People v. Gorsuch

310 N.E.2d 695, 19 Ill. App. 3d 60
CourtAppellate Court of Illinois
DecidedMay 2, 1974
Docket71-177
StatusPublished
Cited by4 cases

This text of 310 N.E.2d 695 (People v. Gorsuch) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Appellate Court of Illinois primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
People v. Gorsuch, 310 N.E.2d 695, 19 Ill. App. 3d 60 (Ill. Ct. App. 1974).

Opinion

Mr. JUSTICE DIXON

delivered the opinion of the court:

After juvenile proceedings the defendant, Todd B. Gorsuch, was indicted for the minders of his sister, Theresa Gorsuch and her friend Rebecca Staley. A jury returned verdicts of guilty on both counts and on June 1, 1971, the defendant was sentenced by the Circuit Court of Peoria County to concurrent terms of not less than 25 nor more than 60 years. He appeals.

The contentions raised are:

1. That he was not proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.

2. That the trial court erred in not determining competency of an 11-year-old prosecution witness even though no objection was raised at trial.

3. That the trial court erred in denying defendant’s motion to suppress an exhibit.

4. That the former section of the Juvenile Court Act which allows a child to be prosecuted as an adult is unconstitutional.

5. That the sentences are excessive.

Around 3 P.M. on the afternoon of October 3, 1970, the defendant, then aged 14, left the Gorsuch home to go into a nearby woods. He was accompanied by his younger brother and sister, Tim and Theresa and two neighbor children, Ed and Rebecca Staley. The defendant was carrying a .410-gauge shotgun and ammunition for the weapon.'

The five children remained together until they arrived at a place in the woods called Suds Falls, a pond with a waterfall effect. The two girls and the defendant went on from there to pick up hickory nuts. Tim and Ed remained at the falls for 15 or 20 minutes and then went back to the Gorsuch home.

After they returned, the defendant came home without his sister, Theresa, or Rebecca Staley.

The two girls failed to return by early evening and so members of both families, a sheriffs group and volunteers formed a search party to look for them. The bodies of the two girls were found in the woods in the southeast corner of the Gorsuch property and, after an autopsy, were found to have been killed by shots to the heart from a .410-gauge shotgun.

On October 4, 1970, the sheriff of Peoria County asked to inspect the .410-gauge shotgun in the Gorsuch house, to have it shot and compared with markings on the shells found at the crime scene to eliminate any of the Gorsuch guns from the gun that may have murdered the girls. One of the sheriffs deputies, after inspecting the muzzle of the gun carried into the woods by defendant noticed a red substance inside the barrel which later testing proved to be human group B blood with fibers mixed in it. Theresa Gorsuch’s blood was group B. An expert gave opinion that the fibers were similar to fibers from Theresa’s T-shirt. The defendant was arrested for the murders of Theresa Gorsuch and Rebecca Staley.

A lengthy juvenile detention hearing was held and the judge found that probable cause existed that the defendant had committed the crime for which he was detained. On petition of the State’s Attorney the defendant was removed from the jurisdiction of the juvenile court to be prosecuted as an adult by indictments for two counts each of murder and involuntary manslaughter.

The defendant was tried before a jury on the indictments. Prior to trial, defendant moved to suppress the .410 shotgun basing his motion on an alleged and illegal seizure by the sheriff of this weapon. A hearing was had on the motion, and after hearing the evidence on both sides, the court denied the motion to suppress.

At the trial, Ed Staley, age 11, brother of Rebecca Staley, testified that Theresa Gorsuch, Tim Gorsuch, his sister and he left the Staley home to go to Suds Falls and in order to get there went first to the Gorsuch home where they met the defendant. At that time, the defendant had the .410-gauge Steven’s single shotgun, which was admitted into evidence as People’s Exhibit 9. The defendant was about to go with the other four children into the woods behind the Gorsuch home to. Suds Falls when Ed stated that he was forbidden by his parents to go with Todd if he had the shotgun. For this reason, Todd disassembled the .410-gauge shotgun and the five children left the Gorsuch home together. The children then proceeded, for the most part in each other’s company, until they reached a hill near Suds Falls which is on the property east of the Gorsuch property, belonging to a Mr. Kirkpatrick. At this point the children separated, Tim and Ed going to Suds Falls and the defendant, Theresa Gorsuch, and Rebecca Staley staying on the hill to rest. After playing at Suds Falls, Tim and Ed left and went tó the Gorsuch home. Ed testified the last time he saw the girls alive was ’ on the hill near Suds Falls in the company of the defendant, who still had the disassembled .410-gauge shotgun. Tim and Ed then proceeded to the Gorsuch house and played with their puppy. Ed testified that, when the pup relieved itself on the floor, Mrs. Gorsuch told Tim to clean up the mess, which he did, and the two of them then left the house where they saw the defendant for the first time since coming back from the woods. Ed Staley estimated that about 15 minutes had passed since he and Tim arrived at the house till the time they went out and saw Todd in the yard. This had been the first time that they had seen him since leaving him at the hill with Theresa Gorsuch and Rebecca Staley. Ed testified that when they saw Todd he was on the lawn ihower in the yard, but did not remember whether he was mowing at that time. He did not see People’s Exhibit 9 at that time. Ed further testified that he did riot remember hearing any shots until that time. In fact there is no record that Ed heard any shots the whole day, Tim spoke briefly to Todd when they saw him and then he and Ed left the Gorsuch house and went to the Staley’s.

The' People also called as a witness one Eugene Ely, who testified that he was combining in the field directly south of the Gorsuch property on October 3, 1970, from 10 A.M. to 5 P.M. Mr. Ely stated that he also did not hear any shots at any time during which he was there that day. His combine was quite loud when operating.

Eemard Kennedy, sheriff of Peoria County, testified that' he .arrived at the Gorsuch home that evening to direct the search for the two girls. Their bodies were found about midnight. Sheriff Kennedy went to the place where the bodies were found on the Gorsuch property and rioticed they were partially covered by some brush and appeared to háve been dragged to the place where "they were found. Sheriff Kennedy then - called Robert Dubois from the State Crime Laboratory and the Coroner before he left the Gorsuch property. The next time Sheriff Kennedy arrived at the Gorsuch property was about 10:30 A.M. on October 4, 1970. He briefly visited the place where the bodies were found and it was pointed out to him by certain sheriff’s deputies that three shotgun shells had been found. Sheriff Kennedy went then to the Gorsuch home and the defendant stated that those were his shells, that he had shot at a squirrel and missed. The Sheriff then returned to the Gorsuch home and told Ronald Gorsuch, the defendant’s father, that he would like to have the Gorsuch weapons to test fire them to see if there were any shells that had been found that were fired from a gun that was not one belonging to the Gorsuch family.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

People v. Wheeler
408 N.E.2d 424 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 1980)
People v. Torres
361 N.E.2d 803 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 1977)
People v. Robinson
361 N.E.2d 759 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 1977)
People v. Stanley
358 N.E.2d 69 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 1976)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
310 N.E.2d 695, 19 Ill. App. 3d 60, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/people-v-gorsuch-illappct-1974.