Oliver v. Illinois Central Railroad Company

135 So. 2d 521, 1961 La. App. LEXIS 1532
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedNovember 22, 1961
Docket9595
StatusPublished
Cited by6 cases

This text of 135 So. 2d 521 (Oliver v. Illinois Central Railroad Company) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Oliver v. Illinois Central Railroad Company, 135 So. 2d 521, 1961 La. App. LEXIS 1532 (La. Ct. App. 1961).

Opinion

135 So.2d 521 (1961)

Mary Terrell OLIVER et al., Plaintiffs-Appellants,
v.
ILLINOIS CENTRAL RAILROAD COMPANY et al., Defendants-Appellees.

No. 9595.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit.

November 22, 1961.
Rehearing Denied December 27, 1961.
Certiorari Denied February 6, 1962.

*522 Nelson & Gray, Shreveport, for appellants.

Freyer & Freyer, Mayer & Smith, Shreveport, for appellees.

Before HARDY, GLADNEY and AYRES, JJ.

GLADNEY, Judge.

This is a suit by Mary Terrell Oliver, individually and as tutrix for the minors, Billy Ray Oliver, Patricia Ann Oliver and Ella Mary Oliver, children of her deceased husband, Arthur Oliver, to recover damages resulting from the death of her husband in a train-truck collision about 12:30 P.M. on June 30, 1959, at the intersection of the Illinois Central Railroad's main line and Bodcau Road, in Bossier Parish. Made defendants, and charged with liability by reason of negligence, are Illinois Central Railroad Company, Kesk, Inc., the latter's insurer, U. S. Fidelity & Guaranty Company, and Sylvester Gould, locomotive engineer of the Illinois Central train.

The case went to trial on its merits and the trial court rendered judgment holding *523 there was an absence of proof of negligence on the part of Kesk, Inc. and Sylvester Gould; that the railroad was guilty of negligence, and the deceased Oliver was guilty of contributory negligence. Plaintiff's demands were therefore, rejected, and she has appealed.

The trial judge, in a most thorough statement of his reasons for judgment has accurately stated the circumstances material to the issues, and we adopt his findings as set forth below:

"At the point where the accident happened and where Oliver's death occurred, the Illinois Central Railroad runs east and west. The right of way of the railroad is 150 feet, 75 feet on each side from the center of the main track. Parallel to the railroad and on the south side of the railroad, is situated Barksdale Air Force Base, with a wire fence running east and west, said fence presumably being on the south boundary of the railroad right of way. Bodcau Road runs north and south at this point. It is a gravel road and, as the Bodcau Road crosses the railroad track, the road terminates at a gate which is one of the entrances to Barksdale Air Force Base. At the time of this accident, Kesk, Inc. was constructing for Capehart Housing Projects a large number of housing units inside of Barksdale Air Force Base and the people employed on this job and those who were furnishing materials and supplies on this construction job used the Bodcau Road and this particular entrance gate to Barksdale Air Force Base to gain entrance to the base.

"There was a spur track on the north side of the main line of the Illinois Central Railroad several hundred feet long. This spur track, and, of course, the main line of the railroad, crossed Bodcau Road at this point. Some 50, 60 or 70 feet from the point where the Bodcau Road crossed the railroad and on the west side of Bodcau Road, some 60 or 70 feet, Braswell Industries had a portable concrete mixing plant which they referred to as a `batch' plant. These people, Braswell Industries, were furnishing cement and concrete in its wet stage, called `batch', for the construction of the housing units inside of Barksdale Base. The allegations and evidence showed that there was a temporary driveway constituting a half circle leading off from Bodcau Road on the west, going by the Braswell Industries concrete mixing machinery and again coming back into the Bodcau Road about 37 feet from the spur track. The empty mixing trucks would return from inside of Barksdale Base, cross the railroad and go to the north entrance of this driveway by Braswell's plant, load up with wet concrete, complete making their half circle and again enter Bodcau Road just north of the railroad crossing. The testimony showed that the center of the south exit of this driveway where it entered Bodcau Road was 37 feet from the railroad tracks. The mixing trucks, after being loaded, as they would come out of this driveway, would be facing east and southeast until they reached Bodcau Road. Then, they would turn south, proceed some 30 to 35 feet, cross the spur track and then the main line and go through the entrance gate to Barksdale Field approximately 70 feet south of the main line of the railroad. There were several mixing trucks used on this job, one of the trucks being driven by Oliver. Oliver had worked on this same job, doing this same work, half of a day on June 25. On June 30, the day of the accident, he reported for duty about 7:30 A. M. and had made some five or six round trips delivering batch into Barksdale Field. On his last trip, as he came out of Braswell plant site and started across the railroad, his truck was struck by a westbound Illinois Central passenger train operated by Sylvester Gould and he was instantly killed. This happened at 12:30 p. m., June 30, 1959. Incidentally, the entire train was derailed as a result of the impact.

"It is alleged, and evidence shows, that there were four gondola cars spotted on the side track east of Bodcau Road with *524 the end of the westernmost gondola just a very few feet east of Bodcau Road. In other words, traffic on Bodcau Road as it crossed the spur track would pass within a few feet of the western end of the westernmost gondola. In addition to the testimony, it is stipulated that, at the time of the accident, there were four of these gondola cars parked in the above stated position. All four of these gondola cars, when spotted by the Illinois Central Railroad, had contained large spools of cable. Each gondola would hold four of these large spools. The cable on these spools was also being delivered at the time inside of Barksdale Field, but not for the Capehart Housing Project. The cable on these spools has nothing to do with this lawsuit but the spools themselves, sticking up in the air, and the four gondola cars parked on the side track, have a great deal to do with the lawsuit. As the spools were delivered into Barksdale Field and the cable removed therefrom, the empty spools were again placed on the gondolas, presumably for a return to their owners. The testimony showed that the top of these spools was 11 feet above the ground. The testimony is indefinite and inconclusive as to which of the gondolas were loaded with these spools of cable at the very moment of the accident."

* * * * * *

"It was stipulated by counsel that if the employee of Illinois Central Railroad who furnished information to the Interstate Commerce Commission were present and testified in this trial, that he would testify that four gondolas were on the side track at the time of the accident and that only the first and third gondolas were loaded with spools and that the load height of these gondolas was 11 feet 3 inches above the rails.

"All of this thoroughly convinces the Court that, at the time of the accident at 12:30 p. m., June 30, Car Number 377243, which was the westernmost gondola of the four spotted gondolas, had on it at least three and possibly four spools of cable. The west end of this gondola was adjacent to Bodcau Road. Any motorist traveling Bodcau Road, headed south, would certainly have had his vision obstructed, of a train approaching from the east."

* * * * * *

"The testimony showed that the seat of the driver of the particular truck driven by Oliver was about seven feet from the ground. The driver's eyes would be approximately nine feet from the ground. The engine approaching from the east was 15 feet high.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

David Lazzell v. Booker Drilling Co., Inc.
816 F.2d 196 (Fifth Circuit, 1987)
Johnson v. Clade
309 So. 2d 794 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1975)
Watts v. New Orleans Public Belt Railroad
287 So. 2d 812 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1974)
Illinois Central Railroad v. Braswell Industries, Inc.
227 F. Supp. 347 (W.D. Louisiana, 1964)
Renz v. Texas & Pacific Railway Company
138 So. 2d 114 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1962)
Casualty Reciprocal Exchange v. Illinois Central Railroad
135 So. 2d 531 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1961)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
135 So. 2d 521, 1961 La. App. LEXIS 1532, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/oliver-v-illinois-central-railroad-company-lactapp-1961.