Plank v. Town of Rayville

764 So. 2d 1194, 2000 La. App. LEXIS 1687, 2000 WL 792510
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedJune 21, 2000
DocketNo. 33,476-CA
StatusPublished
Cited by1 cases

This text of 764 So. 2d 1194 (Plank v. Town of Rayville) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Plank v. Town of Rayville, 764 So. 2d 1194, 2000 La. App. LEXIS 1687, 2000 WL 792510 (La. Ct. App. 2000).

Opinion

JjPEATROSS, J.

This appeal arises out of a fatal train accident which occurred at a railroad crossing in Rayville, Louisiana. Plaintiffs, James E. Plank and Becky Plank Marable, are the adult children of the decedent, Marie Plank,'who was killed when a train struck the rear portion of her car while she was stopped at a traffic light on a street intersecting the railroad tracks. Plaintiffs filed this wrongful death suit against the Town of Rayville (“Rayville”). After a bench trial, the trial court found Mrs. Plank 100 percent at fault for the accident and dismissed Plaintiffs’ suit with prejudice. Plaintiffs appeal, challenging the trial court’s finding of no liability on the part of Rayville and allocation of fault. The Town of Rayville has answered the appeal, asserting numerous alleged erroneous rulings on the part of the trial court. For the reasons stated herein, we affirm.

FACTS

The Accident

Louisiana Street in Rayville runs north and south and is perpendicular to Kansas City Southern (“KCS”) railroad tracks, which run east and west. On either side of the railroad tracks are streets which run parallel to the tracks, U.S. Highway 80 on the north and Benedette Street on the south. There is a traffic light on Louisiana Street at its intersection with Highway 80 on the north side of the tracks. The record reveals that there is enough room for two vehicles between the railroad tracks and Highway 80, provided the northernmost vehicle stops close to the traffic light. On December 9, 1996, at approximately 8:20 a.m., Mrs. Plank left the post office after gathering her employer’s mail and proceeded across the Louisiana Street crossing, coming to a stop behind another vehicle at the traffic light at Louisiana Street and Highway 80. The rear portion of her car cleared the | ^tracks, but remained in the “foul line1,” which is the area on either side of the tracks that [1197]*1197accommodates the width of the train engine.

There were approximately two to four feet between Mrs. Plank’s vehicle and the vehicle in front of her. Several witnesses testified that a person could walk between the two vehicles and others testified that Mrs. Plank had sufficient room to move her vehicle forward to avoid the collision. Mrs. Plank was very familiar with the crossing and had traversed it numerous times.

The train was traveling in a westerly direction at approximately 47 to 48 miles per hour. As the train approached Ray-ville, it passed through two other crossings before reaching the Louisiana Street crossing. As such, R.C. Lindsey, the train engineer, began blowing the train’s horn some distance before ever reaching the sign which alerts him to blow the horn for the Louisiana Street crossing. Mr. Lindsey testified that it was his usual practice to blow the train’s horn continuously while traveling through Rayville, and he did so on the day of the accident.

Mr. Lindsey testified that he saw Mrs. Plank and noted that she was looking straight ahead, in the direction of the traffic light. It was not until the train was approximately 24 feet from the crossing, however, that Mr. Lindsey realized that the train would not clear the rear of Mrs. Plank’s vehicle. At that point, Mr. Lindsey “put the train in emergency” in an attempt to avoid the collision. Mr. Lindsey also testified that he noticed a vehicle on the tracks, behind Mrs. Plank, which backed off the tracks as the train approached.

LThe vehicle behind Mrs. Plank was driven by Darnell Grayson. Mr. Grayson testified that he noticed that Mrs. Plank’s vehicle was going to be struck by the train and he pulled forward toward her vehicle, blowing his horn at her in an attempt to get her attention; however, she did not respond. As the train got closer, Mr. Grayson backed his vehicle to a position of safety and continued to blow his horn at Mrs. Plank. Apparently, Mrs. Plank remained unaware of the train and her proximity to the tracks and she made no effort to move her vehicle or to exit the vehicle to avoid being struck by the train.

According to expert testimony, approximately 27 seconds after coming to a stop at the intersection, the rear foot and one half to two feet of Mrs. Plank’s vehicle was struck by the train. The radio was not playing and the windows in Mrs. Plank’s vehicle were up. Immediately following the collision, Mrs. Plank stated that she did not see or hear the train. Mrs. Plank was transported to the hospital and died later that day.2

Kristie McDuffie testified that she was at the nearby post office that morning. She also testified that it was a clear morning and that, while walking into the post office, she noticed that the rear end of Mrs. Plank’s vehicle was partially in the foul line of the tracks. Ms. McDuffie further testified that there appeared to be room for forward movement of Mrs. Plank’s vehicle when she last saw it. She testified that the space between the vehicles was large enough for a person to walk through. Ms. McDuffie was familiar with the Louisiana Street crossing and testified that there were no visual obstructions of approaching trains to motorists as they approach and cross the tracks. Additionally, Ms. McDuffie testified that, once she was in the post office, she heard the train’s horn blowing continuously and also heard the train apply its brakes, but she did not see the accident.

|4Two eyewitnesses to the accident were Terry Thompson, who was working as an auxiliary police officer for the Town of Rayville, and Rayville Chief of Police Eddie Graham. Officer Thompson testified [1198]*1198that, on the morning of the accident, he and Chief Graham were stopped at the traffic light at the intersection of Julia Street and Highway 80, which is a short distance from the Louisiana Street crossing. Officer Thompson testified that he saw the approaching train and noticed the vehicles stopped at the Louisiana Street crossing. He also noticed that the second vehicle’s rear bumper was very close to, or over, the tracks. Officer Thompson further testified that he saw the vehicle behind Mrs. Plank back up to avoid a collision with the train and that he also saw the train strike Mrs. Plank’s vehicle. According to Officer Thompson, approximately ten seconds elapsed between the time he heard the train’s horn and impact and approximately five seconds elapsed between the time he saw the train’s headlight and impact. Like Ms. McDuffie, Officer Thompson testified that there were approximately three to four feet between Mrs. Plank’s vehicle and the vehicle in front of her and that it would have been possible for her to pull forward or to the right or left to avoid the accident had she heard or seen the train. Officer Thompson had no difficulty seeing or hearing the train from his location, approximately two blocks west of the collision site. Chief Graham confirmed Officer Thompson’s testimony regarding the positioning of Mrs. Plank’s vehicle prior to the accident.

The Louisiana Street crossing

There are five railroad crossings in or around downtown Rayville. Three of those crossings are located in the downtown area: the Julia Street crossing, the Louisa Street crossing and the Louisiana Street crossing. The Julia Street crossing is equipped with lights and gates. The Louisa Street crossing, which is one block east of the Julia Street crossing, is also equipped with lights and gates.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Renfro v. Burlington Northern Santa Fe Railway Co.
193 So. 3d 1192 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2016)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
764 So. 2d 1194, 2000 La. App. LEXIS 1687, 2000 WL 792510, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/plank-v-town-of-rayville-lactapp-2000.