New West v. Marcia L. Fudge

Seventh Circuit

New West v. Marcia L. Fudge

14 F.4th 647

Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit·Decided September 20, 2021·No. 21-1372·Published

Opinion

In the

United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit

CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCG

";G21E1372G < ;;<G!G < ;;<G #<G

!G

;<%'%,G"G"(&!G!G%!G)"#E !'<G #;G

CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCG

! ! ! ! ! !! ! !

! ! !! !! !!!! ! !

CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCG

14<2021F 20<2021G CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCG

"%G <G$<G!G G!G <$ $;G <$$;G'%G'G',G"G "'<G !"&<G "! !GG"(&!G)"# !'G !G,G *G&'G !G *G(.G@"'),G *G&'A<G!G#G:15G "!G "%G'G#%"#%'&<G'G#%'&G&%G"('G'G##%"#%'G

G

* The court granted the parties’ joint motion to waive oral argument.

2G ";G21E1372G

&#"&'"!G"GG(!G*"%'G%"(,G:2;7G "!;G&G(!<G &'&G(!%G"!'%'&G'*!G *G&'G!G'GE #%' !'G"G"(&!G!G%!G)"# !'F*"&G%!'G &(&&G"%G"*E!" G'!!'&G#%")G "&'GG"G'G "!,G"%G"#%'!G'G"(&!G)"# !'FGG&''G "G"G!&(%!G''G "!,G*"(GG)G"%G !'E !!G!G%#%G"G'G#%"#%'&GG *G&'G('G"!G '&G"'"!&G'"G'!!'&G"%G'G#%' !';G *G&'G !E '!&G''<G(&G'G&G!"G"!%G%&#"!&G"%G !'!!G "%G%#%<G'G&"(G%)G'G "!,;G('G'G#%' !'G&G %(&G *G&'B&G !&G"%G#, !'G!G&G"!G'G "!,G"%G'G!-'G"G "'<G*G&(G *G&'G&G 'G(!&BG#%"#%'"%;G G&#('G"('G'G&#"&'"!G"G'G%&%)G(!G%"&G (%!G'G"! !'"!G#%"!<G('G*GG!G$!$ $ "$ ! !<G921G;3G693G@7'G%;G2019AG@ $ $ A<G''G 'G&&(G&G"%GG&#%'G&('G*'G'G#%' !'G&GE !!';G&G&('G&G'G%&(';GG&'%'G(G%!'G'G #%' !'B&G "'"!G"%G&( %,G( !';G2021G;;G&';G G21393G@ ;;G ;G;G4<G2021A;G

$ $ G%&G'*"G"!(&"!&G#%'!!'G'"G'G(%E %!'G&('=G-%&'<G''G12G;;;GD1702G*)&G'G#%' !'B&G &")%!G (!',G '"G G G &G "!G G "!'%'>G &"!<G ''G"!,GG"!'%'<G%'%G'!GG&''('G"%G%('"!<G".%&G *G&'G!,G#%"&#'G"G&(&&;GG#%'&G'G'&G"!E (&"!&G&G)!<G&"G*G!G'"G%&")GG&#('G"('G'G !!G"G'G"!'%'&G'*!G *G&'G!G'G#%'E !';G ('G *G &'G "&G !"'G %,G "!G "!'%'(G ;G !E &'G'G&,&G''G'G#%'&BGG"G#%")!G&(%',G"%G%E #%&G!G !'!!G #&G''G'G "!,G (&'G"!G'"G

