Rivard v. State

Opinion

!9"64#4$13%&349"6%&3494'34"9494!9"13'3#()4*+,+-./0.12/,344594 67 897 8897 84:3!#94624012314137612743"13#369494:33264 3 134612464;84<4&"3144=2'414:4&47>4 ? @4"616716"'#4@@45646 37324'64:A453#4'6246324914!9&324&"34 "19#3!&9#494564'64B3134316324456C#469145646 37324'64'34 "19!3327#4B3134B'9&4"19(6(34!6Ś24'64:A453#46!324B'4$6!34629914 "19"31493)7 @4"616716"'44564623464#313#4946 3769413632494'34631494*+,+-./0. 12/,34D45947>7774=!14E464"19#3!&94914:93#!4A##6&45646 37324'64 :A453#42#137612324"3649 31#419456C#4!9&#3456C#4&1'3146 3769#4 13761274:A453#46""3614941363494323!34622&!3246416 @4"616716"'4@45646 373#4:A453#437673244619!92&!41376127464 6314'64#46 373243F"&7324!&274#33!7464G&14624#&(#3%&342###74 '34631 @4"616716"'4@@45646 373#4'64:A453#432464!1646314624'6464G&2734 2249424"19(6(34!6衢'34!'6173 @4"616716"'4@@@45646 373#4'64646314B6#4324(46423134=2'649&4 :3"&463C#4A9134624B6#4'3416#31132494H37949&4B'31344B6#4 "19#3!&324(4:A45&I345646 373#4'64'34631413#932491464"3649464 3##314!'617345646 373#4'64:A45&I34#9&7'4!9"33!4624#64 36&69#44'34!6#34624#&(#3%&349""9#3243F"&733494'34!164'#914 13!91244'34631 @4"616716"'4@J45646I3#4&1'3146 3769#413761274'34H37946314E4 *+,+-./0.12/,344594  7745646 373#4'64:A453#4E4'34!44'64 74 K'34!9&14#&61L3#46246I3#46#41&34'349!9![46 3769#494'34!9"6 0123144444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444445673484 94  43 13461244634943194346 6314!46234"9##34#633#413761274$%3%31462494$%643&34%34%624 '334()1324'456 *4+616716+%4,45646 373#4%64-.4/3#406324+19#3")91494646314%64 13#9324$%464+364%1334361#463145646 373#4%64-.4/3#437673244 0#6"27494"%6173#144%34631 *4+616716+%4,*45646 373#4%64-.4/3#406324+19#3")9149469%314 6314%6413#9324$%464+36 *4+616716+%4,**45646 37324%64%313461340+3274)+34199)#4"164 "%6173#143%34+616716+%4623#4946 3769413761274-.4/3#4914-.45)23 *4+616716+%4,***45646 373#431191#4'4-.4/3#44%34+13+616949464+364 671333 4-3326#54994624565#439162)449++9#9 04.)7)#44 4-3326#49324942###4-3326#49324%640%#4"4#)4 69%3149464676463+6#7494#)34+19#3")91#4914%31419344"164"6#3#4324 676#4%1489946494-3326#4#9)7%42###64+)1#)6494549 :';:9;4<4 :=;4-3326#4617)324%64-.4/3#46245)23461343324946'#9)34 +19#3")9164)4-3326#4617)324%64%34"6#4676#4%34634!4$%"%4 $313423163494%34"6#4676#4-.4/3#46245)234!4$3134#614'611324'4 )4624)1%314'611324'4#931374)4>6 4-3326#49324%64 565#4"6#4$3134'611324'4'9%4##)34624"64+13")#9?

