Noble, Reginald Arliegh

Opinion

/2 222 .,,/ 55541 5§ l ' / M’MM/// /L/»"

// //12// .2//&

W%%//Z% _ 1_ § 7 222 552 - 772

§§ §§ §

RECE|VED |N CouRT oF chMlNAL APPEALs

/ / 11///, MAY122015 // ///// /// /

752/2222 2 / 222 7 7 ' 7 22 /2§//// /'////22/ //22/ 225 2 222/22/’75/// 25 225/22//2// ./ 2 72 5/22//2// 2// 2 2/'/2/

22 ,/// / /5/72 252/5 2222 '

M//MM 2- 72 225/2 /72 2 ://;/2 272/12 _

bel Acosta, Glewk

b 1 V)€//W:/'”’l ///, ////// ` 52 7 % / 2222212122./2 22 222/52

52 //22////2/ 222/2522 2 /2122 2%2/ _~ 7 {2 2252 2222 2222/52 51

{WI//L//M JH//I //l‘ J//I'// 41 /11// /%//Z M%%/%E

// ////M/,¢W 1522 /2 :/2 /2&2/5/% 2'/2255/

//// /_25”22/2/ 2//1 ///5//2 2/ /2//222§%

g ' 555555555?/

_ " // ) //5/M5M5/5 ///// 55 55524555555553555£55

;///// ' n 7 775/5 , //5551/ 55 W 575 /55/, 5// 5/'/ , ' 7@/5 77l/l ,’ ///5// ///// /////55/"’

555/57 555 ...555 // 1555 // 5/ /'/ 555/55 (5% 455 ~ '///7[5//%/%' %% 555/55 5 5555 / 55 //)'/5 /5/g 55755 557 ,: 5 5755; 555/55555 555?55 555/175 5555/ / v“/555.

755 555 5 555 555 5/555 / 5 555 555///l / 55 555555 557/55 /% ~ 5 ' ' ' 5/

,/§’5'”/55 //5/ 555/557 . 555/555 z 55555%7/5 555/555

/7///7/ / l // //I[’ //_,

/75// 555 n M#// 74 5555/ 555/555/555/5/)

777 /5/555555 /@/5/;5/ 5 ZZ;/% W 77

ill l /A/ l

Z/./’ 555/l /[I 5@/ ’/7 id j . l 5 5 55 //5’/7/ 5.’ y ’ /// 4 //// ,- / /57/%5/ 5/ /// //5 45 / 55 /

WWW/W/// //Wz/// 51/55 / ’ v7 ' 775 %W;Z%- ",/5'/// //-/ ’ //

/1 1 11/11

/IA

"F , 1 111/1171 7;/,1/11 /.11”71/@1 /_ 11 , " 11111// % 1111/11 1111 1111 1/§1/11//11/ /1/ g /111/1

1/1///1 ;11§/11'/

1// 0//’

v 1 1 1/MM ' § 7 1

,/./'._,1_’1, //1. ., 017/11

/1 ,

//7'0//1¢////%y 411 //1/./

,1 11/1’1W1 MIZIF/WO

111;11

/’_ //1//// /% ’1’

g:/77%/114 /1/4 444/444////%771411441%44/ 4441 1111/1444

/W// ;7/1/417 1171% 447/7 74/14 44//% 47 /1§114/// 747/414/44/44 411/147/14 ////

444/411 141/1 4[1 // 7 / /,’, l// 14 741/1//, /,//

I"///'/

4 , 1 / 1444 …,/ 441/444 11 1 4774?44%441/,/4

///’//’/l./ /

711/1 j./ /I//I/”/%’ 141 //,// /4 / li/////,/ Wl/// //1 1111/471;/171/ 777/777 147/544 771 174/445 1417 / 41’///// 7/744/4 41/;/17;/ '. 1 1 ' W v 777"

ZYW//M/ 441/44 15 ’7/ g 411 77 //1/ %W/ / 4£7%

%WWZ// 7;7%/17474// // // l4/44 %14 1177 /1447/ j 777/775 " 1747/1477 7 711/474 77 //4 /;/47:% 44 /7/4/%7 ' _ 4/% 44 441/44 4f

157 4411 / 444/1471 47 / 444 414 ., 4744/74 _1%

n 1141/1 14 4414417114744/ 14/41117/4//74414 744/575

/M

77 755/545 5;:/%:;5 55;5 .. ' , ’ {%j 555 '

5 755/::%/ 575/55755777 7 755/555 757/75/75 7/§/5/'//5 Zj /5/5/555 /5/5’55// %77 ,5@.. 77 7 _.

