IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE CHRISTOPHER BRIAN SANDS, : Plaintiff, v. □ Civ. No. 19-2275-CFC WARDEN DANA METZGER, etal, Defendants.
Christopher Brian Sands, James T. Vaughn Correctional Center, Smyrna, Delaware, Pro Se Plaintiff.
MEMORANDUM OPINION
May 4, 2021 Wilmington, Delaware
CL PCL. CONNOLLY, U.S. District Judge: l. INTRODUCTION Plaintiff Christopher Brian Sands, an inmate at the James T. Vaughn Correctional Center (JTVCC) in Smyrna, Delaware, filed this action alleging violations of the First and Fourteenth Amendments of the United States Constitution under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, the Establishment Clause, and the Religious Land Use & Institutionalized Persons Act (“RLUIPA”), 42 U.S.C. § 2000cc, et seq.’ (D.I. 3) Plaintiff appears pro se and has been granted leave to proceed in forma pauperis. (D.|. 6) The original Complaint was dismissed upon screening and Plaintiff was given leave to amend. (D.I. 8, 9) An Amended Complaint was filed on July 2, 2020. (D.!. 12) The Court proceeds to review and screen the Amended Complaint pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1915(e)(2)(b) and 1915A(a). I. BACKGROUND The following facts are taken from the Amended Complaint and assumed to be true for screening purposes. See Umland v. PLANCO Fin. Servs., Inc., 542 F.3d 59, 64 (3d Cir. 2008). Plaintiff was transferred to SHU? 17 on October 7, 2019, following a disciplinary write-up. (D.!. 12 at 5) Unlike inmates housed in the general population or
' The constitutional violations arise under 42 U.S.C. § 1983. When bringing a § 1983 claim, a plaintiff must allege that some person has deprived him of a federal right, and that the person who caused the deprivation acted under color of state law. See West v. Atkins, 487 U.S. 42, 48 (1988). 2 The Security Housing Unit (“SHU”) houses those inmates who have demonstrated that they cannot be housed in a lesser security and/or whose behavior and history are deemed to require maximum security housing. See https://doc.delaware.gov/views/jtvcc. blade.shtml (last visited Apr. 1, 2021).
"compoiunnmda,ht"oe uss ienSd H Ua rneo atl lotwoae tdt ernedl igsieoruvsi( cIeds..) Plaiantttieffnr deeldi gsieoruvasin cbdei sb slteu wdhye hne w ash ousientd h e compou(nIdd.. ) JTVCiCn mactaewnsa trcehl isgeioruvsi ces bbyIr nosatdicCtahusattni 1no9enl
ont eleviints hieoinr (cIedEl.ffl)esc .tF ievber u2a0r1ya8 n,pd r itooPr l ainttriaff'nss fer toS HU1 7D,e fenCdaapnttDa oidns wohno,i si nc harogfSe H Ub,a nnteedl eviins ions SHU1 7a n1d8 (. Iadt6. )T hne ewp oldiicndyo atf fiencmta itnBe usi ld1i92n,1g 2,s2 , an2d3 (./ dW.a)r dMeent zagpeprr otvhetede levbiasni(.oI nd .) Plaicnotmipffl aaibnoetudhtt e e levbiasininw o rni tsienntgtosD otsaonnd Metzagnewdra st otlhdha ets houhladvt eh ouogfth htce o nsequoefbn eciensg housienSd H Ub efohrece o mmitthtieen df ratchtcaiatou nsh eidts r antshfeer(reI a.dt . 6)Plaianltsciooff m plaiinwn reidt sienntgtoDs e fendSatnatcHseo yl lJiTsV,C C treatamdemnitn isatnrGdau tsCo hrr,i JsTtVoC,fC a ciclhiatpyln aeiinto,hfw e hro m respon(dIedd..) .
Ats ompeo ianfttP elra ifnitlhieifidsfn ictoimapll bauibtne tf ohrefe i lheids Amended Co(mtpdhlaeat wiean snt o ptr ovided)w,a stP rlaanisnftteoSir HfrU1fe 9 d whehreei as blteoa ttend rweeleikgslieyor uvbsiy cw east chCihnagn 1n9eo lnh iosw n televi(sIaidto. nT 7.h) u fsr,o Omc to7b,2e 0r1 u9n thiitlsr antsoSf HeUr1 9P,l aintiff wasu nabtlope r achtiirsce el idguiteoo tn h tee levbiasnih oiincsne alnlbd e cautshee tideirnd o hta vaet elevfioisrni moantt owe ast rcehl isgeirouvsi( cIeds..) Plaisneteiikffns j unrcetlaiinvecdefo mpensdaatmoargy(e sIa.dt8 . )
2 IllL.E GASLT ANDARDS Af edecroaumlra typ ropdeirslmyai nsa sc tsiousnap onutnedt ehrse c reening proviosf2i 8oU n.sS .§1C 9.1 5(e)a(n2§d)1 (9B1)5 Ai("fbt )ah cet iifsor ni voorl ous malicfiaoitulosss t, a atc el auipmo wnh ircehl miaeybf e g ranotres de,e mkosn etary relfireoafmd efenwdhaoin istm mufnreo smu crhe liBeafvl..Fl" a mig7l2i6Fo .3,4d 4 8,
45(23 Cdi 2r0.1 3S)e.ae l 2s8oU .S.§1C 9.1 5((e)if(no2 r)pm aau paecrtiiso2 n8s ); U.S.§1C 9.1 5(Aa ctiinwo hnispc rhi ssoeneerkres d rfersoasmg overnmental defend4a2Un .tS).§;1C 9.9 7(ep risaocnteibror nosu wgihtrthe spteopc rti son conditTihoeCn osu)mr.ut s atc ceaplftla ctaulalle gaitnaci oomnpsl aasti rnautne d takteh eimnt hlei gmhotsf ta vortaoabp lroes ep lainPthiifflv.l.C i opusno tfy Alleg5h1e5Fn. y32,d2 42,2 (93 Cdi 2r0.0 8E)r;i cvk.Ps aornd 5u5s1U, . S8.99 ,3 (200B7e)c.a uPslea ipnrtoicffep erodsseh ,ip sl eadiisln igb ecroanlsltyar nuhdei ds AmendCeodm pla"ihnotw,ei vnearr ptlfeualdlmeyud sb,teh eltdol essst ringent standtahrafdnos r mpalle addirnagfbsty le adw yeErrsi.c"vk .Ps aornd 5u5s1U, . Sa.t
94( citaotmiiotntse d). Ac ompliasnio nattu tomatfirciavloblleyoc uasuif stae it loss t aatc el aiSme.e Doolve.Wy e tz9e5lF7,. 33d6.63 ,7 (43 Cdi 2r0.2 (0q)u oNteinigtv z.Wk iell ia49m0s , U.S3.1 93,3 (11 98s9e)ae)l ;sG or ayvs.Mo any vSitewaH toes p29.3F, . 31d0 31,1 2 (3Cdi 2r0.0 2")R.a tahc elra,ii sfm r ivoonllowyuh se irdtee pen'doasnn " indisputably meritlleegtsahsle oorray" "c lebaarsleylo er"s fsa"n toards etliucs ifoancatlu"a l scenarDiooo.lv"e.W'y e tz9e5lF7,. 3adt3 7(4q uoMtiintgcv h.Heo lrnl3, 1 8F. 35d2 3, 53(02 00a3n)Nd eit4z9k0Ue .,Sa .t3 27-28).
3 Thel egsatla ndfaodrrid s miasc soimnpgl faofiran ittl uosr teaa tc el apiumr suant to1§9 15(e)i(ia2)n)§ d( 1B9)1(5A(ibis)d (e1n)tt oit chlaeel g satla nduasrewddh en ruloinnR gu l1e2 (bm)o(t6i)o Tnosu.r svc.Mh ceCru llo1u8g4Fh .,32 d3 62,4 (03 Cdi r. 1999H)o.w evbeerf,od ries miasc soimnpgl oarci lnatif ormf sa iltous rteaa tc el aim
upownh ircehl miaeybf eg ranptuerds utaotn hstec reepnrionvgi osf2i 8oU n.sS .C. §§1 91a5n 1d9 15tAh,Ce o umruts gtr aPnlta ilnetaitvfoaef m enudn leasmse ndment woubledi nequiotrfa ubtlSiele eeG.r ayvs.Mo any vSiteawHt oes p29.F3,. 3adt1 14. Ac omplmaaiybn etd ismiosnslieyfad ,c ceptthiwene gl l-pallelaedgeaidtn i ons thceo mplaasti rnuaten v di ewtihnegim nt hlei gmhotsf ta vortaotb hlpeel aianc toiufrft, concltuhdtaehtso aslel ega"tcioonunolrstda iasc el aoifem n titlteorm eelniBtee fl.l" At!. vC.To wropm.b5 l5yU0,. S5.4 45,5 (82 007). Though a"ldleetgaaitlieodn sf"a arneo rte quiarc eodm,p lmauisdnttom orteh asni mpplryo v"ildaeba enlds concluosr"i oafn osr"m urleaciicto aftt hieeol ne meonfatc sa uosfea ctiDoanv.vi". s AbingMteomn' I 7H6oF5s .p32.d3, 62 ,4 (13 Cdi 2r0.1 (4i)n tqeurontaalmt airokns
