Newman v. Crawford Cnty. Cir. Ct.

2014 Ark. 308

• Court: Supreme Court of Arkansas
• Decided: June 26, 2014
• Docket: CR-14-268
• Status: Published

Opinion

Cite as 2014 Ark. 308

SUPREME COURT OF ARKANSAS No. CR-14-268

RICKEY DALE NEWMAN Opinion Delivered June 26, 2014 PETITIONER PETITION FOR WRIT OF V. CERTIORARI [NO. 17-CR-2011-109]

CRAWFORD COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT RESPONDENT MOTION TO DISMISS GRANTED.

COURTNEY HUDSON GOODSON, Associate Justice

Petitioner Rickey Dale Newman has brought a petition for writ of certiorari seeking

to quash the order entered by the Crawford County Circuit Court committing him to the

custody of the Arkansas Department of Human Services. Presently before the court is

Newman’s motion to dismiss the petition. Because the questions raised in the petition are

now moot, we grant the motion to dismiss.

In June 2002, a jury in the Crawford County Circuit Court found Newman guilty

of capital murder and sentenced him to death. See Newman v. State, 353 Ark. 258, 106

S.W.3d 438 (2003) (Newman I) (affirming the judgment of conviction on direct appeal).

Since then, proceedings stemming from Newman’s conviction and sentence have wound

their way through our state courts and the federal courts. See Newman v. State, 2009 Ark.

539, 354 S.W.3d 61 (Newman II) (recounting procedural history of the case). In Newman II,

this court granted Newman permission to proceed with a petition for writ of error coram Cite as 2014 Ark. 308

nobis in the Crawford County Circuit Court. We determined that Newman had

demonstrated probable merit in his claim that he had been incompetent to stand trial,

primarily due to significant scoring errors in tests administered by Dr. Charles Mallory, who

had opined before trial that Newman was fit to proceed.1 After a hearing, the circuit court

denied Newman’s petition for writ of error coram nobis; however, this court overturned the

circuit court’s decision. Newman v. State, 2014 Ark. 7 (Newman III). In Newman III, we held

that the circuit court had erred in finding that Newman had been competent to stand trial

in June 2002. Accordingly, we reversed and remanded for new trial. Our clerk issued the

mandate on February 5, 2014.

On February 28, 2014, the Crawford County Circuit Court entered an order entitled

“Not-Fit-To-Proceed Commitment.”2 In this order, the circuit court noted the reversal in

Newman III on the ground that Newman was not fit to stand trial in 2002. Citing Arkansas

Code Annotated section 5-2-310 (Repl. 2013), the circuit court suspended the proceedings

and “committed [Newman] to the custody of the Director of the Department of Human

Services for detention, care, and treatment until restoration of fitness to proceed.” The court

also ordered the director to report to the circuit court, if within ten months, Newman

regained fitness to proceed. If fitness was not restored within that time frame, the circuit

1 In Newman II, we also identified possible discovery violations in contravention of Brady v. Maryland, 373 U.S. 83 (1963), as a basis for reinvesting jurisdiction in the circuit court. 2 Although the order states that the circuit court was acting upon the State’s motion, the record contains no motion filed by the State.

2 Cite as 2014 Ark. 308

court ordered the director to report whether Newman’s mental disease or defect was of a

nature that precluded restoration of fitness to proceed and whether Newman presented a

danger to himself or to the person or property of others.

On March 6, 2014, Newman’s counsel filed a motion for reconsideration, objecting

to the circuit court’s course of action. Counsel asserted that the court’s order was in

violation of the statutes governing the assessment of a defendant’s fitness to proceed because

the court ordered the commitment of Newman without first having him undergo a fitness-

to-proceed examination and without making a finding that Newman was presently

incompetent to stand trial. Counsel also objected to the circuit court’s having based its

decision on this court’s opinion in Newman III, as that appeal involved a retrospective

determination that Newman had been incompetent to stand trial back in 2002. Counsel

maintained that the decision in Newman III could not serve as a proxy for a current

evaluation of Newman’s present competency. Further, counsel argued that Newman was

not claiming that he was currently unfit to proceed and that, should his competency become

an issue, counsel asserted that the court should not appoint a psychiatrist from the Arkansas

State Hospital to conduct an examination, given the erroneous competency evaluations

performed by doctors at that institution, as identified in Newman II and Newman III. The

circuit court denied the motion for reconsideration by an order dated March 10, 2014.

On March 24, 2014, Newman filed the present petition for writ of certiorari to

challenge the circuit court’s sua sponte decision to commit him to the department of human

services. We took the petition as a case with an expedited briefing schedule. Newman has

3 Cite as 2014 Ark. 308

now filed a motion to dismiss the petition. In this motion, Newman asserts that he has been

transferred to the Crawford County jail and that the petition is moot because he is no longer

being held at the Arkansas State Hospital.

As a general rule, appellate courts of this state will not review moot issues, as doing so

would be to render an advisory opinion, which this court will not do. Wigley v. Hobbs, 2013

Ark. 379. Generally, an issue becomes moot when any judgment rendered would have no

practical effect upon a then existing legal controversy. Lott v. Langley, 2013 Ark. 247.

Because Newman is no longer being held under commitment at the state hospital, granting

the relief requested would have no practical effect such that the issues raised in the petition

are moot at this time. Wigley, supra. Therefore, we grant the motion to dismiss the petition.

Motion to dismiss granted.

Julie Brain, for petitioner.

Dustin McDaniel, Att’y Gen., by: Darnisa Evans Johnson, Deputy Att’y Gen., for

appellee.