5 5 5 5 5 755 /5/ ,% % ’%/ / / z/ //l// j / / / / ll l///,A`Z 757/77wa 577 M’”- 777/755

775555575575 7 775 775/7 %777755 77 %7 755/

// M/5 575/555/ 75 " 77 /557/55 755/55%5755

/5%[§7!%/% f% /a,/ 7/ / 5/%/%%5 ZZ/

555/755 755/7 555 5 5 777 //7//:/5577

7//

//, // 77//,/7'/ WW 5 755 57/5/ ,5'/7://57'/77777,; /%/77 57 7% 757 5@5:5:; //55 5 , 7 557/75 %75 555W_ 4 ‘1 l ///5,7/77¢/

555 575/14 /7z "55 '/ // »7

155 /5/:7 //’ /W 5/5/ 555/y //M/?W 55 /// ;/7/5%5’0/% 7/’/ /55/ %

/7/./ 7 / 777 7/757 77,7

5/ %/ 5/IM /é/;;ézé/ /_,/{/;/ /_ / % /

l55 //5/ //:Z:

` .. 577/555

55 555%5

755555//;555 § 5 / § 55 5 , / ¢_' l//// /_//__./ 5/_5_3,/ ;4 577/1755 5 _'5 555”57/5//5/ :5%2/5/ 555/5_2 555¢57555/ _ 555 555/ ////5 //55 5/ /;5/ 55 255%555 5555// 5 5555 M 5 y 5 / 55 //5 /If l //5//: //:5 /f/A/ ’////%/ ’//.W " ///.’ /,//,,/l f/l/ lpg 555/55 555/55 x ‘ 555/5 /llr /////5/// /// 5 ,/l’ ’, 5

MM//,/ WMW/I?WWI/ /5 555 555

555/555 55555 55 5 555/555 555/5555 55/: /5/55

§/ /'/// 5///5%'5/ 55’ ’//////’ 5 //5

J,'/ ;, 5/5,/ j 55 wl /// /:5/5/ 55 55 /}53 5// / 5 555 / 5 /55, / /%5/5 5 /// . h , /%

' //'_’/ ’// /// /d_ ' 555555// 555 5/5§

z , 55 55 55 555 5552£/ /

555/55 5 555 55 5755555// 55 555/5

/ //////

'é//”//////j/’ l//// ll "/’ 1 11,1M/MMM’/jM /I/'Mjl///Mj%' _

11/"11' 115/11M 111/1111 j 11 /

jj/; 11 j 1 j,M/!MM 111

///{///’///1// , /jjjjd///j 1/1j '/jj /1//1/1/ //1 //j/”'/ ,/, /7//£/% j//W/- I/; l / J’ '//1/.//%5/1 // 1 1. ///1`1111 ~ 111 1//1 ///j/j 1'1/1/`j”@q ij ////fj /4/W _§j//E/// //.,1'//1/ 1 ../1// ///// /L/ ’-/ `11’ 7/ /o//j/M%”1/ // /j/ /j/' [/;//// jj/:/j/jl MI////W/ /I’ ’1 // l /_1//11/ .

/1/111/1/i/ /, /'.1j1///z-'jl/j/j//

jj/MIW . / jjjjj/ j/ 157

//

/l// /I 116/j //Ml;/ /jj/jj jj /j jjijij jjij :// j:jj / jj§’

j/jjjjjj:j//% 1 1 //11 /jj/z/;/%/j /j /Wjjj ;j/y% j/jjjj 111/j 161/j /// %/ jjj/ 1/ j'/j jjjj;jjfj/ jjjj

jjj//jj /j%;j /jz: j/j jj/jjy 11 jj /:/j//j/j jj.j jj F/lj//jj; jjj,jj/j/ - /l"/j/ jj //jj%/; g/;/ F/jz //I’ //l// 1211 %/ //H/ t

jj;jj$/ jj/j/j/jj jj/ jj/jjjjj jj %jé/ %/%j%j/;%j/j /jj / //j/*j/ ///§ jj . f/`p/E 515/jj ZJ/// 'j”,// 1 ,1/

@jjj/d/j %:;j///jjjj/ / ;§jj jjj/j/jj

§//" '§§/ '§§§,§§//§§§’ §§§§/§ §§§§§ §§ ,/,/§/. ’//§ / ' , / I§_ /’,//§ ,C/'j ///§ §§ /. W,/M Z/” / ' §/§ /§§/,§ §§ §§ § §§/§§§/§'§

' §§§ §§ j§§ /§§/ § /§ §§§///§ §;///§'§§§ §;/§§/ 7§§§'§§§ %{%§/§§/ §§ §§§/§§7;/ §§§§ § ’/§//Z/ §§§ /§§§/ l ,//, ,7§?:§/§ / / §§€§z§§; ' ,,”' § §/§§§/ §§§/ l, /§§J/ /§§§§ §§§///§§§

