Pena, Allen

Texas Supreme Court

Pena, Allen

Texas Supreme Court·Decided January 20, 2015·No. WR-81,352-02·Published

Opinion

_..

"tC!...0-.'A··1!'lo1; \~JZ.-~\. ·~st-o~.], ~~,')-~\{_h 1:-rl~.)'R DC.,oMZ.-\-J C'.,'\1S~ r--\o1.:. \\-trz., ~~~~-~ !2-1.1; \\\\~~ )0~1\l'A.

\f.

1 1 1 1: +nc flC-H•onRR- stnk~. -ltTRII-\hfull.l'"-1)E. - HRs'' - (E){c.(l,\lk(\1 ~1\i\lc. ''lr (',_~ /.C..\¥\)lY\1 111 _

T \' •II .~o : "\\ . "'r _, J~ 'f~K,., _}- .. PYI\\ 1 YT "' ~- . ,. . , , T

Y1 .\ '" ,,, l ,~ ' ., '" ..... . ....

-~ o -'ll\OI -lRK.t-\dR,R.. ~.1\YE' 'f'R-1.li\o'fi£R ··lt\l\t~'A~1 RF:,\'t~f] __ .

t ~o\1\o II\ -1C'tAtl\0-t 1 -.. t~ , . ·-I~ f'll ~ )t't\lf:.~)i 1l m·, ss ., oT\1 -- . \Jio \ l\\ if\~\~ l~h~ , , \Jn'l-\R d S·t'f\1~~

0

\l~o-1\S-h 4\ltto't\] ... 't\n~''' - {-\-h\l ~ ' ' ·- '[ ~o\l\~w -~\·,~i'"C..t1 '''l~ f~.f'\ ~0.,-\-'''- T ¥\r..C~ 'AC.t ''1 : +h'A-1-'' __ . ·,s'" :

\(i\\~~'A\1. . . ~ v

'[~-1- '\tvr\CRR''\ -\:h~_''' -{1-A·!)l\-\'!~~l.-\lrt<-~Q.L?~n-n ~~ ~JZ;'IiHS \f. ~\JC-R') ~ 4(,9 \l.S.. '3~,7: ){)~ \\ Q.~. <b ·~o 't \'Vb ~ 1 _..1JI-IK. II' flR-hhon~R" -l.S.l-\o\) \o -t \ioK,~\Jt\1~\,\' -- '6~ '~ -1 lZ~'M'tH\Q~~ -·· lo 1 ~

( l\f'fll~\\lr\-~l rRo~K,~(ftf)~~J ... fo1Z''' ~ l\~"R-ff~(\.t\~~l~o\)Y\SR-n of'''-~ \tllrfR,li\1 .... \)~~RR. -'(tht i:o\l\- o\--f'l"lll~) ~t>?K.~\ -lQ\iXJ\Ion1--- ol'>l'\S'A1~'" -lt\l\\)~'li~\ V\\fZ\t] ~0.].

\[:!JJ l11-tK- t'"R-t\*ion£R. ·~s in -1\:J·h~ '" fv2n::JZ.l\\ ~o\l{Z.t& o\ -~ \ Ttlt. \ln·,~RQ &t'At~~ b',.~-\R·,t+ Q,o~rz-{ ttoR'''\}-h£''' ~o\l-\nRl<..A \J·,~tlZ\Q.~ -lo:\''' ~ {IF-~fl[\ C,oRf~~ C).\lZ\~t"~ D'l'~i~·toAI ·JlCi~·~\l-· ,~ / ltl\~~l Ao ."1 ~ 1.·. \~-e.~- oD~34 _. twnc-1~\Jc,Hl_: t ~T~\t·\a'f\-h.-.J"£-1 rKI)tR.}S(f,Y\~ '''l_ . _·,s'''- in{~c.-L l0..\-\ 'f\ \\ICI'l'{},.in~ -~-\h~ &'i\'('V\);_''' -1: 4..Ro\ln os.l :, ~'f\\~ ,,, ,,~o·vRt l \o'" -\H f\~'£1 ''''-lr~of--lZF.t...

111 111

-1&\to\l

t IZ ~ \t~ \'ill-_. I 0 111

~ ~ 0 ~""'A+

111

·-. t ~ \~~\ ·,A~ t!ZR.&-\- o·f ill J~Sil S,ti tK-1 ~ )\n ~ ,,,_ { E~ \) 'f\ ~~ 'R) ELH 1!)l -.. nm \\'' --

tt./)\\t\\'\\)~ ---\o\' ~ ( flKK.'·.J'\\1 \1 . . .

j((~\R.R.~ -l.piKtl~£ 111 - ·,~{olZm ·, \h~ rRltt'!o)\'t'fZ _ .. o\'''- llilll- )!:J'vr<JhR,IZ ,,, - L:i·!,l\+·,~"[ 111 111

.

I yYRoC-~~ 0 -. na& ''' - [C.ol\{l¥..Rf'li~Q. ·, s.w~a·~ tc:.. .Q. \{1 ~o. J _ , . .

11

VJZ~rr~Qx{.u \l\~ S\)tmt·\-iL~ t~~o'R~~ #~ )1[.,-u ?R..o of' of ~~R:~{t Q,K, tl H~1'-l f'K,l\ R R.l=:-\-\lltr-l ~RR~-,0-R To .0.,:0. ~o. 119oQ..I 1 '\.. ~ZJ:.1 \l'R~-t~o PR-kho~ R-1<. . ?·R.c SE ~

-sj\'M'i.~ \1. 'f\\l~o \lll.r\ i ~ \) .~ -~-t n4~J~~tC-ut~a o)\ ~ 1- ,4- 1s. 2._\o\ 'fffi. ~~9 N.

T.o·\~1\ '9l\IZK;Itx~ l{(h6l

r·c./Jvt'-J A' t.~,'n~'!Y\~ \ t\ffK,I\\& 1/ .. ]\_ nf' ~~'J-.1\S. . ~~

\'l\R.h:, !;;)(.

