Pardon v. Moore

908 So. 2d 1253, 2005 WL 1962028
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedAugust 17, 2005
Docket39,949-CA
StatusPublished
Cited by7 cases

This text of 908 So. 2d 1253 (Pardon v. Moore) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Pardon v. Moore, 908 So. 2d 1253, 2005 WL 1962028 (La. Ct. App. 2005).

Opinion

908 So.2d 1253 (2005)

Clifton PARDON, Plaintiff-Appellant
v.
Amos MOORE, Jr., Defendant-Appellee.

No. 39,949-CA.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit.

August 17, 2005.

*1254 Travis M. Holley, Bastrop, for Appellant.

Paul W. Bairnsfather, for Appellee.

Before STEWART, CARAWAY and LOLLEY, JJ.

STEWART, J.

Clifton Pardon, obtained title to the subject property through a series of tax sales. He then sought to have his title confirmed against the claims of, Amos Moore, Jr., who purportedly obtained title through a cash sale deed from the original tax debtor in Pardon's chain of title. Moore reconvened seeking annulment of the tax sales. The trial court rendered judgment against Pardon and in favor of Moore setting aside the tax sales giving rise to Pardon's claim of ownership. For the reasons set forth below, we affirm the judgment of the trial court.

FACTS

Clifton Pardon and Amos Moore, Jr., both trace their claim of ownership to the same parcel of land in Morehouse Parish to common authors David Spencer Rinehart and his wife, Alyson Henley Rinehart. Amos Moore bases his claim on a single act under private signature executed by the Rineharts transferring their interest in the property to him and recorded in Book 514, Page 416 of the Conveyance Records of Morehouse Parish on November 23, 1998. Clifton Pardon, on the other hand, bases his claim on the following chain of title evidenced by the pleadings in this matter:

1. Tax Sale of subject property to Mississippi Land Co., Inc., assessed in the name of David Spencer Rhinehart, et ux, for the 1997 parish taxes by Sheriff and *1255 Tax Collector's deed dated April 29, 1998, registered in Book 510, Page 234 of the Conveyance Records of Morehouse Parish;

2. Tax Sale of subject property to Belle Exploration, Inc., assessed in the name of David Spencer Rinehart, for the 1998 parish taxes by Sheriff and Tax Collector's deed dated May 7, 1999, registered in Book 518, Page 337 of the Conveyance Records of Morehouse Parish;

3. Tax Sale of subject property to Louisiana Tax I, Inc., assessed in the name of Mississippi Land Co., Inc., for the 1999 parish taxes by Sheriff and Tax Collector's deed dated May 15, 2000, registered in Book 527, Page 366 of the Conveyance Records of Morehouse Parish;

4. Tax Sale of subject property to Brown and Lee, Inc., assessed in the name of Louisiana Tax I, Inc., for the 2000 parish taxes by Sheriff and Tax Collector's deed dated May 30, 2001, registered in Book 536, Page 458 of the Conveyance Records of Morehouse Parish;

5. Quit claim by Mississippi Land Co., Inc., Belle Exploration, Inc., and Louisiana Tax I, Inc., transferring all their interest in the subject property to Morehouse Rentals, Inc. dated October 22, 2001, and filed in Book 540, Page 370 of the Conveyance Records of Morehouse Parish;

6. Cash sale by Morehouse Rentals, Inc. of subject property to Cliff's Cable Video by deed dated November 9, 2001, and recorded in Book 540, Page 715 of the Conveyance Records of Morehouse Parish;

7. Certificate of Redemption issued on September 19, 2002, redeeming the subject property to Louisiana Tax I as a result of payment by Clifton Pardue of the purchase price of $1,223.50 filed in Book 548, Page 319 of the Conveyance Records of Morehouse Parish;

8. Act of Correction executed on October 7, 2002, changing the name of the purchaser in the previously issued Certificate of Redemption to James Pardon and filed in Book 548, Page 632 of the Conveyance Records of Morehouse Parish;

9. Second Act of Correction executed on October 7, 2002, changing the name of the purchaser to Clifton Pardon and filed in Book 548, Page 635 of the Conveyance Record of Morehouse Parish.

On June 5, 2003, Mr. Pardon filed a petition to quiet title on the property against any claims by Amos Moore, Jr., and to confirm Mr. Pardon as the owner of the property. On July 15, 2003, Mr. Moore answered the petition and made a reconventional demand seeking nullification of the tax sales under which Mr. Pardon asserts ownership on the basis that the original tax debtors were not provided notice as required by La. R.S. 47:2180. Trial was held on November 13, 2003.

The parties stipulated that Mr. Pardon would testify as to his desire to have his tax title quieted and that he be declared the owner of the property. As his only other witness, Mr. Pardon called Bobby Porter, a civil deputy clerk for the Morehouse Parish Sheriff's department. Mr. Porter's testimony was used to introduce a certified mail return receipt allegedly signed on February 9, 1998, by David Rinehart as part of the sheriff's department records regarding the tax sale of Mr. Rinehart's property. Mr. Porter did not know nor did the return receipt evidence the address to which the item was mailed. Mr. Porter was unaware of whether his office retained copies of the notices mailed to taxpayers but confirmed that the letter would have informed Mr. Rinehart that the taxes on his property were due. No copy of the notice allegedly mailed to Mr. Rinehart was produced.

Mr. Porter testified that the property was subsequently sold at tax sale to the *1256 Mississippi Land Company. He was also aware that after the tax sale, Mr. Moore bought Mr. Rinehart's interest in the property. He stated that after the initial delinquency letter sent to Mr. Rinehart, the sheriff's office sent no further notice to either Mr. Rinehart or Mr. Moore regarding past due taxes. All other notices were sent to the Mississippi Land Company and the subsequent tax sale purchasers listed in the chain of title set forth above.

Mr. Moore elicited the testimony of Dawn Jackson, a tax clerk for the Morehouse Parish Sheriff's Office from 1993 to 2000. She testified that as part of her duties she prepared a process verbal each year for all the delinquent tax notices sent to tax payers and that she filed same with the clerk of court. She had no specific recollection of whether such a notice was sent to Mr. Rinehart or to which address such a notice would have been mailed. She did, however, testify that the office kept "carbon" copies of all the notices sent and that the copies would reflect the address to which the notice was sent. She also stated that it was not the office's practice to send any subsequent notices to the original tax debtor or to his transferee in the years after the initial delinquency notice.

Mr. Rinehart testified that he bought the property in 1994 or 1995 and operated the convenience store located thereon for three or four years and subsequently sold the property to Mr. Moore in November of 1998. While he did not dispute that he had not paid the property taxes for 1997, he testified that he had never received notice of a tax sale concerning the property. He also testified that the signature on the return receipt identified by Mr. Porter as evidence of his receipt of the delinquency tax notice was not his and noted that the printed version of his name located above the signature was misspelled as "Rineheart." On cross-examination, Mr. Rinehart testified that he and his wife were separated at the time the notice was allegedly mailed to him. He had moved to Mississippi and his wife had remained in the matrimonial domicile on Stonecliff Drive in West Monroe, Louisiana. He stated that if the mailing had been sent to that address it would have to have been signed by him, his wife or the nanny. He could not state definitively whether or not his wife or the nanny had received the certified mail evidenced by the return receipt.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
908 So. 2d 1253, 2005 WL 1962028, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/pardon-v-moore-lactapp-2005.