Rodriguez, Mark Anthony

• Court: Court of Appeals of Texas
• Decided: April 29, 2015
• Docket: WR-83,238-01
• Status: Published

Opinion

g§,@§gf©f,@<§

?".R§&}‘i S§§`E~§§`»£§‘.f "c?€;LE`<'XC`~UE¢?. %3.*€`>2$€)7&§ {§f'.>‘.`;&? E§?.§"`"§'\~’EEVE`. H§)., C'JA‘£!‘§Z;§ {,`C’C’m,` L§~ll'§?

51 §.§Z’Z‘Zi~:, §§ '.`1£.`. °Z"i`§~l :.`)‘*€‘.61‘%.:

F-‘§£‘RXL 231 2€?}_?§)

RECEIVED couRT oF chM)NAL ;gPEALs

§§ cng-§§ §m.§;z, cz.e§§ ' ' APR 29 2015

?. G. §~.‘c>'; ¢§`P.$S,\l H§u§i:c§,~ %`§.»>a§§ 7“?&`:1®~@§§§1

Abe| Acosta, C!erk

§§§ §§ §§§§s §§§§ §§§§§ §.L§:§m§ c§§;§.» §§ 2.‘3§§§'5)§~§ § 12:§§§";§~§, lmra §&§t;z‘ic§ Cc§z'§§ §§r:§i§ CQ§§¥:y¢ €§”e§§§ ’ O§;:wi‘xc§§.

De§z:’ Cl§x:k:

1'.§»::1<::::§§ Ql§a§§ .‘.;‘:‘in:'§" 'i:.":§ §?»z.i§~i.n§l of §§ CBTEC‘§`§C?';S w ‘£:’n§ ‘S¥.:§.=.§ i§-i§in§l Arz.:;w§:', 3';§>@§1: Cc:m:'t'§ §:.'ic.;,z'§,ic§ cf .i%.sz§§€-‘§ Prc§,)c§¢a§ §~`§.mié.m_;§ of §`§<:i: §n<:: C<.§'-:- clusion:z 01 haw § "1~§.§.§.'1 Ja.z§._',»a*§:. ?§i.luw §§ fi§z:u§§. i’,l§§§~§ iii.`x.§ §§§§§ az§;i lwi§§:; m§§; to chc €‘.<)uz;t,’§ §§t¢.-~n!:i§n in i“x:§ f,駧t view 0€. §a..§i§§§§ §£¢:§r: §§c§i§)t. §§a:§o£. §m; §l§o, yl§§§§ for§§r:c':‘. §:§;c T§z»c.EZ.z‘-§§,r.‘£h 7?§.¢}{§)€;?) § {§), these §'§`§3£'~,'€‘§§;€§5; to t§§ '-;e;:~'.§;; Cm§i:, §§ C§.‘imi§§}. S§§§§L§ §§ yarn c§: th§ t~§:i'x'a~a§ §§<:§x:'§ §§§vi§u§ly‘ io::§am:&‘§§ ha §;§§t comm

§3,§§, y§§§§§. §§i:§ ‘§§§§ § §:)§§ §§ t§i§ i§§z;a.vm§§§§ nasa mm §§:§§§ §§ mm §ccc)r§§; §§:§§c§e.>,§c§§§ t§§ ;`£»i;~”@§§ §§ _'i`§§§§ in §§i§ r:§t§§r §§ §§"§§§ miami §§ B§WE.` (;"I,»t.€§.

$'i§§lly, a wur§,§§y C§§sy §§ "z'.h§§ ¢Bc»cum§t, haas also §§§§ §§2.“§§:§§¢3 §§ - the Clecu‘< of Lj§§ ’.`£‘§:ce:§ <`.'§u§?; of Crf`z§.in§.¥.~ §§§;§@3§ am this §§iw;>~d§§€;.

