Munoz, Robert

Court of Appeals of Texas·Decided October 1, 2015·No. PD-0958-15·Published

Opinion

ORIGINAL 15Z-I5 Mo. lhl3>-OOl3^ Cg

IM (LOUPL Y-&F- CJZlMlkM L APP£/!L S COURT OF CRW.U^r'-ij? o f reXA S OCT 01 2015

Abe! AcssSa. C's-'- 1A(7

/IPPFLL/Ia/YS P^r/Y/ePAf 7=t?JZ. dl£C£E-T/e>A//1£Y R£ujt=u/

JZU APPEAL a//?. II- 13"0012*1 C£ FILED IN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS £0t*R 7- t?F-/9PJ>£/?L 5 • '• -i v i loij

Abel Acosta, Clerk •T^^X AS

JJc, c?t£SUS-f,7a7/0jJ . ., . . . ^/J/J%C/i",/£ ,)7 ,7?

RRihV y. UAM\.AK\h 373 u.s.?3,irj s.c'4. //t,ss {1 <>s$-s~J-Jt £a) • . - . • .-...'? CHXDUlC i/. US. Mb u.S -Mlt&L.£,„*/S^J. z>u fajfi/) . ,1 J7 CJH?r,U (/. CAtlftSLMiA 3SD U.S. 6,0% olSf #5 s.Cl.jzz.9, Jl JJ, // <. &/. ZSy^fas) // 3£H\CM£ I/. MAMSJtJ W7, U.S.Z5l,ZK-'/O,/O0 S.C4. zrz.*/, 2,£?-jW, £,S L>£

toi&IUlM V.A/ZiTu^A 3J«/U.S.YSC- (!%(,) - • - - . - - . . . . . . . /*> PffklSU, v. /iUmma 2.SiU.S1S,5ZS.CJ.5'7,L.£c/.rtPQ{&*^ . . . ..... /Sj/f QuuJiJ I/. U S. 3^1, \€£>ILI'^^, IS S. C4. M,',i,l3- 7¥, 95 l.&. *fctf?72-7 5 QfSS) • f Btftotetl* V-B&Wi iZS S~C+.ZVSi- (ZooSb - • - . ...... /-S" zesZv.M.S./«// f.suPP.zJOul (2#eh) - - - • * - • .- *' * - • /3 S4imAS ir.-fEiAS izz s»C4>znIt 5M*rd v.U-S 3*1 U.S>,I31,6>1 "5C+. WCCt 13 L.£~£{ /2j/)a.4k.Ci^('7Cu>lu.Ci.JL fi?V . • ..... // Sn/l\C*U/lUA O-UJA^UK/f.'iotJ VOu U. i ..Ut*,ri>'IS.C4. ZofZgptL.e£/ZUA>7

AJZ-f SrSBClQ Of Th/£ T&MS. 0)hi171 Tu7(Crf . . _ - . . - - - • $#*

Hu«7e£ I/. 574-it SSD 5M) i.dS'73 freJ.Cet*A I97?>\ 2 TtMS Covjll 6F MP6.ALS

hie/jess? v.ST47z 2MS.iu.3d' i53ji(rl(-fr*-App.tL>Mo,zn>£) • - • - • • S UZRRfiii 1/.SW* SO S.uf.?4 UZI> L>7~Xr 2-9 Ctft^CliU*. A&>- &cl) - - . . . . 7 OGiAUSOUus^^rbnzSiu.^c/O-CT^^APk-^.UI^&^/lzaoil . , . . . , /S *>/\IikI*S. i/ 5tA-7£ •&£/ S.u>.1iJtfK,ir7 7£6'je.£JefH.AtP.Zt>/&)* . . . . . 9,tUtfi A&-1, l,o 5 . _ . . . . . - .. - . £ .f.jd.j? A&7. l.cSl ^ _ _ . , , , ,.."... /S A£1. ZO\ c ;,/

7BHAS P&Mi- Cot)£ Cobf 3&.07r , . . • . , . , . . 3 ^

tQ4S> 04fas of APPe/Ui£ f&pcehn&r Rule %zii>) . . . . . . . , , - . . z.

