Rodriguez, Mark Anthony

• Court: Texas Supreme Court
• Decided: April 29, 2015
• Docket: WR-83,238-02
• Status: Published

Opinion

_ 1 $§3}35§»0¢,0&

§-§@.`§?i?é §*$M‘§/`€§’:f E€C'E’ZZ~‘X!’:€-';F“');;?i %3.¥:§2 *f:é"l!$ E§}.??Y £%.ZYK\£§EVH ?{§B.J §§?FL‘A"£E;~."?.Z 53€1;`55';1"‘5,’ §§~E.`fi:`? 3§?3§§`§.~§§`&~= 'é"§i?i;?§$f’~ “?'Fh.'i ;3“'§¥%3.&.;

!`551:§€3;§» §@¢ §Z€:T\l‘;§ COUR REcE/vED ,N T OF CR[M'NAL APPEALS § z. Ch§iw §§n£@l¢ Clerk

;:=. ;:. am ¢;;`»;".~l l APR 2942015

3~%:;.»¢;’5`€:€32‘§ .»r ’E€=:z-:£§z`z ‘?“Fé,`:l"&-""§€§i Abel Acosta, Cserk

'R`Z‘: iii XP¢’§§ZT!£ Wh.#»?’§ » "€S‘.’i§€}“i\"i’ ZR'BD§IGU“;§§; C`£e“e;',;‘}” §§Q'.i"f$» AM€§Z'?&?-R §§ 11!$5“§3:*~&; I&&'.€Brci §?Séat;r'icic.: Ccu;':i:,» iim:z¢iea szzw¥;y¢ iam-mta ' GE~;¥Z:X‘I”IKGE£&§

war CL¢».;;::;!§:'

i?n»c:lc»szzsf:` ;,>.l¢;'am: ‘§‘.`:'u'z;£ §:hé: €.?cig,zinal <,»‘ii z;:;`; €W.?i`”” ;‘§'.”§~3 §§ w 133er .>%:M..w»”; i?z§.§}iml Arv;v;@@, i¥zz?>.z§zsuz C¢éuz:`t‘as Af:agz%icm 02 M&&e’@ MW@M§% §§.m'.§é. gsa 055 §:m§; mm Q<)z'z-» clm§ic:r;$ ~c:z; lms e;'» *I»::S.al waives wilma m LHMM.» :';?,m§s.sasz miss mm am syri::@; m '»~: tca §hs:»:» Ceu;;t’:a aatzznir:f§cm in im §,é§:‘§§§: diaz mi mfa;€'zmzz£z

A.%.::a¢;z¢ human z':»c.z‘£:@ "z:hm; az w;;:»;! o£ wm §Mt;a:umrs%; mg mem Mz§we;z£*£ w twa atcom'z~eig wym;e~m:im tim imm c.§:i fieth in &§\jis sim;t§:sz§ "s;z z;a.m»;§ mims sun

waive dam .

§‘ina~.lly. a £m\uz:may ’~i.?cz~;.jsy 421?:', §§in n%cwm:zt. max ea;?»em ?m:z'z:iz amusemch am » shea <;‘3.¢.:~:3<, c>§? 1333 simms cica-six cpi f.f):.‘“:.r:i ¢»~»,a,l;. ,z\_“,;;:§§malez am wigs waive ~:"Ez.~z‘€;<»z;»., ’i?m:~e‘z: ycw war ym,sz~ "'is:wa ag::'§ m;'§:- n£;m§z jim é;§-'x.§.$ maz:@.;§z@, l viii await gauge '<.:<‘agzly §anwciin@ S;hi¢z §§M?;@r‘. . '

S?Y%RK MFIHGNY >§:¥‘.(ZBBKCT}£`.ZZ

ca wm zs>.»aa@;e: :.",» z“'aw.<;o, w£ziszmzm zizi.z;mz:iz:t; 31.;€:$:¢§3;@@§€; mma wm?:y¢ "i'ezm,@; \1;<;: §::>,z .E@§;';€s-l mast-sw marks '?*{mmz C’Bm:§; cz§; flr§.zz;irm}. Q§g¢zz~§§l$, .Wx.mt;§,m %;#.M;,.