omittIenad d)d.i taci oomnp,l mauiscntot n tsauiffni cfiaecntmtua atlta ecrc,e patse d truteos, t aatc el atiorm e ltiheiafpst l ausoinib tflsae c See.eW illvi.Ba AmSsF CatalLyLsC7t,6s 5F .33d0 63,1 (53 Cdi 2r0.1 (4c)i Atisnhgcv ro.Ift q b5a5l6U, . S6.6 2, 67(82 00a9n)dT womb5l5yU0,. Sa.t5 70F)i.n aalp llya,i ntpilffe famaduc ssttus f ficient tos hotwh aac tl ahiamss u bstapnltaiuvseiS beiJelo ihtnys.Co inot fSyv h .e l5b7y4, U.S1.0( 201A4c )o.m plmaaiynn otbt e d ismifosrsi emdp ersfteactte moeftn hltees g al theosruyp potrhtceil nagai sms erSteeiedd a..t 1 0. Ac ourretv ietwhisenu gf fiocfiac e onmcpyl mauistntat k teh rsetee p(s1t:)a ke notoeft heel emetnhtpesl aimnutspitlff e taosd t aatc el a(i2mi);d entify tahlalte,g atio
Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE CHRISTOPHER BRIAN SANDS, : Plaintiff, v. □ Civ. No. 19-2275-CFC WARDEN DANA METZGER, etal, Defendants.
Christopher Brian Sands, James T. Vaughn Correctional Center, Smyrna, Delaware, Pro Se Plaintiff.
MEMORANDUM OPINION
May 4, 2021 Wilmington, Delaware
CL PCL. CONNOLLY, U.S. District Judge: l. INTRODUCTION Plaintiff Christopher Brian Sands, an inmate at the James T. Vaughn Correctional Center (JTVCC) in Smyrna, Delaware, filed this action alleging violations of the First and Fourteenth Amendments of the United States Constitution under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, the Establishment Clause, and the Religious Land Use & Institutionalized Persons Act (“RLUIPA”), 42 U.S.C. § 2000cc, et seq.’ (D.I. 3) Plaintiff appears pro se and has been granted leave to proceed in forma pauperis. (D.|. 6) The original Complaint was dismissed upon screening and Plaintiff was given leave to amend. (D.I. 8, 9) An Amended Complaint was filed on July 2, 2020. (D.!. 12) The Court proceeds to review and screen the Amended Complaint pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1915(e)(2)(b) and 1915A(a). I. BACKGROUND The following facts are taken from the Amended Complaint and assumed to be true for screening purposes. See Umland v. PLANCO Fin. Servs., Inc., 542 F.3d 59, 64 (3d Cir. 2008). Plaintiff was transferred to SHU? 17 on October 7, 2019, following a disciplinary write-up. (D.!. 12 at 5) Unlike inmates housed in the general population or
' The constitutional violations arise under 42 U.S.C. § 1983. When bringing a § 1983 claim, a plaintiff must allege that some person has deprived him of a federal right, and that the person who caused the deprivation acted under color of state law. See West v. Atkins, 487 U.S. 42, 48 (1988). 2 The Security Housing Unit (“SHU”) houses those inmates who have demonstrated that they cannot be housed in a lesser security and/or whose behavior and history are deemed to require maximum security housing. See https://doc.delaware.gov/views/jtvcc. blade.shtml (last visited Apr. 1, 2021).
