Russell v. . Garner

172 S.E. 405, 205 N.C. 791, 1934 N.C. LEXIS 76

• Court: Supreme Court of North Carolina
• Decided: January 24, 1934
• Status: Published

Opinion

Civil action for mandatory injunction and for damages.

Plaintiff alleges that the old Styers Mill Road in Forsyth County has been used for ingress, egress and regress to her farm forty years or longer, and that said road was dedicated to the public use many decades ago. This is admitted by the defendant.

It is further alleged, and supported by evidence, that this road was widened in 1925 with the consent of the adjacent landowners. The defendant, L. G. Garner, purchased 4 1/2 acres of land on the east side of this road, as widened, in January, 1928, and has erected a barbed wire fence across a part of the road, forcing traffic to the west side and rendering it practically impassable with heavy trucks at any time, and with other vehicles when the ground is wet or muddy.

At the close of plaintiff's evidence, there was a judgment of nonsuit, from which she appeals. We are not advised as to the theory upon which the judgment of nonsuit was entered. It would seem to be erroneous under the decisions in Colvin v.Power Co., 199 N.C. 353, 154 S.E. 678, Grant v. Power Co., 196 N.C. 617,146 S.E. 531, and Tise v. Whitaker, 146 N.C. 374, 59 S.E. 1012.

There is evidence (1) of dedication of the road, as widened, (2) of its obstruction by the defendant, and (3) of special injury to the plaintiff. This carries the case to the jury. 13 R. C. L., 231; 29 C. J., 631-632.

Reversed.