Phillips v. LAFAYETTE CITY-PARISH CONSOL. GOVERNMENT

995 So. 2d 1190, 2008 La. LEXIS 2750, 2008 WL 5146644
CourtSupreme Court of Louisiana
DecidedDecember 2, 2008
Docket2008-CA-0922, 2008-CA-1253
StatusPublished

This text of 995 So. 2d 1190 (Phillips v. LAFAYETTE CITY-PARISH CONSOL. GOVERNMENT) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Louisiana primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Phillips v. LAFAYETTE CITY-PARISH CONSOL. GOVERNMENT, 995 So. 2d 1190, 2008 La. LEXIS 2750, 2008 WL 5146644 (La. 2008).

Opinion

995 So.2d 1190 (2008)

George PHILLIPS, Jr.
v.
LAFAYETTE CITY-PARISH CONSOLIDATED GOVERNMENT.

Nos. 2008-CA-0922, 2008-CA-1253.

Supreme Court of Louisiana.

December 2, 2008.

*1191 Mahtook & Lafleur, Kay A. Theunissen, for applicant.

Anthony Fazzio, Lafayette, for appellee.

TRAYLOR, Justice.

In this matter, the trial court granted summary judgment finding that several sections of the Code of Ordinances promulgated by the Lafayette City-Parish Consolidated Government, known collectively as the "junked vehicle ordinance," are unconstitutional on their face and as applied. This case comes before us on direct appeal, pursuant to La. Const. art. 5, Section 5(D).[1] For the reasons that follow, we reverse and set aside the trial court's judgment, finding that the trial court did not first determine whether this case may be disposed of on non-constitutional grounds before reaching the constitutional issue.

SECTIONS OF THE CODE OF ORDINANCES AT ISSUE

The Lafayette City-Parish Consolidated Government ("Lafayette") declared the presence of junked or abandoned motor vehicles, on public or private property, to be a public nuisance in 1997. Since that time, both the definition of a junked motor vehicle and the procedures for abatement of the public nuisance have been amended several times.[2] The specific sections of the Lafayette's Code of Ordinances applicable here are set forth below.

A "junked motor vehicle" is defined in Section 34-31:

*1192 Junked motor vehicle means any motor vehicle, the condition of which is one or more of the following:
(1) Wrecked;
(2) Dismantled;
(3) Partially dismantled; or
(4) Lawfully inoperable on public streets under the provisions of the various statutes and ordinances applicable in this jurisdiction as a result of significant damage, decay or destruction.
The fact that a motor vehicle is being stored or otherwise maintained for spare parts for the repair of any other motor vehicle or motor vehicles shall not exempt such vehicle from being determined to be a junked motor vehicle if it otherwise meets any of the conditions set forth hereinabove.
Junked motor vehicle does not include:
(1) Any motor vehicle in operable condition specifically adapted or constructed for racing or operation on privately owned drag strips or raceways, which is maintained or kept on private property.
(2) Any motor vehicle which is stored under a carport or in a garage.[3]

The section declaring the presence of a junked motor vehicle to be a public nuisance is addressed in Section 34-76:

Section 34-76. Declaration of public nuisance.
The presence of any junked motor vehicle and/or abandoned motor vehicle within the City-Parish shall be deemed and is hereby declared a public nuisance; and it shall be unlawful for any person to cause or maintain such a public nuisance by abandoning, wrecking, dismantling, partially dismantling, rendering inoperable, or discarding any motor vehicle on the real property of another or on public property or to suffer, permit, and allow any junked motor vehicle and/or abandoned vehicle to be parked, left, or maintained on his own real property, provided that this section shall not apply with regard to:
(1) Any junked motor vehicle in an enclosed building, which for the purposes of this chapter shall be considered to include a carport attached to a residence;
(2) Any junked motor vehicle in an enclosed building, which for the purposes of this chapter shall be considered to include a carport attached and/or free standing or detached from a residence; or
(3) Any junked motor vehicle in an appropriate storage place or depository maintained at a location where such business is authorized under the comprehensive zoning ordinance and other regulatory ordinances of [Lafayette].[4]

The authority to seize junked motor vehicles is set forth in Section 34-77:

Section 34-77. Seizure of junked motor vehicles and/or abandoned motor vehicles.
[Lafayette], through its duly authorized representative, may seize or otherwise hold any junked motor vehicle and/or abandoned motor vehicle which is found to be in violation of this ordinance. The owner thereof shall be entitled to regain possession upon the payment of such costs as may be fixed by the policing authority for the violation. The costs so fixed shall cover all charges for removing the vehicle to the place of *1193 holding as well as all other costs incurred during the period of holding.[5]

Lafayette provides for the notification to owners of junked motor vehicles of the declaration of a public nuisance and abatement procedures in Section 34-7[8]:[6]

Section 34-78. Notification of Owners.
A. Whenever any motor vehicle is determined to be a junked motor vehicle and/or an abandoned motor vehicle, [Lafayette], through its representative, shall cause a notice to be placed on the vehicle itself or given to the owner of the vehicle, if known, advising that the vehicle shall be removed within fifteen days after notice. If the vehicle is not removed pursuant to the notice, the vehicle may be removed by [Lafayette] and disposed of in accordance with the provisions of Section 34-78 or 34-79, depending upon the condition of the vehicle. If the vehicle is owned by someone other than the owner of the premises upon which the vehicle is located, [Lafayette] shall further give notice to the owner of the premises by either certified mail or hand delivery. If notice by certified mail is returned "refused" or "unclaimed", notice shall be deemed to have been given.
B. [Lafayette] shall notify the owner of the premises and shall include in the notice posted on the vehicle that in lieu of removal, the owner of the premises and/or of the vehicle may remit the total amount charged for towing, together with a written letter of authority authorizing [Lafayette] to remove and dispose of the motor vehicle. The letter of authority shall be on a form prescribed and furnished by [Lafayette]. In the event that anyone other than the person determined to be the owner of the vehicle grants authority for removal of the vehicle and pays the fees for same, removal shall not take place until the fifteen day delay accorded the owner of the vehicle has expired in order to permit the vehicle owner to remove same at his expense. The owner of the property, the occupant thereof in instances where same is not the owner and the occupant has been given notice in accordance with this ordinance, and the owner of the vehicle are each responsible for removal of same equally, and [Lafayette] may choose to proceed against all or any one of the foregoing to compel removal of same.
C. If the motor vehicle is not removed within fifteen days from the date of the posting of the notice or authority and the fee given to [Lafayette] to remove same within said delays, the motor vehicle may be removed and disposed of by [Lafayette] in accordance with the provisions of Section 34-79 or 34-80, as applicable.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

In Re Pitre
630 So. 2d 700 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1994)
Williams v. State, Dept. of Health & Hospitals
671 So. 2d 899 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1996)
Benson & Gold Chev. v. La. Motor Veh. Com'n
403 So. 2d 13 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1981)
State v. Hatton
985 So. 2d 709 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 2008)
Phillips v. Lafayette City-Parish Consolidated Government
984 So. 2d 4 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 2008)
Cameron Parish School Bd. v. Acands, Inc.
687 So. 2d 84 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1997)
Louisiana Municipal Association v. State
893 So. 2d 809 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 2005)
State v. Citizen
898 So. 2d 325 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 2005)
Sims v. Mulhearn Funeral Home, Inc.
956 So. 2d 583 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 2007)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
995 So. 2d 1190, 2008 La. LEXIS 2750, 2008 WL 5146644, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/phillips-v-lafayette-city-parish-consol-government-la-2008.