Powell v. State

912 N.E.2d 853, 2009 Ind. App. LEXIS 1483, 2009 WL 2869931
Indiana Court of Appeals·Decided September 8, 2009·No. 02A03-0906-CR-241·Published·Cited by 27 cases

Opinion

OPINION

BROWN, Judge.

Jonta A. Powell appeals his convictions for possession of marijuana 1 and possession of a controlled substance, 2 each as class D felonies. Powell raises two issues, which we revise and restate as follows:

I. Whether the trial court abused its discretion by admitting into evidence the marijuana and methamphetamine discovered in the vehicle occupied by Powell; and
II. Whether the evidence was sufficient to support Powell's convictions.

We affirm.

The relevant facts follow. At approximately 2:30 in the afternoon of June 15, 2008, Fort Wayne Police Department Officer Mare Deshaies, a detective with the vice and narcotics division, was patrolling the area of Plaza Avenue in Fort Wayne, Indiana, looking for a subject. While in the area, Officer Deshaies noticed a gray vehicle parked on the side of the street. When Officer Deshaies initially passed by the vehicle, the occupants of the vehicle "turned their faces away" and "got further down in the seat." Transcript at 27. Sev *857 eral minutes later, Officer Deshaies returned to the area and noticed that the occupants were still in the gray vehicle parked on the side of the road. The gray vehicle was properly parked, and the vehicle was "not running." Id. at 21.

Officer Deshaies had "specifically been made aware" that there "had been kind of a rash of burglaries" in the area. Id. at 26. Burglaries were "one of the highest crime rates in the summer" in the area and officers "particularly patrolled] those areas looking for persons that might be loitering in the area, looking for persons that might be in between buildings, that might be in activity that would be related to burglaries ..." Id. at 27.

Officer Deshaies's attention was drawn to the gray vehicle because of the high rate of burglaries. He "pulled up behind" the gray vehicle. Officer Deshaies was in full police uniform and was driving a fully marked squad car. He did not activate his squad vehicle's overhead emergency lights. He then exited his squad car and approached the driver's side of the gray vehicle in order "to conduct an investigation to see what their purpose was in the area." Id. at 7. Fort Wayne Police Officer George Nicklow arrived at the scene "[sleveral seconds" after Officer Deshaies. Tran-seript at 48.

Officer Deshaies was able to observe several items in the gray vehicle "even on initial approach" to the gray vehicle because "it was clear daylight" and because the vehicle's "windows [were] rolled down." Id. at 9. Officer Deshaies observed "a spent .22 shell casing in the back seat, which heightened [his] concern a great deal that there might be a weapon in the car." Id. Officer Deshaies also observed there was "probably a six pack of beer that was half drank in the car" and "[tlhere was also an open bottle of vodka in the car." Id.

Officer Deshaies asked Powell, who was sitting in the driver's seat of the gray vehicle, if Powell was waiting for someone in the area. Powell responded that he was "waiting for his friend who had walked off" and "started mumbling." Id. Powell "couldn't clarify where his friend was, who it was or where he went." Id. Powell kept favoring his right side by his thigh area. Officer Deshaies asked Powell not to put his hand there, but Powell kept bringing his hand back to his thigh area. Officer Deshaies did not know whether Powell was "putting something in that area or retrieving something from that area." Id. at 11. Due to his "concerns for weapons possibly being in the vehicle and his muttered statements," Officer Deshaies asked Powell "to step out of the car so [he] could speak to him." Id. at 10. At that point, Powell "put both hands down by the seat-belt area and turned his back to [Officer Deshaies] to exit the car...." Id. Officer Deshaies testified that Powell's actions "really brought up [his] concern for safety" and Officer Deshaies "immediately removed him from the car at that point." Id. Officer Deshaies performed a limited pat-down search of Powell for weapons "due to the presence of the shell casings in the car and his distinct movements around his waist area and towards the middle of the seat." Id. at 12.

