Moaney, Richard Daniel Iv

• Court: Texas Supreme Court
• Decided: March 6, 2015
• Docket: WR-75,186-04
• Status: Published

Opinion

t w . QAM€./\o, c),vz;-»%, c.,mgz#vs -,5'|9(1)"(13,0‘4

f , § W€ TE)f\ A?§>\l¢¢\@ov\ F@¢ wrr` 09 HAB€A'S @M@ mvv\ekrv\o¢\'\eyU § Cez?u:> v.A'<“>.C‘“P¢ AR+»¢\€ \\»O"

`Aw\m\v\+'s 72 €>?@'\§€ 76 >H\“r€> /lv\»$we'?@ TD W@ HOAUR;¢\E' wm+_' c@~\ez> new T&mlm> DAN`€\ mm@)/ II/ AW\MM ;M ¢p\€ A@L,SUS\M(JD §S“>, z@@@~ma, ~rc> '1+\€ >m~e‘> M)>w€c¢ w\y APW\,\¢/qw/)

`,:r®... +@rl- way 09 HNB€A> C@aqu?w>. @E©§§W§;:® HKYX

mem @z=@mm\'m.‘z&@n@§!x\\,@ ’ 4 am j: w@q\l> 'Ke>p¢=¢+pm\\>, DV\W): MAR% :l:, Ah@£ A@@S?@,CEQYK

A(HWH m;> eis /w S€cwx N>thwo v O/\e/ ‘~M Bg/\) ¢\{;”Q `W{/ ` » /V/\§“{" 0/\ Hé MD?c:l\/`/DA;K\>//V\`):(é\z;.

- § ix P_mzhz %ARB<~IL/ 573 Swél¢\ 834 r\o+e e, zfu+@z,\*€z@@@ C)<)M>@' €)+> @¢ 11me saw wm+ w H»Q@ew> COIZP“>, wH@Kg PM/ 949 €W?OFL \U\Ag ng\> bFZZ€\/z`()\)\${)! @M) ?\QTS€D E>/ AFP\/`CQA/T' ` J:/\) w?,H' ec HAB€A§ C@rz()%,&u" wm mr W§Défb ‘/\l>@‘/\ ®>/ cum ¢\NX 15 Aw\z/\ mw@ m Mz€w~+ wwm` j

mm ` :U: "

~ J (/OD' \ \

m @H%‘K;W wm q nw

- . f 13 ‘ L ‘ , ' ~

»%w §§ Az* wl W AW» ;;;;,:““::M¢M

;L_N C HJ\<€;C')A $€M:¢_v\c€. ~

-U'- fagg {W\ wmz/ f>(`[f>w THA#;E

jj eml M' ..MN/ />> KQQ;\A+?W\

_ -lc '

' l 1 - \ `\

95 '\é>e mem gmc m \)>OlAM»v\ 65 TF\§: “E?uzree~+d SI&QKNWE/ O"¢` ""€ W\‘HD STAT€> C@n§%www/\S Dc)£ _ ?Zm@>)

C\Av»§€'

/t\\b@/ L/\&Ay v, T€)(A,( 01€(2 Swélo\ 7‘1()/ /\%L€ N S?L)QJF€<§, - “`A LA@K_ w <>v\mz§)/@HQA /V\AYZ€ @wez+\`@v\€b> 'L})L AM/

§+Aéuz @p me ,?Zz)

A*\J\ CUN\N\I\\ /NAH~€\LS\ v

#-_`{

wg€@€,@z€, A\>@\IQML p@?@}mu{ P(szg TFW~ 74\€ awqu Q(MMH +\(K 'QW\{¥;A\~M W“ w@}` @F HA?;(>@S C_®Au‘;. ` ,

'RF>PMU f §a@»,#~+\rr>

*VQ`§AL€)§ n /M /\M _

_?"((MA(?/D my\c\erv ;v\oA/L€\/ _'L\_: A"P€\l\LN/\{') ?(Z° §§ T\D\oi§-F)v\g“(vi;q §N"?P`€§ \Av\l`-'\" 0

