Nowata Oil Syndicate v. Commercial Nat. Bank

1923 OK 794, 219 P. 339, 93 Okla. 6, 1923 Okla. LEXIS 300
Supreme Court of Oklahoma·Decided October 16, 1923·No. 11732·Published·Cited by 6 cases

Opinion

*7 Opinion by

JARMAN, O.

This action was commenced by the Nowata Oil 'Syndicate, a copartnership composed of C. W. Eastman, A. L. Sealander, L. A. Lang, W. R. Avery, J. Martin, Earl White. W. H. Kind, Wl W. Gar-wood, Paul Smith, O. L. Sloan, J. H. Burris, - M. Leitner, R. M. TJmstott, R. E. Young, N. C Nyhagen, and John McDonald, as plaintiffs, against the Commercial National Bank, a corporation, as defendant, to recover judgment for $1,500 deposited in escrow with said bank; C. C. Cowdery filed an interplea, setting up that he was the owner and entitled to recover and to be paid out of said $1,500 the sum of $1,415.17 for drilling an oil well for the plaintiff. The case was tried to a jury and a verdict was returned in favor of C. C. Cowdery, interpleader, for the sum of $1,415.17, and judgment was rendered by the court accordingly, from which the plaintiffs bring error.

Among the grounds enumerated by plaintiffs for reversal of this cause, they urge that the demurrer of plaintiffs to the evidence of the interpleader should have been sustained, and that the court should have directed a verdict for the plaintiffs; that the evidence is not sufficient to support the verdict of the jury and the judgment of the court rendered thereon.

The evidence in this ease discloses that the Nowata Oil Syndicate is a copartnership, composed of the persons hereinabove named, and that its . headquarters and principal place of business are at Denver, Colo.; that at some date, the exact time not being definitely fixed, prior to the transactions hereinafter referred to, said Nowata Oil Syndicate was organized, and purchased a certain oil and gas lease located in section 4, township 26 north, range 16 east, Nowata county, Okla., and known as the Clarence R. Rowley lease, from Geo. C.. Waterman, and that it was agreed, as part of the contract, when plaintiffs purchased said lease from Waterman, that Waterman was to superintend the drilling and bringing in of wells that were to be drilled on said lease as said Waterman was an experienced oil man. The plaintiffs decided to drill a well on the Rowley lease and deposited $1,500 in the City Bank & Trust Company of Denver, Colo., to be forwarded to the Commercial National Bank of Nowata, Okla., and there to be held in escrow for the purpose of defraying the expenses of drilling a well on said Rowley lease, and on April 19, 1918, the City Bank & Trust Company of Denver, through its secretary, R. A. Brown, pursuant to instructions given by the plaintiffs, forwarded said $1,500 in a letter of instructions as to the disposition of said funds, to the Commercial National Bank of Nowata. Said letter of instructions being as follows, to wit:

“The City Bank and Trust Co.
“Capital $100,000.00,
“Seventeenth at Arapahoe Street
“Denver, Colo.
“April 17, 1918.
“Commercial National Bank,
“Nowata, Oklahoma.
“Gentlemen:
“Enclosed find cashier’s check for $1,500 endorsed to you, and you are authorized to place this money in escrow in your bank together with a drilling contract for the drilling of an oil well on the northwest quarter of the southeast quarter, and the northwest quarter of the northeast quarter of the southeast quarter of section 4, tp. 26, N. R. 16 east, Nowata county, state of Oklahoma, commonly known as the Clarence R. Rowley tract.
“■Said drilling contract to be in the usual and customary form for drilling contracts in your county. Said escrow agreement and drilling contract to be approved by Paul P. Smith and George C. Waterman, now at the Carey Hotel in Nowata, Oklahoma.
“Yours very truly,
“R. A. Brown,
“Secretary.”

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Nowata Oil Syndicate v. Commercial Nat. Bank, 1923 OK 794, 219 P. 339, 93 Okla. 6, 1923 Okla. LEXIS 300 (Okla. 1923).

1923 OK 794 (Nowata Oil Syndicate v. Commercial Nat. Bank) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Williamson v. Winningham
1947 OK 231 (Supreme Court of Oklahoma, 1947)
Pharaoh & Co. v. Sies
1936 OK 33 (Supreme Court of Oklahoma, 1936)
Nowata Oil Syndicate v. Commercial Nat. Bank
1929 OK 70 (Supreme Court of Oklahoma, 1929)
Prichard v. Dur
1928 OK 330 (Supreme Court of Oklahoma, 1928)
Shuler v. Viger
1926 OK 890 (Supreme Court of Oklahoma, 1926)
Invader Oil Corp. v. Commerce Trust Co.
1925 OK 578 (Supreme Court of Oklahoma, 1925)