"compoiunnmda,ht"oe uss ienSd H Ua rneo atl lotwoae tdt ernedl igsieoruvsi( cIeds..) Plaiantttieffnr deeldi gsieoruvasin cbdei sb slteu wdhye hne w ash ousientd h e compou(nIdd.. ) JTVCiCn mactaewnsa trcehl isgeioruvsi ces bbyIr nosatdicCtahusattni 1no9enl
ont eleviints hieoinr (cIedEl.ffl)esc .tF ievber u2a0r1ya8 n,pd r itooPr l ainttriaff'nss fer toS HU1 7D,e fenCdaapnttDa oidns wohno,i si nc harogfSe H Ub,a nnteedl eviins ions SHU1 7a n1d8 (. Iadt6. )T hne ewp oldiicndyo atf fiencmta itnBe usi ld1i92n,1g 2,s2 , an2d3 (./ dW.a)r dMeent zagpeprr otvhetede levbiasni(.oI nd .) Plaicnotmipffl aaibnoetudhtt e e levbiasininw o rni tsienntgtosD otsaonnd Metzagnewdra st otlhdha ets houhladvt eh ouogfth htce o nsequoefbn eciensg housienSd H Ub efohrece o mmitthtieen df ratchtcaiatou nsh eidts r antshfeer(reI a.dt . 6)Plaianltsciooff m plaiinwn reidt sienntgtoDs e fendSatnatcHseo yl lJiTsV,C C treatamdemnitn isatnrGdau tsCo hrr,i JsTtVoC,fC a ciclhiatpyln aeiinto,hfw e hro m respon(dIedd..) .
Ats ompeo ianfttP elra ifnitlhieifidsfn ictoimapll bauibtne tf ohrefe i lheids Amended Co(mtpdhlaeat wiean snt o ptr ovided)w,a stP rlaanisnftteoSir HfrU1fe 9 d whehreei as blteoa ttend rweeleikgslieyor uvbsiy cw east chCihnagn 1n9eo lnh iosw n televi(sIaidto. nT 7.h) u fsr,o Omc to7b,2e 0r1 u9n thiitlsr antsoSf HeUr1 9P,l aintiff wasu nabtlope r achtiirsce el idguiteoo tn h tee levbiasnih oiincsne alnlbd e cautshee tideirnd o hta vaet elevfioisrni moantt owe ast rcehl isgeirouvsi( cIeds..) Plaisneteiikffns j unrcetlaiinvecdefo mpensdaatmoargy(e sIa.dt8 . )
2 IllL.E GASLT ANDARDS Af edecroaumlra typ ropdeirslmyai nsa sc tsiousnap onutnedt ehrse c reening proviosf2i 8oU n.sS .§1C 9.1 5(e)a(n2§d)1 (9B1)5 Ai("fbt )ah cet iifsor ni voorl ous malicfiaoitulosss t, a atc el auipmo wnh ircehl miaeybf e g ranotres de,e mkosn etary relfireoafmd efenwdhaoin istm mufnreo smu crhe liBeafvl..Fl" a mig7l2i6Fo .3,4d 4 8,
45(23 Cdi 2r0.1 3S)e.ae l 2s8oU .S.§1C 9.1 5((e)if(no2 r)pm aau paecrtiiso2 n8s ); U.S.§1C 9.1 5(Aa ctiinwo hnispc rhi ssoeneerkres d rfersoasmg overnmental defend4a2Un .tS).§;1C 9.9 7(ep risaocnteibror nosu wgihtrthe spteopc rti son conditTihoeCn osu)mr.ut s atc ceaplftla ctaulalle gaitnaci oomnpsl aasti rnautne d takteh eimnt hlei gmhotsf ta vortaoabp lroes ep lainPthiifflv.l.C i opusno tfy Alleg5h1e5Fn. y32,d2 42,2 (93 Cdi 2r0.0 8E)r;i cvk.Ps aornd 5u5s1U, . S8.99 ,3 (200B7e)c.a uPslea ipnrtoicffep erodsseh ,ip sl eadiisln igb ecroanlsltyar nuhdei ds AmendCeodm pla"ihnotw,ei vnearr ptlfeualdlmeyud sb,teh eltdol essst ringent standtahrafdnos r mpalle addirnagfbsty le adw yeErrsi.c"vk .Ps aornd 5u5s1U, . Sa.t
94( citaotmiiotntse d). Ac ompliasnio nattu tomatfirciavloblleyoc uasuif stae it loss t aatc el aiSme.e Doolve.Wy e tz9e5lF7,. 33d6.63 ,7 (43 Cdi 2r0.2 (0q)u oNteinigtv z.Wk iell ia49m0s , U.S3.1 93,3 (11 98s9e)ae)l ;sG or ayvs.Mo any vSitewaH toes p29.3F, . 31d0 31,1 2 (3Cdi 2r0.0 2")R.a tahc elra,ii sfm r ivoonllowyuh se irdtee pen'doasnn " indisputably meritlleegtsahsle oorray" "c lebaarsleylo er"s fsa"n toards etliucs ifoancatlu"a l scenarDiooo.lv"e.W'y e tz9e5lF7,. 3adt3 7(4q uoMtiintgcv h.Heo lrnl3, 1 8F. 35d2 3, 53(02 00a3n)Nd eit4z9k0Ue .,Sa .t3 27-28).