/z§§§/§§//§§//§§§/ ”§/§%§ §§§/ §§§/§/§/§j§

l§§§%”jg //_ //§‘ §§§/§ /:§§Z/§// §/§ §§§ §§§§§ /§§§§§ §§ §§ /§§§

/§§§/§/ §§/ ,,/§/§/§ //V/ l / /;

,M/§/ §§§/ _§§§§§ //'§//// / / // //7'v § §§FZ/§§ / §%§Z% ”7/ /

/§/ § §//§ § § §§/ //§"// §§§§ //§§§/§/ §§§§/:/:/%§/§/

/ 1/_///l“/1// il , ' §§

/F§//%§§§f/Q§)/§§ _ § §§§§/ §§§ /§/§/§§§§§§ §

l ' ' § §§§//§ § ~/ § / ‘§7/ /I° ’ é;/ //_,U,/ /_/§/j%// //§ ///l_ l §// {l// i///’/ /// f/I/ _ l _ _/ //4§.¢.,//{;; §/, /§ ZW§j§Z: . "§/§§ §§

° j/’_// / WI%//A/' / .¢,l”z// ?,1,7/ /”W :/l/W/

% ¢//%/ /f//;%//,%// /;M M/

/f/§ z// /’//// /// //// /%%////IM/ ji'/ ////////%/. // '//// // M/// // z//////%///;é

/// /,,// /zd i//// /

w ///////M,/ /// l/////

, / v 4 /’ /M/// IEJ/ /%///7// ///// “ ////// " / /;/ /// B:Z/ ///// /%/; ,///l// /l/W,]/ 7//%/7///%/ /7/…//’ /7/ //M' ' /fI/z// /// %; //// /' / /// //////(/ ///W//,// // , /M;//

' "///d/A////? //// é” " /M

y ,/Mi/,W/%/ ///'”///jw ///”,,;/ 25 %///// 7%§/ Z/j/W jig/y //f;/Z/ /117%/ %/j/ f: //// ///LW/ /’

57 /77’ ////7 éj.77 ' //,/; 7/ 17 777 77% //71////////'// ~,//17/?//// 77§77”7 7%77 _ j) / 77777 f / 777777 777/777

Z% // 'l£ y 4 l v v 1 vi ` {,/ /// ij 7¢%%/ 7:/// / 7/ / /_/ 777 // /77 / /7/ 777777/;7 777 777 /7//7// ,/// ;/;// //4 7// /7;%7;7:/7/ 7%77/ /’ jH: W7/ ,// / 7/€/7%;///% 777 5777 /”” 577/7 7 577/7 7 " 7 77 777777 770/7 7// 77 7777//:/77% , 77/”77 7/ /777;7 7;77§/7@ 777/777 ::% 775 777/77 /77/77 7//7/7 7, ;:77/;//7/77 / / /%7;% 77 /;7”777 /7777/77/ / ' / /77/§ Q//%z//// / 777 77777 7 /77_, 777 55

175/77:/7 //7//7 7 777 ,, 17;%@ 77 /77 731 j77%/7/ 777/g "//777 7777 7777777 . 777 777/77 77 777 7/% /77/’/ 2/:¢4//7 777/7 77 777/777 7 7 77 7/777/ 77 %7777 7 7 77/£/ /% i///Z§%////z//% /-///-///71

` %'Z/?//Z;%/W/z /z//' ///// //%% ?%// ze 1 /%” M%%Z

_ ,,¢1 , W/;z%/%W?Fl€/jz?/::%:/;/W/;/; %%?:%

_ z z§ /Z /K'I/£/'/ . af% M//EW/ »gW/E 1 /;W /////? /%/%%/Mf?/z/}/%Z// K//z///Z// jg'%/z j ./~ M%;/W/%/% z ///I;/§% /¢/z Z/: /% KM/ /¢/ /LW » ’// 1 ,//7////7%% z/¢;/J///W%:%M%… '

%/7/” gz;////z/%'//%_ ¢/%/ /W// f ZW% z//¢W

… ,. 1 ./ %//Z /// ;%W¢//%/;%J/FY //Z¢//%A;%VM”” ' * f /z/” %/%%W// , , j/W // M/ …/ /%/f/E./ ,/Mz/z ¢VZ 4

¢ ", . //M/ ' y ¢€/ './%%////?/7/.%///%%¢%

,// W; YM;WW%%/ZZ/W/

1 , ;z/¢/% ;//%/ M w /@'//¢~/ Wé/ §WZ//z/%z, ’ /% /%/zf//€7?%5/%KW/W/I//kl ” l -' ' 0 /,//W

