Ryan Klaassen v. Trustees of Indiana University

7 F.4th 592

Opinion

In the

United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit

GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGK

&AK87H898<K 


 B'ABK &
BK

!%K

  

  BK &
AK

GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGK

 ((( (  ((((( (((  $(( (#( #(% & & !"(('(
  $
#( GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGK

 
8B8687K GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGK

&)K
 BKBK%K B' ' AK 
 B' ' AK+)+ %K%/+K*$*+)BK##K*+,H %+*K +K % %K % -)* +0K $,*+K K - %+K  %*+K  H7?K ,%#**K +0K )K /$'+K &)K )#  &,*K &)K $ #K )*&%*AK/$'+K*+,%+*K$,*+K.)K$*"*K%KK+*+K&)K +K **K+. KK."AK +K*+,%+*K&%+%K %K+ *K*, +K ++K +*K &% + &%*K &K 5%%K - &#+K +K ,K )&**K #,*K&K+K&%*+ +,+ &%F*K&,)+%+K
$%$%+AKK *H +) +K &,)+K % K '# %+ 4*FK )(,*+K &)K K ')# $ %)0K 8K &AK87H898<K

%!,%+ &%BK 8687K AAK  *+AK  K 799966K DAAK %AK ,#0K 7>BK 8687EBK%K+0K*"K,*K+&K **,K%K %!,%+ &%K'% %K''#AK  -%K'!%' "BK7?=KAAK77KD7?6;EBK. K &#*K++KK*++K$0K)(, )K##K$$)*K&K+K',# K+&KK - %+K  %*+K *$##'&/BK +)K %F+K K K &%*+ +,+ &%#K ')&#$K. +K- %+ &%K %*+K
H&H8AK# %+ 4*K*H *)+K++K+K)+ &%#H* *K*+%)K,*K %'K&*K%&+K &4)K %&,K ')&++ &%K &)K + )K %+)*+*K %K ++K &,)+*K *&,#K%&+KK*K)%+ #K+&K+K * &%*K&K',# K& *K *KK.*BK,+KK&,)+K&K''#*K$,*+K''#0K+K#.K*H +# *K0K+K,')$K&,)+AK # %+ 4*K %-&"K*,*+%+ -K,K')&**AK%)' & '!%' BK;87KAAK=68BK=86I88KD7??=EBK%K&+)K H * &%*BK*,K%K),$%+K'%*K&%K+K/ *+%K&KK,%H $%+#K) +K %) %K %K+K
$) %K##K+) + &%AK+K& BK. K*,*+ %KK) $ %#K&%- + &%K&)K),* %K+&K K- %+BK*&.*K++K'# %+ 4*K#"K*,KK) +AK&K+K &%+))0BK - %+ &%K )(, )$%+*BK # "K &+)K ',# H#+K $*,)*BK-K%K&$$&%K %K+ *K%+ &%AK
%K+ *K*K *K* )K+%KK&)K+K% -)* +0BK&)K +.&K)*&%*AK  )*+BK K *,*+ %K K - %+ &%K )(, )$%+K ++K #"K/'+ &%*K&)K,#+*AKK7?=KAAK+K96AK,+K % %K % -)* +0K *K /'+ &%*K &)K ')*&%*K .&K #)K - %H + &%K %&$'+ #K. +K+ )K)#  &,*K# *K%K')*&%*K&)K .&$K - %+ &%K *K $ ##0K &%+) % +AK K ')&H #$*K++K$0K) *K.%KK*++K),**K+&K$"K&$$&H + &%*K +)&)K )K %&+K ')*%+K %K + *K *AK %BK * /K &K +K +K'# %+ 4*K-K# $K+K)#  &,*K/'+ &%BK%K K*-%+K *K#  #K&)K +AK*K'# %+ 4*K!,*+K%K+&K.)K &AK87H898<K 9K

$*"*K%KK+*+BK)(, )$%+*K++K)K%&+K&%*+ +,+ &%H ##0K')&#$+ AKDK +K'# %+ 4K&*K%&+K(,# 0K&)K%K /$'+ &%BK. K *K.0K.K-KK!,*+  #K&%+)&-)*0AEK &%BK % %K&*K%&+K)(, )K-)0K,#+K$$)K&K +K',# K+&KK- %+BK*K **,*5*K K %KAK  %+ &%K *K %*+KK&% + &%K&K5% %K % %K% H -)* +0AK&'#K.&K&K%&+K.%+K+&KK- %+K$0K&K#*H .)AK %0K,% -)* + *K)(, )K- %+ &%K %*+K
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
$%$%+K$%*K++KK*++K%%&+K+##K%0&%K .+K+&K)K&)K.) +BK,+KK*++K,% -)* +0K$0K$%K++K *+,%+*K)K+ %*K+0K'))K%&+K+&K)K%K.) +K+ %*K +0K'))K%&+K+&K.) +AK
K*+,%+K$,*+K)K.+KK')&**&)K ** %*BK -%K K +K *+,%+K $*K +K &&"*K )+ #BK %K :K &AK87H898<K

$,*+K.) +K/$*K&)K**0*K*K)(, )AKBKAABK' !%' ' ' ' ' $##BK 7;K A9K <>6BK <>=K D=+K  )AK 7??:ECK ' !%'
BK ?7;K A9K 96>K D:+K  )AK 867?ECK ' !%' '' 'BK>8=KA8K<>:KD77+K )AK7?>=EAK
K *+,%+K +&#K +&K %#01K +K )&#K &K %  # *$K %K &*+&-*"0F*K ' K,+K.&K*,$ +*K%K**0K&,+K &F*K$&+ -H + &%*K %K K. ##K3,%"AK K&% + &%*K&K )K,+ &%K$0K %#,K*,))%)H %K ')&')+0K %K &##&. %K %*+),+ &%*K &,+K .+K +&K )K %K .) +BK +K *K )K +&K *K K )+)K ')&#$K . +K $ #K &% + &%*K++K#'K##K*+,%+*K)$ %K*K.%K#)% %AK
K,% -)* +0K. ##K-K+)&,#K&')+ %K.%KK*+,%+K )*K++K-)0&%K#*K$0KK*') %K **AK.K'&H '#K.%+K+&K)+,)%K+&K)$&+K,+ &%J%K.K&K%&+K+ %"K ++K+K&%*+ +,+ &%K&)*K+K *+%H#)% %K'')&K&%K K,% -)* +0K++K# -*K- %+ &%KD&)K$*"*K%K)(,%+K +*+ %K &K +K ,%- %+EK . ##K $"K %H')*&%K &')+ &%*K *K%&,AK K$&+ &%K&)K%K %!,%+ &%K'% %K''#K *K% AK