4899464 4899464@ ?4899464@9 0123144444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444445673484 94  43 13461244634943194346 5643246439162!449""9#9494$!7!#4%4 456413#"9232494 &3326#'49946#444(6#464994914#!614)!2734*44(6#494+6494 &3326#4617!3#413#6324,34#!-#6.3494,346 3769#44,34.9"64934 ,9(331422494 +99#4942###49146!13494#63464.6 +99#4942###49146!13494#63464.6461342#69132442###64#4"19"31494 (,344#4-392429!-4,64,31343/#4946.#4914.1.!#6.3#4.9##34(,4,34 .9"64,64(9!24334,34"649413340123145678492:;4<1=84>384?84@3;:AB44 C4D4E4F4G4133(74#!.,464994942###4,#4.9!14!#46H346 46.#46 373244 ,34.9"646#41!34IJ2374?84IJ;=B4%KK44LL4%4M%DN4O9(3314,34.9!14#4P94 13Q!1324946..3"46#41!34.9.!#9146 3769#49143764.9.!#9#46#Q!3162746#4 6.!64.9.!#9#R4S27TU;4?84V;UU3W=49TUU=4012314X2AY4Z[Y84 4C4%4E4L4C,34.9!14 .69473316 4.9#23146.#4914631#49!#234,34.9"6441!7494,34994 54% M-N4O9(331 \(],313464.9"64^4P133#4!"946429.!3R44P3173#494,34 "3627#4624,34.9!1464"19"314.9#23144!231464!34% M-NMKN4 994942###R4_T`UT14?8453:AT14Z7T1U;a4b4>38B4<1[844C4DL4E4%4 F4%LK44K4M3N4MQ!9694932N4M3/"674,64164.9!14 "19"31413324943134949(4"64(,3134"64#"3..6 413311324 9444.9"64-!42249466.,4! 43/N4$4.9!14#4949-7632494 6..3"46 3769#44,34.9"64"!1"9174943 44,9(49431"134#!.,4 6429.!346,9!7,4646-7!3#4!#4-34.9#1!3244,34"6c#4 6914dT?2=4?84IJ84e;A231B4d;`f743g4S784%F4C4%F4E4%4%L44F h2A;314?84Z731;4 4ij4%% FL464k4M4!4%%4 N4M!"!-43N $4"36274#37491,464.649141334P#,6 4.964M%N464#,914624"64#633494 ,34.64#,9(74,64,34"362314#43324941334624MN46423624914)!2734914 ,341334,34"362314#33H#R454LM6N4C,34!3413Q!13#4P64#6334.361439!7,4 0123144444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444445673484 94  43 13461244634943194346 !94734"342332646149#3494$"64"34%6&'4#64'4624"34719(2'494$"#"4 413'')*43%9131&'4+93'454,4-.(974/01234567589:;01<44=4>?4-?@AA4334 6'94B0025675C31DEF4?,4G44H4?I4G"346(13494#3464'6(34293'4946 3#4"34 31'494"34#9%64J4"346#(646 3769'46134$"64'413364KF74L4#9(1473316 4 1362'464'3 13%13'3324%6&'4'(M''9'4NM316 *431%1374"34N9416'34"34 '1973'4617(3'4"64"34'(773'*4OE93;PQD15675R3F75STE3DT50U5VE9;01;<4>@4W24 >@?4>@>4-2414IA4-3164.(969461X'46243%"6''4932A4Y9$3314$"34 64'3 13%13'3324764'4332494'93433$64"34764('4'4#9%4$"4 %19#32(1641(3'4Z0E15675[Q9P\4??4G4?4H4  ]519'3#(9164( ^4'4$3 4'3324"64"34634624'4%19'3#(91'43_946M'9(34(4194#4 '('4914%(1'(74#164%19'3#(9'4G"'4(43#9%6''3'4946#'4#9'34 6''9#6324$"47694914%93647694M(4293'494#931462'1634 (#9'49143'7634(#9'4"6461349464%61494"34_(2#64(#94̀TQ91;a95675 bD60934?@44?@4 4-?A4G"('4"34(4N293'494%193#4_(2#649 #31'4 6#74c23DE245:3401F4"34136#"494"3149 #34624_(1'2#9*4b3691;a45675d9DQ01F4?>4 44I? 4-?, A4-3%"6''4'(%%32A4Y9$3314N6#'4$"#"461349443e#3''494 _(1'2#94'(#"46'4"9'34912614_('74642'''649464#164#9%6494 #"6 3734M4%19%314994613494$"9(49134#36149('234"34_(1'2#949464 %19'3#(91*4V029F0E5675CD\DF44?44?@4?@4-?@ A4G"34(43e32'4946 46#'4 6''9#6324$"464%19'3#(91)'4769494646314G"(' #92(#4%193#324M46M'9(34(4'4943249494"346#494 674_(2#64%19#3327'4'3 462494#92(#49##(11744"34 4 G"343194(%319149(14"6'413%363249(24"64]33264"6'42'137612324914632494 #9%4$"4%19#32(1641(3'462491231'494"34#9(14[33<537f7<5[PDP35675g96DEF4+94> ? Ih? IIh? I4]3#'94624012314137612743%13'369494]332643 1346124 -4(%3144i2"414]4(4?@4 Aj4[PDP35675g96DEF4+94?@???4i#14k14 3761274l994-4(%3144i2"414]4(344 A 0123144444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444445673484 94  43 13461244634943194346 !9"11994#"4$3624!"23$46 46!9$4%&!&49!!"144&34!9"1$3494&34 '19$3!"91($419346$464629!63494&34634)&"$4'19$3!"91$46134 6#$9"34"34334914% "49146!9"$4'19$3!"9164$!92"!444 9!!"1$44&343*31!$3494&314629!6914"!9 +,-./012-345367--,887924:4;24<<4<=4>&414 ?4)&3433&41!"462213$$324 &34$!9'3494"44&34!93*4946 3732413'13&3$#34'19$3!"9164$!92"!4 4+2@/,093453A7@B77C4D<<4;4E''F*4==4><&414G ?497 '19$3!"91$461343324946#$9"34"4194!46#4H4914 '19$3!"9164"!9$4$"!&46$4&34694624'"1$"49464!164 '19$3!"94&34'13$36949464$63($4!6$34641646249&314!92"!4 6346$$9!6324%&4&34I"2!64'&6$3494&34!164'19!3$$4 J@KB/0L3453M,18C,NN2-CO44P44:Q<4>G?4)&$4"!964 6''196!&4R9!"$3$494&34!92"!4914%&!&4&34"4$4!63249494 &34&614&64&34!92"!464&634!6"$324914&34S"3$94%&3&3144%6$4 6% "T4J@KB/0LO44P464<&41G?4E&9"7&4 V6"W66$($46#"$3494'36#617674'9%31441"34%6$413'13&3$#34&34$4 332494"4#3!6"$34'364#617674$46346$$9!6324%&464 '19$3!"9164"!94334\N]/093453^7KZ1N7-O4D D4P4D4DG4>G<:?4 >6#$9"34"4#611324!64&64'19$3!"914W9%74"$3246$34 3$94624$"''13$$32463164323!346416?_467YL3453̀90-7K36-1L5O4 :&41?4>6#$9"34"4#61$4a4G=4$"$4 61$749"494334"S"3$96#43764914'19'314!92"!44&34 !&6 373246!94$4'61494&3491642"3$494&34'19$3!"91?_4^07L3453 `b0//2O4D<4;24:4:241:?4>6#$9"34"4#611324!64&64 '19$3!"914!9$'1324946#1!634323!34%&&9243*!"'6914323!34 6242634233264946!!3'74'36?4E249&31436$494 0123144444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444445673484 94  43 13461244634943194346 !9113!74"#$!34$#!%46$4%34!164&19$3!#94'6#(66$46136246!324 6$4)3 46$4&193$$9642$!&346134666*3494%9246!!9#6*34 &19$3!#91$4)%946*#$34%314&9)314334+,-./0142 2434642 45 678.9/042::4;4<&&=>4645?4@%#$46!$4914)%!%4&19$3!#91$461346*$9#34#34 !#234%347494!%6173$4624&364*61767 AB$$#3462464513!#$9 C9%4$$#34624!64&13!#$94!64*3416$3246$4719#2$49142$$$64