7EM3 IZuffcS of aOthErfCg' ZuleT IG3 (/) . ^ j£ Rule: ze I .. . . ' . . - . ,..-•-.-/ Hut*

EXtJtgtTS

(7 tf 3 . 5"

3 , ^ TlJhaX (F A<

S-rA7Km£j-c7 dp Tt/e &1J£ ...>••• °<-

CnftJuUAS HoZ. g£i/i£kf . ,3-/9

•ntiT lZ\AL- CJH&7/}GISJ£6 )7S biSU£'7tt>U /tf Af/dW/fiSfy 7£S7/*tcMr yiM7 /? UJlY*6FSS MAA. Pl£un>uSL.Y BeeU Coi4v}C7<£6 0F ^/^T/W4 A/fAgtfiFUS/cU

Bck.\Al*J& (X?UAaUY <5£77f*Sfi> ef^ SCrfd

b£dti63& afFtC&LS /e**<5Ut?57 &)Z. A S74l^A)icUY.

fprtex. Re fUutfp; . . . ..••...- . . - po

t££7(P/CA7£ 0F smutch ^ .% « « . . • - . PO

11. kit?. ll-tS-OOFS*} C&

cfo^X7 c?F CJ2/7-//A.ML FJFMALS o f rexA 5

U£B£7 MutJi)7 - /4pPe/MA/F __ v. ~~77/£ Sya7c CP-f YtXAS- /tf/wer/ZeiF

/lPfa/MU7S Pb7/7/0/~7 7*4- /J>7SC/e/F7/Oi,C4Zy /OriA/A-U/ — _

-7*2 7l/ Pl£A$£ F/A//S //£)€&/A/ 7}7>/£//4'L/7f J&0~S£ Att-1'OAf, /6>U/£i/&2• TrftT AAJ/7/tfAtAc C^P/a'S Ft£. AtS<'££7'0*M£Y J?tV,£U/ Of1,1 AJ?S &£ *WJFi 7'7£&T AS Mo AC

HWtf /9a7Y £&>/>/£S Ml FAC.JT. ?*/ 7t//S et/fisx/tt. M» %l?M yoc/ /}^j f/ZFc'^.t 7 u„7/ F'UA /}££/ 7/Oi.Ulc fifGtS/it/rA/fS H*i)£ AS 7& SuFA/>/Z7 £/f£AJ

TV StifPAtr £4ctJ /)/Z.4uah£m7. 77(£J£ #//Ai 7£~ PA?<><:cA}i,AHr, /)i/?£y7, 7^/^^/ MiY Ftl/A AA/Y Ai/S7AA^£S 0U 7t/£ f=///A/At, 7s7£~7a?'Ca/&<. /Z£sP£^7r^//y /ee?6u£S7 Tf7A7 777/S {.£#f£"~7>l£eT3t(JAC(4C /Jd7/£F 0F 7V/X £u7(e£~ P&c££U/*/6 U/J6£#- 7£7.4$ Mn/t"S #F £*)££*/<£- /# 3 (f) A*/A ztl, esP£ciA//y tkt ~rtf£ fac-t r/Ysr TlPfe///) 7£~ <:,?<,/jjsz/ /ks Fstt/^A it c-Ji/AtAte*" Tf-IF SUfF/tA£AlCV ep £i/i&FA/tt? /A/ jJ/* RR^F, 7a/£££Fv££; /7£ /faS a/s& B££J/ /'t'AJ£Y/7ct7/e>*./A//y /aY£~FF£"C 7/UiF Fs£ A/e>7 /vA'*/A• M47£R.M'A. f5St/££ ?// 7A7F" )jJSUFFJC/£~AtC Y &F £UtA£7YcA' Ka7i)U/u/A T/T"-* 7 P£7t 7t&jL/£l? CAfA/

I YUaFSuFF/c/£xicy eF si/a^Fa/oF c>J &)££<£ 7 /)PA£*)a,#£ &ig£t:7 &rf/AruA.

.4flPeJUM7 PFAYS. ACC^/PYAa/C/F ZY 7A7/S ArkjAi?gA)BL£~ CukjZ/ TV SAZAt/A, aY/S p£Y/7;s?*A U//7/7 fi/i FX/Z/S/YS AlfJA /}//PA£7/£S Fifeh AaJ7o 7a/£ CSitAtY. Aps&/fav7 AZFSA£e 77=^//^ FFtiuFST tJfiY/af &F P£C£/P 7 jFY>/aS P£7a 7/UfA aIa/J FaZ/a/A .

