Moore v. Loganville Mercantile Co.

Supreme Court of Georgia

Moore v. Loganville Mercantile Co.

191 S.E. 121, 184 Ga. 351, 1937 Ga. LEXIS 512

CourtSupreme Court of Georgia

DecidedApril 16, 1937

DocketNo. 11738

StatusPublished

Cited by3 cases

This text of 191 S.E. 121 (Moore v. Loganville Mercantile Co.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Georgia primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Moore v. Loganville Mercantile Co., 191 S.E. 121, 184 Ga. 351, 1937 Ga. LEXIS 512 (Ga. 1937).

Pincite

Opinion

Bell, Justice.

1. “It has been held by this court that on the trial of a statutory claim to land under the Civil Code of 1910, § 5157, interposed to resist the levy of a fi. fa., it is not necessary, in order to show fraud in a deed to the claimant, to have special pleadings for that purpose.” Simmons v. Realty Investment Co., 160 Ga. 99, 101 (127 S. E. 279). Accordingly, in the instant claim ease in which the claimant relied upon a deed from the defendant in execution, the court did not err in admitting the evidence offered by the plaintiff in execution, to the effect that the parties to this deed were husband and wife, over objection that there was no pleading to authorize the introduction of such evidence. Douglas v. Jenkins, 146 Ga. 341 (91 S. E. 49, Ann. Cas. 1918C, 322).

2. “In a claim case where the wife sets up title to the property levied upon under a deed from her husband, and his creditor attacks the same upon the ground that it is a fraudulent conveyance, intended to hinder, delay, and .defraud such creditor, the law does not put upon the creditor the burden of establishing fraud in the conveyance. On the contrary, it puts the burden upon the husband and wife. They must show that the transaction as a whole is free from fraud.” Gill v. Willingham, 156 Ga. 728 (9) (120 S. E. 108); Simmons v. Realty Investment Co., supra; Cotton States Fertilizer Co. v. Childs, 179 Ga. 23 (174 S. E. 708).

3. The trial wa's free from error, and the evidence authorized the verdict in favor of the plaintiff in fi. fa. The court did not err in refusing a new trial. Judgment affirmed.

All the Justices concur.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Bell, Justice.

1. “It has been held by this court that on the trial of a statutory claim to land under the Civil Code of 1910, § 5157, interposed to resist the levy of a fi. fa., it is not necessary, in order to show fraud in a deed to the claimant, to have special pleadings for that purpose.” Simmons v. Realty Investment Co., 160 Ga. 99, 101 (127 S. E. 279). Accordingly, in the instant claim ease in which the claimant relied upon a deed from the defendant in execution, the court did not err in admitting the evidence offered by the plaintiff in execution, to the effect that the parties to this deed were husband and wife, over objection that there was no pleading to authorize the introduction of such evidence. Douglas v. Jenkins, 146 Ga. 341 (91 S. E. 49, Ann. Cas. 1918C, 322).

2. “In a claim case where the wife sets up title to the property levied upon under a deed from her husband, and his creditor attacks the same upon the ground that it is a fraudulent conveyance, intended to hinder, delay, and .defraud such creditor, the law does not put upon the creditor the burden of establishing fraud in the conveyance. On the contrary, it puts the burden upon the husband and wife. They must show that the transaction as a whole is free from fraud.” Gill v. Willingham, 156 Ga. 728 (9) (120 S. E. 108); Simmons v. Realty Investment Co., supra; Cotton States Fertilizer Co. v. Childs, 179 Ga. 23 (174 S. E. 708).

3. The trial wa's free from error, and the evidence authorized the verdict in favor of the plaintiff in fi. fa. The court did not err in refusing a new trial. Judgment affirmed.

All the Justices concur.

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

191 S.E. 121, 184 Ga. 351, 1937 Ga. LEXIS 512, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/moore-v-loganville-mercantile-co-ga-1937.

Opinion

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack