Ruffin, Johnathan

CourtCourt of Appeals of Texas
DecidedApril 17, 2015
DocketWR-82,256-02
StatusPublished

This text of Ruffin, Johnathan (Ruffin, Johnathan) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Texas primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Ruffin, Johnathan, (Tex. Ct. App. 2015).

Opinion

IJB“. _ gg/Q©U'OZ

E" 7’?"[°" § a:s:l¢»:: :);;>:;/.::F ;)\\\B'U'\‘S{\ /l?/\»\W\'n) RECA-M l ‘TDCD' /\)o, l‘)/%Bo \ § couRT oF chMlNALAPPEALs §\ ' ' APR 17 2015

' , . , ' , , - Ab , , /dpthm§/S E)r\§ma\ c©b<)a@/‘Flm 110 Z//'-»pélif .e| gsé?$m kabeas gvél-"”h?.).?“rjqané_go V/A@(d(,@)gp{, //,07 3 ¢1{,:1£,/:‘, Co/os'r"., Ame/~)D,,. /_) /'7¢;@@/;[@[ §/}aczs§ »é) @vr{'$ BM\ H~o§l/ProW/'m

"To 11/1€ //o,\/OQA$LE :)’u$T,/ce;>' oF Cz)UK/‘T' oF£i€//~A//\ML A?‘?”é>¢?i,$ pFTM§ .-: games /1/01,3>. ’:>';kna#)a/) Qu {:me¢/‘i/ 4030;- ijm /ls /\/07' A/J ' mm€?; bj¢é, wl)kw é/aas wm 710 M/@> _M,j_§ -/1¢077@»/ ,/;.~Wi/j, C‘””"$`£TM@O/ 170 _?@Mlé/ncf /}9/0 scls` -FQ\/<>\$`,,. Se:z, ;,/'/6)//)@$ 1/ ,&n@/; 4’@4 ¢/,§,5/9, 32 5 c,,/, 5€¢/, 30 L,ez/, 2d 453 ~__, habeas C’UU 257 a<>é/@m 471/ls /Y)pf/fcé/n€ Bkna‘n%en “?ug:l:nb£/§/’v%<§@ j CW)C'$ 1/¢ %z 248 § 3101 fcia/l ':Dl's{ricé L'm)r{; sp /'/é’rm”s ,co.,,'/ZXQ\S ¢L>/% '#/;S j$%é~'/' habeas Qa»{v‘¢/n, came nol /3 ‘75’ 314-4 ~ 157 \@¢/ ¢;, mma z@/§," wa _,LA¢ %/§m'$ ¢@, 1935/w cl@/)<» cms ‘®eni@l//@/ Fren\<\fn -’P~<'>, 34 4@5//,%1).:4%,@@§ ‘772.1@~%.<.~/,_ `

t 713 ‘57'#7'5': orueu/\/A£'Aw/Smei°; of /V`MMH zo/_s"/,@S* ml:§cm§évued C/al'm$ ag /QHQ}{¢Q/l-é§ 5 w;#»ow‘)’ elm/wm 143 c@mw£_ M,%f/> 1/¢\@5@ YM/Jow/'W£S_; %@ Swm: l'/)@/'Lw($~$ &wéro\)efé@@/ issues 9)"10[ 'F?WFS , wAi`@/L\ 115 0/3/'/»'\@/ 143 bc aheaan C@/iél@/'G@) §§ J/A@ 577‘*75¢- 7//1<€@@\¢ dwéro\l<¢!‘{:€@[ ‘w£é<‘/‘¥§) %36 'Frzz IJ,/mz~S’O/U@o/ -pec>/ch/ b&$£s g 133 C/@§?/£z,§y § 443 QFP)@,\J¢:< @m£'n¢m£’;,w)];% ,;, .<~¢.@sm .L>/ a Lz)'"@,¢z;f@w' 3'13@6'@@_,kw@’ nwf.~ g ` ‘ %,%/c#/\/fs 33 je:cr/@~/ ' _ _ AW/)'azné’s ‘ObJ¢¢F/%o _,é éw.élsjv¢opw@ gwin/gs op WCT’..); 5(.@`%;@( m 24 MM _zo/§, 3¢,00§;&3/ fn 77(\"53, mart bi><;w% Qrs~{'*o\`e.<“s /f)o)+e§¢ §)@/1331'@/ fm 5%¢_&‘33 3 )'\QS nO-L~@/C/, had g 'de§@'.m“é (?Zno{zfea{ 0100»’))';, ba£;>:`z »[/A@ ['UU[LT;§ D@@g go grme --l@ ;'€w¢%¢¢CZJM/MHL %FFNS oF 75>@¢);€_777'1¢/5, 6'3¢/5//>5 Un{:@fV`/{) mg v~@!{cfa/ {me;érr{é/l% 1[@»0211>( -#\LS AH@ /'Cgmé ,. 57777@_ OFM~$i h€b¢€$ duffl¢<\$_ frOQ,