$#6494 54? D*EDFE4G/0,7HIJK8,LJMINLJO7,,PHJQLJR7SHJ7TJ6ILJU7VHN-80W4 24@4:?4X4 4B$$#34&13!#$94914!9 631643$9&&34*61$41376949464$$#346IYI/JQLJZ808H[4  4@4 4X424B$$#34&13!#$946&&3$4)%3\ D?E4&13!#$94$46$$31324676$4934)%94)6$464&6144%34&19146!9]4DE4%34 $634$$#34)6$416$3244%34&19146!9]4DE4%34$$#34)6$413$9324*46464 "#273494%3431$]4D2E4%3134)6$464# 46246149&&91#4947634%34 $$#344%34&19146!9]4624DE46&&74&13!#$94$461 +HJ0/JO/HILJGILJ^8-LJ6/0QLJO70_L4?: 44?244D?E43346$94̀aV/Q/009YJQLJR7SHJ7TJ R8H-09b[/4 24@42:4X4?4D$63E464&13!#$9491413$4"#2!66 c*61$476949464!64914233$344%31343>$$46464"#27344 9131476944)%!%4%34&613$4$#*"3!46314624!6#$3$4946!94 613423!64914$#*$66 423!6d4e/..H/0JQLJe/..H/0424@4?4X444 D3E4Df#9694932E4g4h9139314ci!j64&13!#$94*61$47694 94!6$4914!6#$3$4946!94)%!%4)31349147%4&19&314%634*334 76324464&139#$46!9d46IYI/JQLJkYHH4?F:44??4? 4D?:E4 Df#9694932E4 eHY__JQLJkYN./04 24@4F4X44a/0ILJb/H9/b4 4lm4?2F?24D34h64:4 E4 3346$9468II7HJQLJ^80nWao94 4@4F4X4? 0123144444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444445673484 94  43 13461244634943194346 !"33#494$34914946%9'19#3%&9 (9413%931491464%64946%9'19#3%&94564&#43#6)#$4$64*3326#4 #&324'19%3327#4676#4$4+,-4.$9&4'19)6)34%64+-4.$46%34624$64 +-4$34'19%3327#4316324456/#469140123345675891:94,; 44<4<=<>4 +,<-4($34$124333413?&13#4$64564239#1634$64$346%9413#932494 $3431#44$#46914@4$64$34A642#'9#94#4#&%$46#4942%634$349%3%3494 $346%% B4CDEFGH44IH114,,<4!24<4;<4+2414,>-43346#94JH32K5675 LDKKMN1O52P5N374 4QR4,>=464S4+,$414&344 - Q$34$34'19%332743163#49$314$6494$3431#4$34%9&14&#4 3T634$34136#9#49143169494#3344$342#'9#9413 3%#4$34 9'9494$34%9&14914$34'19#3%&74'614$64$346%94.9&2494 #&%%3324U413#9&9494$34&231746%94363#46413#2&349429&)4 6)9&4$34'6V#49%3%349146)44#494646916)3431694 #& %3494#&''91464%6袂%949146%9'19#3%&9 L92EEN5W3DX5Y4D1Z75675[ENGNM4<464'1424> =4>;4+644\''4,-4A\42###64 13#&74194379694#33349146713334#473316 494233324646916)34 3169494$34'19%3327#B4CN32P95675J9:]2EK4<464'1424<;4;4+ -4NK5 M4Z9^92Z5415Z219N354^5E2G_`4+644\''43'44 - a"33#494$34914946)ඦ'19%3## 56/#4%649146)ඦ'19%3##413?&13#4$494'3624624'193b4,-4643764 '19'314914&6&$91c324񕔘%9&14'19%3##4*3326#d4-464&3191493491464 &31914'&1'9#3d4624-413#&7426673494564eN:4XK215675[NEf44,;444<4 +,<<-4\#4$343194&'13349&14$6#4932 g3h344ń94#6#46%939#4A$34FE4F2E4ඦ43764 '19%3##44#4946%96)3B4eN:4XK215675[NEf44,;444>4+,<<-4 0123144444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444445673484 94  43 13461244634943194346 !"