7?&SPFC7FA(//y StASHA Y7£A ,

Ftx&tY F?ua~/cx /' /%•> -Sk" hJv. 7 Cu£isto, ~rx. 7795*/

£/A,aJ£A AAJA MYFH ta/aS 25yIi MV

"Ta/F aTPP£//aal/7 aZ£Ou£SY s£A / A£6t4AH£AA7 All 7a/aS Sc/c*7 7)£4*/**£*/-• MAlAl 7~ A/2A L. A9/ZA,t,/A/£Ajr MAY a/s/f SamP/aFV 7>7£~ F&trS aJaM f/AAZAFY 7/j£ ASSU££. SYA7iYAieM7 F>P rA/tTCJStF

Ohl APP.IU TOi ZoU. AfiPelUui WAS y/^xcr'^'6 0U 0) Caum7 £>FFcJLkAc ASUt/L-7 OF H'A-K •UitH> A-//£6£A Silc lUfiS (5 Y&KSfiF A&£j AC££'S7£A J?/ir /// / 3#/J4FF> DA47 skill, Re:-3AS4YC7FlA F/A /jY/ZetZ AlF7F>LA/AZF£Yi3d Atou/AA ///#//Z, /Jau? /2//f%/aSM odiHuM-i'?aA4Yc7AU£-aU7U//FV 7Z>YstY/ A/F f£X£U7 AllF7yi7AC>AJ$) pA?-XWtC7m s/zotZ-s/fAtAt g£~7uA7{7Fi3- A>6> /zo/Z, U7f7fA 0£(6uJ/l'' CllvzTiF fitJA) a/A ArM) YfO+A-tf ChUtdF OF FerMU/t/'A)S$Ac7£ 7. TZfAL WAS //AAfY/z-tOj AJJA 3^>^Y K?u/J4 APPtir/7aiAY Al*a/7Y &F Ai^^TZAUAYF'A^ SFXWAf ASSAUL 7 t>F E07/V CoWAtS/ }F /Au7y Ffr/iAFSeM7£-/Jc&4 /}&

£lA£W7JAcl/6fA7/07 oUzt/fA. AaJ JuY ^aS/jJCY/M&aaYA?F A6f-*e4o!Ah7&D,^a/- jpctfsJXM&Y BY %iA6£ AT- (7e) m4Z-l 76.CJ-. F£> FuaAA»/AS<2'£uiits'ifj^aA Sd7lA £ouaAf£„

SYaiaTm&aY FF pJZoaFdiAPJL. iJts7cA.£Y

lid CausF a/u.C* 2#>Y9t> TUiF APPet/AAA7 UI4S. CaAa^^F^/0AA 7/A/£ VM RE-7AA/>Jt7MeA47 0F S£*H4L. /)£SAC//.Y, Z-CaUAr7S A7tfF~ F)PP£A6)A(7 Jc/AS dlMUIC 7£& aFSucJj TtFFtFAjS £- &aJ t/lz^t 3 A9/JA APPFaAp^ 7*AaY. OlJ tshollS, 7tfaJvac 7/i>aY. Alt) MolAohf fitZ. P^AEKZlAJh fl/t=& QuF 7d WtfLAct^oF I^aAou) ft£^C aF flffziktAl m^M fipfelfalc CvutASrC c9/A Z5 S£P1. /£, 77-//J PtF7/7sUA/ FbA rxstZiFYtotiAPjY iteuuzuj u<4J> r*A*ie/y feP-ivA*Z7\£& Yo 7/Air a^aa^ey-a>f-apP£14/s FvJS. Filf/At PulZS(AAu7 TV Zu/tf?. ZC&\ TsXJS Ru/fS aF /}PP£//a)7c p/Z^dF/H/M,

•A &Xt7tAk/6 J-

7tfk>aAY rfal /f 6>t7?j£jS Mn PXtVitHijfr Be&A C*nJuUl£a OF fHMd&LlUfi /iPpF//AA77S APPXjF/IF7/Sao*Y- /tAZ6UM£lA'7' (I ) Ok} lifF /Jji/tf 7H4-7 THF UA(7AAt£5^ QuF$7<0Aj£n A&<47 AJtAtAiFXJtYAt fUiF fiMZF- f1FAtS/c>

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI