Newsome, Edward R.

Texas Supreme Court

Newsome, Edward R.

DecidedFebruary 17, 2015

DocketPD-0102-15

StatusPublished

This text of Newsome, Edward R. (Newsome, Edward R.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Texas Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Newsome, Edward R., (Tex. 2015).

Pincite

Opinion

/W/^VjZtMlA^f i

FEB 17 2015

^P, Clark

COURT OF C /f^f/^VhMtJfg^L FEB 17 2015

AmJL m^Je//Wc/^

fatty 6 M^MfoJ /U^#k/-/£As/%&&e&

^y -i&vrl /jiAsist Zee/'S-/ok&s l/S SivfrSk&dtJ' 3r£^ ll^YyZ^/M?6^ Af7^

fates* "fUs'&dO&tS&eJ Oddd/St kfafr/ZAifa). . . _..' /hJrhltou foe/Md 7^/ // yvdt

/(-/t~yl?nz^l\cy 17/7,1),.). U ^ xr,

•^NLy/AaricW f^ A4?J 7ye(a/ / s a/&U /dd2adfdA^Jd' d&d£&d± 4.3 dzAAAW &»*,»*

~MjA1 m^e/AyJ «yds ASTA%3ed/ddUJ /hAT/^dAhfA ddf€A (/5 AA

fA/ATj*j\A(AAdJ.Ald: joI 4°A-.AA>^. dtfAA>^A) ^ufid^/vAfrA! /dleddy dWfAe^&^/dtAd &/WWce/ AAcf deddd^ddML7d^sdd&d tM>Al /kAntfSdz^dddceAAd/oJtdj d^yd**/ "iwidc%A. fleJei\teA AAxfeAjteA jdj^fe**dAs* yL

SUA Ma/_ fowjAHtsd ™ (-e^cd /A AifiaJ fcA&

yPd^A^d^f^ ^Jd! ^dAdd^a*/&/^d &dW?fe/f-iJt, ?W oAded &e4fofeya£-~ ^SlA-fid/d-^ ,Ah/potTeJ /Avffatedddd/ -fiA&loL /Id Arf/ZAtfeyiA AtfaeAl UeU ^d&yi^^dyvu AHdd ChiAd aIo&S /WdAw^Afafl*42fl& d <^/kAT A^/hAfcn*.) d/L/hAlA>?iJ AAsAA ^/d StdAsfc^

(dkoJ zdfnAd yWAdtd^ AfydUCGcAldd&d yf- AttAtAd MA/y^AyVQATsVyd ^Wj,/7^/i, / /Mfodd AAA^y* $A&J Mdy bd//%AoiiddA^ust' 6MAt Add A~-/dvJ idd Adddvdvdu^d dAAA hxAAAtVtJJtoWvd^/dfdAkd&yA/tA . . . . . -. /,•-/-•-//• &Ahdkj7d*\ ^^A^^^AA/dA'd'/liAA^/hed) (HAUAdSe/ Ah /d dji/AdAe^Sdd^A fod^lA 7%yd) ddcd^A ^ATdAdd tddAZ £ddy) fmAidA/v^QflyfM&dl tfteteedrsiA Ui ir^dy/M il^fAAtoL) 6M1A6 AhAAAJ TrddW/W&Uefif- « -jU/foteJ d id dojdfod AW^At^A ew«™r duA/d dun fteb uddyy -A*/ Addd/tfAy deA Slide/ AASc/dddfAbu/izrAtf A6d,e^y Ao A', cUy4A6 Ado/CnedAwAhyV^cJ dd^&a^^f^d*d^duvi' 3 V0l A ^(W f^^dwJdddAyl-,,,i*A '-^y

AAr /A

7fe /yJ-d&A /%%T<^ €?dd^'(yddA ydd/

fo/fadj^d/>yAdd> dbxed/hS/d/flA&ote/ -fa AeAec/es'Ah drtd&v;-/%/&w7' -Ae/AZoogtidaf *U oldeteKiJid dU/ ledd S'uddciml^ >d> AceuJ -A^u ^i/ideAce/ JyVde/ /dhtAv>sf'Ad<^/e/ d id>A ideAb A?f rydyd d?dd'A^Sc*wdA^^vd„ OleAm. £ Aft- h%/L M-d I/dmAjddWdA