’imm'§ you §§§ §r§§z' '§:.§ cum §ti;§m:i:;>§ in §§:S\§ §§2:§;§§., 1 win BM_§§_ .Bu°,_, reply re§a\rc`vin';g this umt§_@r.

aim:ez~:<;~ly ¢

}"§£",!EK AK‘IIHC‘£JY _E?(}BHIC#'U£ZE

ca §§n,. z.>§:§l§ .‘.`,.. &»’§§§§, M§i§§§§§ §§§e:r'i§§ §i:t:§a':§§‘i» W§xrxr>§ C§z§’m§¢ ‘ii‘§§§§: ,~'c; ;§:>§;. §§§l‘ §c§§§§, Cl§§‘§, T§§§§ C’§§z:t; §§ €H‘§.§';ir§l §§§§§§1§, .m§§§i§, W;§§§,

{UH>UMBJ ~'=l'i.;'».`,z»~ §,J*~§(r‘:a'.‘.+~' ”'?~\ a .§.3‘51’..5`»»`?‘£'\"'”?£

113 §§:iu f‘£§ M..i“' iiL'¥.£§-'.s\

§§ FBR§*

¢{r.* n~",’,* cox ¢!`~:

?iA§ § A“`é¢.§\i`£'»"i’ ?i’€lf§. ??"<'3££5` C>§;`.? s "£§E;` ¥‘¢¢'§§¢?32£;:` a’.`li»'{i£~s'}`¥» 'A`£.XA;.':

`1’:

431 11;¢~&\

53¥:”£”%.1§£`/.‘£~§§£§ 355,1$§1`¢.4 H'\’.)L.I'.CI$¥\§I. E.¢I£~`,*l`§‘l}.£;'§

GBJ§C§X®N$ §§ $§A§B°$ GR£GENA& &BBWERJ ,UA£EA$ CHUKT‘K BSQ¥T§QH 0§ $TA§E‘$ YHQYGNEQ §XNOE§G$ 33 §KG§3 $ CQNCLUB£ON$ QF 333 § §3EBL JUDGB'B “A§LHRM T$'HEQB§E

{-a'

ix 'H:£; €§C?».i€;’???i’=§"'.£»§” `?€;?LF€*L~ “;`)B` ’¢'§f§£' -¢§f€';!.;£.‘.f':

_HQ§ €CHE£, HQHP knahony F@uriguea. A#vl§cawt dancing ¢m¢ §e§y¢a£i?liy wm§mitw themw SFQFC§-U&` §§ »%§ ns§§h'? $NHHZPJ §§ ARLLR" §§ i;€b§£. §§ wuy?oct

n f

“§'_h’§". ~?%R'i€>rf§+§' €~)$J/i‘i'i"il.`. §":`3.?31.}§.¥€€.3§'*' é\.‘

§§ LQQ&Q DPS h §§\w£: h¢w,zcanz “&`l$ $ncv fha iv§iuv¢h,¢ ta»uit~

ya 3

C{§"."r?.i`~';'§."~£l,".".` £5*:‘€?.¢€ P;£$E?I '-¢C:.‘.;>

l» fha hca$@i 19 ita wga@$nal Anwwer £“Anawwx"?¢ ya&z;& that ‘ay§iicam§’s ai!§gehi@n 91 trial cvurt erroz §§ a ‘;vuu:m claim’ tn¢a Qnoulu ,haws mean za§ac¢ in Ln& &r&di exact ¢u¢ ca czuecz ay§mal. Ccn&e&mwnt£§¢ €h$ ayy£imamh 13 raw gxcumfvzali; vn:xé¢ izom.zaiaigg §nis i&@u¢ by way vi hanw¢m@" hn$wz& ah is new alma

