Pena, Allen

CourtTexas Supreme Court
DecidedJanuary 20, 2015
DocketWR-81,352-02
StatusPublished

This text of Pena, Allen (Pena, Allen) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Texas Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Pena, Allen, (Tex. 2015).

Opinion

_..

"tC!...0-.'A··1!'lo1; \~JZ.-~\. ·~st-o~.], ~~,')-~\{_h 1:-rl~.)'R DC.,oMZ.-\-J C'.,'\1S~ r--\o1.:. \\-trz., ~~~~-~ !2-1.1; \\\\~~ )0~1\l'A.

\f.

1 1 1 1: +nc flC-H•onRR- stnk~. -ltTRII-\hfull.l'"-1)E. - HRs'' - (E){c.(l,\lk(\1 ~1\i\lc. ''lr (',_~ /.C..\¥\)lY\1 111 _

T \' •II .~o : "\\ . "'r _, J~ 'f~K,., _}- .. PYI\\ 1 YT "' ~- . ,. . , , T Y1 .\ '" ,,, l ,~ ' ., '" ..... . .... -~ o -'ll\OI -lRK.t-\dR,R.. ~.1\YE' 'f'R-1.li\o'fi£R ··lt\l\t~'A~1 RF:,\'t~f] __ . t ~o\1\o II\ -1C'tAtl\0-t 1 -.. t~ , . ·-I~ f'll ~ )t't\lf:.~)i 1l m·, ss ., oT\1 -- . \Jio \ l\\ if\~\~ l~h~ , , \Jn'l-\R d S·t'f\1~~ 0

\l~o-1\S-h 4\ltto't\] ... 't\n~''' - {-\-h\l ~ ' ' ·- '[ ~o\l\~w -~\·,~i'"C..t1 '''l~ f~.f'\ ~0.,-\-'''- T ¥\r..C~ 'AC.t ''1 : +h'A-1-'' __ . ·,s'" : \(i\\~~'A\1. . . ~ v

'[~-1- '\tvr\CRR''\ -\:h~_''' -{1-A·!)l\-\'!~~l.-\lrt<-~Q.L?~n-n ~~ ~JZ;'IiHS \f. ~\JC-R') ~ 4(,9 \l.S.. '3~,7: ){)~ \\ Q.~.

( l\f'fll~\\lr\-~l rRo~K,~(ftf)~~J ... fo1Z''' ~ l\~"R-ff~(\.t\~~l~o\)Y\SR-n of'''-~ \tllrfR,li\1 .... \)~~RR. -'(tht i:o\l\- o\--f'l"lll~) ~t>?K.~\ -lQ\iXJ\Ion1--- ol'>l'\S'A1~'" -lt\l\\)~'li~\ V\\fZ\t] ~0.].

\[:!JJ l11-tK- t'"R-t\*ion£R. ·~s in -1\:J·h~ '" fv2n::JZ.l\\ ~o\l{Z.t& o\ -~ \ Ttlt. \ln·,~RQ &t'At~~ b',.~-\R·,t+ Q,o~rz-{ ttoR'''\}-h£''' ~o\l-\nRl<..A \J·,~tlZ\Q.~ -lo:\''' ~ {IF-~fl[\ C,oRf~~ C).\lZ\~t"~ D'l'~i~·toAI ·JlCi~·~\l-· ,~ / ltl\~~l Ao ."1 ~ 1.·. \~-e.~- oD~34 _. twnc-1~\Jc,Hl_: t ~T~\t·\a'f\-h.-.J"£-1 rKI)tR.}S(f,Y\~ '''l_ . _·,s'''- in{~c.-L l0..\-\ 'f\ \\ICI'l'{},.in~ -~-\h~ &'i\'('V\);_''' -1: 4..Ro\ln os.l :, ~'f\\~ ,,, ,,~o·vRt l \o'" -\H f\~'£1 ''''-lr~of--lZF.t... 111 111 -1&\to\l t IZ ~ \t~ \'ill-_. I 0 111 ~ ~ 0 ~""'A+ 111 ·-. t ~ \~~\ ·,A~ t!ZR.&-\- o·f ill J~Sil S,ti tK-1 ~ )\n ~ ,,,_ { E~ \) 'f\ ~~ 'R) ELH 1!)l -.. nm \\'' -- tt./)\\t\\'\\)~ ---\o\' ~ ( flKK.'·.J'\\1 \1 . . . j((~\R.R.~ -l.piKtl~£ 111 - ·,~{olZm ·, \h~ rRltt'!o)\'t'fZ _ .. o\'''- llilll- )!:J'vr

