Owner-Operator Independent Dri v. Eric Holcomb

990 F.3d 565

Opinion

In the

United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPT

'ET:8Q9<<=T Q
T T  T

 FT EF- #-EFT #",
#"FT

%)T

 T  FT'.*&'*T'T &!&F-#-EFT #",
"ET PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPT

(($T*'%T, T&!,T,,+T!+,*!,T'-*,T'*T, T '-, *&T!+,*!,T'T &!&FT &!&('$!+T!.!+!'&ET 'ET9G9AQ.Q888@>Q Q TST  
 F- $ET PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPT

TT:>FT:8:8TST T
TAFT:8:9T PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPT

'*T
 FTFT&TF-!$#- $"ET 
 F- !$#- $ET  T &!&T '$$T 'FT (*,T 'T QA8FT*-&+T9=>T%!$+T*'++T&'*, *&T &!&T*'%T, T'*Q *T /!, T  !'T '&T , T +,T ,'T , T  !'T #1/1T '&T , T /+,ET /&T 1T , T &!&T !&&T
-, '*!,1FT , T '$$T 'T +T&T'(*,T+!&T:88>T1TT$++FT T'&+Q +!'&T '%(&1ET  ,T T &T  *T (&+T '&T +,,T $/FT &T !&T :89@T T (!T , T +,,T C9T !$$!'&T !&T 0 &T '*T :T 'ET:8Q9<<=T

(*%!++!'&T ,'T *!+T 1T ;=BT , T ,'$$+T '&T .1T ,*-#+T J, '+T /!, T , *T '*T %'*T 0$+KET &T , !+T +-!,FT (*+'&+T &T &,!,!+T , ,T '/&T &T '(*,T .1T ,*-#+T '&,&T , ,T , T ,'$$T !&Q *+T.!'$,+T, T'%%*T$-+T'T, T'&+,!,-,!'&T1T $$!&T (*!&!($$1T '&T !&,*+,,T ,*6ET $!&,!5+T $$T , ,T =8BT 'T , T .1T ,*-#+T , ,T -+T , T '$$T 'T ,*&+!,T , T +,,T &T , ,T A8BT 'T .1Q,*-#T ,*6T *'+++T , T +,,M+T '**+T,T'&T,!%T'*T&', *ET! *T,'$$+T'&T, +T,*-#+T , *'*T!+*!%!&,T!&+,T!&,*+,,T'%%*FT($!&,!5+T %!&,!&ET  1T T , ,T , T ,'$$+T *T -&"-+,!3T -+T &'&T 'T , T C9T !$$!'&T /!$$T T -+T ,'T %!&,!&T '*T !%(*'.T , T'$$T'ETJ &!&T&!+T+'%T'T, +T$$,!'&+FT-,T /T++-%T'*T-**&,T(-*('++T, ,T($!&,!5+T*T'**,EKT
T %!+,*,T "-T *'%%&T , ,T , T +-!,T T !+Q %!++T'&T, T*'-&T, ,T &!&FT+TT%*#,T(*,!!(&,FT !+T 0%(,T *'%T , T *-$+T '*!&*!$1T (($!T , *'- T '%Q %*T "-*!+(*-&ET :89AT EET !+,ET  T ::@A=@T JEET &ET
-ET 9:FT :89AKET  T !+,*!,T "-T *T &T !+%!++T , T +-!,T-&*TETET!.ETET9:JKJ>KT'*T!$-*T,'T+,,TT$!%T '&T / ! T *$!T %1T T *&,ET :8:8T EET !+,ET  T <99;@T JEET &ET *ET98FT:8:8KET $"- %)-
'!- ! - ! EFT <:>T EET ?AKFT '$+T , ,FT / &T T +,,T (*,!!(,+T !&S*, *T , &T *-Q $,+S, T%*#,FT!,T!+T&,!,$T,'T!+*!%!&,T!&T.'*T'T!,+T '/&T!,!2&+E-$"T+-+,!&TT'-&,1T, ,T *1$&T(!T !,+T'/&T!,!2&+T'*T, T!+('+$T'T"-&#T*+ET ,*T!+!'&+FT +- T +T %"*- )- %)- #FT <

