Home/Court of Appeals of Texas/Porter, Orvis Wayne

Porter, Orvis Wayne

Court of Appeals of Texas·Decided August 20, 2015·No. WR-50,653-07·Published

Opinion

7@! `

T/c>` ”W\Q> Q@\.w\‘..\w,\ QD\>M OQ QW@A\ 15027" 523 ,0205 ~FO “§\L Co\)?\¥ C\QV\¥\ g) L§§’§ O';)’ -QO jr¥?} M>U Q 5 PECEWED:N ¢‘:'@Qm C€}SUH wm ’ v \ ` -

09\)$8\,0&/€\\’; ‘b{M-QQ, ww\o._ O’)\v\§%`[__ __CC§>§AUG 202015 P;:}qb$$‘\»l§ 'V\,”§C) L>SB_ O*§@@FAUSUCG@W<

Pr\mw>`£°" "r@vqsw')%%w ,L \)O©c)\c) \3 K

"TRQ\?CV\§@ 40 S-WL€) P\MQP\)\$ Qr\)c>)

Qm§we

Q`>\@ jr\/\`{S `\»Q m\/ \QUW\,\Q ~Y»c)' ~H\Q, `§/OD\SQ S,Q '/}Y\Q, CO\)\DFH LUV\C\HV\ \/QQ

Q'\)@\ $@Mc\ YY\Q, C'\>§)‘// ‘>V

v . \ \, 4 @&\)\8 wab`que, QM\¥QQ> ~U"‘W\& `)00" w liab \A ms$\§, ` §)Ac,v\ \ \>¢8\¥

;MOO wmmc€_@@w\ M m\m§r>w. T__a><<¢»g `"7')${:)3

w@ 3 f )€' »-\‘

` °“L\> mm QQ\\~\…A\ `Q.@L>M gem - -‘

" ’“ » °‘\`v\d Y\\)S¥\YQ.TM<\AS 09 ` ® . C<>\SQ, w@.w\b»§%§§'l?@§` 'Sl)\€\z\_uv\w~\~_ C§\>'\)\i QAH md

§X."@M\¥C lm$§x§ 0§§\)`\8 w@\)z\)& Q(>\o»>¢q@\ 40 \"5~ l »w\o~w$:v~; w 'T\’\b SXML wl “Fel\¢\e. . \MM \W&_MS C< 3 QW\'V\'_`\C\*' Q')f>§r€>_\@‘l@\\l " \ " OW€Q ' 8)08¥),1\\ _\Av\'\l)_\¢\ ~ \.\.C>'] 1 59 ©vx.\\(x$ Cou~v\»/ _ k ‘ . w \_ ‘*T(>\QA\)UJ\§€, 40 §MH)FC § ' ' ?\l¥\)l\~. amd Q\»\) wl@\ a mg 5{),\¢\,@0<2,¥

ij :,Y:C) upde \»\0\\)0(2\0\\1;\\@, )' “§MQXE) § §§ X/\\Q, C,P\`\m`\»d¢§\ Cp\)@»\< Q)Q {_\\)QQ(~¥\

§G~BWQ 'Q@Xl)?\r\) m b \Y\’@Qb‘&% -C°Q“Q`)%" QQQ"WU;\/\ P\c$;wed _.~Q\@S§§Q,wc@% 40 \)~‘% X_ `_ 8 'QQ_>¢`\`>Y\\°NQ`Q\) `\‘§`\3‘;§(*\ QC-- mm w ¢*Q\j ‘3~”€~§@\‘< `. §(\[\QJ ,§3\(>,9\5¥ b ' \

. &.‘ ' r_./ n z v b \ y .` . ' z » F“'@Y A\>@M\;>\Q 40 \Q,\\» mm @ Q\)Q&\'\AM :»`C;`/O\NS.€,\_ \»MAS "SNQQQLCA-`\\>Q, .QQQ\ _QW

v 550 C\(\Q\\Jw a A(m SO§QRC,KCQC\} §§ sw\c\mg@ 93 Qo w‘\)§Q/>r§®'

