Schoolfield's Admr. v. Clayton

1 Ky. Op. 420, 1867 Ky. LEXIS 265

• Court: Court of Appeals of Kentucky
• Decided: June 1, 1867
• Status: Published

Opinion

Opinion of the Court by

Judge Robertson :

As the record shows that the law and the facts .were submitted to the court, a jury was dispensed with. There was, therefore, no error, as supposed by counsel, in rendering the judgment without a jury. But there are at least two radical errors in the judgment as rendered. 1st. It is against Barber, personally, when it ought to have been against him as administrator of John School-field.

2d. As the original petition charged a collection by the deputy sheriff, J. J. Schoolfield, of all the taxes which he undertook to collect, and this was traversed by the appellants, there could have been no judgment against them on that issue, because it'appears that the whole balance of about $700 had never been collected. The amended petition made a vague alternative charge of failure to collect that balance without alleging that it was collectible, or even a failure to return a delinquent list. The answer to that charge avers that a certain portion was not collectible in consequence of insolvency. And, to sustain that affirmative allegation, the appellants offered to prove that, when the tax-books were received by the deputy, certain taxpayers were insolvent, and still continued so. This proof would repel any legal liability of negligent failure to collect. And would entitle the appellants to exoneration pro tanto. It seems to this court, therefore, that the Circuit Court erred to their prejudice in refusing to admit their proffered testimony of insolvency.

Duvall, for Appellants.

On these grounds, without noticing others, we are of the opinion that, the judgment is erroneous, and, therefore, it is reversed and the cause remanded for a new trial.