1 any z

\mw ’:: * .»“”: 'a ~~" .+. , @Av@w mens £¢4&&;:»¢ § aimv¢f&~&

§‘:: -‘ §:"»" ¢L»-` Q‘>r -`

RARE SMIHGEY §§HREG§IE»

.,:

:z§_,?~

@Pya§c&;; w AA;»U GULLC§AL ax»:&aaz

~QBJEQTIONS wa SHAWBQS §H£Gm§§a AHSWER» _N&mwm; a$UKT*B AYQSY§@H my $WAK@*$ PHQYQ$EU wawxnsa as YAQFB a QQBQLWSBGHS QF LAW a WHEAL QUHGB'$ YA@LHKB §§ HEQWQE

""" v' ‘_:- »» ~. .»~m»'~ w `,\~ ` `~~;- »`._ .'» `,. ~"‘ .~>N._ wm ltv u@%@wkm£? JW$VM §§ HRSM M,EW»£

,*

_AQM ESNES. HQ§H Rw&h@ny s@¢§iww@;, &vawaamt nms@iw» @3¢

zea§&c$kuliy Buwa§tm tham& §§§HQ$EVL& xi ivy uw#®&'$ §N&w£wi

izr v»r"

. '.\_.;' ,~-` 4~--\ 9~-,~ ~- »#~r' , ,~. _‘~ g v ».¢ _\'~_w {- w ' » '~ 5~, _. _ . , MLJL ."M cxww;tv§ mwh §§a»;w@ ¢@ @whwgn» MN vv,ywz?

si §nu$@ musa€k&@r$, B¢@zza@nt WRR; @n@w aka &mlémwiw;¢ ta»wita

1 )¢w~,\-`.¢_~ .g‘\ _-',.¢` »4,»'»";.».»‘\ _»»4 A. wuhu»hq h;c.a@hzhwp

l» Kh¢ ozai@i &n ita wg&@inal Anwwer §“Su@v¢r"}¢ wma;&a xh@z *va&ac&ah’§ ail$§e@i®n §§ kr§@£ aw§xt v§rox §§ a ‘£uuuah clagm* amax emou;z mw&vw wasn €@Sac¢ in Lw& &£aml cubrn amy gm sxx@§z mg§aal. Cchg@u¢mtég» 236 ayp£&%am; §§ rmw {xeumc»§m£i, umzx§z £z$w rai$in@ anis ia@u¢ W§ way §§ mana¢v§” mewwz &L L; mow almw

Tr$ai cenrt*a §inm&hga 03 ?auu cna §§msluwi@n$ vi Lau {”?Ahwiawn“z

am 2 &3. wwsnz%z@&£$?:

A§€Eic@uz cwm&w&£¢. am$ 205 &H&&; xgaur¢ §u&¢wmm@¢ %he idea

th§w claim 999 not cai$cd 09 9§99¢€ 9999&1;‘909999:, §h& 999£9¢ conv@niently, 99£99_ the; fact' that 99 999 commancemsnt 99 999 gui;a/innocenc9 99999 of 99191,'99£9999 909999£. again. 09399996 t& she tri¢l cbuvc'a commant& 999999199 999 99999 9999£921999. 999 NRMQRABDHH 99 `an at 3 91. Whus. 991§9 tdi& §9999 may not 9999 9999 reis@d on direct 9999911 19 99991? 999 timely 999999999»' 999 999 999999 caurt's 99992§994 withvnu 9999, of 999 Shete’a 990999919 999 wgn 9999£999 _99:9€ 9992 9999§999 999§ 99£9 §9999 99 29tur999 tc 999 trial 99999 999 9 9999£.9'9~ ' v

la 99999$99 999 39999'9 9999999§9 €999 9§99299 9 99 Fact 9 999» 9199§999 09 999)¢ 999 999999 99999 999 999 9§999¢ 99£99¥19919 9§9199 `999§§¢99& to 939 9999§9999 999£99 999 9199 9999939§99 proca§a¢ poasib§y 9999 999@99999. 999 .Whoie‘ 9!9¢999 viola€§v@ of 999§§¢999'9 999 9999999 9£9999 99999 999 999 999 §999'99¢999999 20 the U.$. dcnsti€u@§on»#-thw 99191 cou:€ 999 99999 99 9991§~ 999949 éesira 999 intent no 999993 99§9 i9999 999 99 999999199993. 999 4 99 9 (”... 911 §9999 991999 99 voir éire, the casw»&n* ehie£. 999 99§11 en 999 cavi@'..."i¢ 999 s c£.`999999999 v. 99999, ,§§2 5 w.zd 636. 637 (999.¢9£9.999 i§$?)(wheré is is obviou§ item 999 record th9: 599 tri@§ couz€¢ §9£9999 909999; 996 the 999911992 999 1999r199 99@99 th@ f9199 199¥999§99 99 99999§ 19 in 9:69£¢

999 plea 999 999 9999996 woiumt9ry 999 kuwwin§}.