'3§@ @A lam _Q<,\\wom m

` JY\(\@::)Q\§@\Q Q\\LSQCX\\| \33@§ an Q\S\f\&~§ CL \(\"\5 \

.m%\-\mm;r {Q))QS\AW \\¢X%\XM;W \.A fql»'$\&°¢,\~'_m» gwych @\\@\<\@Q, Q,g M\~@\ ' 'W\Q SJ,ML QQ§\@A lro¢§>&@\l ama €Q:l?'§\‘&€\\»m§§

Y\M>`\\'Pf\f¢\"©§ 0»8 Q' Qm¢¥\ Cw\)\)`\®r§\»$

'~" "‘~. `j_>\\} :)>\(\Q\°\%` `-/L`\\e, SXAB& `:\\UD`A\M§J

1'.""3”8'5‘1`”8 (’§p_v\c§\v¢\©\\] ,\(\Q%`z\r©¥\m f 4 /\:\\)<>,\\ (`/O\\M`\Qvio\& VQQOX)QQ\'\}' ”S, 32va #\'0, j \\Lgb<>/\'-\'\\{ ' ` W \l>\\\\L\w»»‘ gmglro\\)

l,\\d\r\wm W&A%\Q\Q\_m\l>\ _ 03 ®~(-\§V\ `\v\§' AYQUA\ Cd\)\?~)r \RDCOQ\S}§

”S»J\\} \l,“&b\\ 9\\)\'*0`-\0\2'@1 _w>~§l `\~; wa>y

§Q\<>NSL\@¥`SFMM Q>“\\i wl 9<"*°5“\\2“"“\ \ l l

` ` . \,>`\X\(\ 5\'\»30 SLQ v ~ -"~"\.W\ ‘L. oig 3(\\<2) %LYQ\\M

%\\`\€» _` wm ©r'§c)m\\§e, m /

lsch § \jQAQ\LS" ©e\\ \CQ`V>QAM "S, §§ro §§ ` if QP\Q\@\Q\ 984 via {W\ 06\\$1.0\\>_<\ Bé§eme.\¢r, 3§\\"\8 §§ q “§l)f\§m\ Q\`\SHM}: wsm

'/\\ m C©\)O\ C>\\B »§D\SLA\ Q\Wwiw~\\, \§l\l\\»@ \'5\°§ @\<; Y;\@,c;; §§ €Q%OQAN "b{ Qb©§q T\f`\e, `DQ\-Q ONO\ r\qm€) VY 8 ""QNCQ, Cmo\ QQM\M\Q\/\ \g w@&m`§ _QQ\O… » @Né D,P"QQN"(\U¥ C)Q Q@\Rm`\s\\¢§\ ’S»QSX\.QQ, t . > COP\Q\€,QXR\)MA\ w$\~`\¥\§lr§o\\) D§\)K§v\§»l€gbm \2@\¢@88@,“5…@5 c)m;~\<>\mw §§ Q\\%§§Ul;@,¢ CANC} `€®QQ»Q~@\& jim Q->(\r\`\%‘\\r L\ QQ@\&U,\\§F »- §)@m&m¥mw\_) QQQ\/»Q¢ Qc§w\\\r¥m;\ `T\\IS `@QS;RC\A\)\\’ ` QU' Qr\dc\ w@\m\\<:) -w\IO\ law m§QM 4 mo , ~:2\) %Mp\ ‘:2>@\12@\ Q\\\MQ v>f> -<`».\>l*~)r'i\\@@ C`A§Q, bsm§s# wm 403@2\\2<<\, 58 ~¥Y\w»@ Sm\>\d \c\»~\& `\m®v\\ %l\z'm?@¢\€&\ QUA\DM\RQ¥` \QCI &~?5\&0\\-~\\/0 ,1 \\.AQ,§H>,),\U was Qm¢»\ Cw\)?@)r§o~\§ 09 `B\¢'l> \CL<§ '§¢AEC,\A\ `0,\15¥9&€;¥ Q§w@~¥ 8 Qp\m¥i\j §ZQ>QQRQQ@\ ' , v ' Q>l>¥ ‘Q@\\¢\b `Qo\wlvj iSA\\ `\“'\\p. \(Wo\,`i w\@§ 919 C>\)>t.O\Nc,\\)`\c)\A¥QJ \(o'|\q¢\°\ ` '“m§ j¢£§@gm@§v\v& mm c\ §§ (DMW\Q, 2

