Psba v. Psers

804 A.2d 737
CourtCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania
DecidedAugust 12, 2002
StatusPublished

This text of 804 A.2d 737 (Psba v. Psers) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Psba v. Psers, 804 A.2d 737 (Pa. Ct. App. 2002).

Opinion

804 A.2d 737 (2002)

PENNSYLVANIA SCHOOL BOARDS ASSOCIATION, INC., Petitioner,
v.
PUBLIC SCHOOL EMPLOYEES' RETIREMENT SYSTEM and the Public School Employees' Retirement Board, Respondents.

Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania.

Argued April 9, 2002.
Decided August 12, 2002.

*739 Michael I. Levin, Huntingdon Valley, for petitioner.

Charles K. Serine, Harrisburg, for respondent.

BEFORE: PELLEGRINI, Judge, LEAVITT, Judge, DOYLE, Senior Judge.

*738 OPINION BY Judge LEAVITT.

The Pennsylvania School Boards Association (PSBA)[1] petitions for review of a Statement of Policy of the Public School Employees' Retirement System (PSERS). The Statement of Policy allows teachers[2]*740 to purchase credit for their part-time service rendered prior to their becoming members of PSERS, thereby increasing their pension benefits. Invoking this Court's original jurisdiction,[3] PSBA seeks declaratory and injunctive relief to prevent implementation of the Statement of Policy. For the reasons set forth below, we deny PSBA's request for relief.

HISTORY OF THE CASE

Prior to 1975,[4] only full-time teachers were able to participate in the public school retirement system. The current Public School Employees' Retirement Code, 24 Pa.C.S. §§ 8101-8534 (Retirement Code), enacted in 1975, substantially revised the prior system with respect to part-time service. First, the Retirement Code mandated that all salaried teachers be enrolled as members of PSERS, regardless of the number of days or hours worked. Second, the Retirement Code mandated that all per diem teachers be enrolled, if their service exceeded 80 days or 500 hours in any fiscal year. By contrast, teachers whose service totaled less than 80 days or 500 hours remained ineligible for membership in the system.

Since 1975, public school employers have reported per diem service that exceeded 80 days or 500 hours. In 1992, PSERS adopted a statement of policy, entitled "Crediting Purchases of Service During a Non-qualifying Year," which clarified that service that did not meet 80 days or 500 hours was not to be reported.[5] Also consistently since 1975, PSERS's staff has counseled that service that did not pass the threshold of 80 days or 500 hours did not qualify the employee for membership, and, further, credit for this part-time school service could not be purchased should the employee became a member. In other words, membership in the system has been a pre-requisite to earning credit for part-time service.

In January of 1999, PSERS did an about-face on the issue of part-time service. Deciding that its prior position of nearly 25 years was erroneous, it adopted a Statement of Policy (1999 Policy)[6] to authorize members of PSERS to purchase credit for their pre-membership, part-time school service of less than 80 days or 500 hours in any fiscal year. Because the purchase is not mandatory but optional, the 1999 Policy clarified that the exercise of this option does not trigger an obligation in the public school employer to pay the employer share for that purchase. Finally, the 1999 Policy did not change the reporting requirements of public school employers for per diem service less than 80 days or 500 hours; unless or until the part-time teacher becomes a member of PSERS, this part-time service remains irrelevant *741 to pension benefits and is not reportable.

On March 23, 1999, PSBA instituted litigation claiming that the 1999 Policy would financially burden its member school districts and would do so unlawfully because it is without support in the Retirement Code. It claimed the right to a declaratory judgment that the 1999 Policy is invalid as a matter of law and requested a permanent injunction against its enforcement.[7] The preliminary injunction request of PSBA was settled by an agreement that PSERS would stay the processing of any application for the purchase of part-time service until a decision on the merits was reached by this Court. Discovery was taken, and a Stipulation of Facts was filed on September 13, 2001. On September 19, 2001, PSERS filed an application for summary relief pursuant to Pa. R.A.P. 1532(b), and on November 12, 2001, PSBA filed a cross-application for summary relief.

The singular issue before us is whether Section 8303(c) of the Retirement Code, 24 Pa.C.S. § 8303(c), permits members of the system to purchase credit for their part-time school service of less than 80 days or 500 hours in any fiscal year. The resolution of this issue requires a close inspection of Section 8303(c) and related provisions in the Retirement Code.

SECTION 8303(c) OF THE RETIREMENT CODE

The 1999 Policy[8] sets forth PSERS's interpretation of the Retirement Code; it is not a regulation with the force and effect of law. It functions as a notice[9] to the members, their employers and other interested persons that PSERS will now accept applications from members who wish to purchase credit for part-time service rendered pre-membership. PSERS has received numerous requests for applications, and we decide here whether the Retirement Code permits PSERS to accept and process these applications.

*742 Section 8303(c) of the Retirement Code provides for the purchase of credit and receipt of eligibility points for "previous school service or creditable nonschool service." Eligibility points are based upon length of service and determine both the vesting of pension rights and the amount of pension to which an employee is entitled. Section 8303(c) states as follows:

(c) Purchase of previous creditable service.—Every active member of the system or a multiple service member who is an active member of the State Employees' Retirement System on or after the effective date of this part may purchase credit and receive eligibility points:
(1) as a member of Class T-C for previous school service or creditable nonschool service; or
(2) as a member of Class T-D for previous school service, provided the member elects to become a Class T-D member pursuant to section 8305.1 (relating to election to become a Class T-D member);
upon written agreement by the member and the board as to the manner of payment of the amount due for credit for such service; except, that any purchase for reinstatement of service credit shall be for all service previously credited.

24 Pa.C.S. § 8303(c) (emphasis added).

"Previous school service" is a defined term[10] in the Retirement Code that designates any service by a school employee in a Commonwealth school district prior to the member's entrance into the system. A "school employee" is any person working for regular remuneration in or on behalf of a public school. Since neither definition limits "service," it means both part-time and full-time service. Other sections of the Retirement Code support the interpretation that "service" by a "school employee" is the broadest possible group of persons. For example, Section 8301(a)(2) of the Retirement Code[11] limits membership *743 to those "school employees" whose service exceeds 80 days or 500 hours in any fiscal year. In other words, "members" are a subset of "school employees;" they are not synonymous terms.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Hughes v. Pittsburgh
108 A.2d 698 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1954)
Fonner v. Shandon, Inc.
724 A.2d 903 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1999)
Chimenti v. Pennsylvania Department of Corrections
720 A.2d 205 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 1998)
Allstate Insurance v. Heffner
421 A.2d 629 (Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, 1980)
Pennsylvania School Boards Ass'n v. Public School Employees' Retirement System
751 A.2d 1237 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2000)
Pennsylvania School Boards Ass'n v. Public School Employees' Retirement System
804 A.2d 737 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2002)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
804 A.2d 737, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/psba-v-psers-pacommwct-2002.