Phillips Petroleum Co. v. Stack

231 So. 2d 475, 35 Oil & Gas Rep. 70, 1969 Miss. LEXIS 1263
CourtMississippi Supreme Court
DecidedDecember 22, 1969
DocketNo. 45501
StatusPublished
Cited by4 cases

This text of 231 So. 2d 475 (Phillips Petroleum Co. v. Stack) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Mississippi Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Phillips Petroleum Co. v. Stack, 231 So. 2d 475, 35 Oil & Gas Rep. 70, 1969 Miss. LEXIS 1263 (Mich. 1969).

Opinion

ROBERTSON, Justice:

This appeal involves a determination of whether a farm-out letter dated December 10, 1959, which was signed and agreed to by Phillips Petroleum Company, Shreveport, Louisiana, appellant, and J. E. Stack, Jr., one of the appellees, was merged into md superseded by an assignment of oil and gas leases dated December 11, 1959, also signed and executed by both Phillips and Stack, or whether both instruments together constituted the contract between the parties.

After both sides had rested, the Chancery Court of Clarke County sustained a motion to exclude the evidence and dis[476]*476miss the bill of complaint. The chancellor’s reasoning was:

“[T]hat this Court feels that under the law of merger, that in the absence of mistake or fraud there was in fact a merger, and the only instrument capable of and actually conveying any rights was the assignment of December 11, 1959. The Court feels that the intent of the parties as shown by their actions clearly justifies the Court in finding that both of the parties did in fact not intend for all the conditions of the farm-out letter to be in full force and effect. And since the assignment in no way mentions extensions or renewals, the Court feels that there can be and is no equity shown on the face of the Bill.”

The farm-out letter of December 10, 1959, recites:

“Mr. J. E. Stack
P. O. Box 1023
Meridian, Mississippi
Dear Sir:
“This letter is written for the purpose of evidencing and confirming an agreement between you and Phillips Petroleum Company, as follows, to-wit:
“Phillips Petroleum Company now owns certain valid and subsisting oil and gas leases covering all of Section 9, less and except the W/2 NW/4 and Northwest 11 acres out of the SE/4 NW/4; all of Section 10, less and except the S/2 SE/4 NE/4; S/2 and SW/4 NW/4 and N/2 SE/4 NW/4 of Section 11;' N/2 NE/4 Section 15, all in Township 2 North, Range 16 East, Clarke County, Mississippi.
“Phillips Petroleum Company is desirous of having said leases tested for oil and/or gas. Now, therefore, in consideration of the mutual advantages to J. E. Stack and Phillips Petroleum Company, such parties agree as follows:
“J. E. Stack will on or before January 31, 1960, commence actual drilling of a 4100 foot Eutaw wildcat exploratory well to be drilled in the S/2 of Section 11-2N-16E, Clarke County, Mississippi, and drill a second well to the stratigraphic equivalent depth of first well or production at a lesser depth, within ninety (90) days after completion of first well, at a location on the assigned acreage. In consideration of J. E. Stack drilling said wells, Phillips Petroleum Company, upon receipt of an executed copy of this letter, will assign J. B. Stack, without representation or warranty of title, either expressed or implied, their oil and gas leasehold interest on the above described land retaining unto themselves a % of Vs ORRI on all production from gas wells and % of % ORRI on all production of 30 barrels or more of oil per day per well and/or He of % ORRI on all production of less than 30 barrels of oil per day per well attributable to the interest assigned, calculated on a calendar month basis.
“All interests, reservations and rights of Phillips in and to the lands above described and the production therefrom provided for in this agreement shall extend not only to the oil and gas lease (or leases) to be assigned, but also to any and all extensions or renewals of said oil and gas lease (or leases) which may be acquired by I. B. Stack. The term ‘extensions’ of the aforesaid oil and gas lease (or leases) as used herein shall be deemed to include, but not by way of limitation, any agreement or agreements of whatsoever character acquired by J. E. Stack or his assigns under and by virtue of which said oil and gas lease (or leases) is continued in force. The term ‘renewals’ of the aforesaid oil and gas lease (or leases) as used herein shall be deemed to include, but not. by way of limitation, any lease or leases acquired by J. E. Stack or his assigns on all or any part of the lands above described within twelve (12) months from the date of termination or expiration of said lease (or leases) or any extensions or renewals [477]*477thereof. J. B. Stack agrees to execute such further grants and assurances■ as may be requisite to vest in Phillips under any such extensions or renewals the same rights and interest in and to the lands above described and the production therefrom as are reserved by or granted to. Phillips under the provisions of this agreement.
“J. E. Stack further agrees that he will reimburse Phillips Petroleum Company for all delay rentals paid on his behalf after November 1, 1959, and that after the aforementioned assignment has been made, you will make all future delay rental payments. If, after completion of the two above mentioned wells, J. E. Stack does not desire to keep the subject oil and gas leases in force and effect by payment of delay rentals, he shall then so notify Phillips in writing at least thirty (30) days prior to the rental payment date given in such lease or leases. Phillips shall have fifteen (15) days after receipt thereof within which to elect to receive a re-assignment of said lease. If Phillips elects not to accept a re-assignment within said time, J. E. Stack agrees to promptly release of record the affected lease or leases insofar as they cover the assigned acreage.
“On all wells drilled on the assigned acreage, representatives of this Company shall be given access to the derrick floor and shall be given all information regarding cuttings, cores, drilling depths and other information which they may desire and upon completion of any such well you shall furnish us with copies of all logs made in connection with the drilling thereof, which shall include drillers’ logs, all electrical logs and any other logs containing information desired by this Company.
“Unless this agreement is accepted by you and two copies thereof returned to the undersigned at the above address within ten (10) days from the above date, then and thereupon the agreement, at our option, shall be null and void. (Emphasis added).
Very truly yours,
PHILLIPS PETROLEUM COMPANY
By s/H. J. Tyler H. J. Tyler Division Manager
HJT:LGT:vw
Accepted This 15th D.ay of December 1959.
s/J. E. Stack”

The assignment of oil and gas leases of December 11, 1959, is as follows:

“ASSIGNMENT OF OIL AND GAS LEASES
“THIS ASSIGNMENT, made and entered into this 11th day of December 1959, by and between PHILLIPS PETROLEUM COMPANY, a Delaware corporation with an operating office at Bartlesville, Oklahoma, hereinafter referred to as ‘Assignor’, and J. E. STACK, Meridian, Mississippi, hereinafter referred to as ‘Assignee’,
WITNESSETH:
“THAT, Assignor is the owner of certain oil and gas leases covering certain.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Baptist Memorial Hospital—Desoto, Inc. v. Crain Automotive, Inc.
457 F. Supp. 2d 702 (N.D. Mississippi, 2006)
Ferrara v. Walters
919 So. 2d 876 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2005)
Christopher A. Ferrara v. Nancy S. Walters
Mississippi Supreme Court, 2003
Eland Energy, Inc. v. Rowden Oil & Gas, Inc.
914 S.W.2d 179 (Court of Appeals of Texas, 1996)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
231 So. 2d 475, 35 Oil & Gas Rep. 70, 1969 Miss. LEXIS 1263, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/phillips-petroleum-co-v-stack-miss-1969.