\\\[g \je%@\\§

-' \} “\im \A,-S Q>'c>m

@§MM `T wm m A, ` .\_V - m -

,~:@~\4 zm,m"‘L‘:`>Q'* Q‘Q\M-® Yb\/ m OM<>NQQ\_\/ @M)`Smp{… _15;§;:\§:¢\\\3&:> ju\q %\._-A’X j mma . \ ~ Q` QMSQ'AAV

_Q. `Sj@m\sfl wm N£ML vw ` ’QMQ\QA`\Q ‘Q>M\‘» 40 “Y@MS\’:L news m @Q\e_§m\\ W%O'° 5?<%\»~\ ‘R/z\s\\¢m ~w \1\\»»\<§%.'£ ms NWW 32)»\\¥@\\£€,_ QQ\QQ@Q\W iowa `\>F wm .IX\QBM\\/j

flsa m\} Q¥¥c>~ea.\) 40 5‘\@3@\ W\/q M,NJ_ Q,,\;

":O\j ?)'\,\.WZ . ':L`B 3§¢'$ Rc)_ `~SOQRRQ\A\ 0\`6¥9\`\@3¢ ka>§r' n d “\,\3 'Yexf§S-_ ‘

: "»;/\)Q§ \'\)Q}\M)v S>\)\£P\ `\\Q. '@\D\`\§O v \d m\{ \]@0%%'\';&»3 FM»B\’M\.~ `\‘O\M€J w feww\\) "~S.M€> \\) QM\A\& O\Qc) O»\Q@g\f>\d\] C\~\SQ)NW\¢DQH ., W>C.Qm\w>\ §M0\\<@\¢\,@) M\\~\\/; _

\)\\\'\S 0\ \\\Q\)Q‘C)n\‘%@)f>& `\ QAQ®W¢ '% v ”SK¢E Rc) *S\>AIQM QG\N~X,(’»¥ QM@\\J

`%~M§QQ czch wm :50€&5@ `Q¢:y\f… \ jo\m¢§w _ G\WAA`\ SQNXAAQQ m \"q m\%g\,\qqq,\“f\\i§ mm SLQM»QXL QQ,QWCQ; ZQ M\Q@\a S>m\>\c) %QQ>»~\ §M‘JM~MA Q;LA@M,\AQX'_O~¥ ’~Mm\.\ 11> FQ;L_‘M&%\~~\~A) md m €°N-SSS‘TB v§ 919 ~w`\v B(\\ QQ\NH ZSA`\\ Q>'»\\ ` mec \f%~'?>\&.@»\~m»~> ' 9®0.©

`I w Q\\ \ \\@ \ ‘W ix w c; (;:))(:\\,~)\r;@: A(O\DT.'D.Q q\.\> \FO\O\ §'5”6‘1'5 Fe<§.°>¢ ":):4 C\id~'¥ §§ /\r\> QQ\`\§QM R.\> fbwa QA§{{] guy M\L§Q‘“'\C 3v`\“`\‘L. T\\Q`\®\

p&' d x

. §Q\'<\Q.\\X ?\.\3 ‘;§g‘§)w c \_ ® '

O\;® >s\~» \v\w\ %O\ -TY\Q> QSDRA_ g@\`\eg\ 46 'QR/b\re.>

. `§“\\Q> §N\‘\WQQ,W¢~\¥. `\»\B ' 5v\c\sw NGAV`\'QQ, c>€Q (;.A\\qg,mwxg_. 'SL® \E>U\\Q>\¥ 651 wag)\w\) \M%:¥Mm »- Wfl~ i’>\‘@\€c\~mw., (5@@1;®@, law 'L\\@§»D,\\\) \s§e, .$`C\°\-S’l>§‘i?> 3m QM\MQQ \<">\;1»’5\@@\\~~\»0 ims mm %L@___@<>\QAQ Um~ ’Cm \wo@¢\<;\é \_5 j"" S~>§§Q'WQQ\£ _;3(@ -F@\~\\!i<>m$'C-_Q. - FQ&~"§\ Q,O\\ »W\v\) M §§pr §§ m M,j":»wm 'SD@M\ -~ CX`\SH\:Q>¢ Qo\>\@»é, RQ)QOM mci imm WMH\@M QOQ\Q\QQ}\`OQ\M QQ)C/O?\c)\§ §&Q) Q)(Y\Q>\\“ ®,3 T\/\M *W'§)ri§lj `\\» %N\\j CN@\