Officer Nicklow approached the passenger side of the gray vehicle. As he approached the "rear on the passenger side" of the vehicle, Officer Nicklow observed that the person seated in the passenger seat "slowly move[d] his right arm and hand down towards the space between the door and the passenger seat," which "heightened [Officer Nicklow's] concern for weapons as [he] approached." Id. at 48. Officer Nicklow also observed an open bottle of beer. Officer Nicklow asked the passenger to get out of the vehicle out of a *858 concern for his safety. The person seated in the passenger seat of the vehicle opened the door to exit the vehicle. Officer Nick-low was about two feet away when the passenger opened the door. As the passenger was getting out, Officer Nicklow observed "in plain view three small baggies laying on the floor board on the right side of the passenger seat." Id. at 45. The baggies were "directly under the passenger side lever to tilt the passenger seat, exactly where [Officer Nicklow] saw [the passenger] reach." Id. Officer Nicklow noticed that several of the bags "contained a green leafy like substance that [he] knew from [his] training and experience to be marijuana." Id. at 46. Officer Nicklow also noticed baggies containing pills which had a "stamp of Batman, a Batman symbol on it." Id.

Officer Nicklow then advised Officer Deshaies that there was marijuana in the car, and "at that time, [Officer Deshaies] took Mr. Powell into custody and placed him in handcuffs ...," and Officer Nicklow took the passenger "into custody." Id. at 13-14. After placing Powell in handcuffs, Officer Deshaies "checked the area that [Powell] had been putting his hands in." Id. at 14. Officer Deshaies found a small baggie of marijuana "[rlight under the front edge of the driver's seat." Id Officer Deshaies also found a "single loose pill" which was "resting pretty much where the center console, the seat belt and the rails for the seat all joined." Id. at 15. Officer Deshaies noticed that the pill was brightly colored and had an imprint on it, which were "common in ecstasy pills." Id. at 38. 3 Officer Deshaies "believed [the pill] to be ecstasy ..., methamphetamine or dimeth-amphetamine," and a field kit test revealed that the pill "tested positive for that." Id.

On June 19, 2008, the State filed information charging Powell with possession of a controlled substance 4 as a class D felony and possession of marijuana hash oil or hashish as a class D felony. On October 2, 2008, the State filed amended information for possession of controlled substance. 5 On December 2, 2008, Powell waived his right to a jury trial, and on December 16, 2008, the trial court conducted a bench trial.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Powell v. State, 912 N.E.2d 853, 2009 Ind. App. LEXIS 1483, 2009 WL 2869931 (Ind. Ct. App. 2009).

912 N.E.2d 853 (Powell v. State) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Tony Lawrence Richey v. State of Indiana
Indiana Court of Appeals, 2023
Aaron A. Negash v. State of Indiana
113 N.E.3d 1281 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 2018)
Ashley Reid v. State of Indiana
113 N.E.3d 290 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 2018)
Marcus K. Baxter v. State of Indiana
103 N.E.3d 1180 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 2018)
Lance E. Brown v. State of Indiana
62 N.E.3d 1232 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 2016)
Thomas Pinner v. State of Indiana
59 N.E.3d 275 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 2016)
Kelly C. Mullen v. State of Indiana
55 N.E.3d 822 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 2016)
Obed Bailey v. State of Indiana (mem. dec.)
Indiana Court of Appeals, 2016
Cody Rutledge v. State of Indiana
28 N.E.3d 281 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 2015)
Zigfried Davis v. State of Indiana
Indiana Court of Appeals, 2013
Asa G. Wisler v. State of Indiana
Indiana Court of Appeals, 2012
Joshua J. Sharp v. State of Indiana
Indiana Court of Appeals, 2012
Woodson v. State
966 N.E.2d 135 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 2012)
Michael Woodson v. State of Indiana
Indiana Court of Appeals, 2012
McLain v. State
963 N.E.2d 662 (Indiana Court of Appeals, 2012)