Morris v. Hardin

295 So. 2d 755
CourtMississippi Supreme Court
DecidedJune 4, 1974
Docket47376
StatusPublished

This text of 295 So. 2d 755 (Morris v. Hardin) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Mississippi Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Morris v. Hardin, 295 So. 2d 755 (Mich. 1974).

Opinion

295 So.2d 755 (1974)

Sally Ann Lewis MORRIS, Individually and as mother and next friend of William Helm Morris, et al.
v.
William Frank HARDIN et al.

No. 47376.

Supreme Court of Mississippi.

June 4, 1974.

*756 Frank O. Wynne, Jr., Robert G. Johnston, Cleveland, C.W. Dotson, Tuscola, Ill., for appellants.

W. Allen Pepper, Jr., Cleveland, Guthrie T. Abbott, University, for appellees.

INZER, Justice:

This is an appeal by Sally Ann Lewis Morris, Joe E. Morris, Jr., William Helm Morris, and Katherine Estelle Morris from a decree of the Chancery Court of the Second Judicial District of Bolivar County cancelling and removing as a cloud the claim of appellants to approximately 640 acres of land located in Bolivar County and confirming the title to the land in appellee William Frank Hardin. We affirm.

The claim of appellants and appellee to the land involved in this case arises out of the will of Roy E. Helm, who died on May 6, 1937. The first dispositive paragraph of the will devised the land in question to testator's wife, Edith C. Helm for her natural life. The next paragraph of the will devised a life estate to William Frank Hardin to take effect upon the death of his mother Edith C. Helm. The will then *757 made the following provisions relative to the land:

Upon the death of both the said Edith C. Helm and the said William Frank Hardin, I give and devise the remainder interest in said land unto Sally Lewis, who is the daughter of my niece, Sarah Jane [sic] Helm Lewis, and to the heirs at law of the said Sally Lewis, in fee simple.
If the said Sally Lewis should die prior to the death of either of the said Edith C. Helm or the said William Frank Hardin, then it is my will that the said land aforesaid become the property of the heirs at law of the said Sally Lewis upon the death of both the said Edith C. Helm and the said William Frank Hardin.

The will devised all other property to Edith C. Helm and appointed her executrix of the estate to act without bond or accounting for her actions to any court. After Mr. Helm's death, the will was admitted to probate in the Chancery Court of Bolivar County, and Mrs. Helm was appointed executrix. The estate was duly administered, and Mrs. Helm was discharged by a decree of the court dated December 18, 1937.

In July 1938 Cyril C. Lewis and Sarajane Lewis, parents of Sally Ann Lewis, filed a petition in the Chancery Court of Bolivar County alleging that the petitioners and their daughter were residents of the State of Illinois and that their daughter, who was then two years of age, owned a remainder interest in fee simple in the land in question. The petition also alleged that it would be the best interest of the minor that her interest in the land be sold for several reasons. The prayer of the petition was that Mrs. Sarajane Lewis be appointed guardian for her daughter. A decree was entered appointing Mrs. Lewis guardian, and she qualified by making bond. Letters of guardianship were then issued to her. Thereafter on October 13, 1938, the guardian filed a petition in accordance with Section 1883, Mississippi Code of 1930, seeking authority to sell the interest of the ward in the land in question. Cyril Lewis, father of the ward, Grover Helm, grandfather of the ward, and Edith C. Helm, great aunt by marriage of the ward, were made parties defendant to the petition. The defendants answered and joined in the prayer of the petition agreeing that it would be to the best interest of the minor that her interest in the land be sold. On October 25, 1938, a decree was entered adjudicating that the minor owned a fee simple remainder interest in the land and that it would be to her best interest that her remainder interest be sold. The clerk of the court was appointed special commissioner to sell her interest in the land, but the decree prohibited the commissioner from selling the interest of the minor for less than $2,000. After duly advertising the sale, the commissioner sold the interest of the minor at public auction to William Frank Hardin for $2,000. The sale was confirmed by the court, and the commissioner deeded the interest of the minor to William F. Hardin. Thereafter, Mrs. Sarajane Lewis qualified as guardian in the State of Illinois and filed her first and final account in the guardianship proceeding in this state. A decree was entered approving the final account and ordering the transfer of the funds to the Illinois guardianship. Upon transfer, the guardian in Mississippi was finally discharged.

On September 14, 1959, Sally Ann Lewis Morris, nee Sally Ann Lewis, filed a disaffirmance and renunciation of the sale of her interest in the subject land alleging that the sale was invalid for several reasons. At the time this instrument was filed, Mrs. Morris was over 23 years of age, married and had one child.

Mrs. Edith C. Helm died on May 5, 1956, and her son William Frank Hardin became the owner of the life estate and whatever interest he acquired by virtue of the commissioner's deed.

*758 This suit seeking to remove any claim of the defendants to the land described in the bill of complaint was instituted by William Frank Hardin, his wife, and children, although his wife and children actually own no interest in the land, against defendant Sally Ann Lewis Morris, her husband, Joe E. Morris, Jr., their two minor children, William Helm Morris, Katherine Estelle Morris, and any unborn children of the adult defendants. The bill alleged that the complainant William Frank Hardin had acquired the fee simple remainder interest of Sally Ann Lewis by virtue of the commissioner's deed and that said deed was valid in all respects and in compliance with the law. It further alleged that at the time of the filing of the disaffirmance and renunciation Sally Ann Lewis Morris was 23 years and 7 months of age and that she was barred by the virtue of Section 745 and 1388, Mississippi Code 1942 Annotated (1956) from asserting the claim to the property in question.

The defendants answered the bill of complaint alleging that the will of Roy E. Helm devised to Sally Ann Lewis Morris a contingent remainder interest in the property and her heirs born and unborn received alternative contingent remainder interest. The answer alleged that Edith C. Helm as executrix of the estate of Roy E. Helm owed a fiduciary duty to Sally Ann Lewis Morris which was violated. The answer also charged that the proceedings were tainted by fraud and wholly void, that the consideration paid at the 1938 sale was grossly inadequate, that William Frank Hardin was a party to the fraud, that the guardianship proceedings did not attempt to sell and convey the alternative contingent remainder interest of her heirs and that the claim of Sally Ann Lewis Morris to the property was not barred by the statute of limitations.

By way of a cross bill, Sally Ann Lewis Morris prayed that the 1938 guardianship sale be set aside and that the claim of William Frank Hardin to the remainder interest in the land be removed as a cloud on her title. She also prayed that the court adjudicate that she acquired a contingent remainder interest under the will and that if she does not survive William Frank Hardin, then at his death the remainder interest be vested in her heirs. The answer to the cross bill denied that either Sally Ann Lewis Morris or her heirs owned any interest to the property in question.

The court appointed an attorney as guardian ad litem for the minor defendants and the unknown, unborn and undetermined heirs of Sally Ann Lewis Morris.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Frierson v. Moorhead
51 So. 2d 925 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1951)
Hemphill v. Mississippi State Highway Commission
145 So. 2d 455 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1962)
Jones v. State ex rel. District Attorney
295 So. 2d 755 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1974)
Palmer v. Habig
87 So. 2d 68 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1956)
Wheeler v. Williams
108 So. 2d 579 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1959)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
295 So. 2d 755, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/morris-v-hardin-miss-1974.