Residences at Biltmore Condo. Owners' Ass'n, Inc. v. Power Dev., LLC

778 S.E.2d 467, 243 N.C. App. 711, 2015 N.C. App. LEXIS 892
CourtCourt of Appeals of North Carolina
DecidedNovember 3, 2015
Docket14-1222
StatusPublished
Cited by1 cases

This text of 778 S.E.2d 467 (Residences at Biltmore Condo. Owners' Ass'n, Inc. v. Power Dev., LLC) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of North Carolina primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Residences at Biltmore Condo. Owners' Ass'n, Inc. v. Power Dev., LLC, 778 S.E.2d 467, 243 N.C. App. 711, 2015 N.C. App. LEXIS 892 (N.C. Ct. App. 2015).

Opinion

DAVIS, Judge.

*712 Plaintiff The Residences at Biltmore Condominium Owners' Association, Inc. ("the Association") filed this action seeking a declaratory judgment that various disputed areas within The Residences at Biltmore Condominium ("the Biltmore Condominium") were common elements of the Biltmore Condominium as opposed to properties retained by Power Development, LLC ("Power Development") in its capacity as the declarant. Power Development and Mountain Mortgage, Inc. ("Mountain Mortgage") (collectively "Defendants") appeal from the trial court's order granting summary judgment in favor of the Association. After careful review, we affirm.

Factual Background

In 2005, Power Development purchased a 6.6 acre tract of real property on Biltmore Avenue in Asheville, North Carolina for the purpose of developing the Biltmore Condominium. On 12 December 2006, Power Development recorded the Declaration of Condominium for The Residences at Biltmore Condominium ("the Declaration") in the Buncombe County Registry in Book 4330, Page 1427 pursuant to N.C. Gen.Stat. § 47C-2-101 of the North Carolina Condominium Act. The Declaration included plat maps illustrating the plans for the Biltmore Condominium and showing the approximately 5.7 acres of the property that Power Development "desire[d] to submit ... to the terms and provisions of the North Carolina Condominium Act." The Declaration addressed the rights and responsibilities of the Association, which was organized in November of 2006 through the filing of articles of incorporation with the North Carolina Secretary of State.

The Declaration also set forth the definitions of various terms that were contained therein. One such term was "condominium," which the Declaration stated "shall mean and refer to The Residences at Biltmore Condominium as established by the submission of the Property, portions of which are designated for separate ownership and the remainder of which is designated for common ownership solely by the owners of those portions, to the terms of the North Carolina Condominium Act by this Declaration."

The Declaration also defined the term " 'Declarant Retained Property' or 'Retained by Developer' " as

*713 property or other areas which will be retained by Declarant which are reflected on Exhibit "A" or the Plans attached hereto and which are not a part of the Common Elements or Units associated with this condominium and which are, in fact, held in ownership by Declarant. These areas must be built by the Developer but the Developer will keep these properties and may convey the same to the Association but is not required to convey the same.

The plat maps illustrating the Biltmore Condominium plans showed various shaded areas that were labeled "D.R.P." with a note explaining that D.R.P. was an acronym for "Declarant Retained Property." Some of the areas labeled "D.R.P." were inside condominium buildings where residential units were located. The Declaration stated that the Condominium was intended to be a "concierge condominium," meaning one that "has resources in place (i.e., on-staff concierge) to accommodate the al [sic] carte needs (identified within a concierge menu and individually billed per service requested) of the owner, guest, renter or other occupier of any one unit within the condominium."

On 28 September 2007, Power Development executed and recorded a commercial deed of trust in favor of The Bankers Bank, N.A. to secure a loan of $15,580,000.00. The deed of trust encumbered "Tract B," 2.074 acres of the condominium property that encompassed both the remaining units Power Development owned and the areas at issue in the present litigation.

Power Development defaulted on its loan, and foreclosure proceedings were initiated by the substitute trustee, Raintree Realty and *469 Construction, Inc. While the foreclosure sale was pending, Power Development executed a document entitled "Supplemental Declaration of Condominium for The Residences at Biltmore Condominium" ("the Supplemental Declaration"), which was recorded in the Buncombe County Registry in Book 4854, Page 698. The Supplemental Declaration stated, in pertinent part, that (1) "when Power Development, LLC recorded the Declaration, the Declarant labeled certain portions of the common elements in the Condominium Plans attached to the Declaration as 'Declarant Retained Property' "; (2) these common elements labeled Declarant Retained Property are "critical for the operation of the hotel condominium known as The Residences at Biltmore Condominium and the individual unit owners' use and enjoyment" as they include electrical, plumbing, and telephone utilities; (3) "it was always the Declarant's intention that the property labeled as Declarant Retained Property ... be a portion of the unit owners' common elements"; and (4) the *714 original Declaration was "hereby amended for the purpose of clarifying that all of the properties labeled as Declarant Retained Property in the Condominium Plans attached to the Declaration are Residential common elements. As explained in Article III of the Declaration, each residential Unit Owner shall be the owner of an undivided interest as tenant in common of the Residential Common Elements." No vote was held for the unit owners to approve this Supplemental Declaration. 1

On 31 January 2011, Pios Grande Power Development, L.P. ("Pios Grande") purchased Tract B in a foreclosure sale, and the trustee's deed was recorded in the Buncombe County Registry in Book 4858, Page 1173. Pios Grande subsequently conveyed its interest in Tract B by special warranty deed to Serrus Residences at Biltmore, LLC ("Serrus") on 2 November 2012.

Several months earlier, on 20 June 2012, a document entitled "Agreement to Transfer Declarant Retained Property & Rights" ("the Agreement") was recorded in the Buncombe County Registry in Book 4992, Page 620. The Agreement was dated 7 April 2009 and stated that-contrary to the above-quoted language in the Supplemental Declaration-Power Development had retained the rights to "various common elements of the project known as The Residences at Biltmore" because these rights were not included in the commercial deed of trust securing its outstanding loan. The Agreement then explained that in consideration for an additional loan from Mountain Mortgage, Power Development was transferring to Mountain Mortgage the rights it retained in

[a]ny and all properties or other rights which were specifically and clearly retained by POWER by virtue of that certain declaration of condominium for The Residences at Biltmore dated 12/12/2006 and recorded in Deed Book 4330 at Pages 1427-1523; including all developer retained or declarant retained properties as identified on those certain plats and within the intention of the subject declarations and all amendments thereto[.]

The Agreement further stated that the properties retained by Power Development as the declarant were "clearly intended to entail ...

*715

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

In Re Skybridge Terrace, LLC
786 S.E.2d 5 (Court of Appeals of North Carolina, 2016)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
778 S.E.2d 467, 243 N.C. App. 711, 2015 N.C. App. LEXIS 892, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/residences-at-biltmore-condo-owners-assn-inc-v-power-dev-llc-ncctapp-2015.