#9694932$4%7464199#&46'&#4(3139134)694&3 4*34(34 +132)63491464)6,4(3491413"#13&4(64(34-+19)3&&3&494(34)9#14(634 (3&33&4*334#&324+19+31.4/012345675889:;5<3=>?0@A5BC?7A4DE4 %#++24DF4D F4!GF$4!)69&4932$4H))9124I06>CJ5675:>KL5J45 /3M5NJOPA4F4%24Q4EE4!2414$4!R3'4S91T4(6&4-6234)3614(6464 6)9#&493469344293&4947341&349464)6#&34946)949146*#&3494 +19)3&&.$4!"#9694932$,49J?KJOU15811J?175675V3>W@3A4 4%24FX4FFD4 !241FQ$4!(9274(64#231493))#46'4-946314'(64 &)92#)4*4(349136&9149))#1&4*39134(34)93)33494&#44&4 944&3 4646*#&3494+19)3&&4*3)6#&34(3134&49434+19)3&&494 6*#&3.$,4YZ175[ZW@UC1A5BC?75675IK3\23CA4FD4R]4FD4QQQ4H24 44 !F$4!4-^_`(347331641#34&4(64(34694943a69#&4)4 +19)3327&4T9'494*34719#23&&4&4946*#&3494+19)3&&.4!"#9694 932$4!3+(6&&413932$$ V3>C1K3>C5675b3JC0O=4F4_4FQ4c4  ]H*&9#34+19&3)#9164#46++3&494(34)6&4676&4(34634624 676&4G3+#463d&4H913&4R3&46245#T34914(314+19&3)#9164 6)9& 56d&49)9)#&914)6&4676&4GH&4R3&46245#T346 413634213)494 (34694624+#1&#494+19&3)#9&494564*4(34634943194_(34)6&4 934+19&3)#91646)9&4&#)(46&4(347494)164)(6173&4+61)+6944 2&)9314624+131647694+364*617674323)34+13&332464164624 &33)742&&&6494+19)3327&462413&+927494+9&e#273499&4_(3&34 61340@@4)9134+19&3)#94#)9&4914'()(4GH&4R3&46245#T346134#34194 &#4/3OJ5675C1P>4FE4464 

0123144444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444445673484 94  43 13461244634943194346  564!6"463244"63464#64$% 4&!#!41334#64'34716324&!413"%3#44 !"4#6"4676"4()4*3"413761274!346314 4+,-,./01/230-454* 4   66 567"4 # #$" 14#6"413761274()4*3"44624!346314 4+,-,./01/230-454 * 4  6646%%36144136344()4*3"743346"4!34#44!346314  46"464%1"3#$148!34396#46$134 4!34#64"4$#3614: &33144!343934!64 5646""31"464#6461"74$4 464# %646234'4()4*3"44!34% #34 "$#!4"633"461346'" $34%137324;-<-=5-4/01/>-=?@.A,.4B>C4D@E4 F484GH4 I4 4564#6 4%1364464#64 46#$"4%1"3#$4"#34!346314224 4 316344!"4614J4!346#K &3273"4!34&6"4# #324 4(" 12314 2$#4 )2264564!6"4 4637324646#"474643764%1%31414 $6$! 1L324$"34 464# $14%1#3""4'4()4*3"44!346314(332646"44"634 #6"4 146#$"4%1"3#$4146'$"34 4%1#3""4$% 4&!#!41334#64'3471632 0(M (3326"74 4"4N)*8M(48!346314"42"""324&!4%13O$2#3 M3#1#64"732P4QQ 46PFHP 45R4%$1"$644MS4T2U

VVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVVV !4481362&3 $%3114 $14$273

01231444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444444456734894 489  43 13461244634 431 4346