Ogea v. Ogea

378 So. 2d 984
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedJanuary 28, 1980
Docket7201
StatusPublished
Cited by16 cases

This text of 378 So. 2d 984 (Ogea v. Ogea) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Ogea v. Ogea, 378 So. 2d 984 (La. Ct. App. 1980).

Opinion

378 So.2d 984 (1979)

Joseph Alca OGEA, Plaintiff-Appellee,
v.
Barbara Ann OGEA, Defendant-Appellant,
Leary Nicole Ogea, minor, through court appointed attorney, Appellant.

No. 7201.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Third Circuit.

October 10, 1979.
Rehearing Denied November 21, 1979.
Writ Refused January 28, 1980.

Reuvan N. Rougeau, Hunt, Godwin, Painter & Roddy, John S. Hood, Lake Charles, for defendant-appellant.

*985 Norman L. Williams, Lake Charles, for plaintiff-appellee.

Before CULPEPPER, DOMENGEAUX and STOKER, JJ.

DOMENGEAUX, Judge.

This case concerns itself principally with the issues of divorce, separation, and disavowal of paternity. Secondarily, there are questions of alimony, custody, and child support.

The parties are: Joseph Alca Ogea, plaintiff-appellee, (hereinafter referred to as Husband or Joseph), Barbara Ann Ogea, defendant-appellant, (hereinafter referred to as Wife or Barbara), and Leary Nicole Ogea, minor sought to be disavowed by the husband, (hereinafter referred to as Child).

Numerous pleadings have been filed, which are chronicled as follows:

(1) May 9, 1977—Petition for divorce by husband, against wife, based on two years separation from June 10, 1974, (La.R.S. 9:301), and alleging that no children were born of the marriage.

(2) June 1, 1977—Answer by wife, general denial, with allegation, however, that she was several months pregnant.

(3) June 10, 1977—Supplemental and amending petition for divorce by husband alleging abandonment on June 10, 1974, and additionally alleging adultery by wife with a man named "Darrell", which resulted in her becoming pregnant. Husband also alleged that he paid the sum of $463.00 to an obstetrician for services to be rendered to wife in connection with the pregnancy, but that the payment was made under protest.

(4) July 13, 1977—Answer and reconventional demand by wife, general denial, except to admit the amount of money paid to the obstetrician. Reconventional demand for divorce averring that husband is living in adultery with a woman named Paulette at a named address in Crowley, Louisiana, and that husband and the named woman hold themselves out to be man and wife. Wife further alleged that a reconciliation with husband took place on February 11, 1977, at a home in Lake Charles, Louisiana, at which time husband and wife engaged in sexual intercourse, following which husband abandoned wife and refused to return to live with her. Consequently, she also prayed for a legal separation. She further asked for support during the pendency of the proceedings, attorney's fees, and a partition of the community.

(5) July 21, 1977—Answer by husband to wife's reconventional demand in form of general denial.[1]

(6) January 6, 1978—First supplemental and amending petition of reconventional demand by wife, alleging that a child, Leary Nicole Ogea, was born on November 3, 1977, issue of the marriage between her and husband, praying for custody, child support, and attorney's fees.

(7) January 11, 1978—Answer by husband to wife's first supplemental and amending petition of reconventional demand, in the form of a general denial.

(8) January 11, 1978—Second supplemental and amending petition for divorce by husband, and petition for disavowal of paternity, alleging, inter alia, that: husband and wife had not lived together as man and wife since June 10, 1974; wife was guilty of adultery; a child was born, but that the child was not his; and he proposed to and did disavow the child. He prayed for a divorce and a decree by the Court to the effect that he is not the father of the child, Leary Nicole Ogea, born on November 3, 1977.

(9) January 17, 1978—Motion by husband to have court order wife and child to submit *986 to physical examination involving blood grouping tests designed to show that husband could not possibly be the father of the child.

(10) January 20, 1978—Answer by wife to husband's second supplemental and amending petition for divorce and disavowal of paternity.