'%%*T $-+T ,'T +,(+T 1T / ! T +,,+T *-$,T , T Q .!'*T 'T (*!.,T (*,!+ET
+T &,*(*&-*+FT , T '-*,T *Q (,$1T+1+FT+,,+T%1T .T$!#T(*!.,T-+!&+++T&T +$$T,'T/ '%T, 1T($+T,T(*!+T, T%*#,T/!$$T*TJ'*T,T +-+!!2T(*!+KET $!&,!5+T!&+!+,T, ,T,'$$T*'+T*T!5*&,S.&T, '- T , T+,,T!+T *!&TTT'*TT+*.!S-+T, T%!&,Q &&T 'T *'+T !+T &T N++&,!$T '.*&%&,$T -&,!'&OT , ,T $#+TT(*!.,T)-!.$&,ET
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
T 3*T ,T '-,T , T '&+,!,-,!'&$!,1T 'T Q *$T !&.'$.%&,T !&T !&,*&$T !%(*'.%&,+T $,T (*!.,T &Q ,*(*&-*+FT/!, T'+!'&$T+,,T!FT+T, T(*!&!($T%&Q *+T 'T ,*&+('*,T *,*!+ET  T (-$!$1T '/&T !&,*+,,T ! /1T+1+,%FT/ ! T&T-*!&T, T9A=8+FT/'-$T .T &T -&, !&#$T T &,-*1T *$!*ET  &T , T &,!'&$T '.Q

*&%&,T *'#T !&,'T , T ,*&+('*,,!'&T -+!&++FT !,T /+T +T T (*'.!*T'T$&T'*T(*!.,T*!$*'+FT&',T+TT-!$*T'*T'(Q *,'*ET
&T .&T !&T :8:9T *)-&,$1T -+T .&-+T 'T ,*&+Q ('*,,!'&S'!$T&T+T(!($!&+FT$,*!$T!+,*!-,!'&T*!+FT &$+FT +'%T !*('*,+FT +'%T *!+FT %&1T **!+FT %&1T ('*,+T&T *'*+FT%&1T*!$*'+S*%!&T!&T(*!.,T &+ET  T!T, ,T,*&+('*,,!'&T&++*!$1T!+TT+,,T-&,!'&T!+T -&,&$ET -+,T +#T , T .$'(*+T 'T *+!&,!$T +-!.!Q +!'&+FT&T, T'/&*+T'T*%+FT/ ! T*T0(,T,'T-!$T &T%!&,!&T, !*T'/&T*'+ET T %1T +-(('+FT +T ($!&,!5+T $$FT , ,T , T C9T !$$!'&T *!.T'*T, T:89@T,'$$T!&*+T/+T-+T'*T+,,T(-*('+Q +T -&*$,T ,'T %!&,&&T 'T , T '$$T 'ET  1T + '-$T , ,T %7*IT
T +,,FT $!#T &1T (*!.,T (*'(*!,'*FT &T ,-*&T T (*'3,T*'%T!,+T,!.!,!+ET$!&,!5+T('!&,T'-,T, ,T!&-%"%, !$!-
! !#-
$#!#(- %)- #-
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

