Plumbers Local No. 75 v. Coughlin

481 N.W.2d 297, 166 Wis. 2d 971, 1992 Wisc. App. LEXIS 1
Court of Appeals of Wisconsin·Decided January 23, 1992·No. 89-1155·Published·Cited by 7 cases

Opinions

SUNDBY, J.

The Department of Industry, Labor and Human Relations (hereafter "department" or DILHR) administers the Wisconsin Manufactured Building Program which it bases on its administrative [975] rules mandated by the Manufactured Building Code, secs. 101.70 to 101.77, Stats. The key to the program is the Wisconsin insignia the department issues for manufactured housing1 which conforms to the Manufactured Building Code. Manufactured housing which bears the Wisconsin insignia may be manufactured, offered for sale and installed in the state on a conforming installation site, regardless of any other ordinance, rule, regulation or requirement. Wisconsin Adm. Code secs. ILHR 20.15(2) and (3), and 50.125. The department appeals from a judgment which effectively forbids the department from issuing insignia for manufactured housing in which the plumbing is installed without complying with sec. 145.06(1)(a) and (2), Stats. We reverse.

THE ISSUES

The ultimate issue is whether the department may approve manufactured housing for sale and installation in the state, irrespective of sec. 145.06(1)(a) and (2), Stats. Section 145.06(1)(a) provides that "[n]o person [976] may engage in or work at plumbing in the state unless licensed to do so by the department . . Section 145.06(2) provides that " [n]o person shall install plumbing unless at all times a licensed master plumber is in charge, who shall be responsible for proper installation

The plaintiffs-respondents, Plumbers Local No. 75, and a Wisconsin-licensed journeyman plumber ("Plumbers"), contend that nothing in the department's administrative rules or the Manufactured Building Code makes sec. 145.06(l)(a) and (2), Stats., inapplicable to manufactured housing. However, it is undisputed that the department construes its administrative rules to permit it to issue the Wisconsin insignia for manufactured housing in which the plumbing is installed without complying with sec. 145.06(1) (a) and (2). Therefore, the first sub-issue is whether the department has correctly construed its administrative rules. We conclude that the department's construction of its administrative rules is neither inconsistent with their language nor clearly erroneous. Its interpretation of its administrative rules is therefore entitled to controlling weight.

The Plumbers contend that the department may not enact an administrative rule which conflicts with state law. Therefore, the second sub-issue is whether the Manufactured Building Code authorized the department to adopt its administrative rules which it has interpreted as permitting it to approve, for sale and installation in the state, manufactured housing in which the plumbing has been installed without complying with sec. 145.06(1)(a) and (2), Stats. We conclude that the department's construction of the Manufactured Building Code is reasonable and is consistent with the legislative purpose in enacting the One- and Two-Family Dwelling [977] Code and the Manufactured Building Code.2 We therefore defer to that construction.

I.

DEPARTMENT'S CONSTRUCTION OF ADMINISTRATIVE RULES

We first examine how the department has construed its administrative rules as to one- and two-family and multifamily manufactured housing. The department has interpreted its administrative rules to authorize it to adopt and administer the Wisconsin Manufactured Building Program. Information Bulletin to Housing Manufacturers and Inspection Agencies, June 1989, DILHR, Safety & Buildings Division (hereafter "Information Bulletin"). The department describes the program as follows:

The program is intended to apply to manufactured "closed-panel" structures, which would be difficult to inspect after leaving the plant. However, the program may be used for open-panel structures as well. Assuming compliance with code requirements, a Wisconsin Insignia (label) would be affixed to the building. The local inspector at the installation site will accept the labeled building as being basically code-complying, and will normally inspect the on-site and other accessible work only.
Please note that various state and local trades-licensing requirements do apply to any on-site work [978] and that any local building code requirements do apply to on-site work of multi-unit dwellings. [Emphasis added.]

Information Bulletin, Scope.

Section 8.b, Procedures, provides that "[o]n-site plumbing must be . . . installed by Wisconsin licensed plumbers." Information Bulletin. For in-plant plumbing, however, plans must be submitted to the department's Plumbing Bureau as a Product Approval Application. Id. at sec. 8.a. Applying the principle that the expression of one excludes the other, Teamsters Union Local 695 v. Waukesha County, 57 Wis. 2d 62, 67, 203 N.W.2d 707, 710 (1973), we conclude that the department has interpreted its rules not to require that in-plant plumbing be installed by Wisconsin-licensed plumbers.

We next consider whether the department's construction of its administrative rules as authorizing it to adopt and administer the Wisconsin Manufactured Building Program is inconsistent with the language of the rules or clearly erroneous. See Pfeiffer v. Board of Regents, 110 Wis. 2d 146, 154-55, 328 N.W.2d 279, 283 (1983) (An administrative agency's interpretation of its own regulation is entitled to controlling weight unless inconsistent with the language of the regulation or clearly erroneous).

The rules of administration and enforcement as to one- and two-family housing are contained in the Uniform Dwelling Code, Wis. Adm. Code chs. ILHR 20 to 25.3 Subchapter V, secs. ILHR 20.12 to 20.17, governs [979] the design, manufacture, installation and inspection of one- and two-family manufactured housing.4

The administration and enforcement rules on which the department relies to include multifamily manufactured housing in the Manufactured Building Program are contained in Wis. Adm. Code secs. ILHR 50.06(2) and 50.125, of the Commercial Building Code.5

Inspection procedures are prescribed in Wis. Adm. Code ch. ILHR 26 and subchapter II, ch. ILHR 81, Wisconsin Adm. Code ch. ILHR 26 establishes the stan[980] dards and procedures for certification of inspectors and independent inspection agencies for enforcement of the Uniform Dwelling Code and the Commercial Building Code. Section ILHR 26.01.6 Wisconsin Adm. Code Reg., Dec. 1978, No. 276, eff. Jan. 1, 1979. These procedures apply to one- and two-family and multifamily manufactured housing.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Plumbers Local No. 75 v. Coughlin, 481 N.W.2d 297, 166 Wis. 2d 971, 1992 Wisc. App. LEXIS 1 (Wis. Ct. App. 1992).

481 N.W.2d 297 (Plumbers Local No. 75 v. Coughlin) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Marriage of Paulhe v. Riley
2006 WI App 171 (Court of Appeals of Wisconsin, 2006)
Modica v. Verhulst
536 N.W.2d 466 (Court of Appeals of Wisconsin, 1995)
Kastengren v. Wisconsin Department of Revenue
508 N.W.2d 431 (Court of Appeals of Wisconsin, 1993)
Irby v. Bablitch
489 N.W.2d 713 (Court of Appeals of Wisconsin, 1992)