2. 19 599 Hepiy 99 9991§¢999'9 999999 9r9999 fox 991399¢ 999 ina££@étiva 99919@9999 99 99999§999 9999991 91919» 999§§9999*9 wriz 99 9» 9999:99999 09 999 x9 3999999 99 19¢ 999 999m9 99999999

99 9bf9999t9 t99 19999 99 999999§999999 991939 on th9 voir diss

\

yortion to suppcrt it$ elgin §hst N$~ Hil;@: £aila¢ no w@;act# howevexi ae awov@menzicned, HB. willez tim$lg 0&3@€10¢ to &§u trial couzt°s commanzing on twa @vi¢en¢@ of the yricn convicciuns at £he cmmm@ucwenc 0€ t&@ §uil£/inn$c&mc@ ghaae ci triai ana thiw m@ttet ia Qzes$rv@d ang ripe to éaz@r$inatiwn. Iu. at 1~23 3

RR 7. OWJECTIOW(B)z

Ay§licanc object@ tc the Staxe'm pwsitiom aa $nuicaz¢d abov& &n& to mha hawaa& couc&‘$ a&c§%iow vi ama B&ate’a wrogoaa£s, and few é@ny£nw @n evié@nmi&€y heaziwg mw %ha iaaua 0£ inwz£waniv@ &a$imhanca uf agg@lkmt@ couw@ai, BNQ $WM¢A§§GQ&&F zaguw$tm_th@z an avi¢em§ia§y hwhtimw we h@§é to §eswlvw tkka &maum bem&wma umw iawuw cf th& trial court cammi%tin§ asrwr Dy ¢i¢ylaging an§ commenting on the eviéence Ha$}&a:& v£mm;@ ayyell§t& iv$uw and ap@@ilac@ counaai maée ma &£iozt §§ rai§e §t ca direct myywal¢ causing Applican% @ze;umic@ my §§Qrivin$ him of an oyymzcunitj

to have his conviction an£/Qr sant@nc@ owarzurneé on av»@&l. iv

3. The Habama Court¢ without holding amy ty;§ of n&azinv¢ wummav rily adeytem cba Sta&e'a¥rcpo%ed'§inéinga Gi Fac€ and Ccnclu$ion§ O§ haw {Fin€in@s), without even rwviewing the z:i&l recozd in mrdwr to be in a powit§cn to ”r@cail” twa evanta in qu@stion.

ad&itiomaliy, applica§t al$c wh}ecim so twa §§ia; conva°& zozluc@

s

to raaumewic$el§ becmu$¢ AK HQG @m inher@wt &m tha mumcumw of

dh@$& yeum&w@inwa~*~qum$hiwnin@l i&$ 43“$@@&9& QH awm@gmainw on

the evié@nc@ of cba @rior Qcmv£cmioma§§n tha gung'w anaencu° i

1`

PRAHHR

SHBREFGRS¢ PREHI$RS GQHSIDBRE§. Agylicant Prays thi& uanarabl@ Ccuwt viii r@turn th£$ €ewa §§ _&M@ trial c$mxh ca QQHMMGR an mvid@ntiasy bva&rin¢ to gwaoiv¢ tva iaeu$e ma§aed in bia %¢bees &pylication; to fczwar& Rp§lic&mt’@ R¢cu§@l anion nn €h@ R&Wimn@l Juéwe for §e§enmination: &nd grant any ¢th@r @56 £urth@r raiie£, at law or in ~Q%uity¢ an& conviat¢n$ with th% felie£ sequa&&ed

h&r@im¢bove-

Hm§§}£mq?§i;;£)§a§ mM-=Xl§£i“ml

:.‘M§: m§'§§§x»f§ mii§»:mms&§ fla»?,wn'; cs§s§£> P¢;TMRW¢: man wausau sam maxim A:H;I.w;:¢;¢ zz;x:»:; 'ri§).§»e&lz§

WMMEWMK IMU%K@

CEB?IFICA?K QF &EEV§CE

3‘ h@z@uy carci£y amax § cane QBQ emerawt nagy §§ thaw inacrumant has w&an werved by glacimg se£z: im the pzi@om‘e icgal zac§§aacl@ for out§aing lmwal wmil. U.S. Eirsn Cl&a@ yasta§@ yzcyaid, cv this thw EG, 2935¢ ad§rass@a

iws~ Eamwka S~ PR§$Q _ Asai&tanc ni$tricz hukczney

§2@} Eran%lin, ban FLGQ$ AM¢XF §§ »015 Heustcn¢ Wexa§ ??DGR t ' w

setormay fox tew Snmte af T€xa&

wm emwa zzc:wmm

WM/QQ»f/\

§§