l@§@lf@ § 443 @Fp)»zg»-é;v am 123me ,%:: QW).&QA+

13 711-315 711 53 1115 @e‘bréeawe 31>1>\¢’ 591-113 §111:.-111111+ 3'°500¢ 3 volé;én~‘agp\@’,. 5501‘11'\1'115 533 been walmeal 33 655€0)1'6315\5 :@tigin@l 0295&05/’31..-§31\05 91® ej<"; unless me 5>01»505 '001}1\£ 553 333> m331"¢§ 15@1“®31;`51'/3§ ` op _5\319@€5 mead 1'./,35> Q~,S 311 #Nswef"»_» 5)55510 5511`5 AW/ 562/1555 O~\Q\Semgw’); 5`€¢ <`e?{)e$’é:'j#\@';§)/@{/§£ 5 " v " ° w ‘ l

7) 131/5053/13"2@ 5@3'1`1/15 ,2`)"®1'6 couerj 1/`)'€0§;5$ SDFP¢OOQ“O(L[W] ahd'fn§femL/% expvaer 315 mikva 'i'»>/C&or{: m1'51351

> `7r1'35 633-b 71“31~13'1`{>3 , 35 <55\<'>¢ £UU¢T r_¢¢ofd?$~memo's 5>'®0¢1,(,1@_. ‘~33¢3 e){o¢@v€$z 313 1/3155433?/0 05 53553/10'#\57 , e5c11... ` ' _ /\/0.551//\5 5135 325£/)’17(01?3\/7 035e1’12051`/1 -551115 5)3;5e3§ 3>5?/)7, 15111),-511@£1>@5/13 M> 553 9€1>,’"€?“5' 536/1311 553 55‘@ §‘m’l€$ 031/5 311193)110€)`§55\3 i/)e§Ql¢'§ § 5`15~5 émffnemen"éj 11)5\<23 %e'gqg¥.é 313_(;, 1135 43115@1)”/, 225»/1331 20/5, 1115 \0351235 1 1131>»<1 5“'l>aiéme13@l kaye 333 " 1110 451-1133 333 OF - 5 M 1 '“"`55‘0\* “ ¢¢1@€1'1'¢3»5$‘ 5055<:05/39 3 ewers 1311)“1>11\16$* 1336

CU.\5 1031 r> 3/1'53’13'3:7 5\<;2(1`/\5 313 ` »/_D[$ao\d@rj /F./@cs_z§$ § 012-55\1’0 _~//511“_5 013 55@’1'/@,\/9 _755,3-{» we,fm

1131155\¢/1/+()1,133311315 rm\05e:`e<>l 30 §>\051\1"5{1 _5_5\@(@{0,._

7*`/<1/+1_ wom- 1015/plugs

/?31533/13 50 %A&@U,)Q,Ar{jeale l/:.O'Y)' I// /»,;1,@¢;,< LWF“S i553e.5 muir -I>e 1050/bed fn 553 T¢~j’a/ §,_,,r~r_) b¢.l;,{-@ PiM',/UJ 35 33 131 ha eaa/veal 315 ,e¢a»med@€a,.$ 1933 y 5:@"““°5@5 5"'" 550 1'@'<>05 50 »550’ fwva 1515 CmM)/QAL 3%%: 5 05`“'1’9'izn,~é) no, )3'7<% 2314 ( 211/835 ”Dz`sérlL+ 31.)(~5 35 kf/'grrfs @0_,)"1/@<3$>) hc@w$ wm ), gm 3m m@"j -?@'"w@ 3091-011va maker/al -!0 553 /05011'!3 »5` A!,o//'CQ/"é/¢S M£Emm'é »-':/_:r) 10511'051 .) %e$e; Cw),/Ya:/Ve;f{'ed /'SSHCS need 5 be (‘e;olve@/ i`/) 45510<7’¢1'3[ Ay»r{: 1/;3 3#}’013~?£:) 050500?51'0»$,1}1/5@¢/033751/1'@, 3105 an 301'313153@ 5130€7/§; 5:>1`3 535 5 3111/5 1530 1`1'§.51‘5'. 050 7:,»'@3-35)7 %@ Mr£§..,,d,j, @’,4, 001\15'/’41141:13'1>5./)/`¢/¢_' - 1 ' 5 * ' '