+~ 9 "SE»)< ‘/)b\'O §A+@\)‘\lv ”'X Yeg¢M

IMA@M@… y w /_ l l .` Awe`/ / 170 +\e@FB men TF\M' Q 619 " ap `W\€" ~|GP€G ' . Au;\:;ld\w§`>+;::@p +t:%m§‘ W“V M+OSL`}[ ‘\€`{ pywa €zmmpkjpv T(»\€ 27¢ OM( , ' l , l O ‘ l v z l ` ‘ § y ov\Tb\€ DA+€ ;z§[@w /BE\ “’“'\W'P@B@¢ WO.Y€\+§¢'\TX%SIB-

~ -9&>'&;/ _ ~ ` § ba+€ ` won-nw D/.\m:\ mm@\/;m’/ § A¢F*\'A~\/ ' .

1 §1"

(:,:) 5]`1<1{ jr§;}(,¢f§,§" C/:.j;~; 055 ¢;,3155… M j 5 5 11 9 >€11\5 ~

‘ 12 -'1:52\ 15 211 0 222 1552 1~ 212 _+51122212~2:;5 35 _ 1"'( 1‘ V\ /

n {" ' wv ’?p~ . C C¥ 37 5 19 '1(5115 11`5._5@`77 ._ 555555_) ’§`}1'_\1"\1:~`\ 1“'\.‘$','~1*`\‘§"§‘:/ .1)`~"‘ " 1211 225 \}:5/1 ~ A‘\+ 555 5 5.

AWMMS 13 5555;1,5\5¢ 522 _;5011115.>5 411/2211 fm 11`\(5 1101‘5:1 31( C.w~\;”£*f,' 5 5 /555 WD~' 1121\5~»;~:> 1252 511'221_> 321\` 51 2\@2¢521:‘/:13:55- 1~' 2221-1221 ' 521 910 912ij ""L//` 5_ 3 """ 1252 01111\_1'1 "1'€> +1¢\1' %11\“11;5 95'/"\) `>W"“¢ '1@ "AA`/. 1191".’6/`)9%0 ’5° '

' 1129 wm rif 111 '>551\2 1222 '°>w..>»

5 C’\%(;\(>;: »-:)/

, 121,\1;,15( 2151,;5 152 1122 ;~ 51'<@1\1\ 115"1>?111,1100 ;1\>/ 211121“ O/\Q 51’~»1'1$ ' D( 23 M, 15/ 555 1121 252 522 _.52\2?><) 1221 /\<=~';<11 g ' 5 "i§/‘< 1412/1212 212 2,5\4~<~ 9 "1°1'>1;5>;511 §;; "` 6212/153 C#?,"`>F" ,:,::_, éy…/‘ ';:5’;21'? 1155£,121\(.., , 115/1111 1\'¢10! ~1~155121-/1£'11~ (C“W`* 191561<€ 1511ka 010 121 21 1115 1222 2215112*% 511”"`1€2‘1’"

55';""\) 1292 O+ 1111/2115 (011'912`1.22' 1\)1`~"> 11121 /"`”"T) ij “‘POA"‘“>’/ {£'…'(!

11 1355 1112 2:;11\ Q;\_;5;> ;;\ 533 /2<:5,@15.1\515 l 1/\51_¢1,-

v " ";'Y "‘ 51 51\ ~51"` \. l 25 - _ ' . `551555€5?<5:1,1/55£/ 0:6 5551¢.1* 5(,,;131;“\1'\11\1121 115(1;'(,1'»"1:?2&(~41¥ 55 511 55_55 155 \55555,:555555,5 :5(;{5\ (W\ L`j 1131/113 - \` 31 *:"' 1§,,5~‘ ~",21”"5§1‘ i»/~¢` \»\7~,5,7 5 \ 5 1 11 /;,_ d ?pj::`i 55);;\5:/ f;(5` r\ 5555:551 10 \,J`\ /Sf\Afg\}:»/\{’) {,‘"f s‘/: (’@1\5'_'»..’}§15_51'\.\7.5{5¥/§¢; €'5"6 poR 1111 f',‘// ‘ 25 5 22 22 €5’~"5 112 1915¢215012 55'15 510 _2:.~. . d..,/,A5 L 5 5 \) £5!5/ 5 5 21911011 1221 111 5 )5:\1 M-( _ QL_$LO 1 _-5'1'\) (¢`(55'15"1'1\5\1\\}\§ ':`\.11:5"5\(5’:55;'\1]\551\5,510555 55 . § . 115(');£\ 1 .5,'/;‘\11;`1)“111(‘»‘1{555 :)51;5,5)1\;\56._5'