Tz$al court*a Pin&§v$m §§ ?au; ana §uncluvxun$ wm §§ w {”?inwih$a"z

ii 25 §l,

$%SHQWZ$N{$SS

AYQX`:¢ , aunt QBJ¢. hn& xvi zc£wg zaauru §w§ywrnm¢ z§c fame

§§§§ claim §§§ §§§ §§§§§§ §§ §§§§§§ §§§§§§; §§§§§§§¢ §§§ §§§§§@ §§§§§n§§§§§§» §§i§§» §§§; §§§§, §§§§ §§, §§§4§§§§§§§§§§§§ §§ §§§ §§i§§/i§n§§§§§§ _§§§§§ §§ §§i§§¢ §§§§§§§ §§§§§§§¢ §§§§§¢ §§§§§§§§ §§ §§§ §§i§l §§u§§°§ §§§§§§§§ §§§§§§§§§ §§§ §§§§§'§§§§§§§§§§§§-§§§ §§§G§A§§U§ `§§ `§§§ §§ 3 §1* §§§§, '§§§§'§§§§»§§§§§\§§§ §§§ §§§§ §§§§ §§§§§§ §§ §§§§§§ §§§§§§, §§ §§§§§§ §§§ §§§§§§ §§§§§§§§§,' §§§ §§§' §§§§§§ ~§§§§§’§ §§§§§§§§¢ §§§§§§§ §§§§¢ §§ §§§ §§§§§*§ §§§§§§§l§ §§§ y§§ §§§§§§§§ v§§§§§ §h§§ §§§§§§§§ §§§§ §§§§ §§§§§ §§ §§§§§§§§ §§ §§§ §§§§§ §§§§§ §§§ § §§§§§n§§ ' l

§§ §§§§§§§§ §§§ §§§§§ § §§§r§§§§§ €§§§ §§§§ §§ §§ §§§§ § §§§§ §§§§i§§§ §§ §§§), §§§ §§§§§§ §§§§§ §§§ §§§.§§§§§¢ §§§§§§i§§§y §§§§§§ `§§§§§§§§§ §§ `§§§ §§§§i§§n§ §§§i§§ §§§ §§§§ §§§§§§§§§§ §r§c§§§» §§§§§§§g §§§§ §§§§§§§§§» §§§ .§h§§§' §§§§§§§ §§§§§§§§§ §§ §§§§i¢§§§*§ §u§ §§ §e§§§ §§§§§§ §§§§§ §§§ §§§ §§§ §§§§ §§§§§§§§§ §§ §§§ U.§. §§§§§i§§§ § §n*»»§§§ §§i§§ §§u§§ §§§ §§§§§ §§ §§§§§~ §§§§ § §§§i§§ §§§ i§§§§§ §§ §§§§§§ §§i§ i§§§§ §§.§ §§ §§§§§§1§§§§§. §§§ § §§ § €”~e¢ §§§ §§§§§ §§§§§§ §§ v§i§ §§§§, §§§ §§§§»§§» ch§§§. §§§ §§§11 §§ §§§ §§§§§ ,»§“}¢ §§§ § §§. §§§§§§§§§ §. §§§§§¢ _§§§ §.§.§§ `§§§. §§v g§§§.¢§§§.§§§.§§§vz€§§§§§ §§ §§ §§§§§§§ §§§§ t§§ §§c§§§$§h§§ §§§ §§§§§ §§§§§¢ §§§§§§§ §§§§§§§ §§§ §§§ §§§§§l§§§ §§§ §§§§§§§§ §§§§§ §§§ '§§l§§ §§§§§§§§§§ §§ §§§§§l §§ §§ §§§§§¢ §§§ §§§§ §§§ §§§ §n§§§§§ §§§§§§§§y §§§ §u§§i§§}» l § §. §§ §§§ §§§§y §§ §§§l§c§§§'§ §§§§§§ §r§§§§ §§§ §§§§§§¢ §§§ 'i§§§§§§§§§§ -§§§§§§§§§§ §§ §§§§§§§§§ §§u§§§§ §§§i§:_§§§§§§§§§*§ §§i§ §§ §¢ §§§§§§§§§§ §§ §§§ §§ §§§§§§§ §§ 1§, §§§ §§§§§ §§§§§§§§

§§ §§§§§§§t§` §§§ §§§§§ §§ §§§§§§§§§§§§§ §§§§§Y §§ §h§ §§§§ §§§§

\

portio§ to Supp®rt its claim tw&t F$~ wil;@r §ail€@ go Q@;&ct» howeve$¢ am abov@mentioned, Hm. Milie€ tim@lj 0&§@€10& 30 §§c axial court°s ccmm@n£ing en tha Qvidcn¢c of £h@ grier cenvic€iuns &t the cemm@ucm&nt §§ ibm guilaf&nnacwmc@ §haa@ ci axial and