[l-.C-.t\lAo.l·.wK.-tl.t,-s~-o~.J, 1 · iHIRn ~n'A TLrrz:,f\ \j C,o\)lt+ ~ft'l\SF-- ~~ ·1·. ·n-CR- !,SS7- b till

J

\V~~oh·"'" '\'oR\\,~\tJ;:.fl {R.om t'A.U ~-l]

'I(_

-r~R. S-\:11-\-£ of' \l~.:~~~ ~)\\O~'mR-'n~ 'f\Y\~ oR~K,R_ j _:_ : '"a?-_"' .

oRaL~,, of '

11

't)\IJ~~'W\~ n~· Jl,i=R~ -lZ_. td- V, G:,o~~ ltl. t~ru.hr~~y.:,"'!~"'t\h.Rh~~ -~l\c.+~'- ·,s~~~s'' 1, . ..)

"[~_J t·t r-1 '" -~~ +~,,, - \\J..'l\lSo~~) - &2~h~o\' '.·;~~"lit 'f\~1J ~ t ·~l, \T

F-.

· 1 \:''

\"-_:~ liRhI tic.- i : -\-\1_:-'

of\ '' pK-t-~ -t·~o)\t,JZ>\lCJfv · "' ...., l 'fll<J \~ -

111

"[~ ~~Lt\lh.& - 1\...~~\)-\-·hn~ J, -tn~ '' ?_1<-.'R.S.\I'f'fl?\::ol\ of' ~ )..~.olt.~CH..r-l:s~ ~ , ·, _t\~·'' ~t=.J:;~];~~tt~:~~ hJ --· t '\\Q~\I't\\-'R.\'\'" ·- lR~\1-\-m~ '"- ~ ~[~·· -l-4.l?..~\lll~~· - )l\o 1" ~'-h;Q.{- '-\.C.l~Br<..'' ~ 'tlnd (orrvinln~ - • ]t <;~'"",~~ ~ ,f:-

\l~,:y,,l• -i: ~<'.onS\i\>l\·:1'\11~ ~ l ~\11in ~ R.R.R.~R~1 ; t"l1i\:' -I~IlCX'' --lmK"RRl{~ 1: fOln-\s. o\l '-l- . ~~~\lt~1- f~fhrm1K-l2.-ltol2.~ ·- lL~oA ·-\t~F--~\1 \-\' _-·of ..:\L\tr-l ·- tlllu1'A \( ·~t~s1R'fHY\+1· ~ rm~ -

1

.1Cii]'" ~ \C t,o \~-t-, or!l--· o.f''' ~! ~~t&jnn·\'l'f\ 'J,,,Rt~\\-\:~.- .. 1\l\~~'-l\'~rz{~~i n\oR~''' -lsvC."''' ~ lb:rhnnl;t:RR.o~ l);fO~. ' ' ·-t_·,~ff\0-t] ~ t·d\R~l\ \j'~Ct~ i- \ -\-hl\t . -· '1\R~ ·- t t-JJ2...o~0,~\Jil\) -f~ ·,\\~~)1 \1 \J' - (offlZL~S. i)'){, '''- t.t\w.'''-

r rt+ttlonK-1Z'' -\i)m~'''- Is.\)c.~1 ·- }:R~~\~0.-\~''' ... t\\1 ::~~ f(~j ..:,,~~r-\ }R.)l--- ~~~ ~ 'lTHr.:,''' \l)lih.~ ~'Bh.s -·· \l.C.o.~~+A\l·hor.l], }\no"'-'i,J)~~~1- t~\\o'''- o~· ... thv~ -1,..\)'\~~\~\~ -tC:.o·n~+·AvtK:~~ ~t\'\1 ~12:1\~Y -

\( ~ W\'!&0-'ARKXli~R.j ~. 1

.... of' , ~ ¥l I :( Ill 'J\lS-r\t~l

_/ 1\ \\\ V ''' 1' · 1 !' 1\ ;1 .....lNWI·\'l~..,..\\ - )~\S. - "'INt\tl:-i ~ ·-

\{ ('). c.\ ~ "-~';:) _ 1111o

\)\I· -Nl \I'

-

\I· l \ ll,..'~"'o

111 1· 111-J

- ~n ~

l: \~o~R'li\1-~~nO'f\11\LY\-\'AQ- lto~~·h~\l~\o)l~\1 ~ l ~~"'-olZl -~ {'f\Y\~''' ~"{s\)C,\\j .... t\tt"lS-~'' -l-thr~''' ·\,oal\t~ '''-

1

t~VJC'!.-\-,or1] __ -\hn-\ •-\ -nzo<.\'\'"1- Y\~1\"t-\}<;R& .'. 11 t \'\\l\~1\1'1\!C'nh ~ ~it u..lfii\1ZY1JC~~ q_ I, _; - - . , I 't u~o..tt'' -thf."'f.j1,~ \~14] rKo~; ~lons] -t roR.&ul\f\5- ;ro" ~ t zt u. ~ (1.. ~ ~-s'l; 1\.d1• __ {~(.~ ~ 1: \-t'AlZJZ)r!<S.~o~ i · '12,)C..~·h:1Z ; \' \ ~. <:.. -T. l1 o ~ ·7 Cb ~ \.~a\\ 1 ; i '\ \lo±~w~1-/ ·n:.1<Y-J _ _; l \itllt\1\f/\ \\f. ~~~\oiZ'~, '$2.._~ \).s. 'b~~ ~ ~\'t "ktoool ~tz.~ \i.s..t.~vvs4 :- lo1.:111 ~{~~st1~<.olll. t~L"( ~ t KIC,Hh:.IZ / )'3\ s.. tt tl{iiCbro. r ls.~~~l- l?;\Q.\-l-\~lZ;, \'3\ ~.(-\-.tt\-\]14>fo-lh'1. tS.~K_:)t~~ \LS..C..~ ~2.S4_;lLJJ:\l · t&~K~ "t -1..~ \J.&.C.·. ~ 2.. ~S~ ~ 1: K:l. t :z.l JC~·1 . [Sn::; -~ lL i-\v:\)'vl"t\-\c·D \). sfv~\lL ~ot-\-W'AR~; 't,-..!C. _; ·z.:st f-3~; 41"3;. 41'? ! s*tt (l__iR_-ZoooJ]_ t 1 _; ~- t -\-h~''lC.\~'Ar?:'' ~ ~t2.KoTZ-~ --· o{ '" .Jt\\mo'fl'ffi~lYt'f\ ij -1\'dEr<.'t\ ~-l \Jl)C,o)l$,-\\\\)-\·,an'A ~ PvRRoR~1-- .. }tRr:".

)II

1 il'i\'1\~-\ } ... l~-~~'(Jilt~~ ' ' jJm()"' -l-,~o~{KNd~a"- \ S.\l'£\\Q.\R. Y\~\\\''' ·-l1 ~ 0 K£h:.R ,. _..\o ' -\o~·hflY\ l- t 'A ~1~'- · 1 '

~lio~~v'A·h:."' ~ t \-\'AfbR.'t\S. (- {K'I(·,6~t.lti'AR~l ~~'fi_!Z-,n~ ( -tl-\\lo'' -\~ +nv.s ,., - t~m~,1z.d'\ 1" -\LR~f)f.C..+s '"·-l·thl1+ ' '_ -t

l. s \n6''' ~ii{io)\f.R.'s "'- ~ ( ~~ll·,~s / .~,TZ.~.ilY\ ~s 1-: 'fi~F-"' ·-i:,r-\ f"A~+1 :''-\t YVI KR\to1t1o\l~\\~ 1' - {'f\~~ u'flhJ\\ 1'~- ..

1

l:~rz;T-1 \of(th] ___ )i-Arw-!' -ts\r,o' -t~'Af:)f-..'t\qWlZ\t1 ~ 'ft)IO"-tS.\lCJ\1 ...l:m~1~:~.\) 111 -I~o~~l<.n~-

\.

p~<.l.t,anRR•- t~<l~vllh::l 1''- ( nHrz;~ ~" j .; [)\ ~;;)lsanlle,i<.1-l fRoC<:<lvRiiy:

t+hB-\.- t Slifl'iC:liC ntl'\"'- t: a~fv/ZC.ow1K5j_:; ,; t -\-hf." -I d£f )I" I 1- r'-

.. . btl f.'' ll{l n& ''-

t f"\ fMS ]_- t pJto(l_jcQijrzll ~ S\1\'1;;' l!,vm<d Q .-_lin~·"-{svc~·-~s"- T.,Nfnctr. Ov" '" -"(To"'- FhE'' -[n;~eRK"'_

i

~ RrPRfZKeiU"~ '\tfnt« .. +h~t ··-I. s v'-'«1'"- t \'aRmu IHt!W1- I C.1R;ms]"' lt+h"' ...

~?10~' {, ~~ ~ :t,_;-lh:.ll_:-~-h~ Hj : -~ n!'in I ~G" -~Sa ~-\-; -i~eO U'\" ·1 n~"'{+t..~tvi'

(L,\1,,(1.)1 -lC 1Z. •-l: Hn&''

L ~"- t V1!'ili:~f -(l~llf.J ~ lLRw .l - It n~.:· _IwitH' -

j f'h 1 t R If' , Wold;

;~R.:~c_v \\1: i t~Siif vh:s::I '': l[_&VC'_H]'~t C.l"im~J - j!: I'\"-~ To - (!,f.rJ - ][., N - J +J - li<6 H of' - HhlC" itldJSYl h

IZ!:.~Vitmb ~ 11~'-- ~ f~ 11tHiS " -'( -'[ Qo;-lS+;i To ' l':i!O "'j__ SI!Yif hlf.I\F;I '\"-

)In~"- ~ 'SVIZolZ~ 'iR~<~Sonflt\TCY1JCS fhcN~ ( _-IL1 flto -[1!.( lU Etllhl .. -\-h ll-1' -).iS"- )\,.)IR,iS i fRom" - b<: fvn Ct fi¥1Ji:RS] l t ,)1<i>ll-\~:.l J"-- ot'" !Zovn~s oiZ" tol'" -ls vc_H]-1.{. C 1 __ q _. Ylnd'"- lf.:\-h VS" -l,RJc, '"- .. th\1t '"-[SuCH]"'_ ' _

~ 'l-faint;n~·-~ o~T] ·- HhL" -I~1'.1-~n~"-\);,~!lie+ .

ll~~]

• -'[is'" ·tmJO (ZF:I,\"

HOF:~un+ I~,. - t n Y\~1<, - {lo4iGnlIIufn"-+l II\ M .. +hAl-., , J _; f:lVll a1\m..Yl tn 1\ "' iZRo R s]--

illll

'' ~ bR~<" -t~M~(I,v -'j,_IZJCth-.1'.-\~~p/Zat(l<.t\in ~ ti\\Et-1\~€.]~Ch. 1 ... of"- b.-iT'.)t ~n\'~ir<l TRiA~.. nnJ'~-

IL s\1 {!,\\1 .·IL(Jta ",nM. / cl 'f\1 ]

_- " 1YI "'R !C \ '\' ·,.l )0 I'.H illS

tlJ1.1-hl\-\-

l&o" - l\.ll,.l" -I ijA'fl\1R._'i· h Pf '-I I fltE (

l'rvii..l,il£~ ~{ '3 viZ') l j J vR 1St} n~() •- oR ~ lHn(l.i}f;nO ER l--~ rl.v \~ " (H'~~ IZICol<l<.RJo 0 .. 1 . 1,~\IQ\j_j ;

iflll . . .,~ 'Ela\!,.iQ.~~)1 -{Rf-.fi~C'-t.s-- ~'h"' 'JLn•J~o-·1 1 -I~o7-1R£nsonA~I<;f- ~-h-lfn,f'J.lE~_l- ., ,,, 11\l \lwrL(\ ~1• 0T£

J 1 111 . . .

~LR.<l;l'.+]-tup~,Jj J~Hiil" -{ HHi>EliS},f'~<-il11aY1j , ,.'An~ R. ] •

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

_..

"tC!...0-.'A··1!'lo1; \~JZ.-~\. ·~st-o~.], ~~,')-~\{_h 1:-rl~.)'R DC.,oMZ.-\-J C'.,'\1S~ r--\o1.:. \\-trz., ~~~~-~ !2-1.1; \\\\~~ )0~1\l'A.

\f.

1 1 1 1: +nc flC-H•onRR- stnk~. -ltTRII-\hfull.l'"-1)E. - HRs'' - (E){c.(l,\lk(\1 ~1\i\lc. ''lr (',_~ /.C..\¥\)lY\1 111 _

T \' •II .~o : "\\ . "'r _, J~ 'f~K,., _}- .. PYI\\ 1 YT "' ~- . ,. . , , T

Y1 .\ '" ,,, l ,~ ' ., '" ..... . ....

-~ o -'ll\OI -lRK.t-\dR,R.. ~.1\YE' 'f'R-1.li\o'fi£R ··lt\l\t~'A~1 RF:,\'t~f] __ .

t ~o\1\o II\ -1C'tAtl\0-t 1 -.. t~ , . ·-I~ f'll ~ )t't\lf:.~)i 1l m·, ss ., oT\1 -- . \Jio \ l\\ if\~\~ l~h~ , , \Jn'l-\R d S·t'f\1~~

0

\l~o-1\S-h 4\ltto't\] ... 't\n~''' - {-\-h\l ~ ' ' ·- '[ ~o\l\~w -~\·,~i'"C..t1 '''l~ f~.f'\ ~0.,-\-'''- T ¥\r..C~ 'AC.t ''1 : +h'A-1-'' __ . ·,s'" :

\(i\\~~'A\1. . . ~ v

'[~-1- '\tvr\CRR''\ -\:h~_''' -{1-A·!)l\-\'!~~l.-\lrt<-~Q.L?~n-n ~~ ~JZ;'IiHS \f. ~\JC-R') ~ 4(,9 \l.S.. '3~,7: ){)~ \\ Q.~. <b ·~o 't \'Vb ~ 1 _..1JI-IK. II' flR-hhon~R" -l.S.l-\o\) \o -t \ioK,~\Jt\1~\,\' -- '6~ '~ -1 lZ~'M'tH\Q~~ -·· lo 1 ~

( l\f'fll~\\lr\-~l rRo~K,~(ftf)~~J ... fo1Z''' ~ l\~"R-ff~(\.t\~~l~o\)Y\SR-n of'''-~ \tllrfR,li\1 .... \)~~RR. -'(tht i:o\l\- o\--f'l"lll~) ~t>?K.~\ -lQ\iXJ\Ion1--- ol'>l'\S'A1~'" -lt\l\\)~'li~\ V\\fZ\t] ~0.].

\[:!JJ l11-tK- t'"R-t\*ion£R. ·~s in -1\:J·h~ '" fv2n::JZ.l\\ ~o\l{Z.t& o\ -~ \ Ttlt. \ln·,~RQ &t'At~~ b',.~-\R·,t+ Q,o~rz-{ ttoR'''\}-h£''' ~o\l-\nRl<..A \J·,~tlZ\Q.~ -lo:\''' ~ {IF-~fl[\ C,oRf~~ C).\lZ\~t"~ D'l'~i~·toAI ·JlCi~·~\l-· ,~ / ltl\~~l Ao ."1 ~ 1.·. \~-e.~- oD~34 _. twnc-1~\Jc,Hl_: t ~T~\t·\a'f\-h.-.J"£-1 rKI)tR.}S(f,Y\~ '''l_ . _·,s'''- in{~c.-L l0..\-\ 'f\ \\ICI'l'{},.in~ -~-\h~ &'i\'('V\);_''' -1: 4..Ro\ln os.l :, ~'f\\~ ,,, ,,~o·vRt l \o'" -\H f\~'£1 ''''-lr~of--lZF.t...

111 111

-1&\to\l

t IZ ~ \t~ \'ill-_. I 0 111

~ ~ 0 ~""'A+

111

·-. t ~ \~~\ ·,A~ t!ZR.&-\- o·f ill J~Sil S,ti tK-1 ~ )\n ~ ,,,_ { E~ \) 'f\ ~~ 'R) ELH 1!)l -.. nm \\'' --

tt./)\\t\\'\\)~ ---\o\' ~ ( flKK.'·.J'\\1 \1 . . .

j((~\R.R.~ -l.piKtl~£ 111 - ·,~{olZm ·, \h~ rRltt'!o)\'t'fZ _ .. o\'''- llilll- )!:J'vr<JhR,IZ ,,, - L:i·!,l\+·,~"[ 111 111

.

I yYRoC-~~ 0 -. na& ''' - [C.ol\{l¥..Rf'li~Q. ·, s.w~a·~ tc:.. .Q. \{1 ~o. J _ , . .

11

VJZ~rr~Qx{.u \l\~ S\)tmt·\-iL~ t~~o'R~~ #~ )1[.,-u ?R..o of' of ~~R:~{t Q,K, tl H~1'-l f'K,l\ R R.l=:-\-\lltr-l ~RR~-,0-R To .0.,:0. ~o. 119oQ..I 1 '\.. ~ZJ:.1 \l'R~-t~o PR-kho~ R-1<. . ?·R.c SE ~

-sj\'M'i.~ \1. 'f\\l~o \lll.r\ i ~ \) .~ -~-t n4~J~~tC-ut~a o)\ ~ 1- ,4- 1s. 2._\o\ 'fffi. ~~9 N.

T.o·\~1\ '9l\IZK;Itx~ l{(h6l

r·c./Jvt'-J A' t.~,'n~'!Y\~ \ t\ffK,I\\& 1/ .. ]\_ nf' ~~'J-.1\S. . ~~

\'l\R.h:, !;;)(.

[l-.C-.t\lAo.l·.wK.-tl.t,-s~-o~.J, 1 · iHIRn ~n'A TLrrz:,f\ \j C,o\)lt+ ~ft'l\SF-- ~~ ·1·. ·n-CR- !,SS7- b till

J

\V~~oh·"'" '\'oR\\,~\tJ;:.fl {R.om t'A.U ~-l]

'I(_

-r~R. S-\:11-\-£ of' \l~.:~~~ ~)\\O~'mR-'n~ 'f\Y\~ oR~K,R_ j _:_ : '"a?-_"' .

oRaL~,, of '

11

't)\IJ~~'W\~ n~· Jl,i=R~ -lZ_. td- V, G:,o~~ ltl. t~ru.hr~~y.:,"'!~"'t\h.Rh~~ -~l\c.+~'- ·,s~~~s'' 1, . ..)

"[~_J t·t r-1 '" -~~ +~,,, - \\J..'l\lSo~~) - &2~h~o\' '.·;~~"lit 'f\~1J ~ t ·~l, \T

F-.

· 1 \:''

\"-_:~ liRhI tic.- i : -\-\1_:-'

of\ '' pK-t-~ -t·~o)\t,JZ>\lCJfv · "' ...., l 'fll<J \~ -

111

"[~ ~~Lt\lh.& - 1\...~~\)-\-·hn~ J, -tn~ '' ?_1<-.'R.S.\I'f'fl?\::ol\ of' ~ )..~.olt.~CH..r-l:s~ ~ , ·, _t\~·'' ~t=.J:;~];~~tt~:~~ hJ --· t '\\Q~\I't\\-'R.\'\'" ·- lR~\1-\-m~ '"- ~ ~[~·· -l-4.l?..~\lll~~· - )l\o 1" ~'-h;Q.{- '-\.C.l~Br<..'' ~ 'tlnd (orrvinln~ - • ]t <;~'"",~~ ~ ,f:-

\l~,:y,,l• -i: ~<'.onS\i\>l\·:1'\11~ ~ l ~\11in ~ R.R.R.~R~1 ; t"l1i\:' -I~IlCX'' --lmK"RRl{~ 1: fOln-\s. o\l '-l- . ~~~\lt~1- f~fhrm1K-l2.-ltol2.~ ·- lL~oA ·-\t~F--~\1 \-\' _-·of ..:\L\tr-l ·- tlllu1'A \( ·~t~s1R'fHY\+1· ~ rm~ -

1

.1Cii]'" ~ \C t,o \~-t-, or!l--· o.f''' ~! ~~t&jnn·\'l'f\ 'J,,,Rt~\\-\:~.- .. 1\l\~~'-l\'~rz{~~i n\oR~''' -lsvC."''' ~ lb:rhnnl;t:RR.o~ l);fO~. ' ' ·-t_·,~ff\0-t] ~ t·d\R~l\ \j'~Ct~ i- \ -\-hl\t . -· '1\R~ ·- t t-JJ2...o~0,~\Jil\) -f~ ·,\\~~)1 \1 \J' - (offlZL~S. i)'){, '''- t.t\w.'''-

r rt+ttlonK-1Z'' -\i)m~'''- Is.\)c.~1 ·- }:R~~\~0.-\~''' ... t\\1 ::~~ f(~j ..:,,~~r-\ }R.)l--- ~~~ ~ 'lTHr.:,''' \l)lih.~ ~'Bh.s -·· \l.C.o.~~+A\l·hor.l], }\no"'-'i,J)~~~1- t~\\o'''- o~· ... thv~ -1,..\)'\~~\~\~ -tC:.o·n~+·AvtK:~~ ~t\'\1 ~12:1\~Y -

\( ~ W\'!&0-'ARKXli~R.j ~. 1

.... of' , ~ ¥l I :( Ill 'J\lS-r\t~l

_/ 1\ \\\ V ''' 1' · 1 !' 1\ ;1 .....lNWI·\'l~..,..\\ - )~\S. - "'INt\tl:-i ~ ·-

\{ ('). c.\ ~ "-~';:) _ 1111o

\)\I· -Nl \I'

-

\I· l \ ll,..'~"'o

111 1· 111-J

- ~n ~

l: \~o~R'li\1-~~nO'f\11\LY\-\'AQ- lto~~·h~\l~\o)l~\1 ~ l ~~"'-olZl -~ {'f\Y\~''' ~"{s\)C,\\j .... t\tt"lS-~'' -l-thr~''' ·\,oal\t~ '''-

