Opinion of the Justices

373 So. 2d 278, 1979 Ala. LEXIS 3012
Supreme Court of Alabama·Decided July 17, 1979·No. No. 260·Published·Cited by 3 cases

Opinion

To the Members of the House of Representatives

State Capitol

Montgomery, AL 36130

Dear Sirs and Mesdames:

The Honorable John W. Pemberton, Clerk, Alabama House of Representatives, has forwarded to this Court House Resolution No. 265, a copy of which is attached hereto, requesting our written opinions on the following important constitutional question which has arisen concerning pending bill S. B. 481, a copy of which was attached to the resolution and is likewise attached hereto:

“1. Does Section 65 of the Constitution of Alabama of 1901 prohibiting the Legislature from authorizing lotteries or gift enterprises prohibit the Legislature from authorizing horse racing in Lawrence County with a pari-mutuel system of wagering as proposed by said SB 481?”

We answer the question you pose in the negative, that is, § 65 of the Constitution of Alabama of 1901, which prohibits the legislature from authorizing “lotteries or gift enterprises for any purposes” does not prohibit the legislature from authorizing horse racing in Lawrence County, Alabama, with a pari-mutuel system of wagering as proposed by said S.B. 481.

The Justices of this Court specifically opined that pari-mutuel wagering is gambling, but that the Constitution of Alabama does not restrict the legislature in its authority to authorize gambling but only prohibits its authorization of “lotteries or gift enterprises for any purposes.” Opinion of the Justices, 287 Ala. 334, 251 So.2d 751 (1971). The reader is referred to this .citation for the views of the various justices.

Although your resolution does not direct our attention to any other constitutional provision respecting the constitutionality of S.B. 481, in all candor, we think we ought to mention that the opinions reflected herein do not mean that S.B. 481 passes general constitutional muster. Particularly, we offer no opinion as to the applicability of Article IV, § 104(14) or of Amendment No. 375 or the decision of this Court in Peddycoart v. City of Birmingham, 354 So.2d 808 (Ala.1978), or Code 1975, § 13-7-50 et seq., or State v. Rogers, 281 Ala. 27, 198 So.2d 610 (1967), or Williams v. Kelley, 289 Ala. 440, 268 So.2d 485 (1972).

Our opinion is limited solely to the question posed as to whether § 65 of the Constitution prohibits authorizing horse racing and pari-mutuel system of wagering as proposed by S.B. 481, which we have answered in the negative.

Respectfully submitted,

C. C. TORBERT, Jr., Chief Justice

JAMES N. BLOODWORTH

JAMES H. FAULKNER

JANIE L. SHORES

ERIC EMBRY

SAMUEL A. BEATTY Associate Justices

[279]*279I agreed with the opinions expressed above but feel compelled to call certain matters to your attention. Section 104(14) of the Constitution of Alabama 1901 specifically prohibits the Legislature from enacting a local law fixing the punishment of a crime. Senate Bill 481 contains several provisions which purport to proscribe certain conduct, a violation of which would amount to either a misdemeanor or a felony. If these provisions be held unconstitutional as violating § 104(14), and the remainder of the legislation held valid under the separability provisions, horse racing would be authorized without any safeguards nor protection as originally contemplated by this legislation.

Perhaps more important to call to your attention are the general laws of this state contained in Division 2 of Article II, Chapter 7, Title 13, Code of Alabama 1975 (§ 13-7-50, et seq.). Section 13-7-50 makes it a misdemeanor for any person to buy or sell a pool or an interest or share in a pool or make or take a book upon any horse race. Section 13-7-51 prohibits any person giving, taking or receiving from another any money or thing of value to be bet or hazarded upon any horse race. Section 13-7-52 provides for a fine and imprisonment for any person or corporation to carry on bookmaking or pool selling, or keeping a place for betting on a horse race; and Section 13-7-53 mandates the forfeiture of a corporate franchise if any corporation is convicted of a violation of these sections. Senate Bill 581 does not purport to exempt Lawrence County from the provisions of the Code sections hereinabove referred to as did H.B. 251 which was introduced in the 1979 Regular Session of the Legislature. An advisory opinion was requested of the Justices by House Resolution 34 with respect to the constitutionality of such legislation (H.B. 251), but such request was withdrawn prior to the time the Justices answered this question.

This writer thought it appropriate to add these comments, lest the Legislature conclude that the Justices sanction the general constitutionality of this pending legislation.

HR 265 REQUESTING AN ADVISORY OPINION OF THE JUSTICES OF THE SUPREME COURT RELATIVE TO SB 481.

BE IT RESOLVED BY THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES OF THE LEGISLATURE OF ALABAMA, That we respectfully request the Honorable Chief Justice and Associate Justices of the Supreme Court or a majority of them, to give this body their written opinions on the following important constitutional question which has arisen concerning the pending bill, SB 481, a copy of which is attached to this resolution and made a part hereof by reference:

1. Does Section 65 of the Constitution of Alabama of 1901 prohibiting the Legislature from authorizing lotteries or gift enterprises prohibit the Legislature from authorizing horse racing in Lawrence County with a pari-mutuel system of wagering as proposed by said SB 481?

RESOLVED FURTHER, That the clerk of the House of Representatives is hereby directed to send nine true copies of pending bill, SB 481, to the Clerk of the Supreme Court of Alabama, and to transmit this request to the Justices of the Supreme Court forthwith upon adoption of this resolution.

(R78-1697¡4-13-79)

S. 481

By Mr. Martin (N & P)

RFD — LL # 1

Rd 1-6-12-79

FUNDING NOTE: This bill will increase county revenue.

A BILL

TO BE ENTITLED AN ACT

To create and provide for the Lawrence County Racing Commission for the regulating, licensing and supervision of horse racing and wagering thereon; to prescribe the composition, appointment, powers, and duties of the Commission; to provide for and regulate the pari-mutuel or certificate [280]*280method of wagering within the enclosure of a licensed race track; to provide for the distribution of license fees, taxes, commissions, and other monies received under the provisions of the act; to provide certain penalties for the violation of this act and for other purposes relative thereto; and to provide for a referendum of the voters of the county on the question of whether the act will become effective in the county. BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF ALABAMA:

Section 1. The Lawrence County Racing Commission is hereby created and established and is vested with the powers and duties specified in this act and all other powers necessary and proper to enable it to execute fully and effectually the purposes of this act.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Opinion of the Justices, 373 So. 2d 278, 1979 Ala. LEXIS 3012 (Ala. 1979).

373 So. 2d 278 (Opinion of the Justices) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Opinion of the Justices
468 So. 2d 881 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1985)