thxw matt@v §§ gr@@&rv@d and riye no GQKQ Win@%iwn» Ed. mt 1~33 3

sea 7 . ol@.;r'$c

Ap§licanc QWJQGKB tc the SEAMe's positiem am inuicaz¢d Mbwv& and to Lhe haw@ae court'@ adoption §§ §h@ S&at@'m grosuaais» and for d@myin§ an awié@ntiary Hearim@ w& she iaaue of §u@t£ec§iv¢ assimcanca of §§Q@l£@t@ coum@ai, an $Y@cii§calxy z@quwstw_that an avidwn€£a§g h§§ring mm h@i“ am §e¢®£v@ thi@ $wawm bauaum@ mbm igwuw §§ th@ &mial maur% ca$mxtting Wsw@r my dx@ylagimg Hu£ commenting wm ah@ mvi&enua wasf$& a w&&w£@ aygell§&@ iw@m@ and &pge£lac@ swunaal made md @££ozh to ra£$e it en widest ayg@al¢ causing App£icani yz@;adic@ by éegriving him of an oyyczcunit§

to have his ccnviccion au£/or sentence ovexturnad on apy@al.

3. The Habaaa Court, without holding any ty;a of h@azimvi &umma” rily a&cg%em th@ Sta&&'$Qrcpos&d'Finéini@ §§ Pac& and Cancimsions Q£ haw {F§méin@@), 4without @ven rmvisw£ng twa tri&l reccxa in Qrd&r tm be in a §omi€£$n tc "r@c@il” th@ @vmth in gu@$tion. adairionaliy, ap$lica§r al$w nb;ec@w no §h@ €zial cwuxt'¢ £@xluu@ tm reauwewitsel§ bac¢us¢ iu dad am inver@§t in ihs muucumm ct Rhes@ groc&w@inga~~~qu@$ticn£ng its gug$m&nz ¢n cc§m@n€ing ca

the evidence o£ §hQ Qcior convic%iona ga the jurg's grazencu°

PR&HER

§§§§§§§§§a~§§§, ;§R§§§§;s§§s co§§§§§§§§§§m. A§§;y§i§:§m. §§mya §§§§.-§ §§Qm§m§§§.§ C¢uwt viii ratarn th£§ ¢§§§ §§ §§@ §ria§ ca u§§ no §Qn§f§ct §§ §§ic@nni§§y .hnacin@ §G §@§oive §§§ §§§ug§ §§§sed §§ bia §§be§§ §vylic§t§on§ 20 f¢rw§rd §gwl§c§w§’§ Q§cu§§l H§h§on §§ §h§ §§gi§§§l Sudge EQ§ dec§rmin§t£mn: amd 9§§0§ §ny ch§§ §§d £uv§her §§1$@£§ §§ law or in '§qui§y¢ ané consi@t§n§ wi§h €§§ §§§ie£ §§queet§§

z§r@iw§bov§-

§LPECTKJ%E‘ZVT§

§§§§§' §§§§ §§§§§§ §§§§§§§GUL§ §§§§€§§1§ §9€§$,) §§;§§§§§v§:; mm §§§§“§§§; .:§§:f§‘*§‘ _ §:§§§.'§.r §H§LS§@N¢ §£F; ??SAQ»SG§H

A;§,;§l§c;§§§§: E*x§§-$§e§

CEH§IFICA“E O§ ““*V§CB l §Q§@Dy certi§y §§§; § csu§ §n¢ co§§§ct cog@ §§ thi§ in§t§uw§mt h§$ b§§§ §§§v§d by pl§¢i§g §§§§: §§ th§ §§i§a§ § lc§al L§§§w§§m§§ §0§ nutwoinw §§%al m§i§§ u.§. Fir§§ Cl§§§ ya§§§g@ y§cy§§§, §§ t§im nw§ §§ PQIB, §§§§§§§@G amy i§a» Pam¢la S» Fa§sc §§ai§t§nc Eim r§CK he§c§ney

§~2®} E,.W\.“l»`§}¢l i¢'?» l gus h § 3 902 '~ ~ ' "! ¥’ H. - § FI§ 2b §Gl§ Hon§§eny W§§§§ VVDGR HC x §

§cdcrn§y ice trw £§§Le §§ Te§§§

.%*PRE§. P.~Z§."§W3523'.‘£ §*O§£<`Re§i€~§$

va/C%Ȥ/\

.§fz,