U3i. LzB. TdiMdMjA^ lows A&ffeJ'Ja>A£tSAfegdfa ^ 'y&ttiA ' '~%A%ALy™/~> //A/y/P^y

fv/ly le/H#A-h file/&?, AA**) A^^y^d/yycAAj.rcdA^ i /tdfae^/friyw-A^/ede^Tcy^^^-A^^ddd Qrr&lJ^AA^A],9^AAd/7Y£ A^yd/?d<.c ^ {*JHfc\(ta, Yd) JAy^d^a^A'^da^tfAides *A^z&ioeAs ^£X$dL^,dd,AA.Aa) r(U^mdm^ ^.cy/d,//,/^

(P /Wd&wd^AAr%^ (".0utd'/y dddl^w/ld APd>A/c 'fre,': FAmPj/-£e>Ar aU>as^s 7Ta>, a, #wm6

AD -A/o^t - AT

AMfA/dd MAfcd d/J> /#kteA d, /T/rdrftei*/7 A^ydA/Pd /M,6L»,firf /J ddrd ?/?, //

r- -dl^ df^dlad't:djarfs/d-/AL). x6\-01 ^J

MmjA AeA/uesrA>A A/m/AeddbuAfed d AtdAU^y-ddA •AC /to /yjVOCp/cey A> /^/^d^9zdd#//d&nei/c-JZ 7^/^dc, /d/2dd//^A^yH^cddzdAdd-AtddZdd

&dMd^WSkl^±dd ZW'-dCeA ^Adr^^,^/md<; uAyAeAsdMslgj-^.Lt -/- d PJsJAO J -- 3o.2. AA/yd AJsy^R. I§L dv /A%fpwd issues ddTdds od£#&d /d JZjPAza.Kd fi'AkiA'sf OwnyhyMd &d' MGuyed?> /%byr? Adass S/Ad3 mr;38,A (d drt & d&d/cd £/&ed/d £ddz..% de&SdvdA/ndsd 70 AfGd /*A £*kL22A£ dtus, y

•iltidd Apu/id d fata 3®' r dA~d»e/d ddddted /d aLIsJ XRd„ 6) ujdi d?li>/l0djd> &(7k^7Jy»ey/?/€ Attodfidr/?Afj#A /d %Jj>s/o. *//<£) dp /ton*i*fJ*rr/ iSiAtfJl#hed /d /LL,3A.y fie disdddd>&'d 'ft Ad AH/

v^&.fdd^ddzs /b.Cfcc/&^a&0d&&e>/ffif t^lf,/^^ ^d^/ddtesA^^Av t/Jiict 37-3 ^d W2J

1^Z/£d^X£§W^d t £?FddAtAS- Att^dfifeddot ddy(d^A%^y ^l£ey Ui/ded Jdfes cCed/douAd /A^dd^A. Z9-X #-S. titt* #3* cd/d:/?/¥•> 9 Z dd.ddd, :atf*Wl/W£oy>AA^/UdAA^ A^WyjL*7Ay,F^ ,Wdhbdes Ah^Tdddd/h/h/d^-7^^y^Sdl Afafynr ^^m^er%^/d/i^fisddWc^y^dz^sd -.. '/dJsyP^y/9S &U AiJd^dm>yd yft ^46dfj A^£AAA. ,„„ sKsr,, wd-dyrrjdd>y/d Aid dffwd Ate; d/AyMSA&ddA -^fiUtd-do Mfedjrfeyrusted j uuoh /*/'/&t7Alt«gi •fodfy

ee.

