Salinas, Martin

Texas Supreme Court·Decided April 27, 2015·No. WR-73,707-05·Published

Opinion

~!.NO#-~ V.A.~?J-74'7· d{ Nif,·..lh;;fo- J 57

ex Pfif(rE ·:

CouA. I t;F

M Al~:r:zjl! SilL 7J)IifS

V) C/l.Zfrt z#A-L /lf>I'/Ei'll5

17-IE )./' 111/)zslA.zc/ fluS~ /£~5- (JJul/.:7 oF L<.,£/JA lrllf vzs c. 0Ctt,J7}'1:'

Co t.tPfy; 7&/tAS ~~£~~~l},Jtfu

Morzbf\1 APR 27 2075 1/Pt~LZC.A {z:-0/V Foil. 1,./AzT e;JF Abe~ Acosta, C18rk

MlftJ01tM&t5

;VoLt! C-ul'tl£f ti111A7z-/l SI1{.:QI/t5 AE.L/-17,/f</lf~PLz61tJ/, /1 L'"T-:-lllr /~l(o-S/.5

1

:ztJ 7itz:s CASF- /cl/1/) ;:_t.E.S 7/iz:.r /'4v'?7co/\/ 1?-;0PLzCA--;I:i>A/ . Fc;lt vAz/ cJI::/',1/1/ti/.)4-M tt.S z;v 't/;zcJL/t 7ic'f.?Af /'~oct£S5 /fli/V t?l: j)l4;:Z

". FffTII ~ srx·7lt /f/J'lt~0fl.t~IJ7.S 01: ?tire Co/JSTrl'i4 T.z:-vAI CJI;- 71{£ UJJzi:~o S747f0 oF dM lfl<~cA A/i!U l,J.Zt.L 51/.;w 7lf,.::: ;:::OLLfJt..J:z;J6~, . . / l"

1/~o 7 /111/JEA_S C.oll.f>qS !<£L:r~l--~/ :1...) 171/:/14i31U5" Cvu/1."/ /(4t) Uit.J/l£4)0/lllf/JL}/ .4~;>Lzr:7.) 7/r'>f Co/JS ?Z-7u 72:-cJ,Jtl/ L ;=;~:,::c>l-zw;: ttSS:ZS??JJu-: S?/;,4/);;1(/) 5 L/lz/.) otAT ~"N St&?d<UAI/) -V- WASII:.. ~fr ff!ti.lt-Ci6 Gt .sr ,,. B>~ os-~/ AN/) Ji;zi.L- v--loc..l<l/4111; 1.1-7¥ u.S". ~:J." 71-tt!-[ tli~'": O.::f7Az~1' Cvull7 {;.JlM1/i:// /1- cod/)z7:Z~/I//1L W~Z/ /1-{AIIJ 0/( /J;.('/( 1:!) 51~~..,-/:ZL /J£Al~A./Vt;ftlu.:-: ol:- 771/~ ol(z6zt-Jt1L 1::;~4. u/7.;:~ ~: S:z:;c Ii-I ;f.;:;::-zA..I'-'tt-:Vo ~.J;JLy.::N't. ,.Sr&.ze.l(.fAAf'J. -z-7 !0{,(;'i/O 77i.r?t CZ/<..C,f.l(-;:7'

CvuJJ steL 11-10 I,)Ro v z 0;=0 V/:-;:.zc Z"/~-N 7 iJ£~ ;:J/<.MA N C.t:.- /(,:: S(Je;tULJ- 1~1 S4t~-:;z.A.r-I.J /3t:cA-tt5tf ;.;,-: L~s;;- 7lt;.; o/.)/.J(/1( '7:tN:.z-r-y· ·r~ //11~,~ 721&-i" !t-1{)/{I.C ;::;r;vo/<../I/3U:J.- 3/~tvTF-.11/Di ot=/-/-i"/(1::;:) .-=N /11/c /:/L/~ ..

M. ~ss o~A::z- v- FI<.J(§_ t:.z7Jt /fS ~·' u.s.. __ (;Lot;z.). · 311 sw. J.r/ 3s-o f/AiJM-S e.~S·- 6h s-. I, 818 (J) . 7N.z-J jlllv'iZOIV ;<flf.JLzc..l'l /:zv;v (::c::>/l.. v~;r7 c.J 1:: M/l;v/.)/1~ us~ /7/V

oAzC- ziJIIL.. of< .Su8St-Etlt.-u~N7 ~pL-zc.l$1 T#v 1~/l 1..//Z,Z-7 V/:=- //~07 1/.4/}rtf. s~ coa;J£-t'li<£Lz-r:r:

ll JLfll( caN\1-z~?i~/J l'1-;.f.;L£Ll41vT {-vll ltC-ld.AvJ1-1/E-0 /1-SSktll T i./rill Ptr4/JLy W't?A/?o~<.l IJAf/) SBJ7/-vJuZ 117-, ·7"0 (,o(sz~ty) '(1~4-/lf ;z-/J PA.zSO/I/.

A-PPL~CAIJt r-.:ztr: !fd t/.o/!l!f/Jn4.> &llt:>qf, 44;/) -=N t=t~3'!.;:_~tl?}:;_, ~-3,.---:..<oto ·::t~~ 3) Cot4/l..-r cJI..: CA.~r/IJ~ll tfr?MtS /l.rf:..114-1AJ0rCO 71(,_::_ C-4Sl'- t?.; ~~~/: ?A.zt!( c_::

!~·f/411-U[ MAA7;z:t./ $4~/ff N~J,·w~t-73 -7o7. . CJI {:J!{/)1£1<,' l'f-;Vplzc:4#t' C..o/117};./11/)J 7li47' 1/.~s 771-~~l C(.)~NSt~L /{£/J/),.;/k.:U ~#/Ct~=e-?Zv/: 4-S5- . .zs74 tJu:: 8;..-c4 ctsr: ·rwt:£/.1.. ttlr.t~: Si"': f.>ll.;:,v r-N;;...-LJ· 11.;.:::~ ~~/C.;)H 2t5'2Ztj/~,/£. :zgJ f{:c>· /);;.t:;EtlSt~- Jf-/110 L):zL) IJo/ ~f)i!'4Ju47/-:Ly .:ri4/V.·~/.z64k- 711/£ C4Ji:.-: .11-tltzUr.lt t/45 . 11Lt.t-:.6r-:IJ t=-/fc.-?J· 7/f..-1~ zt: ~1.("_7 M.:rt.V/ 1~/11~/Zr.-- ll~ -r:> ;2£t. ~;.;,:: .,s"fllrd_<4NIJ -v- &JJISHz~l€~ La'

~...S 6oft Of 9"¥)

(!~PMTi: L,£;11(~ /J Sw. J,/ 79~ 79S: '~' {Ui;~: 0'1.~- Ai~l~ ::l~uol .

71(,{ Cat.!A;/·r.JI~ C/<;Q~-?:zN.-f/.. lftJfJr-4{5 0£hzr:,£) A-p;JL.z:c.4NiT 1/. o 7/14/3/3/IJ COI'l/JCJ!5 iJI<Z'f' (J)j./ /2tr- ;:::zd)r;.i (.);: 7tY.£ /t413d45 C.Jc..t/!..7. /(1( ;),£c75:7.~t ?7l~~­ ;:;zwt:rt:zc.7Z.Vtt: ·-4f:JZSt4/llu: c..t./?z-~ CIN n~-,.- (,..A.<.:~wn.~IJ•J~-~~r /Ztfr-: I(£G?ct/D 7 ot: 11-/';JLCU,.;,/~f /d.:z/IL H77oMiif 4# If /ev/l.;vL'Cr_· ];.)z/1/ GhU-~/? £)(....

1

P~-::£d_t:Jf, 11-f ~ ell::;./~. j)~;£/1/Si~ ~ :-?.J/2/lJ/~f' ~55 zs-z:.:_-iJ A;¥Lz_::!~Jrs /l/ 7v..~J!Itt.y· Ovtll..-::..wt ///""- //CU'~ AnO !ILL l?~t&::-0 /7147 47+>'-zc..-?AJ ~ W/1--..>r AIDt.

- {;..v::z'Aiv

. I "/:

·t--o ·--- __.... -

//-~sc·~"/--y 1

tllr: S74?A- /l-'f/3r-:4) "//l.ZdL Cou/l7 /~O~N/) ~47' l~tL LSO/il /)~;tzZAI/.. /lt.lf 13~ 1~4--1< ~w ?k/c 7/t...z.~¢£ 7~>1/) s /fl,:::E:A11S ;.;;:/\) 11iA/?.5 oN LJ 1.)~,-=.s (~1/ (.'1[ 7iM7" fl£ 1(--ft) /26-f ~-'-tttT c.:> ~73:::1~, :zd./1711 $#{ L..u.J#f /tcx:.£=?,.;~z} ;;Ll .::::.."{ o1v /IND j:Jd-id..S~,/ /{I) Vzui" /V.J/ / z-_;;, ;:=;,;;s;4/-y· .

fllii S/47/: 1(.-fl}ll,(.f ?;1.Z4t Co'-td7 //;~tJ) 77147 PA;Ift2So~v ·;,//15 ;vu7'k /),.; i~;zc. z!CtJ7 t=-o~t PM'VJ£N/;;zd r54tz-AIIfS) ;::;z.;;,vt -;;::::.f /~Fv....:;-/1-)t- ,I ( SAt.~/15) w-1-5 :ZIJ NllM£:£) v1: tVzs /{"".61/7 -z; ?!"::s /~Fy- .=:A/ It .... -;> owrv 0£!-",:;;/IJsr.;, !1--P~-~1} 7/i~z VJ?f /I..ZS /)£ crs:zotv i,J/I£72.£/:;e 7 ) 72'5/:rr l/7 L>l(-b/11~ s] I./£C...z-.ur

,, .)1 -./)

.... v JJ,;?7

-- -~

~__,

.,.-:-- - - /,_-:.J~'~~r-·.

,~

tf) T/IF-!<r: Ill/£ 1\10 FAc.-1'5 '70 S~;Jo/2.. T 7fl,r F;;ql/);zntS 11-/110 COAl c.L f.{ s zJ/V &r /ltr; /{4i3M.S 7ll.c;/fl CcJ({r<7'i /flfBM5 JuL)61i f!JAJ'Ly ;ll,-ct<p/F-tJ ~~­ /Rr-

£LL;zs "N~ 7/..s7Zno1"_, l3y Accti(::i77/ll ;vt~£Llz5o/JlS /47Z~()/IIY /1-S z:t':.. llr: W/15 [o·-~Sfif wz/h' M>- /)M.--1.5i>N ~ /ll.:z:;.f Coi//C:l.c.tSZV# :zs /"f.ZSCMil.dt= c:Jt= Jt.tr~zu::/ /l(~ I</£ Co/4./) 31/ov~ ?'i/4 7 rtA. t=:-LLz,>:>N w/fS A/i>'T' /ljJpLz-c._4/v/5 A-7/oMr.y t11JO 72{~ ST/11?.: ll-4tY4.5 cc:Jt..(d ~ ';;er~t. c, /Cb!L t.ll!/1 c- "£"7 t.JA-5'.. cSlit r£ ~E.)lr~:oJt.. l'tS~ J->aii.)Qidl )

7'Jl T/.lZ/fL /f 77v/l/IIA-Y .1!§. .flii1J;· 1/AIJ&r.> :ft<IJk- AdN~wL£1!J£j} 7Hifr PIA. &l.tzsoev V4.5 N£v£/l- ol'l=-zc. z:Ati..y'- A/!'A-..z~t) A;$ co-CoutvS&i. (i~v. 11. P- l3 8') -rHi£$741'tb:· --.. rrv. ~===::::::=:=-

-

4?- '({{UJ W'/C i/"1/) -VII£- f'c/I.A /)~/) /(.lfVt£ CO-C.<-X.L#S/;:1. ?

6-u~IV't. 7.:? o/J "J£c..7 /"''ll- £Lt.z-s011/ w-45'

,MJl.S{I!liOI'f/1/1, ·__ f'vf.dl-1/oliJo/l. . Zr--r N1YrJl tJH--zc~tly 4;<Jj?~z-N7X'U n) C<J- Ct.n.u.I~/L-t. ~ A-Pif /(,( $42;/J 1*':- /'1-ppl£1/?/;-t)

4-5 14 M ~oil';} .z M/'.:/9/1/ ::L JH~I< z, 7 /1/;:r:-iJJ" ·£.:>_ IJ;-..- LJa:-z/v/£0 Fo/l w/t4i :;( w4..s-.

:zs S14S7A~AI£LJ ,, w:z: 7"11

1

71ft= o/}';]f£C tz-o;V !<£Fit'A&nt:JE :£o {¥r woll/) /11£ t£LL;zso,r/ - IJt£:&#/fr co- CounS £L ·

/Vlll.t 13LL::ZSvN w/IS No-t' I~Pj)LZL.J1;J7'S H7'Z'o!VW~- ,1-{1)0 771~ /UPIZ45' 7A_:afL CcJL~tJ1.7 f/l-AC£P M~>llA Vt:::zC-117 oN J'-t/l, i;--a~sJ/11) ..z:::s7Fz..-r.t¥Vy· .1-S ·7i.> 27?,.£ /(r: CtJLlt&:.;t;..v,.V cJI.: 7#,-: ~Sk/WvA~y· oC: rfr;t)t:z-c/IAJT<f 7/l.z:/f( /¢ 77~/VI~-,