,’h f ’// 1 / ,14 4 '

'_ //_ / jW/Y/ ~/ /'z?///%//////;/z' _4 '///%%/0

1 …//F/WI///%////U7//W/. B//W%/

-…WW% z li% _~//////¢//,/ »z/ %/////

/7” -ff /;Y ~” W' “ // _%//% %//z ' 3//;§ 15 //?/ /’z%{€VY

%: 1 31 71 1' 113 v y _ § ;§,Z§&p/i// '1;:."? /"/- 3 //1 //// ///// // §

. 131/111:/§,:/ 3

/ //' ’/’

1 73 /51/ /z 1111 /1/ /111/%1 1 b/Z%bbé /3@1?1/1111 //313/ ./1 1/”/ 1 ’

M/W”/W/ /W”IW // _ :/ /l[ // /A' MIW////z/bi/ 1111 1 3111/1311

figb;I//bbzfi/ 3//7/33 /l//i/ //7-13/./1z11 111/11/I l/// /I //V// b// /',"/3,://b// ’ / //////1%% 11 //

_ /1/ .1,' 211 /1’1M/ ,// 11 MIZZ W,/,, ////1/ 1HW /”§1//11'/§§ /1 //1

nmi/1111 '

, .1111111 1, M:M/ib 3 1111/111/11 ` /1

\

` ' 331 s 0 . ,' » * 3 / ,- `, 0 1 ` /"1///¢’731/3/3 1311/111 1 /14///,1’ " ` \11/1/1/ 11 \ /'/ /// _1.” M // (/{ /1'."/ y /,1 ./ / /1, l 1,1/1 // ///i //.,/////_1/,'_ / 41 1 » ”/);.11/,11/ 11 1 11"/””['/¢// /WWZW 1 k y a 0 " _ /11/4'1!/1¢17/%1/1111//1111 1114 1111/1113 111 1 /7 / //1 "

//M,, l’ ,/ /'11////1.’1_//_1/"'_3 ' / //.,111111 111/171/31/1/1111//11311;1% 1 1111/13 b/

'/ / ' 11 » 3

j/f 1111@111/1/%11311113/ 111 /1¢13111113 111/111

11 11111% 11,11 . z%Z/W///i/ / / “’;W/://,1 1 v [//// '1/ //, / , /y 323/3 / 3%%13 . 111/1 ;1134/1111% 1131 /” /b§ 31 13 1// g

- 113/311”1//11/4 ,/1/113”131'/ ”/%I/ 1111 11 / 1 /131 1111/1111 1111 @1/ 111/13 %1; 1//%13 ‘///3/// 1113/1111/111 131 1:;31111 1 1173/113 113 111/333113 3 f /

»'13¢7313131/3/13/3// 3 ' /f%? %//3/%/;/ d%/%:Z/ 1%/ 111111/,-1/11; 111@%/111% /_13 ' MWW%/zé;% 111 11 11/1/1%11/131 1111¢_/;%%3 . / 1151/11 111 511/111 11%§11 11 111/31 1 /,111 , .111111%111/15

311 _11131_%17'/_ 111,31' 1141-

1 . . , '7/ ,1///1.'/,/’/ . f///f//g,’ /'1:4//1/ , 1414 '// '

/ . -// ;/'é///,O- 111//’,./ , '

/1/, ’ ,,/WZ'/ 17 '~ 1 /MMMb// 2111111111;/11 y 0 0 , ll;”/MM”//g//// //, 1/1/11 ’/ ',.//.,’////1//1,' , 111 11 11 s?//ZM/MWM/ 11111//?311' .

‘ 1137

, 1 ///// / 1 , //{I 1 / 1//1@,- ‘1/;/ //) l 5/11/’ 1 /.//{, 1111// /1/ /1%%%1 1111 11 1 11;11 ),W/'W 1/!¢ 111 1111/1%/151/1111§111111 1 111 111/1111 f111111 111/1711 1111/11 ’/'II// 14 l /// / / //,r

1111/1111111”11 , ,, 1 /M@,, » 1 1111/1115 111 /M/

1 1111/11 141/11 / '

11%11/' ' '“/111 1111/11;11,/1 1 ' ,;1117”" ’117”11111”1111 '

1 111111: 111 1 111 1 MWWM /;// // 1 1 ,. // / "M /’/111M //;'§ 111/1 111/////11 /111511111 11 MMWF/ / / ~ A ///// ///// //:/l I/”1 ; W// /1//, ;%/ jj // ` !_/ /»/// /Y W€" W% //// 111 1111/j 111-1111 1 1111 1211

111 1 " 1111 1111/§ 11 11 1 %11/1///`// 1 111/?111 /11§1% /1/1/11 Z/111/1/1 11 1;/1;11 / 1 11

/1%;/;1/;1/ 1111/151;§;1/;1%1§1%;?11 z1/://%/%1111111Z1 /§1:1// y/Y _ .