1

t~VJC'!.-\-,or1] __ -\hn-\ •-\ -nzo<.\'\'"1- Y\~1\"t-\}<;R& .'. 11 t \'\\l\~1\1'1\!C'nh ~ ~it u..lfii\1ZY1JC~~ q_ I, _; - - . , I 't u~o..tt'' -thf."'f.j1,~ \~14] rKo~; ~lons] -t roR.&ul\f\5- ;ro" ~ t zt u. ~ (1.. ~ ~-s'l; 1\.d1• __ {~(.~ ~ 1: \-t'AlZJZ)r!<S.~o~ i · '12,)C..~·h:1Z ; \' \ ~. <:.. -T. l1 o ~ ·7 Cb ~ \.~a\\ 1 ; i '\ \lo±~w~1-/ ·n:.1<Y-J _ _; l \itllt\1\f/\ \\f. ~~~\oiZ'~, '$2.._~ \).s. 'b~~ ~ ~\'t "ktoool ~tz.~ \i.s..t.~vvs4 :- lo1.:111 ~{~~st1~<.olll. t~L"( ~ t KIC,Hh:.IZ / )'3\ s.. tt tl{iiCbro. r ls.~~~l- l?;\Q.\-l-\~lZ;, \'3\ ~.(-\-.tt\-\]14>fo-lh'1. tS.~K_:)t~~ \LS..C..~ ~2.S4_;lLJJ:\l · t&~K~ "t -1..~ \J.&.C.·. ~ 2.. ~S~ ~ 1: K:l. t :z.l JC~·1 . [Sn::; -~ lL i-\v:\)'vl"t\-\c·D \). sfv~\lL ~ot-\-W'AR~; 't,-..!C. _; ·z.:st f-3~; 41"3;. 41'? ! s*tt (l__iR_-ZoooJ]_ t 1 _; ~- t -\-h~''lC.\~'Ar?:'' ~ ~t2.KoTZ-~ --· o{ '" .Jt\\mo'fl'ffi~lYt'f\ ij -1\'dEr<.'t\ ~-l \Jl)C,o)l$,-\\\\)-\·,an'A ~ PvRRoR~1-- .. }tRr:".

)II

1 il'i\'1\~-\ } ... l~-~~'(Jilt~~ ' ' jJm()"' -l-,~o~{KNd~a"- \ S.\l'£\\Q.\R. Y\~\\\''' ·-l1 ~ 0 K£h:.R ,. _..\o ' -\o~·hflY\ l- t 'A ~1~'- · 1 '

~lio~~v'A·h:."' ~ t \-\'AfbR.'t\S. (- {K'I(·,6~t.lti'AR~l ~~'fi_!Z-,n~ ( -tl-\\lo'' -\~ +nv.s ,., - t~m~,1z.d'\ 1" -\LR~f)f.C..+s '"·-l·thl1+ ' '_ -t

l. s \n6''' ~ii{io)\f.R.'s "'- ~ ( ~~ll·,~s / .~,TZ.~.ilY\ ~s 1-: 'fi~F-"' ·-i:,r-\ f"A~+1 :''-\t YVI KR\to1t1o\l~\\~ 1' - {'f\~~ u'flhJ\\ 1'~- ..

1

l:~rz;T-1 \of(th] ___ )i-Arw-!' -ts\r,o' -t~'Af:)f-..'t\qWlZ\t1 ~ 'ft)IO"-tS.\lCJ\1 ...l:m~1~:~.\) 111 -I~o~~l<.n~-

\.

p~<.l.t,anRR•- t~<l~vllh::l 1''- ( nHrz;~ ~" j .; [)\ ~;;)lsanlle,i<.1-l fRoC<:<lvRiiy:

t+hB-\.- t Slifl'iC:liC ntl'\"'- t: a~fv/ZC.ow1K5j_:; ,; t -\-hf." -I d£f )I" I 1- r'-

.. . btl f.'' ll{l n& ''-

t f"\ fMS ]_- t pJto(l_jcQijrzll ~ S\1\'1;;' l!,vm<d Q .-_lin~·"-{svc~·-~s"- T.,Nfnctr. Ov" '" -"(To"'- FhE'' -[n;~eRK"'_

i

~ RrPRfZKeiU"~ '\tfnt« .. +h~t ··-I. s v'-'«1'"- t \'aRmu IHt!W1- I C.1R;ms]"' lt+h"' ...

~?10~' {, ~~ ~ :t,_;-lh:.ll_:-~-h~ Hj : -~ n!'in I ~G" -~Sa ~-\-; -i~eO U'\" ·1 n~"'{+t..~tvi'

(L,\1,,(1.)1 -lC 1Z. •-l: Hn&''

L ~"- t V1!'ili:~f -(l~llf.J ~ lLRw .l - It n~.:· _IwitH' -

j f'h 1 t R If' , Wold;

;~R.:~c_v \\1: i t~Siif vh:s::I '': l[_&VC'_H]'~t C.l"im~J - j!: I'\"-~ To - (!,f.rJ - ][., N - J +J - li<6 H of' - HhlC" itldJSYl h

IZ!:.~Vitmb ~ 11~'-- ~ f~ 11tHiS " -'( -'[ Qo;-lS+;i To ' l':i!O "'j__ SI!Yif hlf.I\F;I '\"-

)In~"- ~ 'SVIZolZ~ 'iR~<~Sonflt\TCY1JCS fhcN~ ( _-IL1 flto -[1!.( lU Etllhl .. -\-h ll-1' -).iS"- )\,.)IR,iS i fRom" - b<: fvn Ct fi¥1Ji:RS] l t ,)1<i>ll-\~:.l J"-- ot'" !Zovn~s oiZ" tol'" -ls vc_H]-1.{. C 1 __ q _. Ylnd'"- lf.:\-h VS" -l,RJc, '"- .. th\1t '"-[SuCH]"'_ ' _

~ 'l-faint;n~·-~ o~T] ·- HhL" -I~1'.1-~n~"-\);,~!lie+ .

ll~~]

• -'[is'" ·tmJO (ZF:I,\"

HOF:~un+ I~,. - t n Y\~1<, - {lo4iGnlIIufn"-+l II\ M .. +hAl-., , J _; f:lVll a1\m..Yl tn 1\ "' iZRo R s]--

illll

'' ~ bR~<" -t~M~(I,v -'j,_IZJCth-.1'.-\~~p/Zat(l<.t\in ~ ti\\Et-1\~€.]~Ch. 1 ... of"- b.-iT'.)t ~n\'~ir<l TRiA~.. nnJ'~-

IL s\1 {!,\\1 .·IL(Jta ",nM. / cl 'f\1 ]

_- " 1YI "'R !C \ '\' ·,.l )0 I'.H illS

tlJ1.1-hl\-\-

l&o" - l\.ll,.l" -I ijA'fl\1R._'i· h Pf '-I I fltE (

l'rvii..l,il£~ ~{ '3 viZ') l j J vR 1St} n~() •- oR ~ lHn(l.i}f;nO ER l--~ rl.v \~ " (H'~~ IZICol<l<.RJo 0 .. 1 . 1,~\IQ\j_j ;

iflll . . .,~ 'Ela\!,.iQ.~~)1 -{Rf-.fi~C'-t.s-- ~'h"' 'JLn•J~o-·1 1 -I~o7-1R£nsonA~I<;f- ~-h-lfn,f'J.lE~_l- ., ,,, 11\l \lwrL(\ ~1• 0T£

J 1 111 . . .