·/ii;.c 114/JiiA) Cot.tll7 /1-IJuSr.:P o/: J)CSU<t::..l"zv/1/ 13y /vv/ 74-1<=/.lt ;vt5: 1);;;1/l. Solll P-:.s&~o~t~y oiL tt;;p~c4/4f/J X57"~ "J'Jf'· 72/4 ~ Co;.,r{/2./f /)~d'S

1

"fl;lrC J~c_"hj' ~AI/) co,Jct..u5z-o;.) t.J/::' /H/-:- /14/}r:/I..J COuA 7/ F.:ztif/).,;zll){;S

$) 7lJ/£ ;:4c;7i5 A-/C/-C 7ltr- II~/:JtC45 C.>c-ttt. 7' k)zL} Nti7 ul</£' .....::::./v 0 CotJ s~;.J;;M 7:..-CI/V .1-N)/ cY /t(/C/(. 7l=s7~ ~7:~ 13'-t' 7" P"-1~ lzL l--;J:PN'f ALvllt:::. 7/{z-AL 11/7oM~y ~~-tS- /~A:4£.S::J/t/ 7li::S~1:r· Til ?71;-:- /.::JLLoL./-::.:;/6:

J.

/E . .u . ,,) { /11.5. Ptr41<$v/lj_ '7i:~trr/=y::zWt J ( 1- V~ tl ( . / 1T ·711.'Z!fL 11 r rv/2.NI;y (.(u;.[Sfil//,. IJ'y' /24/(. $/;.;'_{() 1"'1AI .

Q _. s 0 1/IM (' 1lk- --r ~~t=~-5 Z.5 - /1 ?" L F-A-.fT L)q;P._;rw[;_ 7li/C 71( zAl.. Y""' IVGV/£"~ IJ~-st:.LtJ5£tJ tlzs· /<Zt/(7' To i-~~~y· w.zrt{ /{.z~.

If~ :r /):zb A/PI - --c:= -./ N_o. ~

(!( -ol~y~JUiJO :ztJ Fille-T ;Jfi.Z"d?l< Tv 7A £/fL tit: /(41) I~KPL /lzlv/50 t:"o yoct, 7714T /'It-: W/1-/117/~tJ z-~ ~?i-1-y ~

li ~ yEf _% bo fliic.ILl T/111{.

( Ev. I{ P. l l ) )

6>- s~ wlletJ 7l1C /1/Jt.>L.zL/1111'1' 1"1/t~. S~L~AS 5t/fll£S £/1/ /lzs-- ZIJ (-IrS (->,=::~kP;y'

" , , 7ti47- · z;J t{~ #-f';>Lzc.17fvl~ 71//17 c..o,aiiSF-L t«;;t:-u)1·~t)1 ~;) /o u·~/ t:>;~7Z'?Z-..¥Vt£'..( ~£Srzr:-~ o# !lz.r-0 w,v /]t£1t4u: 1 1,./ttr-N z~t~ !~c.--r H~-c £v"--J yvl.f 71~4r it't-::. WI!AJ7i=tJ t.:; i),-."-CAI.{.5l: w-~utO I.)Atrv.r~ tl:z::> Z/1/Noc.CE/Ifct:.- 71fA 7 Y'cJL< /l"~~~s.~:: --zt;

z 1

At.Lf)w tt:z"" ·r-=' fi~s7zt-y,,. l)o YP4. lf6/vi;: oil. LJ.:c-5~~--z;:: ;;./z71t /dAr s/4;;;;~ N/?

II- -w£tL" 7114 7 ·-- yvCA 1<1ik1W .z Jt..tsT-- -r l(Aw:: (v u/<J~ r,:) l?cCc.Jwf/,rr MA_, t5"t:.L-

ZJ.:v,P5 7/;:~(zpt,op.~y- J1S Wt~LL·

<..P- t-.)~LL Z'M No7. ..

Q- OMy - /Joy.;~,. t=tu~L -- /Jo yv{..( /f{,../lti/i" I34S1-:0 et/t.l yoult ..c/Jl0!tt14/?-?"E-d/v A-LoNF[ 7'it47 v~u f<t[I--U$1-L/) 7;:; u 7 /{.Z~ 7/CS"Tz.f'y· nJ ,,,:c S//177-5' ZiJ liz> 4pp i.,zcA·/.z~d::

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Salinas, Martin, (Tex. 2015).

Salinas, Martin (Salinas, Martin) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.