jrflv*% ome/nme Ay\/$@oa€"`

‘ "Me: 553£05>01\01 hale eva‘§me~ believe;’bj /15§ pure 3@’"6511_§/"0/)') 13 145/1315 553@>530[ e/faie/)<:e'~ 05 313 ‘)Ci'nd 515/1315 ,&vmcl was eLFmL)H/e @f 510 359 51"@@/1'5 /@05:005 015»_ 550#‘¢@”; 1'/1 .M@ 57131*5£5 0361/1//1¢ /41~151)113<, w)\€f¢ 510 §fW’E/]p/M'O\eo/ €>(#/BITS , 521 550 CUD.,lCV,.'“/#ESE &<17‘133/7: stw

l I 1`}¢§2{/71)/@¢@{)0@$ 5 577‘)‘7'63 9<'#/7¢23’/7' /4 f gm emerme pf'°Sf/D€R:|' wman oF c@/JSTI/'MTIO»ML 2116#75) %KEM&;,T .TD

sm m/,A»re,#m> `FMD»¢i/H_ cw/F€ssi¢>~ " /\[g,z)"zs¢§§$@z ,. 77¢/5

` WA]VBK '[5 j¢¢é@#{,;*po(:¥A}g§O/LL?[@ f`|(g/\+S cC/ZWHO‘€ b@ »

wafv@r)@m w ;~w.~ MU'€; rmpz¢ m@é@b"@ 041 +¢WS@ <\\'S)\‘€S 115 004 510'500@4 3’\34 \*@emoé ha L'O@W@/ of ~14<;)¢-4-`¢’¢£@/,. }<1<1:564\' ruich \/é §=éa‘bz.,_‘il) 5@2.»>{ /5(¢,.. me@rc; ~[/Af_$ ;FM'. 75 »M lam‘é'/J,Ji'gr\eol @-@ixk/:r, 15 \/ou) ¢m ;-‘}5'15&¢§,,. ZL)}\;,;@Q;; ~@\ ONLY cvi‘o\& Az‘sm wwgf<’] .‘5“01.’¢;@! aw.\€¢§$im’,_-~/P)¢Q.s@$@, AC/l£'\@r¢ V, s+@%¢:,§€s 5@204 éBc,z,@/)£ S~Mz:vj ‘"'If 7!//;;;§ ¢jwq,'dg{ w.`€’¢$;im" was -Mc @nlj wider/me in _,§A¢ m¢¢‘,~¢/(, wcc would .k@\r¢ ~é@ .szL/MO(C ~é¢\él£' '[¢a: C'uide/)¢@ ¢03_<; ,’/,.. -5¢,¢-@§:10,&@4 40 514$€21!(/) c'? émI//'l‘/~é/?Y)M. g)C»L)/'LGL /Q;owc

. ,él\@ 657;97€5 oa\é]/d,¢;/L, ANSM>erL’) is 3 nq~ewm\z/){/j Qm@{'@/

3"\'@’“ m€”‘é<°/l 54<`>1@“'*\¢”'5 »~`4'~5; ‘SM &-»W-S Ex'l~'ib#:> ,,.clwlg 511@_»»$ -£A;é “QICF@AM Q(,(§ZH',) )GT>'L»A@U`QA QWMJ w;l’i\ 040"@€0_048/»4 was -H\C '6.~/\<;

1040 @X@QMJCCA __.-44¢°».$. 04060\'¢1\¢04,6&)141\/@& 060 QOQSWWT[WML R\QGPT`S, H*é(§ée’/vla$s' Tbi‘“SWM/-ME,,M CY\)\\)\Q,\AL coppeg;m,j"_~j{:$ vis a 'Qn'm\"n@l` 0¢;4 r.";//@<é’$/P@Q/{ 5000 §‘3‘37,105’/.'00|00/?7€7 4 10':44 éw\)c):mmvn~€;»l faceij '>_ 633 533 ,__"T/)/'.S §§ch w\»\.

l §_D‘}TES @ON.SY`}T|,(TloA'/) /}¢`UMT .III-"', 1(74\'uv§i»~;] -/@ 4rle 403 F,‘M“j'$ 3“‘4_, CO\)NS¢/é,

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
Ruffin, Johnathan, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/ruffin-johnathan-texapp-2015.