~LR.<l;l'.+]-tup~,Jj J~Hiil" -{ HHi>EliS},f'~<-il11aY1j , ,.'An~ R. ] •

'tRT'_; l:.-4.vi lf<l] · . 1 · oR. _; 1\_:R.iR qCoURt(_:- {i',M~<.] r-Io.{. ,f'"-tsn"l" : t,i/hc'<!.RU»I'.-1&/ omitsions ~ -JWHLR.f. -tna..qvn1d'\ - '(Co,.tt~d£0]_ I rR.o p'-RI1",II)~ " tn '-'' 1: ;._H -, ~ n<:.R: s'" -::,l!J()n~ ('_ vn ~~e I L nn0" - oIZ'' - ~ 't ll me II nk{ C.ouns" G-

1

l(: -4 rJ ~i(i.H" - \t~ hn r Ij t BI\1SL~' · '( fn1 rz- J l\11 .t<l ~:.0 J _:. ""

1

• o i '--

t SE;o __; ll\'lvR\?.1\'j ~. CHR-R.\<:R ; 4(Ild\~'f\~lttK-mrvn-t .• ~ -~ , ~~ 'b \t I"''/,<; J .

1i.

'til~CF:~1\.Hooil-\o'i?-O '-J. '/iS<'.ioth . '53( ~-S.. 1'\; 1.1 -ltooZ.].

ts"-"'~ 1 ~;s Z.; t:,<;~ h ~ I 2..oo4] tJZ,C.Hh:R. I 'i. . 1~1 ~-C.-t'.fn+J -~~G-f~>lo-\•11~]-/~ _ ~MZ1SoiZoOC..H \1. »I~MZNdo: s41 V.&.

J

Jt:SEF:-~ tEJ>!(;I~<; V. HI\ c_('_ . 4(; 'S U. S. I o1 , 11."' \t l'l 'bt ( · itS<:JC ~)!. W~m rJIZi(\.Hf '/. ~1\<,JCS , ~33 U.S. 7t ltW?]. 1[ SIC<: ~1: <'.oiJ<. mnr-l v. Tltomp So r! , ~o I \J. ~ ! n-\-1 'l -so .

I"JL, \J'1SC.us~·\oll1{

r' T~<;... l'R.+;{; 01\ER' -I-, s.-l:tvRRM-l-1 ( -t'i"'~,._ \!J h~<: ,, - U!li+d st nitS lllS{R_;(l,, c.u;z-f -I."'t.•R• -

:

0

)tt:, I J I

111 '''TCf!.aU-\ht;.RN101!\hz;Q.+ J of'"~ t U:"-Ri\ .. 'l:C.oRl'D'-'1 C, ~ R I(>,-\ J Dl '/ i "\oNr '}\)') 6'" \t-Sui\H] "-

t·ls -t'~Jf,(', M&!e" -l +1\JC "'1:. pd;+; onRR "--.JC iS,, -IN oW "--t c. H\1\bc..j(!, i ,J~. -llhTCSE'- ~i\ IIIR. ·!~tx.n <~+] ' .-

lth<. i

1

J: >trzovnilS •... !Jh~t· -l-R~ "--(i--lfn U 1'-'( tl<.1l\orl StRl\+dJOij"' ltJCJ'LI'.uh; ~" -t Wi-\hi N S~i ~:-

\.,~; I~ "~ " ·'\:

( HA6LM] pd;f,o,.{] - bna '-I-thuS'". t f'ld:+s '"- 'tfoR"- .'\N i 0"' -I Co\liZ-i l l'{oT] To

1

'l

~Zi<,OIZJ:_ss" +~<.SJ".'" -l ~LR ~ ~ ho~'j\~ ~ r,:'m 1 (I.RII(-

t J /.

t~ ~·1110 ~ 1( ' ,. lt.Wl\n-io,.tT' I mn lii!,.Ainl'f+} Vl'ltor-IS-l-itu n <:RRoRS Ih! fn s . :.. + - t I M n(l. 1- t.Rl: '{' IJCC'. +1 ;r l\] ._ t'l lCR. 'i' -'[ vt! RR.nso AI nl\ho I - {f:.i n -lv,.! C-a,.\ S{!M 01) n]

t l

U!J!,; sioJJ ... +hM. -)LIS. - 1\l.'.o]"-lt»l 'I'<.IZ·I'' -!oiJ'/Io\lS"_; rlnin]£r<JZoiZ { . ] ,_\ t . W~HCH.-

~.

' .. ,, .

l ~ HMt1 f;Na>c!ZS}. Wov\Q ) t£.._ "It·,,~'" ·J(dl' &nbc]~~ r o~<;R'" . AnJ" -1-lhuS'

f-£ 'ASoNn&hc ,,

t h.otiC-1\ll ~ ~-1?-{I~SC ts" -r 1\N ...~t~Jt4U NtJcl.-ltJ<J>lto~ IZl\ if.IY\En:. ··~:~ of""-H~ ~RfhER." ·, I li h~l\~ Vc..] ..( f~oC.JCJCdi nts ' - i..loiZ<lJCR.' ~ )lTo '"·liZJcmJCd·•~e c(+h~;" p!;;}i+i<>n<. R.:S '.:

Ill ' .•

]!; ir-l vrzd'' -1sutshnt i ~ 1] ~ i ~~.+ sl NWn~~:~\ ' - \t su<O »T' ,~ill '"-X n<H u~II • I» ISo{_ i )L.