Cf>ey Mel UTtysSeS'. A PdFoAde&AJcey ' (Agcowed eJdd^dmmd/mics-d-AA'6 _ &dd»j^d^^ddddd idd'ji'/Ad**'/^e/k'0&^^d?%A%%k LjkfofM/cJd* ^^dMZ?d^A/^£ '^^mdddriW^^ uiUaI A"~ iy'*?i //\_ 0LS£yyVC&( /)CALd l^y

-3 ^Msmis AouAJ.sd cJiXLaa. ^hd/he4ds defiedy^/^Ad/fcdy&dd uLeA Udfmkd do JeoTdv dAeAl/sd^f/ A/fa/jA/todt&id Bdm^&us aA&fry; lv(Y^ddkMAA/, kMv\edpddd^^Adcdyftdh*si DouAleyOeod/MOd AAJy/Adrd/eddo AdJhcTAftdbsnA ddAddldL (diAAAi'e/ hJ0wd d /ydiyV5t7dAA& dAedd/did/A^ *d A>/// ttd€4/ec^ &AAeyitey^ dddtfed ihey/ /AdiA!A<7WuiAf7

MMMd^^r d?JJec7 ad dU/Ad)^jJs qFemcAa/^ A^Si^Cey^AAAuAS^i /KA^^rAkoyZ edlddey^it-

fird>(& ^ / W ^ ^ W ^ ^ ^ ^ ,dw> A \^#^(^™ ^^*rt/tfaA^^j de/A^A ;A^ecfy^A?fr

•AULy A&amaa /HA ddddMsAUd'dtf udAfe* (MdAWx 1< ?™"rL dd"^ dtyft* ^"idd/s-ak&ttoe. td^dist M Ao Atddd d^de/mXtoeZ/sruey- Id dUy APAAryrfA,, I/fa*6e^dtej5wh>„ dddd/d)'ddd'd , '^-('^jrtp ifo id-AAyA- /mm), lUySuF/i^e¥cdld 4/icm/Cd Skcxdd/ttrdtbes /WhSudd d<^/UJdt.ydd dffc n*A(\;ui- M<

ddzyAAuAZd fold «2T

3

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

/W/^VjZtMlA^f i

FEB 17 2015

^P, Clark

COURT OF C /f^f/^VhMtJfg^L FEB 17 2015

AmJL m^Je//Wc/^

fatty 6 M^MfoJ /U^#k/-/£As/%&&e&

^y -i&vrl /jiAsist Zee/'S-/ok&s l/S SivfrSk&dtJ' 3r£^ ll^YyZ^/M?6^ Af7^

fates* "fUs'&dO&tS&eJ Oddd/St kfafr/ZAifa). . . _..' /hJrhltou foe/Md 7^/ // yvdt

/(-/t~yl?nz^l\cy 17/7,1),.). U ^ xr,

•^NLy/AaricW f^ A4?J 7ye(a/ / s a/&U /dd2adfdA^Jd' d&d£&d± 4.3 dzAAAW &»*,»*

~MjA1 m^e/AyJ «yds ASTA%3ed/ddUJ /hAT/^dAhfA ddf€A (/5 AA

fA/ATj*j\A(AAdJ.Ald: joI 4°A-.AA>^. dtfAA>^A) ^ufid^/vAfrA! /dleddy dWfAe^&^/dtAd &/WWce/ AAcf deddd^ddML7d^sdd&d tM>Al /kAntfSdz^dddceAAd/oJtdj d^yd**/ "iwidc%A. fleJei\teA AAxfeAjteA jdj^fe**dAs* yL

SUA Ma/_ fowjAHtsd ™ (-e^cd /A AifiaJ fcA&

yPd^A^d^f^ ^Jd! ^dAdd^a*/&/^d &dW?fe/f-iJt, ?W oAded &e4fofeya£-~ ^SlA-fid/d-^ ,Ah/potTeJ /Avffatedddd/ -fiA&loL /Id Arf/ZAtfeyiA AtfaeAl UeU ^d&yi^^dyvu AHdd ChiAd aIo&S /WdAw^Afafl*42fl& d <^/kAT A^/hAfcn*.) d/L/hAlA>?iJ AAsAA ^/d StdAsfc^

(dkoJ zdfnAd yWAdtd^ AfydUCGcAldd&d yf- AttAtAd MA/y^AyVQATsVyd ^Wj,/7^/i, / /Mfodd AAA^y* $A&J Mdy bd//%AoiiddA^ust' 6MAt Add A~-/dvJ idd Adddvdvdu^d dAAA hxAAAtVtJJtoWvd^/dfdAkd&yA/tA . . . . . -. /,•-/-•-//• &Ahdkj7d*\ ^^A^^^AA/dA'd'/liAA^/hed) (HAUAdSe/ Ah /d dji/AdAe^Sdd^A fod^lA 7%yd) ddcd^A ^ATdAdd tddAZ £ddy) fmAidA/v^QflyfM&dl tfteteedrsiA Ui ir^dy/M il^fAAtoL) 6M1A6 AhAAAJ TrddW/W&Uefif- « -jU/foteJ d id dojdfod AW^At^A ew«™r duA/d dun fteb uddyy -A*/ Addd/tfAy deA Slide/ AASc/dddfAbu/izrAtf A6d,e^y Ao A', cUy4A6 Ado/CnedAwAhyV^cJ dd^&a^^f^d*d^duvi' 3 V0l A ^(W f^^dwJdddAyl-,,,i*A '-^y

AAr /A

7fe /yJ-d&A /%%T<^ €?dd^'(yddA ydd/

fo/fadj^d/>yAdd> dbxed/hS/d/flA&ote/ -fa AeAec/es'Ah drtd&v;-/%/&w7' -Ae/AZoogtidaf *U oldeteKiJid dU/ ledd S'uddciml^ >d> AceuJ -A^u ^i/ideAce/ JyVde/ /dhtAv>sf'Ad<^/e/ d id>A ideAb A?f rydyd d?dd'A^Sc*wdA^^vd„ OleAm. £ Aft- h%/L M-d I/dmAjddWdA

U3i. LzB. TdiMdMjA^ lows A&ffeJ'Ja>A£tSAfegdfa ^ 'y&ttiA ' '~%A%ALy™/~> //A/y/P^y

fv/ly le/H#A-h file/&?, AA**) A^^y^d/yycAAj.rcdA^ i /tdfae^/friyw-A^/ede^Tcy^^^-A^^ddd Qrr&lJ^AA^A],9^AAd/7Y£ A^yd/?d<.c ^ {*JHfc\(ta, Yd) JAy^d^a^A'^da^tfAides *A^z&ioeAs ^£X$dL^,dd,AA.Aa) r(U^mdm^ ^.cy/d,//,/^

(P /Wd&wd^AAr%^ (".0utd'/y dddl^w/ld APd>A/c 'fre,': FAmPj/-£e>Ar aU>as^s 7Ta>, a, #wm6

AD -A/o^t - AT

AMfA/dd MAfcd d/J> /#kteA d, /T/rdrftei*/7 A^ydA/Pd /M,6L»,firf /J ddrd ?/?, //

r- -dl^ df^dlad't:djarfs/d-/AL). x6\-01 ^J

MmjA AeA/uesrA>A A/m/AeddbuAfed d AtdAU^y-ddA •AC /to /yjVOCp/cey A> /^/^d^9zdd#//d&nei/c-JZ 7^/^dc, /d/2dd//^A^yH^cddzdAdd-AtddZdd

&dMd^WSkl^±dd ZW'-dCeA ^Adr^^,^/md<; uAyAeAsdMslgj-^.Lt -/- d PJsJAO J -- 3o.2. AA/yd AJsy^R. I§L dv /A%fpwd issues ddTdds od£#&d /d JZjPAza.Kd fi'AkiA'sf OwnyhyMd &d' MGuyed?> /%byr? Adass S/Ad3 mr;38,A (d drt & d&d/cd £/&ed/d £ddz..% de&SdvdA/ndsd 70 AfGd /*A £*kL22A£ dtus, y

•iltidd Apu/id d fata 3®' r dA~d»e/d ddddted /d aLIsJ XRd„ 6) ujdi d?li>/l0djd> &(7k^7Jy»ey/?/€ Attodfidr/?Afj#A /d %Jj>s/o. *//<£) dp /ton*i*fJ*rr/ iSiAtfJl#hed /d /LL,3A.y fie disdddd>&'d 'ft Ad AH/