T .T+!T&'- T,'T+ '/T, ,T, T,'$$T!&*+T!+T.$Q !T .&T !T ,*,T +T !+*!%!&,!&T !&+,T !&,*+,,T '%Q %*ETT&T,'TT$*T'&T, !+T('!&,GT/T .-++-%T '*T, T+#T'T*-%&,T, ,T, *T/'-$TTT'&+,!,-,!'&$T (*'$%T!T &!&T/*TT*-$,'*T*, *T, &TT(*'(*!,'*FT -,T /T 'T &',T +'T '$ET  T ,'$$+T *T &-,*$T /!, T *+(,T ,'T , T '*!!&T &T +,!&,!'&T 'T , T ,*-#+ET  1T *T &-,*$T /!, T *+(,T ,'T ,*-#+MT '/&*+ !(T ,''ET !,!2&+T 'T &!&T / 'T-+T, T'$$T'T,'T -$T*! ,T*'%T$# *,T,'T*1T (1T , T +%T *,T (*T %!$FT (*T 0$FT +T 'T !,!2&+T 'T !+Q '&+!&T / 'T -$T *! ,T *'%T  !'T , *'- T &!&T ,'T $$!Q &'!+T&T1'&ET !+!'&+T +- T +T
!- !$-
""#"*- )- %)- !FT <@;T EET :>>T J9A@?KFT / ! T ,*,T 4,T ,*&+('*,,!'&T ,0+T +T !+*!%!&,'*1FT 'T &',T 5,T , T .$!!,1T 'T T (*Q %!$T ,'$$ET  T ('!&,T '-
!- !$T /+T , ,T T 4,T ,0T J+1FTC=88T(*T,*-#T(*T1*KT/'-$T$$T%'*T .!$1T'&T, T '/&*T 'T T ,*-#T , ,T (++T , *'- T &&+1$.&!T '&T T 1*T, &T'&T, T!&Q+,,T'/&*T'TT,*-#T, ,T%T$'$TQ $!.*!+T !&T !7+-* ET  T '-,Q'Q+,,T '/&*T %! ,T &T -(T (1!&TC=T(*T%!$TJ&T%&1T, '-+&+T'T'$$*+T!T', *T +,,+T T, T+%T+ %KFT/ !$T, T!&Q+,,T'/&*T/'-$T (1T'&$1T(&&!+T(*T%!$ET
T(*Q%!$T,'$$FT1T'&,*+,FT,*,+T .*1'&T $!#ET &T , !+T *+(,T T (*Q%!$T ,'$$T !+T &'T !5*&,T *'%T T ,0T '&T +'$!&T '*T !+$T -$FT '*T , ,T ,0T !+T (!T !&T (*'('*,!'&T,'T-+ET  T -(*%T '-*,T %! ,T /$$T %T , T +&T 'T 0Q (*++T !+*!%!&,!'&T '&$-+!.T !&T .'*T 'T T (*Q%!$T ,'$$ET T *'&!2T , ,- - %)- !$- $!*- )FT ;A?T EET 9;?T J9A?8KFT *)-!*+T ,T $+,T +'%T 0,*T "-+,!3,!'&T J1'&T , T +,&*T *,!'&$Q+!+T ,+,KT '*T +'%T *-$,!'&+T , ,T *T >T 'ET:8Q9<<=T

.!$1T'&T!&,*+,,T'%%*ET-,T!,T +T&TT$'&T,!%T +!&T, T'-*,T-+T M+T((*' T,'T%T&1T+,,T$/T !&.$!S&T, T%'+,T*&,T!&+,&T'T!,+T-+FT'-
$#, #- ! )- %)- &"- #! !""*- )FT <@>T EET @@@T J9A@@KFT %T !&T T +T , ,T *'+T *'%T 0(*++T !+*!%!&,!'&ET ',T +!&T, &T +T&1T+,,T$/T&T%T!&.$!T-&*- ET  T (*.!$!&T ((*' T +T &T ,'T +-+,!&T &-,*$T +,,T $/+T / !$T 3&!&T !&.$!T , '+T , ,T !+*!%!&,T !&+,T !&,*+,,T'%%*ET
+TT'-*,T'T(($+T/T*%!&T'-&T 1- T-&$++T, T -+,!+T'.**-$T!,FT-,T/T&T&',T(($1T !,T ,'T T +,,Q+Q(*'(*!,'*T +!,-,!'&T / &T , T '-*,T +T &',T '&T +'ET T #$(-  !##- - %$- %)- %"FT ==;T EET;:@FT;=;R=>TJ:88@KET.!&T $T, ,TT+,,T+TT%*#,T (*,!!(&,T %1T &T !&T 0(*++T !+*!%!&,!'&T !&+,T !,!2&+T'T', *T+,,+FT, T'-*,T!+T&',T$!#$1T,'T-+- T,'T * TT'&,**1T*+-$,ET
  T