Rl::c\~tts.S] I~ Ail'.~ l <'.or,st;\ut ionl .. j 1{; J!:tFv~d\liZR, 0].; +hE"' - l[i iltin lij '] I'R.onif Vlj 1J: Vio {,o II \ , &hk:' Un i+IC4 Si tsrt ;ltz ~ ~ s d z.zs-4 {JCi •11. l~tL~l">lnC.K 'i.'fl1~D-ANiTC\. '>24 v.g_ 47-s. 9~Y I I ~'

Tzoooj

-\JJJ....t

(SJCro ~ t sIni'.k. 'f. mC. DI\,.J i>c I " r n+] ~ ~ 4 . " l(&E~<, .:. 1: JC:x. )"l'II'Ct£. 6R.nVo I o'l... S. w. 2)J > \9,~ ; l'l 3 Thn el(_;m \<\ pp. n$2..1 {Sf.JC _; 'J;; fl oUS£R. 'i. l)lttfi)E : 3 '1 S" F ·3d )(,o; --;<;, >Z.. l -;th Ci R. Zoo Y1 . . -n:~~~ -~ 1: z~ v.s.Q. ~ 2.z;s4 .td]. \[SEt<-~ I <'-A ld!:R.o,-.1 und£'o Nntts DiS-IRiN C'.<>uR+ , 14 4 t. 3d Co I~ 11 CiR. 11 ~ q,1 tS>e~e ~ 't UvfJnnks -v. t~'4lt<- '\ , 3'l>o F. 3d 'i

'17 ~ 't b c.·,R.. Z.oo41.

ih

~ L Z'b ~ ~ u s-4: ):Jc] J.:z..7. ~ 'l3Z., th t&t!C u.s ltlliok ~ h~E" st~ -, .J:r: .e. A](I A\n11 o(IRpptnF ol7-, l<:'IE Yl - LConh: "'.11 ; +h R' pd; t: OhJ<:R'S"

+E ,, ·l<loES( n

't;llL l&uf.f; ci'm]'4 Ro~n ds f'DR J:.RJckf'1l~ [1]17"

~ ~ \~-lion~ ~nO • • • _.1 •

[(l_J t,Q 't<'.onsl; 1] lim>cndmJC ntsl , 1st , 'S+h: (, +h , 1 •- 14 ,h . l Src.: '.lh:i\ iZ <Oi-l l' 'S i, J:O1c J: il " 1 IT ~~ ~· t Ff: d . 1Z. C2.i v. p. ~ \ .

l'\1k> J . )[. 1C)(Sn ~ I.(l,.~/ StJZ;C,~IAnO'e.lnim; lHJCRAinAJJOZ '1 ..StntE, I%\\ r.\. 2-d S3; olho.<:.Rim ~ff. . tSEJC \(:<.oS:<_,. k. e '6o 1:. ~t

F-:<) .;

"I~d~tRi('Nmld'

0;~ l( 1qd~illl

2>l(]. ~ t s+RiQ~Innd '{

. WnSKinl!.to!'i ' ~<::b u s. (,q,~' 0~ s ~t I

lSJC~C ~ t «n£,.:1\ s\ i'.oRr/s-\R;C~I Rnil'

:r: <', us

A :Z.. C.\ Rim ~ Jt n< l"llRh: ~ood II , t C.R.. nw 111J t]( (, (l"TI 19 I W Zd 7 1\ · 3Z S So

)J;~JC~l.t:.t~.jSIJz;C~I~nd'Cintlli~t~;v;t-ts V l-.u(l,JC~ ,4~1 vs. 3q, loS ge+.~5al:l~to1 n:JtRl\ G-1z.z.s4}-tHn&~CllS] WR.i t l ~tAUt n P"-11!\ W•ll·,nm skp~~<:ns;

l Ci vi\ Mt·,o\1 -'iJ;~\fZ;(l,"-I [SlOE Jts";J"

t] rio.] . -t: 14- CC ~- oo3 3it . _ f<;t;han£R.'S -.J.

lt"::C'{~ Con('J uS i on llll 0 l'Rll '\"- R.1~ ;

Pll\ln·\:iff'".. on "I''' -}2;m rhl"- hE")IJE~t'' 1E~S '" -is~ iO ''l~auR+ ' :.

~"id '" -tshlkil ]1\, ofion 1; duJC ''(T~ '" ·t {hE. ~ t.i lltlb111 ~ ',~Sionq.J:Rlc'.fo 1[ cl] t+hJC" ,lJ!n Q,. - IpJZ.l\ lo '".: \iR.nn t 1 l.liR.o~ni\1 -t Wi-\H '"J:.sw~ "'L <'. .Q. ~J No j - wW• <'-K '" .. lori'RJ<-~S ~ O'fr1 l'lin'i!.]-

iS" -1t HR.onl!,{ut! '\ -

""J~lZ.itl\\." '+hE" unitEd sM._s 'I:Coi1St ~Viiorq' linG" -~niO'- t PEt·,f;~nER.'&'.:

iN iV El1 "' -

lt i

l.S u!1,s.·tn n·h ni] R.-. ib ~ h 1 . ~r<-l'.t.f uII'\ s~ t'illl;th:O cPA _,;f:fO

Jtl.ib v S l\ &li~c<;] F-:X ~e(l,u+<: d on : 1- 14- IS . \iiiRD f-l"R-'ilt\ 1-~.C,.-:s. ND. \/"'o-2. . /1 3. fdi-\\ onrJ~- ~ PRo ~ :f'A-nl£.~ \j. ¥\IIIZk:() \JnH-

•t .. ~ '- ...

!:H.] RX P}UZtR, niiRI'! PRnt~ v. tHR &+~qtR: of .1R:X)1s

Pena, Allen, (Tex. 2015).

Pincite

Pena, Allen (Pena, Allen) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.