' 94444/ 4 4744/144 4 41 444 4744444 44 7 /4/ 4 444 441/44 9 771 499 ’/ /// :/7/

11 4 /4 4 4 44444 4M47M/II7WI/I/M 99

W v 4/ 1- 4/97/4/77947494 44 /’4444/ " L/4, 444/4774%4 479 449/249 779 444/14 » 4 ,1 _ 9 499 4 //497 44?9/7?9 444 79 1 ., 9799944949 4%,7// 944/499 414 4 744 /94 425 /9/74/47; 547/979 4 7/ g747 779744479 /4 44 9 /444 944 494/447 444999/ ”4444, / 4 //74 4// /1/4/]1" 479/74

4 1454174 744 4 499 44 4 947 j / /// 9//7/9 19 // 719/¢// j 4/ 774/li 747/94174744/441 417.

/ /‘9 4/1/ / //1;9 //"'9% ;:/9 419/474 /?94944 477/j 7 99 /99977 494 779 49 4 474/4744 449/44 4%44:7

;9§{§/9 74 414/949 417 474ij 7777 499/94 44

777 994 447/44 4 4 /7949 44:4:9::/ 449/979 444/1494 47799 99 9:9% j

449 44 494 447 ?4//47/ 4/94447499479:194/799 744 444/97 447 49 494/444 447;// 94774149979 44 491/949//1/1;//7444/79744 799 /47974/947// 44 4 414//%//4/44(,74 794/1747 7 4 444 447 947 494/4 414/997 49 /:9/4 749 4 1

4447_ 4497 447 ` _77

' /// J// /// l //"// %j? !00%5/ MJ/{/Z ///// 1 /1”/»///1/1/_;15/// 511/f ' 1111 /1/ /1//7 6 ’.'/1:’//’11/ 11,- ///j ////r 11 1 1111/11 / 1111 1111 117 /11111

_// ////// pf ////1/ 1//0 ’ 1/7 _/1-/// // /%//M 11/,, “ / ' 151 1171 13111/11!11/ 111 1%/11/ " 1/ 211 111'1 .,11,1/ %11 11 » 1 111/1111 1:1<1/ 1111§ j 1 1111 w 1~1§11% /j %11:1/11/ "

. .11/1 // )1% WW/. f/, M% 1115 /i//% 1;1/@/%1 11111111/ /// 111/1111 //111

111 1 111/1 1;/11111/1:/111 1 /W 1:1%/%%11[%

1 1:: . 1%1111% 1,;1;;:/1/11 1111§1//1/1 1111 1111 ////111/1 1/;/1/ / 111111%11/% ~ 111 // 11/1111::11//1//11/1;111(1/111/ f

.§ZZl//;Z ////// 1 j/././/’ ' ////Z /[<’f§

1111 /1111111/11/1111/1/' _ 1 / 11 111 1111 1 / 111 1 '1/ 1111,/

§///1 '/ /// MMMW ,,/1 111/j z%1111/%/@11111 1111 111%£11/

~ %11 111 1111 iga/11 1111/115 / f 51'//

%1§/1///

/ Z¢/€/%//f LW/%%;r% %// /Z//;/€jé;@/’/Y/Z/ 1 //M%_ /O I/L/ JM/Y/'~ / ff/// 277/f ' / ./ __ 4 , " j ,/ ’ /4"////, 4 ' 4 ZIZ////////,///,./ '1M/‘

/'#// //,4¢ //%% /// //M' 1 y /#//‘%€// w ` »\%JW//' %//5/////5/§/ H%%;z %ZZ'/ % / . %¢; W/EW gr%/f£¢/” ’%/`/Z”/' "z%%z ;///%%/ /F/?/%;//%%/%%U ///S”W%,%// // %/;/M z 7a %/y//§i;g%/% 4 h / _ ' %/ M ///a/M //A€ /- W/%%/z/ f 7/ /%/////%4 -

, = 7 / ///I 0 ' 4 4 / ,_ 1 M/////z%//z/LW,¢/%%:%// /%¢/%///,W/QMW/;//¢W 45 /f./

77 /H f . _- 1 , 0 d / 1 11 d 14 ' ///W%//;z/;%¢%/…@//ZWZ%// /4 / _./ 4

"`7%411 ” /7

[// _

7/% % /@M //V’a” // / / (7/ /// ’#% J% 7/%/ /0///}, '//// “'I./. , /é,////K%/I% 4./~'/7,4"/ /// / '//’ '4,4//1%!/ /7%/ , ’/@Z/§§// €%N %4%// 554/7

/W/§/M/% `//// ,-4¢// //%/QW/%z%¢ Lz%z 4 / F///% "¢` 7 JI//WL§//I /W// / - s ' /4: 4 I/ /////! //?///%/A%/// W//%z %WM// 4

' ///z//%/% /WA%//%_ ZI//% /J/%%/%/%I/f%”//?/j/I//z?j% ”%%/WW% »%/;§%%//

v // /WW///, /zg¢/;/’é;// c z /‘/ 1%%;§%/%%5””%%%%” ' %/

%/7 _

l //'///”//4 ',,0 , ` j 541/1 {//W/W/"W/%/%W@//¢ , ///'MM/ 7,/)%5 €f////%%/:///?/%@”// .[/ ,/1?;/%////; 01%%/%?% %”/0/;;///%/ //// //?;;//%

‘ / ` d 1'…%%7%//¢ /4?//@/ %/ .

¥, 1‘i,

54 ' ‘ z . j/¢ ,.z///, 411/7

UW ' ' .4/%//7/ y z %%7/' 4

// ,M d/ // €/ , _

j 1 /4/ /MF ,/ ' M '/%//z//"/// ,/// - %1!//%////% / /z////' ' ~ /4/;//4;/1€

/I` ' 1 //w/¢// /"

M{// 1 - ’z/// //1 %7/

1 ,_§//// ~ %:Z://Zé;/Z%

/ /

w /v %/;54/4/:/7;7%0 v/ / %%% %//MM 29 y ,/,// 544 '/f %/1/31 “

711/f

,-».,l ,.¢

v ,. /Z/"/// 554

t /') /1/@ - j /;_/// 7/71:1-'1 rj/

. 55 ///

575 z /7[ [/5:’ ,._./_/.//{/L.. l// .,/ _./; , _ 1 /57/5

jé////&//W/M” /’z////"*'j////”-//¢%? 1145/55 ///5 4 , j Wj}’ d . 4 4 , l

`

f

. . ,, /755//5%/%1/// 155 555 1/ .¢: 4 4/77'/1’(/524/ ;2,5/1555/5///////5555/, 555;/;,:55 _ 4 515/j 5///5//1/¢/1// ./ /5 5 5 155 ,,//1/1;;/?/) 59 ///5,1// 5: /5 ¢

/4 / -' 1 » /

» ~1]. . ». ". 4 ` “ ~ ’: ` ' .. . l l ' 4 / ff .» ,r 7 / )) , x 4 f » ¢

555/55 551/5

.L ' m %'%//1 . /1>%

,»` §§ 4 7///%;//’ ' //

4 ,~ , 4 - 4. / - 4 _ / . . _ 1 ~ / 4 . , y .4 4 .1 / .': 11 ‘ 4 ' . 1 ,1'41 / /'Z//// 1£>' 172 / ~ ' . ' / 11 11',»<<' 11»,' ` ‘ ' ¢,~-:\€'4-",“,»":`- .’ ‘:‘~ = ~'-~ ~ l <\- . rV' /11/ » [ :'_/-1:.» 4/// , ',1. . /' //, '

/5”‘:5 55 41 //7 17 _ ` f/Q///,¢ 555 1 'f v 4, . .L. , 5 5 55

--__._,.

4 .

. c ¢_rf. ._.mx>m Om=<=z>r _r><3 50§000_ 00_.00000 005.< 2 0 558 00__ 20_03< 230__ 00 00332300 22 0.5:0 0020020_03< z 5 5 050£3 03 50 50_ 250 25300 505 . . § 0 0000~< 200003 00 003300 3 m00203 ._.o~ 205 0000 2 0§_0_80 0250 50 0235_.0083 250 220:00 2 025@ §500_0~0 365 8__0§3@ 50 023330083 250 050300..030 503 50 50§000_ 500 2 0§5:0_0 50 0000_< 200003 2 200 0 003< 8 50 220300 030 §0<< 503 0 0000_< <<00003 2005 00 500 2 0§5=09 2 , § 50 55<5:0_ 500 20<_000_< 0003 2505 003<_0"00 2 03< 20_03<~__ _ A>V __200 5 m0983 w£mx$_ >&0_0 A~.S_ 0000 2 05350_ 30300. 020“ 2 _. . . _ § 22 2505 50 50@303~ 003850 03 _03_.332_<0 2,_305@ 0300_. m0\0~83 @@Amxmv. >3_0_0 $.S_ 0000 2 953503 3000020.