-sj\'M'i.~ \1. 'f\\l~o \lll.r\ i ~ \) .~ -~-t n4~J~~tC-ut~a o)\ ~ 1- ,4- 1s. 2._\o\ 'fffi. ~~9 N. T.o·\~1\ '9l\IZK;Itx~ l{(h6l r·c./Jvt'-J A' t.~,'n~'!Y\~ \ t\ffK,I\\& 1/ .. ]\_ nf' ~~'J-.1\S. . ~~

\'l\R.h:, !;;)(. [l-.C-.t\lAo.l·.wK.-tl.t,-s~-o~.J, 1 · iHIRn ~n'A TLrrz:,f\ \j C,o\)lt+ ~ft'l\SF-- ~~ ·1·. ·n-CR- !,SS7- b till J

\V~~oh·"'" '\'oR\\,~\tJ;:.fl {R.om t'A.U ~-l] 'I(_

-r~R. S-\:11-\-£ of' \l~.:~~~ ~)\\O~'mR-'n~ 'f\Y\~ oR~K,R_ j _:_ : '"a?-_"' .

oRaL~,, of ' 11 't)\IJ~~'W\~ n~· Jl,i=R~ -lZ_. td- V, G:,o~~ ltl. t~ru.hr~~y.:,"'!~"'t\h.Rh~~ -~l\c.+~'- ·,s~~~s'' 1, . ..)

"[~_J t·t r-1 '" -~~ +~,,, - \\J..'l\lSo~~) - &2~h~o\' '.·;~~"lit 'f\~1J ~ t ·~l, \T F-. · 1 \:'' \"-_:~ liRhI tic.- i : -\-\1_:-' of\ '' pK-t-~ -t·~o)\t,JZ>\lCJfv · "' ...., l 'fll

"[~ ~~Lt\lh.& - 1\...~~\)-\-·hn~ J, -tn~ '' ?_1<-.'R.S.\I'f'fl?\::ol\ of' ~ )..~.olt.~CH..r-l:s~ ~ , ·, _t\~·'' ~t=.J:;~];~~tt~:~~ hJ --· t '\\Q~\I't\\-'R.\'\'" ·- lR~\1-\-m~ '"- ~ ~[~·· -l-4.l?..~\lll~~· - )l\o 1" ~'-h;Q.{- '-\.C.l~Br<..'' ~ 'tlnd (orrvinln~ - • ]t <;~'"",~~ ~ ,f:- \l~,:y,,l• -i: ~<'.onS\i\>l\·:1'\11~ ~ l ~\11in ~ R.R.R.~R~1 ; t"l1i\:' -I~IlCX'' --lmK"RRl{~ 1: fOln-\s. o\l '-l- . ~~~\lt~1- f~fhrm1K-l2.-ltol2.~ ·- lL~oA ·-\t~F--~\1 \-\' _-·of ..:\L\tr-l ·- tlllu1'A \( ·~t~s1R'fHY\+1· ~ rm~ - 1 .1Cii]'" ~ \C t,o \~-t-, or!l--· o.f''' ~! ~~t&jnn·\'l'f\ 'J,,,Rt~\\-\:~.- .. 1\l\~~'-l\'~rz{~~i n\oR~''' -lsvC."''' ~ lb:rhnnl;t:RR.o~ l);fO~. ' ' ·-t_·,~ff\0-t] ~ t·d\R~l\ \j'~Ct~ i- \ -\-hl\t . -· '1\R~ ·- t t-JJ2...o~0,~\Jil\) -f~ ·,\\~~)1 \1 \J' - (offlZL~S. i)'){, '''- t.t\w.'''- r rt+ttlonK-1Z'' -\i)m~'''- Is.\)c.~1 ·- }:R~~\~0.-\~''' ... t\\1 ::~~ f(~j ..:,,~~r-\ }R.)l--- ~~~ ~ 'lTHr.:,''' \l)lih.~ ~'Bh.s -·· \l.C.o.~~+A\l·hor.l], }\no"'-'i,J)~~~1- t~\\o'''- o~· ... thv~ -1,..\)'\~~\~\~ -tC:.o·n~+·AvtK:~~ ~t\'\1 ~12:1\~Y - \( ~ W\'!&0-'ARKXli~R.j ~. 1 .... of' , ~ ¥l I :( Ill 'J\lS-r\t~l _/ 1\ \\\ V ''' 1' · 1 !' 1\ ;1 .....lNWI·\'l~..,..\\ - )~\S. - "'INt\tl:-i ~ ·- \{ ('). c.\ ~ "-~';:) _ 1111o \)\I· -Nl \I' - \I· l \ ll,..'~"'o 111 1· 111-J - ~n ~ l: \~o~R'li\1-~~nO'f\11\LY\-\'AQ- lto~~·h~\l~\o)l~\1 ~ l ~~"'-olZl -~ {'f\Y\~''' ~"{s\)C,\\j .... t\tt"lS-~'' -l-thr~''' ·\,oal\t~ '''- 1

