Home/Supreme Court of Pennsylvania/Porter, D. v. Toll Brothers, Pets.

Porter, D. v. Toll Brothers, Pets.

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania·Decided April 18, 2023·No. 308 EAL 2022·Published

Opinion

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PENNSYLVANIA EASTERN DISTRICT

BRETT ADAMS, TAMRA ADAMS, JILL : No. 300 EAL 2022 O'DONNELL, MATTHEW O'DONNELL, : JASON TEPFENHARDT, JESSICA : TEPFENHARDT, JAMES WIEGERS, ANN : Petition for Allowance of Appeal MARIE WIEGERS, BRIAN BENTRIM, JEFF : from the Order of the Superior Court CAMPAGNA, ELIZABETH CAMPAGNA, : CATHERINE BENTRIM, JAMES COY AND : DENISE COY :

: :

v. :

: :

TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A., ANDERSEN : WINDOWS, INC., THOMAS E. MANION T/A : MANION CONTRACTORS AND/OR : THOMAS E. MANION, MICHAEL : ANTOLINO CONSTRUCTION, INC., RSB : CONSTRUCTION CO., MACK DONOHOE : CONTRACTORS, INC., ELK : CONSTRUCTION, PETR JACH T/A BRICK : FRONTS, .L.C., EXTERIOR OPTIONS, INC. :

: :

PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA, L.P. AND : TOLL PA GP CORP. :

JAMES COOKE AND TRACY COOKE : No. 301 EAL 2022 : :

v. : Petition for Allowance of Appeal : from the Order of the Superior Court :

TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, VI L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A. :

:

:

v. :

: :

ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., NEW : MILLENNIUM CONTRACTING CORP., : MACK DONOHOE CONTRACTORS, INC., : MAR JOHN MASONRY, INC., CONNOLLY : STUCCO AND PLASTERING :

: :

PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA, VI, L.P. AND : TOLL PA GP CORP. :

JAMES COY AND DENISE COY : No. 302 EAL 2022 : :

v. : Petition for Allowance of Appeal : from the Order of the Superior Court :

TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A. :

: :

v. :

: :

ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., MICHAEL : ANTOLINO CONSTRUCTION, INC., RSB : CONSTRUCTION, EXTERIOR OPTIONS, : INC D/B/A EXTERIOR WALL, INC., FRANK : BADOLATO, AQUARIUS SIDING :

: :

PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA, L.P. AND : TOLL PA GP CORP. :

THOMAS DEANGELO AND CAGLAYAN : No. 303 EAL 2022 DEANGELO :

: : Petition for Allowance of Appeal v. : from the Order of the Superior Court

[300 EAL 2022, 301 EAL 2022, 302 EAL 2022, 303 EAL 2022, 304 EAL 2022, 305 EAL

: :

TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, II, L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A. :

: :

v. :

: :

ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., MS : BUILDERS, INC., M A CARDY : CONSTRUCTION, INC., DOMINIC C. : DEFRANGESCO, MACK DONOHOE : CONTRACTORS, INC. :

: :

PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA II, L.P. AND : TOLL PA GP CORP. :

TODD ELLIOTT AND JUDITH ELLIOTT : No. 304 EAL 2022 : :

v. : Petition for Allowance of Appeal : from the Order of the Superior Court :

TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, II, L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A. :

: :

v. :

: :

ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., MACK : DONOHOE CONTRACTORS, INC., M.A. : CARDY CONSTRUCTION, INC. :

: :

PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA II, L.P. AND : TOLL PA GP CORP. :

[300 EAL 2022, 301 EAL 2022, 302 EAL 2022, 303 EAL 2022, 304 EAL 2022, 305 EAL

BENJAMIN LACSON AND EVELYN : No. 305 EAL 2022 LACSON :

: : Petition for Allowance of Appeal v. : from the Order of the Superior Court : :

TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA, L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A. :

: :

v. :

: :

ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., THOMAS E. : MANION T/A MANION CONTRACTORS : AND/OR THOMAS E. MANION A/K/A : MANION, RSB CONSTRUCTION CO., : EXTERIOR WALLS, INC., MACK : DONOHOE CONTRACTORS INC., ELK : CONSTRUCTION, INC. :

: :

PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA, L.P. AND : TOLL PA GP CORP. :

MICHAEL MILEY AND JENNIFER MILEY : No. 306 EAL 2022 : :

v. : Petition for Allowance of Appeal : from the Order of the Superior Court :

TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA II, L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A. :

: :

v. :

: : : :

[300 EAL 2022, 301 EAL 2022, 302 EAL 2022, 303 EAL 2022, 304 EAL 2022, 305 EAL

ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., NEW : MILLENNIUM CONTRACTORS, MACK : DONOHOE CONTRACTORS, INC. :

: :

PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA II, L.P. AND TOLL PA GP CORP.

FURRUKH MUNAWAR AND AAIYSHA : No. 307 EAL 2022 MUNAWAR :

: : Petition for Allowance of Appeal v. : from the Order of the Superior Court : :

TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA II, L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A. :

: :

v. :

: :

ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., MACK- : DONOHOE CONTRACTORS, INC., : MILLENNIUM CONTRACTING : CORPORATION :

: :

PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA II, L.P. AND : TOLL PA GP CORP. :

DANIEL PORTER AND CAROLYN : No. 308 EAL 2022 PORTER :

: : Petition for Allowance of Appeal v. : from the Order of the Superior Court : :

TOLL BROTHERS, INC, TOLL PA II, L.P., : TOLL PA GP CORP, TOLL BROS., INC., : TOLL ARCHITECTURE, INC., TOLL : ARCHITECTURE I, P.A. :

[300 EAL 2022, 301 EAL 2022, 302 EAL 2022, 303 EAL 2022, 304 EAL 2022, 305 EAL

: :

v. :

: :

ANDERSEN WINDOWS, INC., DOMINIC C. : DEFRANGESCO, MACK DONOHOE : CONTRACTORS, INC. :

: :

PETITION OF: TOLL BROTHERS, INC., : TOLL BROS., INC., TOLL PA II, L.P. AND : TOLL PA GP CORP. :

ORDER

PER CURIAM

AND NOW, this 18th day of April, 2023, the Petition for Allowance of Appeal is

DENIED.

[300 EAL 2022, 301 EAL 2022, 302 EAL 2022, 303 EAL 2022, 304 EAL 2022, 305 EAL

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Porter, D. v. Toll Brothers, Pets., (Pa. 2023).

Porter, D. v. Toll Brothers, Pets. (Porter, D. v. Toll Brothers, Pets.) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.