v^&.fdd^ddzs /b.Cfcc/&^a&0d&&e>/ffif t^lf,/^^ ^d^/ddtesA^^Av t/Jiict 37-3 ^d W2J

1^Z/£d^X£§W^d t £?FddAtAS- Att^dfifeddot ddy(d^A%^y ^l£ey Ui/ded Jdfes cCed/douAd /A^dd^A. Z9-X #-S. titt* #3* cd/d:/?/¥•> 9 Z dd.ddd, :atf*Wl/W£oy>AA^/UdAA^ A^WyjL*7Ay,F^ ,Wdhbdes Ah^Tdddd/h/h/d^-7^^y^Sdl Afafynr ^^m^er%^/d/i^fisddWc^y^dz^sd -.. '/dJsyP^y/9S &U AiJd^dm>yd yft ^46dfj A^£AAA. ,„„ sKsr,, wd-dyrrjdd>y/d Aid dffwd Ate; d/AyMSA&ddA -^fiUtd-do Mfedjrfeyrusted j uuoh /*/'/&t7Alt«gi •fodfy

ee.

Cf>ey Mel UTtysSeS'. A PdFoAde&AJcey ' (Agcowed eJdd^dmmd/mics-d-AA'6 _ &dd»j^d^^ddddd idd'ji'/Ad**'/^e/k'0&^^d?%A%%k LjkfofM/cJd* ^^dMZ?d^A/^£ '^^mdddriW^^ uiUaI A"~ iy'*?i //\_ 0LS£yyVC&( /)CALd l^y

-3 ^Msmis AouAJ.sd cJiXLaa. ^hd/he4ds defiedy^/^Ad/fcdy&dd uLeA Udfmkd do JeoTdv dAeAl/sd^f/ A/fa/jA/todt&id Bdm^&us aA&fry; lv(Y^ddkMAA/, kMv\edpddd^^Adcdyftdh*si DouAleyOeod/MOd AAJy/Adrd/eddo AdJhcTAftdbsnA ddAddldL (diAAAi'e/ hJ0wd d /ydiyV5t7dAA& dAedd/did/A^ *d A>/// ttd€4/ec^ &AAeyitey^ dddtfed ihey/ /AdiA!A<7WuiAf7

MMMd^^r d?JJec7 ad dU/Ad)^jJs qFemcAa/^ A^Si^Cey^AAAuAS^i /KA^^rAkoyZ edlddey^it-

fird>(& ^ / W ^ ^ W ^ ^ ^ ^ ,dw> A \^#^(^™ ^^*rt/tfaA^^j de/A^A ;A^ecfy^A?fr

•AULy A&amaa /HA ddddMsAUd'dtf udAfe* (MdAWx 1< ?™"rL dd"^ dtyft* ^"idd/s-ak&ttoe. td^dist M Ao Atddd d^de/mXtoeZ/sruey- Id dUy APAAryrfA,, I/fa*6e^dtej5wh>„ dddd/d)'ddd'd , '^-('^jrtp ifo id-AAyA- /mm), lUySuF/i^e¥cdld 4/icm/Cd Skcxdd/ttrdtbes /WhSudd d<^/UJdt.ydd dffc n*A(\;ui- M<

ddzyAAuAZd fold «2T

3

w^3 evntfee/'Ad d?mwyd /hoi ATmtAA/dddy do A^Anyn^/yredyded^d %bdd f& dUZ /A/Ajfay)'A?At^dyWyd^yZ/d^dAn d^dAFoF/r^//^f&d/h AfAyyA/hni^^yy^AA'^i^Ai Ad XAuiS-p fa, idvCtdcyidi -ZldAeMiAA adATAdcdfioJ'A&2 .2d) i/ldf /HeyftS-.SLdl IS st-A&ficd'SdzZde-A/Ley %Ceeds,. /ddlS die/OdteL /&/&£«/?(£. -d-/%dv8d do dUdd/dA tdPoAiytAedmA AAifavdfFt^/dtAdsA tt&J iidd >/yd do AAld&yAT&Aqddtd d^oSeA AWtfe/lS d£ /Wyi/dv A&Atea)', /did'CbuAJ&ddtfddk. yrdd^d^dduA^^jrdodtdLS d&^d^eyJy&diri- d a&Aieddi4j &^isldTdfA\ S~Mfes ddfeynfAAbiiJyFAlWA/d^ M\M/'A/y^nAledddd^d)d^Awd/% AdyUf-A/y/^cf-jwd^c^ I ZU/'AAddl ad ApdSf&yAZTuddeAt/doF ^dd&y d*d& Leyd3.L> do £&Ae/dc/AlA/c /FAZdkds&r#AA^ Atedhc