3 Thel egsatla ndfaodrrid s miasc soimnpgl faofiran ittl uosr teaa tc el apiumr suant to1§9 15(e)i(ia2)n)§ d( 1B9)1(5A(ibis)d (e1n)tt oit chlaeel g satla nduasrewddh en ruloinnR gu l1e2 (bm)o(t6i)o Tnosu.r svc.Mh ceCru llo1u8g4Fh .,32 d3 62,4 (03 Cdi r. 1999H)o.w evbeerf,od ries miasc soimnpgl oarci lnatif ormf sa iltous rteaa tc el aim
upownh ircehl miaeybf eg ranptuerds utaotn hstec reepnrionvgi osf2i 8oU n.sS .C. §§1 91a5n 1d9 15tAh,Ce o umruts gtr aPnlta ilnetaitvfoaef m enudn leasmse ndment woubledi nequiotrfa ubtlSiele eeG.r ayvs.Mo any vSiteawHt oes p29.F3,. 3adt1 14. Ac omplmaaiybn etd ismiosnslieyfad ,c ceptthiwene gl l-pallelaedgeaidtn i ons thceo mplaasti rnuaten v di ewtihnegim nt hlei gmhotsf ta vortaotb hlpeel aianc toiufrft, concltuhdtaehtso aslel ega"tcioonunolrstda iasc el aoifem n titlteorm eelniBtee fl.l" At!. vC.To wropm.b5 l5yU0,. S5.4 45,5 (82 007). Though a"ldleetgaaitlieodn sf"a arneo rte quiarc eodm,p lmauisdnttom orteh asni mpplryo v"ildaeba enlds concluosr"i oafn osr"m urleaciicto aftt hieeol ne meonfatc sa uosfea ctiDoanv.vi". s AbingMteomn' I 7H6oF5s .p32.d3, 62 ,4 (13 Cdi 2r0.1 (4i)n tqeurontaalmt airokns
omittIenad d)d.i taci oomnp,l mauiscntot n tsauiffni cfiaecntmtua atlta ecrc,e patse d truteos, t aatc el atiorm e ltiheiafpst l ausoinib tflsae c See.eW illvi.Ba AmSsF CatalLyLsC7t,6s 5F .33d0 63,1 (53 Cdi 2r0.1 (4c)i Atisnhgcv ro.Ift q b5a5l6U, . S6.6 2, 67(82 00a9n)dT womb5l5yU0,. Sa.t5 70F)i.n aalp llya,i ntpilffe famaduc ssttus f ficient tos hotwh aac tl ahiamss u bstapnltaiuvseiS beiJelo ihtnys.Co inot fSyv h .e l5b7y4, U.S1.0( 201A4c )o.m plmaaiynn otbt e d ismifosrsi emdp ersfteactte moeftn hltees g al theosruyp potrhtceil nagai sms erSteeiedd a..t 1 0. Ac ourretv ietwhisenu gf fiocfiac e onmcpyl mauistntat k teh rsetee p(s1t:)a ke notoeft heel emetnhtpesl aimnutspitlff e taosd t aatc el a(i2mi);d entify tahlalte,g atio
4 becautsheea yrn eo m orteh acno ncluasrineoo netsn ,t ittotl heaeds sumpotfti rount h; an(d3 a)s sutmheve e raocfai ntwyye ll-pflaecatdaueladll e gaatntidho endnse termine whetthheoras lel egaptliaounsgsii bvrleiyt s oea n e ntitlteorm eelniCteo fn.n evl.l y LanCeo nsCto.r 8p0.9F, . 37d8 07,8 (73 Cdi 2r0.1 6) (ciinttaeatrninqdoau nlos t ations
omittEelde)m.ea nrtsesu fficailelnetwglheyed tn h fea citnts h ceo mpl"asihnottwh "a t thpel aiinestn itfitfto rl eeldIi qebf5a.5l U6,. Sa.t6 7(9q uoFteidnR.g.C ivP..8 (a)(2)). Decidwihnegt ahc elra iipsm l auswiibblell e" a c ontextt-asstpkhe racetiq fuitichr ee s reviecwoiutnrgodt r aowni tjsu diecxipaelr iaenncdco em mosne nsIed.." IV.DISCUSSION PlainnatmieHfdof l alsia ds e fenbdeacnatu" ssehi esi nc harogfae li ln mate treatamnepdnr to gra(mDs.1.I2a". t 9 )H en ameCdh riassat d oe fenbdeacnatu" shee itsh fea ciclhiatpyla anhidan as s aiyne veryptehritnagti orn eilnigsg eirovuis(c Ieds..)" Plaisnttaittffhe "asnt e i[tHhoenlrol Crih sr iwsrtoobt]ae c tkoh iomr h elpc[headn]tg hee situa(t/ido.n). "