";G21E1372G 3G

'G"!G'G#%"'B&G"*!%&#G#&&&G'"G&" "!G&;G&G *G!"'G";G%#&<G(&G'G "!,G G%" G'GE %G%&(%,G'%"(G'G#, !'G"G")E %'G%!'&<G'G "!,G&"(G%)%'G'"G'G%&(%,;G%G#%#&<G(&G'G "!,G&G&!G'"G#%")G&(%',GG'G#%"'B&G"*!%G &G'"G 'G'&G%&#"!&'&<G'G(!G&"(G#&&<G*'G'G (!&<G'"G'G#%"'B&G!*G"*!%;G%G#%#&<G(&GG "G "G 'G (!G &G '"G #%"''G '!!'&BG !'%&'&<G 'G "!,G &"(G G &'%('G '"G 'G '!!'&G "%G (&G '"G %(G '%G %!'&;GG!%G"')G"&G!"'G%&")G*G"G'&G#"&E &'&G'G"!'%'!G#%'&G';G'G%$(%&GGE &"!G!"G!G%G!(<G*G'&G"!'%'&G;G *G&'G&G'G#!'.G!G%&G'G%&G"G!"!E#%&(&"!;G "E*'B&E&'EE'!&E"!&%G&GG#""%G&(&''('G"%G "!%'G!(G!GG"!'%'G&;G "*G'G&!B'G$('G%'G'"G&,G''G *G&'G,#&&&$G "!'%'(G !(;G (%',G % !'&G )G 'G #%'E !'GG!G"!G'G(!B&G"!'!'&<G!G'&G%G'G"!,G"!E '%'&G"!G*G *G&'G%&;G!G'G"! !'"!G*&G " #'<G!G *G&'G!"G"!%G"*!G'G#%"'<G'GE #%' !'G %&G '&G !G ,G #%"#%G "( !'&G (!%G 'G !"% G" %G";G"%!G'"G *G&'<G'&G!E &&%,G&"*&G''G'G!"*G"*!&G'G(!G"('%';G('G''B&G !"'G &";G G !G "G 'G !G !&G ''G 'G #%' !'G !"G "!%G&GG&(%',G!'%&';G('G*"$ G'G(!?GGE &!G "G G &(%',G !'%&'G "&G !"'G !&*%G 'G $(&'"!F !<G &G *G +#!G ")<G 'G #"&&'&G !(G *G &'<G 'G ',G "G "'<G 'G %&(%,<G !G 'G '!!'&;G &G &!&G(&GG'"G'G"!'%'&<G*G"G!"'G%&&G'G&(E ';G *G &'G )G 'G #%' !'G &(%',G !G *')%G #%"#%',G!'%&'G *G&'G#"&&&&G!G'G(!<G('G'G'G "G"!G&"G"&G!"'G&'&G*'G *G&'B&G!'%&'G*&;G 4G ";G21E1372G

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

";G21E1372G 5G

(&G12G;;;GD1702G&GG*)%G"G&")%!G (!',G'"G#(%E &(GG'"%'G ;G "'G''G'&G /%&;G"G)GG G"%G'"%'"(&G"!)%E &"!G "G #%"#%',<G *G &'G (&'G -%&'G &'&G ''G 'G "!,G!G'G%&%)G(!G&G'&G#%"#%',;G !G"'%G*"%&<G'"G *!GG'"%'G G *G&'G (&'G-%&'G*!G'&G"!'%'G F !GG'GG!GG'"G#%)G"!G'G"!'%'G G@*G 'G !B'A<G *G &'G *"(G !"'G )G !G G "!)%&"!G G&GG;G AFFIRMED

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

In the

United States Court of Appeals For the Seventh Circuit

CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCG

";G21E1372G < ;;<G!G < ;;<G #<G

!G

;<%'%,G"G"(&!G!G%!G)"#E !'<G #;G

CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCG

! ! ! ! ! !! ! !

! ! !! !! !!!! ! !

CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCG

14<2021F 20<2021G CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCG

"%G <G$<G!G G!G <$ $;G <$$;G'%G'G',G"G "'<G !"&<G "! !GG"(&!G)"# !'G !G,G *G&'G !G *G(.G@"'),G *G&'A<G!G#G:15G "!G "%G'G#%"#%'&<G'G#%'&G&%G"('G'G##%"#%'G

G

* The court granted the parties’ joint motion to waive oral argument.

2G ";G21E1372G

&#"&'"!G"GG(!G*"%'G%"(,G:2;7G "!;G&G(!<G &'&G(!%G"!'%'&G'*!G *G&'G!G'GE #%' !'G"G"(&!G!G%!G)"# !'F*"&G%!'G &(&&G"%G"*E!" G'!!'&G#%")G "&'GG"G'G "!,G"%G"#%'!G'G"(&!G)"# !'FGG&''G "G"G!&(%!G''G "!,G*"(GG)G"%G !'E !!G!G%#%G"G'G#%"#%'&GG *G&'G('G"!G '&G"'"!&G'"G'!!'&G"%G'G#%' !';G *G&'G !E '!&G''<G(&G'G&G!"G"!%G%&#"!&G"%G !'!!G "%G%#%<G'G&"(G%)G'G "!,;G('G'G#%' !'G&G %(&G *G&'B&G !&G"%G#, !'G!G&G"!G'G "!,G"%G'G!-'G"G "'<G*G&(G *G&'G&G 'G(!&BG#%"#%'"%;G G&#('G"('G'G&#"&'"!G"G'G%&%)G(!G%"&G (%!G'G"! !'"!G#%"!<G('G*GG!G$!$ $ "$ ! !<G921G;3G693G@7'G%;G2019AG@ $ $ A<G''G 'G&&(G&G"%GG&#%'G&('G*'G'G#%' !'G&GE !!';G&G&('G&G'G%&(';GG&'%'G(G%!'G'G #%' !'B&G "'"!G"%G&( %,G( !';G2021G;;G&';G G21393G@ ;;G ;G;G4<G2021A;G

