Private Capital Group, LLC v. Harris

363 P.3d 529, 273 Or. App. 529, 2015 Ore. App. LEXIS 1080
CourtCourt of Appeals of Oregon
DecidedSeptember 10, 2015
DocketCV03120084; A150011
StatusPublished
Cited by3 cases

This text of 363 P.3d 529 (Private Capital Group, LLC v. Harris) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Oregon primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Private Capital Group, LLC v. Harris, 363 P.3d 529, 273 Or. App. 529, 2015 Ore. App. LEXIS 1080 (Or. Ct. App. 2015).

Opinion

HADLOCK, J.

This judicial-foreclosure action led to a sheriffs sale of residential real property to which defendant Steven Harris had held title, and against which he had borrowed several hundred thousand dollars, secured by a trust deed on the property. A general judgment of foreclosure was entered in 2004 and a supplemental judgment for costs and attorney fees was entered in 2005, but the sheriffs sale did not occur until 2011. In the interim period, plaintiff — a successor to the lender and trust-deed beneficiary — paid taxes and other expenses on the property while defendant continued to occupy it. At the 2011 sheriffs sale, plaintiff credit bid an amount that included the advances and that was, therefore, an amount larger than had been included in the money awards in the 2004 and 2005 judgments. The trial court concluded the litigation, post-sale, by (1) ordering that plaintiff could not properly include advances in its credit bid, (2) entering a “second supplemental general judgment” awarding plaintiff the advances it had made for taxes and certain other expenses,1 and (3) entering an order in which it purported to apply the excess amount of the credit bid to satisfy that newly entered judgment. On defendant’s appeal, we vacate the “second supplemental general judgment” and remand.

I. FACTS

A. Events Leading Up To, and Including, the Foreclosure Sale

For purposes of our review, the pertinent facts are procedural and undisputed. This is a foreclosure action related to residential real property in Portland. In 2003, plaintiff GreenPoint Mortgage Funding, Inc., filed a complaint for judicial foreclosure against defendant Steven Harris, who held title to the property, and others.2 Plaintiff [532]*532alleged that defendant had executed a note in the amount of $490,000, secured by a deed of trust on the property in favor of plaintiffs predecessor in interest, and had agreed to make monthly payments on the note for a term of 30 years, starting in 1998.3 Plaintiff alleged that defendant failed to make the required monthly payments starting in October 2002. Consequently, plaintiff claimed, it was due several hundred thousand dollars, including over $400,000 in principle and interest, certain escrow advances, foreclosure costs, undetermined amounts of “prejudgment collection costs,” and attorney fees. Plaintiff sought a judgment foreclosing the deed of trust and awarding the amount of money allegedly due to plaintiff.4 Defendant eventually filed an answer that incorporated affirmative defenses and counterclaims.

The parties entered a stipulated general judgment of foreclosure and money award in December 2004. That stipulated general judgment provided, in pertinent part:

“BASED UPON THE STIPULATION OF THE PARTIES,
“IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that judgment shall be entered in favor of Plaintiff GreenPoint Mortgage Funding (GreenPoint), against Defendants Steven D. Harris, Rebecca J. Harris and State of Oregon Department of Revenue (DOR) as follows:
“1. GreenPoint is awarded Judgment against Defendant Steven D. Harris in the amount of $600,859.73 for past due principal, interest, advances and fees as of October 31, 2004, itemized as follows:
[533]*533“Unpaid Principal Balance $469,921.29
“Interest $ 65,909.76
“Escrow Advance $ 64,106.87
“Recording Fee $ 21.00
“Accrued Late/HSF charges 8 900.81
“Total $600,859.73
“plus pre-judgment and post-judgment interest * * * until paid, plus costs and attorneys fees incurred herein to be determined pursuant to ORCP 68 and set forth in a Supplemental General Judgment, plus GreenPoint’s costs (including attorney fees) to partition the property encumbered by the Trust Deed * * * from the larger parcel owned by Steven Harris, which shall be set forth in a Supplemental General Judgment following the partition, plus any advances Greenpoint may make which may be set forth in a Supplemental General Judgment.
“2. The Trust Deed executed and delivered by Defendant Steven D. Harris *** is a valid lien for the amount of Plaintiff’s Judgment entered herein against [the subject] real property * * *
“3. GreenPoint’s lien for the amount set forth in paragraph 1 is superior to any right, interest, lien or claim of Defendants or any of them, in that property. Defendants Rebecca J. Harris and DOR have valid junior liens. * * *
“4. GreenPoint’s Trust Deed is foreclosed against the [subject property], and all interest that Defendant Steven D. Harris had on and after May 7, 1998 in the real property, or so much interest as may be necessary to satisfy the Judgment of GreenPoint, shall be sold by the sheriff of Clackamas County, Oregon * * *
“5. The proceeds of the sale shall be applied first toward the costs of the sale, then toward satisfaction of Plaintiff’s Judgment awarded in paragraph 1 herein and partition costs, advances, costs and attorneys fees awarded therein; and the surplus, if any shall be distributed as follows:
“[Specifying payments to Rebecca Harris and the Oregon Department of Revenue.]
“(c) In the event the above-named parties are paid in full, the balance shall be distributed to Defendant [534]*534Steven D. Harris or to such party or parties as may establish their right thereto.
“6. Each Defendant and all persons claiming through or under any Defendant, as purchasers, encumbrancers, or otherwise, are forever foreclosed of all interest, lien, or claim in the real property * * * excepting only any statutory right of redemption as any Defendant may have therein.
“7. GreenPoint or any other party to this suit may become the purchaser at the sale of the real property. GreenPoint is permitted to bid by submitting a credit bid in an amount up to and including the amount of the Judgment set forth in paragraph 1 herein, plus any advances. * * *
“8. The judgment granted herein is solely for purposes of foreclosing the residential trust deed and GreenPoint shall not be entitled to a deficiency judgment pursuant to ORS 86.770(4).
* * * *
“13. Until partition and foreclosure is complete, GreenPoint agrees that Defendant Steven D. Harris may live in the house, and shall be responsible for all utilities, regular maintenance expenses and insurance, and shall generally keep the house in present condition or better until the property is partitioned and foreclosed. * * * Defendant Steven D. Harris shall be responsible for all outstanding property taxes, and all pro-rata property taxes that accrue up to the date of foreclosure sale. In the event Defendant Steven D. Harris fails to pay the taxes, Greenpoint may advance sums for the payment of taxes, and may add the advance to the amount of Greenpoint’s credit bid or may set forth the amount in Supplemental General Judgment.”

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

State v. Colgrove
480 P.3d 1026 (Court of Appeals of Oregon, 2021)
Lincoln Loan Co. v. Estate of George Geppert
477 P.3d 7 (Court of Appeals of Oregon, 2020)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
363 P.3d 529, 273 Or. App. 529, 2015 Ore. App. LEXIS 1080, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/private-capital-group-llc-v-harris-orctapp-2015.