Tot heex teHnotla lniCdsh riasrtneoa meadsd efendbaanstuespd o tnh eir supervpiossoirttyih ocenl sa,if masiI iltsw. e ll-esttahbtalhtie isrnsheo er de spondeat supelriiaobrui nldie1tr9y§8 3S.e eP arkeD/Iavn.b e8r3gF3,. 33d1 33,3 (03 Cdi r. 2016A)d .e fenidnaac nitrv iiglah ctts"i coann bneho etl rde sponfsoair b le constitvuitoilowanhtaiihlcoe hn[ n]e itphaerrt iciinnp oaartp epdr ovpeedr"s;o nal involvientm heaenl tl ewgreodin rsge quiBraerdav.k.M a c Gree4v8e1Fy .,31 d8 72,1 0 (3Cdi 2r0.0 7s)e;ae l sPoo lCkt vy..D ods4o5nU4,. S3.1 23,2 (51 98(1h)o ltdhiantg liabiinal i1§t9 y8a3 c tmiuosnbt eb asoendp ersoinnavlo lvneomrtee nstp,o ndeat superSiuocrih)n .v olvmeamybe en" ts hotwhnr oaulglhe gaotfpi eornssod niarle cotri on
5 ofa ctkunaolw leadnagdc eq uiescEevnacnecv.h.F"o i sh4e2rF3,. 33d4 73,5 (33 Cdi r. 2005). Thearrene o a llegatthiaHoton lasln iCdsh ridsitroec catulsPyel da intiff constithuatroimrto hntaahtle d yi reocttheetdro vs i olPaltaei nrtiigfhAftn'sfys. a ilounr e
thepiartr otr esptooPn lda inlteitffti'nesso ra stv ioloaftP iloani nctoinfsft'ist utional righSteseD.a vvi.Cs o rrecMteidoS.ne arvli c4e3sF6,. A pp5'2x( 3Cdi 2r0.1 1) (affirdmiisnmgio sfcs laalti hmpa rti sooffinc wihaodl in do rte sptooanl de twtreirtb tye n inmaftaeit loae ldl aec goen stitutioTnhaelr evtfihoocerll eaa,tia imgosan i)Hn.os ltl is anCdh riwsitbloeld ismissed. Simitlota hroe r igCionmaaplil ntthA,em endCeodm plianicnlttu hdleea sb oefl s thFeo urteAemnetnhd maenntdth Ees tabliCslhamuuesnnedt te hrFe i rAsmte ndment. Plaianltlieffg evsi otlhaeitinairc o onnsc lumsaonrnvyei ro lawtiitohfnoasuc tt ual suppoTrhtAe. m endCeodm pldaoiennsto p tl efaadc stusf fitcosi heotnwht ea itt her
clahiamss u bstapnltaiuvseiT bhielriettfyhoc.erl ea,iw mibsle ld ismissed. Libecroanlsltytr huaeil nlge gaitnti hAoemn esn dCeodm plaPilnatih,na tsi ff stawtheadat p petaobr eF irAsmte ndmferneetxe e racnidRs LeU IcPoAg nizcalbaliem s agaiWnasrtd Deann Mae tzagneCdra ptain Dotson. V. CONCLUSION Fotrh aeb ovree asotnhCseo, u writl( l1d:)i smtihsFeso urteAemnetnhd ment anFdi rAsmte ndmEesntta bliCslhamuceslneat i (m2ds)i; s mDiesfse ndSatnatcse y HolalniGdsu sC hriasnttdoh cel aiamgsa itnhseptmu rsutao2n 8Ut . S.§C§. 1915(e)(a2n)1d(9 B1)5(Ai()a);bn )(d(3 1a) l lPolwa itnopt riofcfe ed Daegfaeinndsatn ts
6 WardDeann Mae tzagneCdra ptDaoitns oontn h Fei rAsmte ndmferneetex ercainsde RLUIcPlAa ims. Ana ppprroioartdewe irbl ele ntered.