$ $ G%&G'*"G"!(&"!&G#%'!!'G'"G'G(%E %!'G&('=G-%&'<G''G12G;;;GD1702G*)&G'G#%' !'B&G &")%!G (!',G '"G G G &G "!G G "!'%'>G &"!<G ''G"!,GG"!'%'<G%'%G'!GG&''('G"%G%('"!<G".%&G *G&'G!,G#%"&#'G"G&(&&;GG#%'&G'G'&G"!E (&"!&G&G)!<G&"G*G!G'"G%&")GG&#('G"('G'G !!G"G'G"!'%'&G'*!G *G&'G!G'G#%'E !';G ('G *G &'G "&G !"'G %,G "!G "!'%'(G ;G !E &'G'G&,&G''G'G#%'&BGG"G#%")!G&(%',G"%G%E #%&G!G !'!!G #&G''G'G "!,G (&'G"!G'"G

";G21E1372G 3G

'G"!G'G#%"'B&G"*!%&#G#&&&G'"G&" "!G&;G&G *G!"'G";G%#&<G(&G'G "!,G G%" G'GE %G%&(%,G'%"(G'G#, !'G"G")E %'G%!'&<G'G "!,G&"(G%)%'G'"G'G%&(%,;G%G#%#&<G(&G'G "!,G&G&!G'"G#%")G&(%',GG'G#%"'B&G"*!%G &G'"G 'G'&G%&#"!&'&<G'G(!G&"(G#&&<G*'G'G (!&<G'"G'G#%"'B&G!*G"*!%;G%G#%#&<G(&GG "G "G 'G (!G &G '"G #%"''G '!!'&BG !'%&'&<G 'G "!,G &"(G G &'%('G '"G 'G '!!'&G "%G (&G '"G %(G '%G %!'&;GG!%G"')G"&G!"'G%&")G*G"G'&G#"&E &'&G'G"!'%'!G#%'&G';G'G%$(%&GGE &"!G!"G!G%G!(<G*G'&G"!'%'&G;G *G&'G&G'G#!'.G!G%&G'G%&G"G!"!E#%&(&"!;G "E*'B&E&'EE'!&E"!&%G&GG#""%G&(&''('G"%G "!%'G!(G!GG"!'%'G&;G "*G'G&!B'G$('G%'G'"G&,G''G *G&'G,#&&&$G "!'%'(G !(;G (%',G % !'&G )G 'G #%'E !'GG!G"!G'G(!B&G"!'!'&<G!G'&G%G'G"!,G"!E '%'&G"!G*G *G&'G%&;G!G'G"! !'"!G*&G " #'<G!G *G&'G!"G"!%G"*!G'G#%"'<G'GE #%' !'G %&G '&G !G ,G #%"#%G "( !'&G (!%G 'G !"% G" %G";G"%!G'"G *G&'<G'&G!E &&%,G&"*&G''G'G!"*G"*!&G'G(!G"('%';G('G''B&G !"'G &";G G !G "G 'G !G !&G ''G 'G #%' !'G !"G "!%G&GG&(%',G!'%&';G('G*"$ G'G(!?GGE &!G "G G &(%',G !'%&'G "&G !"'G !&*%G 'G $(&'"!F !<G &G *G +#!G ")<G 'G #"&&'&G !(G *G &'<G 'G ',G "G "'<G 'G %&(%,<G !G 'G '!!'&;G &G &!&G(&GG'"G'G"!'%'&<G*G"G!"'G%&&G'G&(E ';G *G &'G )G 'G #%' !'G &(%',G !G *')%G #%"#%',G!'%&'G *G&'G#"&&&&G!G'G(!<G('G'G'G "G"!G&"G"&G!"'G&'&G*'G *G&'B&G!'%&'G*&;G 4G ";G21E1372G

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

";G21E1372G 5G

(&G12G;;;GD1702G&GG*)%G"G&")%!G (!',G'"G#(%E &(GG'"%'G ;G "'G''G'&G /%&;G"G)GG G"%G'"%'"(&G"!)%E &"!G "G #%"#%',<G *G &'G (&'G -%&'G &'&G ''G 'G "!,G!G'G%&%)G(!G&G'&G#%"#%',;G !G"'%G*"%&<G'"G *!GG'"%'G G *G&'G (&'G-%&'G*!G'&G"!'%'G F !GG'GG!GG'"G#%)G"!G'G"!'%'G G@*G 'G !B'A<G *G &'G *"(G !"'G )G !G G "!)%&"!G G&GG;G AFFIRMED

New West v. Marcia L. Fudge, 14 F.4th 647 (7th Cir. 2021).

Pincite

14 F.4th 647 (New West v. Marcia L. Fudge) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.