`mmn=.§u §§ 8 333 Bw0zmq § 0§030_.03`

mcuoz. O. mxomv.:cz>r mmszzcmm 1 00 @S..S. or>mm_m_o>joz on ommmzwmm Oc._,m_om jim oocm. 52 0200@05 2 5._0 53050203 03< 003<§._03 32 020500 2033 0 2000. 02_03 0300_. 55 0000 050__ 00 0_0$.2_00 00 8__0$0..

3 __20_03< 2 50 5:0 00200__ x 53030033302 5 0 003:03:0€ _,.... 2. 580 8 50.020300 00 0 00005_0 0:3_055035 _ _

§ ._0_050 w 3_00030032__ = 50 25300 5 32 0.20“03< 030 003=30. 502 5 0 __0~ a 03X00 8 50 2533 00 0 00005_0_00.355303:

§ ._9000 0 350050032._ 2 50 020300 _0 0035500_0 0< 230 03_<.

UO m._m.»~. vmz>§._mw nom m_mnm>.~. >zU I>m§.C>_¢ mm_¢Oz< .Omwmzommm._ . . _

ll|||||ll\|| ||||.|.|.¢l|ll

830 20<`.2.0= 52 §§ 50 ~0§0000 3 03052`

205 § §§9.3,`_ _2 5 5 050<<3 03 50 50_ 2 0 2030 5__ 20_03< 2303§. 00_0.0300_. m003_03 B.@m@ 2 03 50 50_ 2 0 5=0.00200 883< 52 50 0203003~ 500 0003 0300 u220 0.03<§00 2 0 20_03<. 03 003<_0:03 50 050__ 00 0_._35500 8_. 0 000030.00@_200 20_03<.

205 .§. g 39.§ 3 x z 50 050<5 03 50 50_ 2v 0 220 _.

»..0_03<

0035500_0 0302 m00"83 §.@20¢ 55 50 0203003" 500 20<_00.0_<_0003.

3,_30__< 003<§00 2 55 208 §_ 20_0.3_00_ 03 003<8~_03 50 0203002 230= 00 00350500 22 0.5.=0-00@..00 20_03<. .

§ : :._0 0:0<<3 03 50 50,_ 2 0 085 5__ 20_03< 003_0_300_0 030_0_. w00:03 §_wmmmv 503 50 0.0203003~ 500 20<~000__\ 0003 250=< 003<_080 2 58 20_03_09 030 50 000030 20<_000 20_03< 003<§83 5 8_. 03 25300 503 0000:00 000,000002 8 50 333 20<_000 003<_0:03 50<5@ 000050 330__ 03 003<_0:03 50 00203003" 0:0__ 00 §55300 8_. 0 00003.0.00@2.00 20_03<.

§ _3, z _0. 050<<3 03 50 50_ 2 0 088__.0__ 20_03< 0035500_0 502 m00:03 §.00@ 0_. 03 50 50_ 2 0 5:.0.00@_00 34083< 503 50 0203002

' " snis¢;\=rr.~;}z_v.__~.w..-_~.~=-.._~=.~»-.- r~v'~x~ x

,,0_<_.0838_. 505

_umz>_r GOOm wo vs AN d

h

500_ 0003 0300 0220 003<§00 20 20_03<_ 003_0500 8_. 0 000030-0020_0 20_03<.

_ fill § x _.~ _0 050<<3 03 50 5.0_ 2 0 000030-00

505 0003 0300 0220 003<_080 2 0 20_03<_ 3500 22 0 2._§.&0200 20_03<.

§ : 3 _0 050<<3 03 50 50_ 2 0 32.00@_.00 20_03< 52 50 0203003» 500 000_3 03.00 0220 003<_080 2 0 20_03.<_ 03 003<§83 50 230__ 00 003_.0500 0<_ _3.303003302 5 50 52=§030_ 0§083 2 50 l1080 00003303~ 2 033_30_ 000:00 81_20_. 2 8_. 03< 523 2 32 520 503 00 <00; 2 _050 503 30 <020. 5.00_0503 8 __.32503503~. 03 _30~<500_ 50< 00 003_0500 0< 0 330 32 8 0x0000 w._c_ooo. . _ 4 4

|!|/III

830 Eos.u.o: 52 §." 00 32003 3 03050`\

§E. .§. §=.§§.§_\ : = 5 050<<3 03 50 5.0_ 2020_03<_01035050~ 50 0203003~ 500 20<_000_< 0003 330__< 003<§

50 500030 20<800 5_03< 003<§_03 30 22 03 25300

03 003<5:03 50 050__ 00

200 20_03< 50~ 50 0203005 03 003<§83 50 050__ 50 003.

