Rogers v. State

95 So. 3d 623, 2012 WL 3516842, 2012 Miss. LEXIS 399
Mississippi Supreme Court·Decided August 16, 2012·No. No. 2010-KA-Q1191-SCT·Published·Cited by 44 cases

Opinion

KITCHENS, Justice,

for the Court:

¶ 1. Alen Rogers, Jr., was convicted by a jury of two counts of child sex abuse and was sentenced to a total of thirty-three years’ imprisonment. In Count One, Rogers was convicted of sexual battery against eight-year-old Benjamin Hicks. In Count Two, Rogers was convicted of fondling William Hicks, Benjamin’s eleven-year-old brother.1 Rogers has appealed, arguing that the trial court erred by overruling his hearsay objection to statements made by Benjamin to a forensic psychologist. He also argues that the State failed to prove that Count Two occurred in Scott County, as alleged in the indictment. Finding error on both counts, we reverse Rogers’s convictions and sentences and remand the case for a new trial.

Facts

¶ 2. On August 15, 2009, Benjamin and William were eating dinner with their mother, Christy Pope, and their stepfather, Michael Pope, when, according to Christy, William “made a comment about Benjamin.” Christy did not testify about the details of the conversation, other than “it didn’t sound good,” and that the comment was “sexual in nature.” Christy testified that, after she and Michael had questioned the boys further, they took them to the Scott County Sheriffs Department, where the family was interviewed by Sergeant Scott Lingle.

¶ 3. Ater interviewing the family, Lingle referred the ease to Investigator Willie Anderson, who conducted his own interview with the family on Monday, August 17, 2009. On Wednesday, August 19, 2009, the investigating officers referred the lam-[625] ily to the Wesley House, a Child Advocacy Center (CAC) in Meridian, Mississippi, where the children were interviewed, separately, by psychologist Olga Kahle.2

¶ 4. Kahle testified at trial about the substance of the boys’ interviews. During Benjamin’s interview, Benjamin told Kahle that Rogers had both anal and oral sex with him at an apartment in Sebastopol, Mississippi.3 According to Kahle, Benjamin said that Rogers “put his mouth on Benjamin’s penis,” and that Rogers “put his wiener inside Benjamin’s butt.” Benjamin told Kahle that this abuse occurred in the bathroom.

¶ 5. Benjamin also told Kahle about an incident in Rogers’s bedroom involving Rogers and a man named James. Before Kahle could relate the details of this incident, Rogers’s trial attorney made an objection, and the prosecutor told Kahle that she could “dispense with” the remainder of Benjamin’s interview. Through Christy’s trial testimony, the jury had learned that James was Rogers’s brother, and that James also was charged with some unspecified sex crime involving the boys.

¶ 6. During William’s interview, William told Kahle that he had witnessed oral sex between Rogers and Benjamin through a hole in the apartment’s bathroom door. William also told Kahle that he had witnessed this abuse once, and that it had happened two years before the interview. William did not tell Kahle that he, William, had been sexually abused.

¶ 7. On August 25, 2009, six days after Kahle’s interview with the boys, Rogers gave two statements to Lingle and Anderson at the Scott County Sheriffs Department. The first statement was written by Rogers in very rudimentary handwriting and contained numerous spelling and grammatical errors. Anderson’s reading of the statement at trial was transcribed as follows:

I, Allen Rogers, Jr., sexually abused Benjamin and William Hicks once. I was drinking. Had a lot too much to start playing with the boys and slipped their pants down and put my penis around their hole. I never went and got Benjamin to put my penis in his mouth. Not William.

A copy of the statement, as handwritten by Rogers, with the alleged victims’ names redacted, is attached to this opinion as Appendix A. Because this first statement was “hard to understand,” Lingle typed a second statement for Rogers’s signature about an hour after Rogers had completed and signed the first. This second statement contained significantly more detail, including an admission that Rogers had engaged in oral sex with Benjamin:

I have asked Sgt. Lingle to write this statement for me. I have not been forced, promised, coerced anything. I am giving this statement on my own free will.
We were living in the apartment above the Napa store in Sebastopol. The people living in the apartment at the time were, Me, Allen Rogers, Jr., Amanda Rogers, Adam Rogers, Christy Hicks, Michael Pope, Benjamin Hicks, and William Hicks. Michael was gone but everyone else was there. This happened in the room that Benjamin and William [626] played in. It was at night and I had been drinking beer and was drunk. I was playing around with Benjamin. I was picking him up by his legs and his pants came down. I was playing around and put my penis toward his hole, it didn’t go in. I put my penis in Benjamin’s mouth. William was asleep in the same room but he woke up. Benjamin went and layed down with his mother and I started playing around with William. He was wearing underwear. I told him what I was doing and he said he wanted to try it. I put my penis near his hole but did not go in. I rubbed my penis on his crack. William said stop and I did. William went to his mother’s room. I realized what I was doing. I sat in the room and cried. I went to sleep in that room and my wife woke me up later to go to bed. That night was the only time I ever done anything like this. After that I would not let myself be left alone with any kids.

Both statements were received in evidence through Anderson, over defense counsel’s objection.4

¶ 8. On April 1, 2010, Rogers was indicted for two counts of child sex abuse. Count One charged Rogers with sexual battery against Benjamin, specifically, “causing [Benjamin] to engage in fellatio on [the defendant].” Miss.Code Ann. § 97-3-95(l)(d) (Rev.2006).5 Count Two charged Rogers with fondling William. Miss.Code Ann. § 97-5-23(1) (Rev.2006). The indictment alleged that both crimes occurred in July 2009, in Scott County, Mississippi.

¶ 9. Rogers was tried by jury on June 9, 2010. In addition to Rogers’s two statements and Kahle’s testimony, the State’s main evidence included testimony from William, who was twelve years old at the time of trial. William testified that he had seen Rogers “sticking his private part in Benjamin’s butt,” but he repeatedly denied witnessing any oral sex. According to William, the abuse occurred in the bathroom of an apartment in Sebastopol, Mississippi. William testified that he could see Rogers and Benjamin in the bathroom because the bathroom door was slightly ajar. William also said that the incident occurred during daylight hours, but he could not recall on what date.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Rogers v. State, 95 So. 3d 623, 2012 WL 3516842, 2012 Miss. LEXIS 399 (Mich. 2012).

95 So. 3d 623 (Rogers v. State) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Allen v. McClure
N.D. Mississippi, 2025
Jimmy Allen v. State of Mississippi
Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2024
Scott v. Banks
S.D. Mississippi, 2021
Bobby Kidder v. State of Mississippi
Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2021
Jontavian Eubanks v. State of Mississippi
Mississippi Supreme Court, 2020
Willie Carl Pickett v. State of Mississippi
252 So. 3d 40 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2018)
Bryan Morton v. State of Mississippi
246 So. 3d 895 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2017)
Hosan M. Azomani v. State of Mississippi
222 So. 3d 282 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2017)
James Howard Wordlaw v. State of Mississippi
218 So. 3d 768 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2017)
Lamarcus Jones v. State of Mississippi
203 So. 3d 600 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2016)
Hosan M. Azomani v. State of Mississippi
222 So. 3d 343 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2016)