409( C). Thus, Greggs had until 2: 11 p.m. on July 28,

2021, to obtain an order of appeal and post bond in the sum fixed by the court. See

Dumas, 446 So. 2d at 749. Greggs timely filed her Motion and Order for Appeal

on July 28, 2021, at 12: 00 p.m. In the order of appeal, which was signed by the

3 district court that day, the court ordered the posting of bond in accordance with La.

R.S. 18: 1409( D), in the amount of $3, 500. 00. However, Greggs did not post the

bond until July 30, 2021, at 11: 55 a. m., nearly three days after the rendition of

judgment. Accordingly, we are compelled to conclude because Greggs failed to

file her motion for appeal and appeal bond by 2: 11 p.m. on July 28, 2021, her

appeal was not properly perfected. As such, the district court' s judgment

disqualifying Greggs as a candidate is now final.' See Dumas, 446 So. 2d at 749.

CONCLUSION

For the above and foregoing reasons, Colette Greggs' s appeal of the district

court' s July 27, 2021 judgment, disqualifying her as a candidate for the office of

City Judge, City Court, ES 2A, City of Baton Rouge is dismissed as untimely.

APPEAL DISMISSED.

We reject Greggs' s argument that the district court' s judgment was not a valid final judgment. The language of the judgment was precise, definite, and certain in disqualifying defendant Colette Greggs as a candidate for the office of City Judge, City Court, ES 2A, City of Baton Rouge, on the Petition for Disqualification of Candidate of plaintiffs, Scott Keeler Cornelius and James C. Finney. Moreover, because the district court retains jurisdiction after an order of appeal is granted to set and tax costs, La. C. C. P. art. 2088( A)( 10), language in a judgment casting a party with costs without specifying the amount of costs does not render the judgment an invalid final judgment. See Kelly McHugh and Associates, Inc. v. RPDE Development, LLC, 2019- 0709 ( La. App. Is' Cir. 3/ 5/ 20), 300 So. 3d 417, 421- 422, & Interdiction of Metzler, 2015- 0982 ( La. App. 1st Cir. 2/ 22/ 16), 189 So. 3d 467, 469 n. 3.