§§V. § § 3202 z 5 5 050<<3 03 50

503 0 205 _.~.0= 20_03< 0035500__0 0302 m00=03 ._N.QHS 502 50 0203. 002 500.20 _0§_<000_3 _,_30__<.003<580 2 55

0003" 8 50..3§ 205 00 003<_0:.03 50<5@ 0000330 330_ … . . 230__ 00 003_0500 0< _.52503303" 5 50 5052830_ 05<. . 00U033033.2.033._50_ 0053_0081:0. 01203 <00$ 2 _000 503 § <00~0.

§ >.003~03003~ 050= 00 0035500 0:32_003302 550 52_.8:.030_ A>V. 50 0203003. _0 003<_0200 2 03 220350~ . € 0300_. m00:03 ~N_m§. 0030_ 0000" § 552 m0.0:03 mo.oi£§_ 0030_ 0000.

023_.3500 50 020300 §5 50 582 0__<_. 2 _

_ A§.c302 w00:03 wo.o~. 0030_ 0000_ 03§30¢ . .~_03 § 2_50»_ 000=03. x 50 0203002 005333_…3¢00 250_@%033@@@,__%030500 582 8 00.53_~ 0_._.0_03< 0002500 0< mcc00$.@_.005 3 2 § 2. 0 20_03< 0302 m02_03 E_.: 2 -.o:_ 0030_ 0000.“ 030. .

. Amv 50. 0203003~ 500 0003 20<_.000_ 0103¢00_ 2 _002 030 2 2505 5 03 220300..

. 2 50 0203003~ 8 <_0_0~0 2 000¢0 50 <§_5 00§.

3 03002 m02_03 .G.mm 23&@_ v030_ 0000“ _ _ 03002 m00~__03 §.:_ mm.o:. NN.o§. 2~0_

V 3502 m00:03 mo_o£mx£. 0030_ 0000_

M_n_vhw§§a 50 25300 §5 50 582 8 <8_08 2 0000“ n 0_. . _

< 003<880 2 58 20_03<

0~_ §§ 030

x 50 0203003~

HOB»LE§ .REG~INA§L " HKH:-' ~ ‘ '“-'

.Form 2ll-FIN-AL SHEET

AND rHE GRAND JURORS AF"RESAID do further present upon their oaths, that prior to the commission of the aforesaid offense by the said REGINALD ARLIEGH NOBLE, to~wit: on the 26TH day of MAY, A.D. 1992, in the 265TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT of DALLAS County, Texas, inn cause number 'F91-72411-UR on the docket of said Court, the said REGINALD ARLIEGH NOBLE under the name of REGINALD NOBLE, was duly and

' . l . . __ _ ' \. - . in said last named Court of a felony, to-wit:

|__l Cb

egally convicte UNAUTHORIZED USE OF A MOTOR VEHICLE, as charged in the indictment, upon an indictment then legally pending in said last named Court and of which said Court had jurisdiction; and said conviction was a final conviction and was a conviction for an offense committed by him; the said REGINALD ARLIEGH NOBLE, prior to the commission of the offense hereinbefore charged against him, as set forth in the first paragraph 4hereof, v

AND THE GRAND JURORS AFORESAID do further present upon their oaths, that prior to the commission of each of the aforesaid offenses »was prior to the commission of the offense set forth in the first

paragraph hereof,

Againsl the\peacc and dignity of the State. 4 n _ ' BILL HILL l/M

Criminal Districf Attomey, Da.llas County, Tcxns. \J Foreman of the Grand _]ux)l

\'_hereof,

AND THE GRAND JURoRs AFoREsA'iD do further present upon their oaths, that prior to the commission of each of the aforesaid offenses by the Said REGINALD ARLIEGH vNOBLE, tO-wi`t: 011 the 17T‘H day Of JULY, A.D. 1987, in the CRIMINAL DISTRICT COURT of DALLAS County{ Texas, in cause number' F87-77432-KH -on the docket of said Court, the said REGINALD ARLIEGH NOBLE under the name of REGINALD ARLEIGH NOBLE,`was' 'duly and legally convicted in said last named Court of a felony, to~ wit: BURGLARY OF A BUILDING, as charged in the indictment, upon an indictment then legally pending in said last named Court and of which said Court had jurisdiction;.'andk said conviction was a 'final conviction and was a conviction for an offense committed by him, the said REGINALD ARLIEGH NOBLE, prior to the commission and conviction of the offense hereinbefore charged against him, in the second paragraph hereof, and said commission and conviction set forth in this paragraph was prior to the commission of the offense set forth in the first

Againsl the peace and dignity of the State. - d - _ l BILL HILL ' l/M/

_ \ 1 Crimina.l District Attomey, Dalias County, Tcxas. `r’ Fore_man of ,the Grand _] ury