Republican Governors Association// Chris Bell v. Chris Bell// Cross-Appellee, Republican Governors Association

421 S.W.3d 42, 2013 WL 5477475, 2013 Tex. App. LEXIS 12192
CourtCourt of Appeals of Texas
DecidedSeptember 27, 2013
Docket03-10-00783-CV
StatusPublished

This text of 421 S.W.3d 42 (Republican Governors Association// Chris Bell v. Chris Bell// Cross-Appellee, Republican Governors Association) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Texas primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Republican Governors Association// Chris Bell v. Chris Bell// Cross-Appellee, Republican Governors Association, 421 S.W.3d 42, 2013 WL 5477475, 2013 Tex. App. LEXIS 12192 (Tex. Ct. App. 2013).

Opinion

OPINION

MELISSA GOODWIN, Justice.

These cross appeals concern alleged Election Code violations during the 2006 Texas gubernatorial election. Appellee Chris Bell sued appellant Republican Governors Association (RGA), seeking statutory damages based on RGA’s two contributions of $500,000 to Governor Rick Perry’s political committee, Texans for Rick Perry. See Tex. Elec.Code §§ 253.131, 254.231. After a bench trial, the trial court rendered judgment in Bell’s favor and issued findings of fact and conclusions of law that RGA violated the Election Code when it made the disputed contributions because it failed to (i) file a campaign treasurer appointment, (ii) file a report showing its contributions and expenditures, and (iii) provide a donor list to Texans for Rick Perry that was in compliance with the Election Code. See id. §§ 253.032, 253.037, 254.1581. In its final judgment, the trial court ordered RGA to pay Bell $2,000,-000 — twice the amount of the contributions — plus attorney’s fees and costs. See id. §§ 253.131, 254.231.

On appeal, RGA contends that the trial court erred by holding it liable for the alleged Election Code violations. It argues that the Election Code does not require it, an out-of-state political committee, to file a campaign treasurer appointment or a report showing its contributions and expenditures with the Texas Ethics Commission (TEC), the Federal Election Commission (FEC), or other state filing authorities. It also argues that section 253.032, the section of the Election Code concerning the donor list, does not apply to it. See id. §' 253.032. Bell contends on cross appeal that the trial court erred by not awarding him an additional $2,000,000 in statutory damages. For the reasons that follow, we reverse the trial court’s judgment, render judgment that Bell take nothing, and remand the case to the trial court for the limited purpose of determining whether to award attorney’s fees to RGA.

BACKGROUND

Election Code Provisions

We begin with a brief overview of relevant provisions in chapters 251 to 254 of the Election Code. Those chapters are within Title 15, which regulates political funds and campaigns. Chapter 251 provides general provisions such as definitions, chapter 252 addresses campaign treasurers, chapter 253 addresses restrictions on political contributions and expenditures, and chapter 254 addresses record-keeping and reporting requirements.

Chapter 251 contains definitions for a “political committee,” “general-purpose committee,” “specific-purpose committee,” and “out-of-state political committee.” Tex. Elec.Code § 251.001(12X15). Section 251.001(12) defines a “political committee” as “a group of persons that has as a principal purpose accepting political contributions or making political expenditures.” Id. § 251.001(12). “General-purpose committee” is defined to mean:

a political committee that has among its principal purposes:
*45 (A) supporting or opposing:
(i) two or more candidates who are unidentified or are seeking offices that are unknown; or
(ii) one or more measures that are unidentified; or
(B) assisting two or more officeholders who are unidentified.

Id. § 251.001(14). 1 An “out-of-state political committee” is defined to mean:

a political committee that:
(A) makes political expenditures outside this state; and
(B) in the 12 months immediately preceding the making of a political expenditure by the committee inside this state (other than an expenditure made in connection with a campaign for a federal office or made for a federal officeholder), makes 80 percent or more of the committee’s total political expenditures in any combination of elections outside this state and federal offices not voted on in this state.

Id. § 251.001(15).

Section 251.005 expressly exempts out-of-state political committees from being subject to chapters 252 and 254 except as otherwise provided in that section. Id. § 251.005. If an out-of-state political committee voluntarily chooses to file a campaign treasurer appointment under chapter 252, the committee “becomes subject to this title [title 15] to the same extent as a political committee that is not an out-of-state committee.” Id. § 251.005(b). An out-of-state political committee also “becomes subject to this title [title 15] to the same extent as a political committee that is not an out-of-state committee” if the committee “performs an activity that removes the committee from out-of-state status as defined by Section 251.001(15).” Id. § 251.005(c); see id. § 251.001(15). Further, “[a]n out-of-state political committee that does not file a campaign treasurer appointment shall comply with [the reporting requirements of] Section 254.1581.” Id. § 251.005(d).

Chapter 252 provides statutory instructions for how and where to file campaign treasurer appointments, such as the content of the appointment and the specific authority with whom the appointment should be filed. See generally id. §§ 252.001-.015. A general-purpose committee must file its campaign treasurer appointment with the TEC. Id. § 252.009.

Chapter 258 addresses restrictions on contributions and expenditures. See generally id. §§ 253.001-.176. Section 253.081 restricts contributions and expenditures by candidates or political committees without a campaign treasurer appointment on file. See id. § 253.031. 2 It expressly *46 states that it does not apply to an out-of-state political committee unless “the committee is subject to Chapter 252 under Section 251.005.” See id. § 253.031(e). The next several sections in chapter 253 place additional limits and restrictions on contributions and expenditures, expressly delineating who is subject to the particular limitation or restriction. For example, section 253.032 restricts the acceptance of political contributions exceeding $500 by candidates, officeholders, and political committees from out-of-state political committees. Id. § 253.032. Section 253.037 places further restrictions on general-purpose committees, prohibiting contributions and expenditures until 60 days after they file their campaign treasurer appointment. See id. § 253.037. Section 253.131 authorizes civil liability and statutory damages to opposing candidates for violations of chapter 253. See id. § 253.131. Section 253.131(a) states: “A person who knowingly makes or accepts a campaign contribution or makes a campaign expenditure in violation of this chapter is liable for damages as provided by this section.” Id. § 253.131.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

20801, INC. v. Parker
249 S.W.3d 392 (Texas Supreme Court, 2008)
Columbia Medical Center of Las Colinas, Inc. v. Hogue
271 S.W.3d 238 (Texas Supreme Court, 2008)
Galbraith Engineering Consultants, Inc. v. Pochucha
290 S.W.3d 863 (Texas Supreme Court, 2009)
Presidio Independent School District v. Scott
309 S.W.3d 927 (Texas Supreme Court, 2010)
Cameron v. Terrell & Garrett, Inc.
618 S.W.2d 535 (Texas Supreme Court, 1981)
American Transitional Care Centers of Texas, Inc. v. Palacios
46 S.W.3d 873 (Texas Supreme Court, 2001)
Osterberg v. Peca
12 S.W.3d 31 (Texas Supreme Court, 2000)
Lee v. City of Houston
807 S.W.2d 290 (Texas Supreme Court, 1991)
Underkofler v. Vanasek
53 S.W.3d 343 (Texas Supreme Court, 2001)
McBride v. Clayton
166 S.W.2d 125 (Texas Supreme Court, 1942)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
421 S.W.3d 42, 2013 WL 5477475, 2013 Tex. App. LEXIS 12192, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/republican-governors-association-chris-bell-v-chris-bell-texapp-2013.