Peshtigo Co. v. Great Western Telegraph Co.

50 Ill. App. 624, 1893 Ill. App. LEXIS 491

Opinion

Opinion of the Court,

Gary, J.

The appellant is a corporation, under a Wisconsin charter, to conduct a lumber business. We need not go into particulars as to its character further than to say that there is in it nothing having the remotest allusion to doing a telegraph business, or buying or subscribing for shares in a telegraph company.

Unless ultra vires has ceased to be a defense under any and all circumstances, it is a good defense here for the Peshtigo Company, sued upon an assessment upon shares subscribed for by it. The fact that the court made the assessment upon all stockholders as a class, does not charge the appellant, if it was not a stockholder; and if it be legally incapable of being a stockholder by subscription for shares, then it is not a stockholder.

See the argument and authorities in People v. Chicago Gas Trust Co., 130 Ill. 268, at p. 283, et seq.

The ease having been tried by the court without a jury, final judgment will be entered here for the Peshtigo Company upon a finding of the facts. The judgment of the Circuit Court is reversed.