dd/vdyldfarcey

u»M y^^i-^jmAud^Add^ydA^J^ dM'courts*'AAtJdA^ 6^^%^/^ ddaL lAO«\d l/We/AyAc/iAdsrddl^A^Jy^AAkJSc^, /auddht cfFdedAAzJ sWLdeAce/) dA^A^WJAddAwd eMx?/V /fe>/Ufl(d feSuHzddyu'AFcAMsioAeddFosvey (ajAS /tedz^ldL/ddtfteifce/y oeAA^WdzAeZ/dsACisy •JUddl*K AfeF KAfDusA do AldMA dhddyheA&Fdfa^AaJ dddylAi eAed d^MAdy^di^e)^ddiddtLZ&/c&/> /owjT ^&/ AWdA&fd- tid&d i&iddcedoA/A&cjfe- dAUFAAyZey /hAhlMd'AYTdtdAA^A?F,/h /fe, e/lAAAZA WAZAZAteJApsU

/WAiAST A-ihiiM2diyhfe ^FddFce, -> Sec^uS^y'£AAtf A^Aad ddto A>-fme/wddd%$dd/dded/ddid deAkACey/) Aid /iladda,y/AoiyJ,31ctimAeAkMrs, day CdAAMdidddA'. ol <£& yfA^fFMedcdeVCey &o diolAftd dfAnyisF/ld A/UedSL Ad&eSFA/dd/ddAS FewkeA .od(o~((*,~aoo^ ^yrdA^s d&uydt&d/dt7 y?d A£~W0c4d?QAjdadd6 4^d dkddb /m6 /ALj/o dfa4«ZAc. TidTheAt~y>FA/&*aAJt?d JUsde^ dc4^scy fn/de/ dddyJiSt&J f> - y^ddd) oF AAA/Fw&Am <2£ AAii, dfn die/ Addd/Addd • oVtf&AAMAd/^aydoj Undid did dcyi>t/ds . _ ds do. dtd/dd tody /ds Apndjd/jA/TW^d&^y /WsAdd eA^dyt yyA^iyddd AdddU d&AAZtdr dlddAAu-tedi ^dde/dZdAdedydAFAyfr /Li dd diddic/d /dAdd Artd^dAddAdl dfdfi edf&eSSioO fF dddccd' dcdL^JdVcdd cAkdtey AA dd2oyi, Aa?s ZdzuAed'yAdAdeZ yd -s- Codd^/f-'ddd^cdy tikdleZy^dATAdzd^dd^5 aFd^dSddr/Udde4lkdidf- ds /yvfej A#6 £/l iy&hdd%%//A%m/hdd&g^ AAi^d^A ZdZ td^ftj, .dd Addld/ldd editedd^di^A -A& Spdjhb ddAWdz%o$edje ___ AnA d&d AyAYiydTdddAZ da%&>dAd^A^Addd FfeeAedd^ d fddyylddAFiAdi) 6JM A/Bu) d-dAhS^iuSeAd/df /%eed Al^teyedeJ FldA^dyZcd'> l/> ke/ld/mdAA^ZiA..„ do ddiF&drfeAdAd' dudd d/% dks&t^d^&vdwc e
Mbd/AMotA ds A^/iy^JedcAdyidd ddted ikfidld d /AddtSe/> uUdJd^AAKMX^d^ deyduAdL Fp,&^6d6ed/, dl^^/KCASedMS sv&Td&A?, ,w ,_ _,, r£dnd **d AdAleJ dAey AeddAFj^ y^yFmkJo ddd)

A\u-i - -a^aZddldicAfy d dldddyfrt^ud?^ AdL -dlwAl ff teas d^d UjdAAoiAjd^yeSi ^ VMS*.

.^ <%dudt/A /yi?Ahedcc?-svdo. a}A/yd Jdwd ^'^^/7m>KFi^/d^m&ddFy'AA^/MlAit
^HcA^y^Fcr^ f„ ipj&ASfi>AfitaJ AdF /Lls>d

8*1?/fy llj Id (A W /J&wfi1j. ~^^

^dflt/2y^

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

Newsome, Edward R., Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/newsome-edward-r-tex-2015.