5 j» 15 d 505,\51_\ 912 1 1;'~51?{=(.1 1511 \\\/ ") 1'"111113 3

5555~?1[,»;2 111 j mm V\5\\5./2 511/1 11“\€ 195 151{,1:..\112.: 1213 J&\MJ (,+{CA

I\\l 1315 111 1115 611(1)1\1\1\5 ' 1110 §\. v 011\+111\ 191 17\; "1?>11;;11.~,@.,,¢1{

1\?'\=\ \1\11\1'\~1~/ 015 ’75'\5 ig-/\'_‘YD »5>55/'5\551> CC’>555\\555W55 5555\€5- 555‘555:5‘5'5755'55 11

Cl£l_v\.@f§ ` “ ' ’ _ _ /5`15.7;€)1 1111111 1)!7.75571`$><9»/,151(13 5>‘7/\)\<'-5-*5‘7“5‘ 75’/@1'\17¢1/"? S"/¢/~\+©, A .1:',1\¢1< 5 615 3111€'”~1¢1\`""11/\ 11'\11\{ 359 @1\:1:55+\ 111/1670 ¢}/' /§’\V

"451“1"*\€16 199 -'11+ "7?11<'13 !\(~15 ibm O/\ 7/~§11`/',&:’¢11,~'1?59‘ ??O#‘l 'C"`\/"@ 1’§;)‘1\ C]Z_`\;~v\§ ,'\1\\ /“1'\[\1112 < /

591211"1[5¢ i~TZ, ’

1051/11 P'“~'»"555'55' 55555°5555` 55 7 7 "”L+ml Y \55`?_?<1»*1"&/»'7.5 '5‘55`5555 5_555551." 75C<:O'V\.1’;# _ 6122117'“* ¢7’~7§, 111 11"1"_?(\7‘1.¢\11"1>17 11wi 1131 191 H~'Y`H c'@?f',w:>' ' 7

Q(»>r)€(,|¢fv\ }{5 §6\:>)*’\>`3`4`\9

U~;?#» 1177 -' bd m )(` . DKJH' . »;“ 7 '- 511£1\.11(11) D§w`§;:\ l\A5oA'5A'~/j j)£ 1`1?¢’\ 151¢\1\+ 1 1/';3_.~ §§ ‘1_'- T`~`L‘ C 5 }1\§<`("5/,#(4 3 11\.1'2.#\1 \ \11'\( 54' \:‘\~ 5'=;) 1’).¢/( L,¢'_,§_(/“` 0 , _' v ' 5114€3\)\(1 7@.§"!“7

f

v-~-....

/;. l 7 . _`(UM-v 066 SH€.'\}.(_.G 4 v . . ", "-5. 5 ' ’5`515,§\ 5`? 5{:: ~.. ~1 ' . ` -. ‘. ,,, - , . ;' du " ~> "/‘W` 13 »/5‘/\~"~11*\.€:} 355/711 \1\€1‘7) by 1 11\1';1/ 11\ ~.+ c;\ (0@1{ _ 015 `H\_ 0`6:6701(\91

W\G-lj`w\ 1115 /1\1_1|11) 1 L N d 4 ` __ . . \ \,~ ‘5<.~,‘1* \., .4.1.91_1{\ \(y‘\' 111/5 §7;;1?, ~;'/- '/" "

. l `l ¢\{_ .\/ C;~\ s / 0*'\7 75`§.‘\1~“ ”D£\+€ 314on 555 555 55 555 0 j 50 11711>1’\71'>1’ 7515'

M/M

?1511.1,1;» DAv-`f(:\ MO£AAQ¥/_)/_5 111-1113 -“"\T =

.'. v - ~ . 1 . . .‘..'~"_ .i_,;.' j!‘¥' ’ ' ` ~. 7 ,'».;; \5~. 1