t~VJC'!.-\-,or1] __ -\hn-\ •-\ -nzo<.\'\'"1- Y\~1\"t-\}<;R& .'. 11 t \'\\l\~1\1'1\!C'nh ~ ~it u..lfii\1ZY1JC~~ q_ I, _; - - . , I 't u~o..tt'' -thf."'f.j1,~ \~14] rKo~; ~lons] -t roR.&ul\f\5- ;ro" ~ t zt u. ~ (1.. ~ ~-s'l; 1\.d1• __ {~(.~ ~ 1: \-t'AlZJZ)r!fo-lh'1. tS.~K_:)t~~ \LS..C..~ ~2.S4_;lLJJ:\l · t&~K~ "t -1..~ \J.&.C.·. ~ 2.. ~S~ ~ 1: K:l. t :z.l JC~·1 . [Sn::; -~ lL i-\v:\)'vl"t\-\c·D \). sfv~\lL ~ot-\-W'AR~; 't,-..!C. _; ·z.:st f-3~; 41"3;. 41'? ! s*tt (l__iR_-ZoooJ]_ t 1 _; ~- t -\-h~''lC.\~'Ar?:'' ~ ~t2.KoTZ-~ --· o{ '" .Jt\\mo'fl'ffi~lYt'f\ ij -1\'dEr<.'t\ ~-l \Jl)C,o)l$,-\\\\)-\·,an'A ~ PvRRoR~1-- .. }tRr:". )II

1 il'i\'1\~-\ } ... l~-~~'(Jilt~~ ' ' jJm()"' -l-,~o~{KNd~a"- \ S.\l'£\\Q.\R. Y\~\\\''' ·-l1 ~ 0 K£h:.R ,. _..\o ' -\o~·hflY\ l- t 'A ~1~'- · 1 '

~lio~~v'A·h:."' ~ t \-\'AfbR.'t\S. (- {K'I(·,6~t.lti'AR~l ~~'fi_!Z-,n~ ( -tl-\\lo'' -\~ +nv.s ,., - t~m~,1z.d'\ 1" -\LR~f)f.C..+s '"·-l·thl1+ ' '_ -t l. s \n6''' ~ii{io)\f.R.'s "'- ~ ( ~~ll·,~s / .~,TZ.~.ilY\ ~s 1-: 'fi~F-"' ·-i:,r-\ f"A~+1 :''-\t YVI KR\to1t1o\l~\\~ 1' - {'f\~~ u'flhJ\\ 1'~- ..

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
Pena, Allen, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/pena-allen-tex-2015.