c/\5\~{\\] w¥\\`r€,-\\);)A§\v\h~\§\-w§ D‘Q` N\)m\©&(% O~\)f§ Q>N& ,Q\,A‘>Q({QQ\§»J\'

Ql@`pm\/\z\q QNQ T. C>NQ Q`\C};\>RQJ, QN@\ `“(v\m SQQQQ\M_Q- QA§@, N\,m`»&v\) ~\?C\&>"s.\ myva md \:’W-$':>Bq'g v >M, U…~\M\ C`/\`\§.\R\Q§r C,Q\)Wr `1\\&5\1%\ \>SQ' bqlm C/¢>,§Q, \\\\)~\(BLQ\

`\`x\\ yR>Q\~'jw\f\¢ar~\)f A@& Q\_/U>, Q)N\§O»`\"Q\ O\MG'MQAQ/\$Q)\j ~‘U¢ w\m\>\a wm cwa \:O\O\ _»55':>€3 <‘M§\M\]~ ' \(\Q&)~\_.§_`,."§(»\~WY\\ F®\(>L~‘§'$(bclvzd., QQ\D»'XYQQ\ “\'C%'X\S)vj "\"l' AYQ\\\A\ ?\Q\~€@:"\% \w w¢r§v<\§ \\1\0\<2, - m \<>1 qq ,. uly§¢wu\\) Q®G)M/ MM>'U

MMSXSMMX YY\Q) Q,@\(\C»AC,QMM¥

¥O¥~YQ:K\) `OY‘\)Q\\ \ %m& §\(\ `Q (;\f§\€,(/\

l,Afg-L;M erme&\} <>\,\xc/\ \>S& @M\J\O®C&mm§~

O\\‘L\ WWU\ O\¥ AYQ iEk\/\)%*;§»M€c,\

Q'§ »Q’\Q!QM»\ QQ\P\@@\`\,¢Y_\N Q>Q©P\Q`)@v>y&\\§@®d C>%SQQ¥ gm _\QMQ @;UQA\ wit §§Q)M\\@ 40 §MMQQ\TQ\;@\ w@m% w»-»@: m gm QXY\I%;¥ QQO\QD(AV\‘(>Q \)‘\\O\MIO)\\ §\)GQ€Q\ t Q,HQMQ(L\) `Dw;~\%m`»¥\f\ §M§€\\\ “§~\q N\°\`W> `Ld 3(\\@ 3(03 RO 'SOOMC,M 0,\:53<9\§@¥ QMM owc) §p{\x`\%\§r Q§'\ A(\m> NQ¥EQQ. Q>,§ Q§\(\QJQQN\€¢\% §§(\\Q)§§r'[;§ "Q)Q\ch\§ `\D,QQQR~%WA§Y C»Q /, . CoQ\V\Q-C;¥`\Q\A,`~\r`\`<~ry)'§!\(\9¢~153¢3 (3,\§\1§`. NDNX€/ USQ __ `\Q C)(A<§w Mmom$ C>Q\\»K$ Qc>\@é,e@\l CS?M¥\ ¥\\$~XW`S"' ij \/\W>r$ F~C,M\Qz()\®§e,o\ W mexl\`\.$.\} m @WMM mmpch

C@»C\Q@. Qm¢&i»¢l§@

QQ\Q\) W;.m £%\dc)z q » d ( S')b`~<<»‘i<)’§.

FQ%QQ&QN :S‘ '§mc~>04 /&\wz>

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Porter, Orvis Wayne, (Tex. Ct. App. 2015).

Porter, Orvis Wayne (Porter, Orvis Wayne) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.