In the above posture the case went to trial, after which judgment was rendered as follows:

(1) In favor of husband and against wife granting a divorce "a vinculo matrimonii" under the provisions of La.R.S. 9:301.

(2) Decreeing that husband "is not the father of the minor child, Leary Nicole Ogea."

(3) Rescinding the prior judgment on the rule heard on July 21, 1977, referred to in Footnote 1 herein.

(4) Assessing costs against husband, as head and master of the community of acquets and gains.

As was observed by the trial judge, there seemed to be a close relationship between everyone who testified in this case. In addition to testifying in his own behalf, Joseph called as witnesses his brother, Wallace W. Ogea, and Alma Faye Rogers. Barbara testified in her own behalf and she called as witnesses Mrs. Paulette LaRocca, Orlanda Bass, Regina Ralls (Joseph's niece who is the daughter of Wallace and Leary Ogea), Eunice Hutchins, and Mrs. Wallace (Leary) Ogea.

We find from the record that Joseph and Barbara were married on December 1, 1967, in Orange, Texas. Each had been previously married to other spouses and had children from those unions. They subsequently established a matrimonial domicile in Crowley, Acadia Parish, Louisiana. While being domiciled in Acadia Parish they became separated on June 10, 1974. They have not resumed living together as husband and wife. Joseph has continued to reside in Acadia Parish and was so residing at the time of this trial, March 7, 1978. Barbara apparently continued to reside separately in Acadia Parish for some time, and subsequently moved to Lake Charles, Calcasieu Parish, Louisiana.

Pertinent to this case is the location of four residences on and around Eliza Drive in Lake Charles, Louisiana, all of which are situated in proximity to one another. One residence belonged to Joseph's mother; another residence was Joseph's separate property; a third residence was the home of Wallace Ogea, his wife, Leary Ogea, and their daughter, Regina Ralls; and the fourth residence was owned and occupied by Eunice Hutchins. At different times from the time that Barbara was separated from Joseph she resided in Joseph's house (see Footnote 1) and also resided at the residence of Eunice Hutchins. From the time of the separation of June 10, 1974, Joseph would regularly visit his mother's home and would stay there frequently during his off days, which practice continued even after his mother died in October of 1976.

It is an uncontested fact that Joseph and Barbara saw each other rather frequently from the time of the separation, both in Crowley and Lake Charles, certainly through the last of February or March of 1977.

Barbara contends that she had sexual relations on or about February 11, 1977, with her husband Joseph, which caused her to become pregnant with the child involved in these proceedings. The child was subsequently born on November 3, 1977. She testified that the act of sexual intercourse occurred at Joseph's mother's house. Joseph admits that he saw and talked to Barbara in those surroundings at about that time but he contends that he was never alone with Barbara, and that when he spoke with her at his mother's house, the conversation always occurred outside of the house. There is some testimony that Barbara and Joseph were alone in his mother's house in January of 1977. There is also testimony by Joseph's lady friend, Mrs. Paulette LaRocca, which contradicts Joseph's testimony that Barbara never came into his mother's house while he was there.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Congregation of St. Patrick Roman Catholic Church v. City of New Orleans
575 So. 2d 415 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1991)
Crawford v. Trapani
563 So. 2d 567 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1990)
DeVillier v. DeVillier
543 So. 2d 1142 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1989)
Bonura v. Bonura
505 So. 2d 143 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1987)
Anding v. Anding
480 So. 2d 507 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1985)
Durr v. Blue
454 So. 2d 315 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1984)
Heard v. Heard
424 So. 2d 1177 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1982)
Fontenot v. Thierry
422 So. 2d 586 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1982)
Mock v. Mock
411 So. 2d 1063 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1982)
Hall v. Hall
404 So. 2d 1328 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1981)
Migues v. Migues
398 So. 2d 1279 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1981)
Mock v. Mock
400 So. 2d 248 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1981)
Florent v. Florent
393 So. 2d 912 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1981)
Ogea v. Ogea
379 So. 2d 1104 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1980)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
378 So. 2d 984, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/ogea-v-ogea-lactapp-1980.