Patriotic Bank v. Webster

2 Hay. & Haz. 47, 1851 U.S. App. LEXIS 488

• Court: Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit
• Decided: May 15, 1851
• Status: Published

Opinion

The note on which this suit was brought was made by-Henry D. Kenny, who promised to pay to the defendant, sixty days after its date, viz: 13th of September, 1837.

The defendant endorsed the note over to D. A. Hall, who in turn endorsed it over to the plaintiffs.

The usual counts were inserted in the declaration.

The pleas of the defendants were in substance as follows:

First, that he did not undertake and promise in manner and form, as the said plaintiffs have above complained against him.

Second, that the plaintiffs ought not to have or maintain their action aforesaid against him, because he saith that he, the said defendant, did not at any time within three years next before the commencement of this Suit, undertake or promise in manner and form as the said plaintiffs have above thereof complained against him.

Third, that the plaintiffs ought not to have or maintain their action aforesaid against him, because he saith, that the several supposed causes of action in the said declaration mentioned did not, nor did any or either of them accrue to the said plaintiffs at any time within three years before the commencement of this suit, in manner and form as the said plaintiffs have above thereof complained against him.

Replication to the defendant’s pleas.

That the defendant was beyond seas at the time the debt came due and was payable, and continually thereafter to the bringing of the suit.

Rejoinder to the plaintiffs’ replication.

That on the 3d day of October, 1840, the defendant returned to the city and was here four days, and his being here was well known to the plaintiffs.

The plaintiffs demurred to the defendant’s rejoinder.

Judgment for the defendant on the demurrer.